Remember: recruiters approach you, they are technically in the least favourable position during the negotiations and it will benefit you to keep them there as long as possible.
Asking them for their 'range' is perfectly ok, if they don't want to provide you with an answer then it is absolutely fine to wish them good day but to keep the door open in case they change their mind and wish to part with this important bit of information you require before you start to invest your valuable time in the relationship.
Have you actually tried that? I have. I have never got a number in reply to such a question. Usually the recruiter himself does not know neither does the hiring manager. All salary talks I had were with the CEO/GM/etc. If I refused to talk with any recruiter/hiring manager who does not have a range I'd never been employed.
>Remember: recruiters approach you, they are technically in the least favourable position during the negotiations and it will benefit you to keep them there as long as possible.
This is the thing I don't understand. The recruiter is still trying to hire me if I said or have not said my salary requirements. Not saying does not appear as a strong leverage, in fact, it does not seem like a leverage at all. I ask straight what I want and am willing to negotiate down for non-monetary perks and use the scarcity of qualified applicants on the market as a leverage (e.g. mention other offers I have). I'd love to strengthen my position but I just don't see what I gain with withholding my requirements.
I suspect the hiring managers were never told the real reason I never interviewed there.
He said to go ahead and ask what their budget is, or to say what your requirement is:
>When asked this question I would suggest you ask the recruiter for his budget in return, or to simply state your salary requirement (rather than your current salary) instead.
If you're the one that applied for the job outright, then there is more pressure on you to give up what you're current making.
One other comment - if they come in with, "Well, they're only looking to pay between W and X" and X is lower than you'd like, you can then play the, "Well, I'm making Y, and would need to make Y + Z% to consider a move. I'm happy to give you a name or two of some more junior folks who may be interested."
That's a polite way to tell them to shove it off. I like it.
Thank you so much for the reply message. I was hoping I would have a few moments to talk on the phone but looking at my upcoming schedule I figured I better get some details out to you right away regarding a position one of my client's is looking to get filled. Thank you again for your replied message. JM is committed to helping small and large businesses with all of their needs, specializing in social media marketing. We are not a staffing agency but from time to time we are asked for help with staffing for everything from restaurant staff to office managers.
> but here is an alternate ending: they regrade the job req to meet your requirement. They won't always be able to do this, but when they can you win big.
I find it very unlikely that a company that cannot even afford my minimum rate is going to turn around and "win big" unless winning big means getting what I already have with less job security on top (if I am pushing well beyond the salary range - I am the first one to go when the money runs dry).
I am not a celebrity programmer who is worth keeping around just for the bragging rights, I survive by selling the value I add at discount. If this value is unfavorable then neither myself nor the counterparty benefit from such a business.
I really don't agree with this. I've gotten a ton of value out of seeing what works--and even when I don't go to work for somebody, I've usually stayed in contact and made a lot of acquaintances that way.
But I treat interviewing as a game, and a game I enjoy; last time I was looking I interviewed at thirty-five places just to keep meeting people.
There isn't always "1 truth". There are multiple ways to answer most development questions. A range of answers are usually acceptable. A reaffirmation that an answer is effective is a change for me. It's an additional weight for those answers that are successful (even if I have to reason out to the interviewer why). That's just my algorithm.
In the long run $30k won't break them, if it does then they have bigger problems. Most firms that intend to gain a competitive advantage realize they should pay a little extra to attract talent. Be that talent.
More importantly, it does not even have to be in any error band as all it takes to suffer from anxiety over being paid too much is to believe your own estimate. It is not worth it for me as there are plenty of jobs where I'd get just as much or more and be confident the company can afford it.
Sure, I'd like to get the maximum salary the employer could possibly afford, as same as the employer would like to pay the minimum salary I could possibly accept but I just don't see how being the second one to call a number resolves this. It's like believing that if you put an ask order only if there is already a bid at that price and vice versa then and only then you will be extracting the whole value from the market.
The only situation, I can imagine, where this work is when your maximum ask is below the firm's minimum bid, which, provided that you already have a job and understand few things about your industry, is very unlikely to happen. Even people out of college are pretty informed about the market situation as they talk to their friends who are getting offers too. And, even if this happened, you just got literally low-balled anyways, you took the lowest bid they could make!