So, yes. Please find a good primary care physician you trust and visit on an annual basis. Make sure you update that phsyician with what's going on in your life. That includes any family history, pain, issues etc. When in doubt, see another physician. But please don't go out and get a full MRI of your body just because (which, you are not saying, but does happen). There are enough VOMITs[0] in the course of normal defensive medicine. Don't go looking for problems because -- although they'll definitely help you look -- you might not be better off for it.
When the procedure was finished, I was told they would analyze the result, but I had a cancerous tumor and they sent me for a CT scan which confirmed stage iv colon cancer with liver metastasis. I'm now 8 months into chemo and after having my sigmoid colon removed, seem to have "stable disease" in my liver. I was otherwise asymptomatic.
Another chap at my company wasn't so lucky. He got hit by a car and lost consciousness. They did an MRI to check out his brain - and found tumors. A CT scan showed the same don't diagnosis as me, but his was far more advanced, with mean mastastasasis to the liver, lungs and brain. He passed away about 5 months later and was otherwise asymptomatic.
In both our cases, A blood test given after the diagnosis (CEA) showed highly elevated numbers - perhaps two orders of magnitude from nominal.
So my question would be: given that this blood test was a marker for our disease, why can't it be given more regularly as part of a routine checkup? I realize there are other reasons for a false positive, but couldn't it be an indication that further testing should be done? Yes a CT scan can cost $1500, but my chemo costs $12,000 per month.
Basically, radiologists are more afraid of being sued for missing something then they are of being sued for being too cautious. Evasive language is a defence against the latter.
This is a uniquely American condition BTW. Most other places, the liability rules are different and doctors aren't as afraid of lawsuits / insurance premium hikes.
Colon cancer can be effectively treated when Caught in it's early stages. During my (first) colonoscopy they found another tumor that got removed in the first of several surgeries, and it had clear margins and required to further treatment.
A central problem is that you get loads of false positives when you are screening symptom-free individuals, and these false positives can cause real harm: beyond anxiety, they often bring on potentially painful, expensive and side-effect causing treatments. Just see the recent recommendations over the PSA test: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostate_cancer_screening.
Definitely go to the doctor if you notice any symptoms or worrisome changes. For other types of screenings, be aware that the recommendations often change and that there is a real cost/benefit analysis (even in terms of your own body, not just financial cost) to be done.
I am thankful every day that I had a great GP who both did enough to be prudent, and also helped me stay balanced and not go overboard, in just the right way. I could have been a lot worse off had I continued to pursue treatment.
That said, in a state where anxiety is controlled and my health is now stable, it's still important to be aware of changes and new symptoms, and to have an annual standard physical with a doctor you trust and stick with consistently so they know you and your body over time. Just don't go overboard.
Say that a random scan uncovers that you have a minor brain aneurysm. The aneurysm's size and location implies it has a chance of rupture of around 0.2% per year. The operation to resolve the aneurysm, however, may have a 5% risk of death.
Weighing up the decision to have an operation is incredibly difficult, since most would be rather distracted by the idea of a ticking timebomb going off in their head at any time, yet the risk of the operation is more immediately significant. If undetected, the aneurysm may never rupture, or it may grow to a size where it causes other symptoms and can then be operated on.
(Or, of course, as in the case of a young friend of mine in his then early 20s, pretty much anyone can keel over at any time due to an undetected aneurysm anyway.. it's totally pot luck.)
There's nothing wrong with getting an MRI every year if you aren't actually looking at it on its own, but rather diffing it in a time-series, and extracting chartable statistics from it, to see if anything in your body is getting progressively [adjective]er each year.
This approach won't actually tell you if you've got six months to live, but it's not supposed to. It's to show you that your liver has been getting 10% more scarred over with each visit, so—with evidence!—you'd better lay off the booze already. Or to find something like arteriosclerosis before it presents clinically.
There is a whole team clustered around an MRI machine and tying up the machine is effectively tying up the team.
If everybody got an MRI every year on the off chance they might have something then the machines would not be available to those that actually need them (because they have symptoms that require an MRI to narrow in on a cause).
