Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera...
by brc on Sunday May 03, 2015 @11:15PM
(#9484106)
>Here's another fun thought: 6% of electricity is lost due to transmission costs. Will it be more efficient (in some cases, at least) to physically move charged batteries from solar fields to (nearer to) end users than to send it over the wire?
No, not in this universe, anyway.
The most basic power distribution in the world is people with Ox and cart distributing lead/acid batteries to remote villages. Transmitting power this way is the least efficient way possible.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera...
by saalweachter on Monday May 04, 2015 @07:28AM
(#9485486)
I was thinking more like barges / rail cars that were essentially one giant battery, cycling back and forth. Even the most optimistic figure for current technology is still too high, about 0.03% / mile, so you only get about 200 miles (round trip) on a 6% budget. I suspect over-the-wire transmission losses are lower over that distance, but it's only a little impossible.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera...
by mc808 on Monday May 04, 2015 @03:22AM
(#9484784)
Regarding the 6% transmission costs, if you have 17 charged batteries and use 1 of them to power a self-driving vehicle with negligible maintenance costs (and in a future where all vehicles are electric), it would make sense to haul the other 16 within whatever distance the vehicle can manage on a charge.
It looks like a Tesla S battery pack is a little over 1,200 lbs. So for a rough estimate, consider the distance a Tesla S can tow 20,000 lbs. Probably not very far.
Unless I botched my reasoning somewhere, it looks like battery energy densities would have to increase by an order of magnitude or two for this to become a thing.
Re:Tesla battery storage will accelerate exit of coal genera...
by joshvm on Monday May 04, 2015 @02:24AM
(#9484616)
This has already happened somewhat in Germany. Solar panels have completely disrupted midday wholesale electricity prices. The effect is so strong that occasionally the spot price goes negative: if you're not producing renewable energy, you have to pay to put your energy into the grid.
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/plugged-in/2014/10/07/en...
Here's another fun thought: 6% of electricity is lost due to transmission costs. Will it be more efficient (in some cases, at least) to physically move charged batteries from solar fields to (nearer to) end users than to send it over the wire?