And that's besides the whole fall-out further down the chain in case something does show up that does not generate symptoms and even further down the chain where probably un-necessary operations will be performed on symptom-less patients.
Doing the right amount of screening is a really hard problem. Getting an MRI done every year just because you can afford it is probably not even near the right amount.
Imagine if you could get an MRI the way you currently get a blood pressure test or ultrasound or x-ray. Imagine a simplified MRI machine in every GP's office 40 years from now. Imagine the machine having a networked software layer integrated that doesn't even allow the raw static-image data out to the doctors, but instead just reports out weighted-average feature-change velocity heatmaps.
Presumably, the only people getting an MRI done every year now are the ridiculously rich, who could buy an MRI machine of their own, and a hospital wing to put it in. But the theory behind getting one isn't bad. It's just scarcity, and the effect scarcity has on the level of trust we put in the few samples we can beg, borrow or steal.
So you're going to need the crew of attendants and interpreters with associated costs regardless of the price of the machine.
What cheap MRI machines will do is marginally reduce the cost of a scan, which would be a good thing but over the life of the machine it is the people that make up the bigger chunk of the cost.
Mobile MRI machines are currently truck sized, something that could be moved around in a suitcase and set up on the spot would be a game changer in the third world (as would be cheaper MRI machines to begin with), but for the first world it wouldn't be so much of a change.
What did change things dramatically was the reduction in the cost of ultra-sound but the complexity of an ultra-sound scanner compared to an MRI machine is orders of magnitude less, interpreting the results is still not the job of the tech administering the scan (though in the case of say a look at an infant in utero even a lay person can make out what is what and that's already useful).
Healthcare costs are an interesting subject of study, you could easily make a career out of that.
[1] https://health.ucsd.edu/specialties/ehw/services/Pages/gold....
The thing to think about when you test for something, is what are you prepared to do about it if the results are positive? Not everyone will answer this question the same way.
As one example of many, consider prostate cancer screening: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/811846
Most tests do have some degree of false positives, but there a number of defensive diagnostic tests which are nearly error free and clinically significant
To name some: * BUN + Serum creatinine - Kidney health * LFT - Liver health * Sugar levels - Early detection of diabetes
I am not recommending a MRI, but everyone should get an annual health check, for some values of comprehensive.
http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-07-03/star-treks-t...
> Most tests do have some degree of false positives,
I think many people don't appreciate the danger of false positives.
The complications that can come from unnecessary treatments, the dangers that more invasive tests might cause, the aggregate effect of all the time and expense the extra testing causes (e.g. by putting a strain on hospitals who may need that MRI for someone else), the negative emotional consequences of the stress from the false diagnosis, the possible financial implications etc. Even a very small chance of a false positive can have huge consequences if the test is deployed widely enough.
Yes, but to most people, we compare that danger with the danger of a positive test that never gets done. More information is never a bad thing. And I'm reasonably sure that for almost every test that can have a dangerous false-positive, there is also a corresponding test that can corroborate those results, if not detect the false-positive.
Also, avoid being caught in modern media's constant drive toward polarizing sensationalism; your own life is actually fair simpler and more enjoyable than the internet and TV would have you believe (if you live in the first world)
So sure - get health checks done. Then be prepared to spend weeks or months double checking what your doctor is telling you, and possibly getting 2nd opinions and more tests.
Personal story: Head health test. High A1C. Diagnosed Diabetic, despite being a very fit triathlete who hasn't drank soda in 6 years and eats < 20g of sugar a day. Literally had near 2 weeks of full blown panic attack. Tried to change my diet to crazy low glycemic index food and eat 8 times a day to try and get my A1C down without medicine.
2 weeks later got into a 2nd doctor for another opinion. Turned out my test was just bunk. A1C is fantastic. Apparently it happens all the time (a bad test). My first doctor did not tell me this at ALL.. just told me I was a diabetic and to stop drinking so much Soda.
My takeaway? If not showing signs, don't bother with routine tests. Too many medical quacks.
67, been following a congenital heart murmur for years. Cholesterol at 130. Noticed my running and biking dropping performance dropping off, so think time for a heart valve replacement. Routine pre-op catheterization shows coronary artery blockage. Have bypass and valve replacement, doing great. But 130 was too much cholesterol for me apparently. On statins and down to 95! I am now 68, no prostate, artificial heart valve, bypassed coronary artery, but feel great and am still active.
Glad the heart surgery took place after I started medicare though. Say want you want about government ineptitude administering anything, but medicare works.
It's a good question what are the best tests to do periodically. I doubt that "none" is the right answer.
Here is a good article I read today on the topic:
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/05/11/overkill-atul-g...
Basically.. lots of things can be found by a test (say a slow or non-growing tumor) that the risk of removing them is > than the risk of leaving them alone.
Of course doctors are paid for doing work not for leaving it alone, so which do you think they will choose?
And yes, you should stop drinking soda, diabetic or not. Nothing bad will come from not drinking it, but plenty of bad things can come from drinking it. Telling you this doesn't make either your doctor or me a "quack".
Or you might want to postpone your visit to the doctor until you have an actual reason to go there:
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/09/opinion/skip-your-annual-p...
http://kaiserhealthnews.org/news/ritual-not-science-keeps-th...
(Six months after surgery - I'm well so far, still doing chemo for the next three months. We'll see, we'll see.)
Still, one needs to be careful about taking one incident and generalizing from that. There is, for example, a very real possibility that performing an ionizing-radiation scan for every patient who presented with acid reflux would cause more cancer than it cured.
> Yeah, pancreatic cancer patient here. Mine presented as acid reflux, which my GP treated with Prilosec.
The fact that you walked in with pancreatic cancer and got told you have heartburn doesn't exactly argue for regular checkups.
Probably 99 out of 100 people with GP's symptoms (if not more) actually do have acid reflux. It therefore makes medical sense to assume that until additional symptoms indicate a different conclusion.
It's perhaps unintuitive, but more testing isn't always good. The benefits need to outweigh the risks, and it isn't always the case. There are ongoing debates about who should be screened for various types of cancer, for example, and the "right" answer changes over time - as we find ways to reduce false positives, as we find better treatments, as we better understand the diseases, etc.
It's tempting to do more tests because it feels like you're doing something. You don't want to get sick later and feel like you could have prevented that. But that's an irrational form of thinking. All that we can do is make the best choice now, given our current information. As GP's links mention, the best choice we have now often seems like "avoid tests that aren't clearly needed."
There has been a big push back recently against using an improvement in 5 year survival rate as an indication of success in the war on cancer. For example, if a new diagnostic test lets you find out you have cancer earlier, but you still end up dying at the same age you would anyway, the 5 year survival rate would go up, with no real benefit to you. In fact, there could be lots of real negatives, like anxiety and an increase in other tests and procedures that don't actually improve your lifespan or quality of life.
The conclusion: "Although 5-year survival is a valid measure for comparing cancer therapies in a randomized trial, our analysis shows that changes in 5-year survival over time bear little relationship to changes in cancer mortality. Instead, they appear primarily related to changing patterns of diagnosis."
According to http://www.clinchem.org/content/47/4/624.full
> CEA as a Marker for Colorectal Cancer
> screening
> In screening for colorectal cancer, the aim should be to detect disease at either Dukes’ A or B stage. Malignancy detected at more advanced stages is unlikely to be more treatable than that detected through the usual course of events. Using an upper limit of normal of 2.5 μg/L, Fletcher (19) calculated that CEA has a sensitivity of 36% and a specificity of 87% in screening for Dukes’ A and B colorectal cancer. These findings, combined with the low prevalence of this malignancy in unselected populations, render the positive predictive value of CEA unacceptably low and thus of little value in screening healthy subjects. For the present, therefore, we must rely on fecal occult blood and endoscopy to screen for colorectal cancer (20).
What does 36% sensitivity and 87% specificity mean? Imagine that you test ten thousand 40-year olds and twenty-five of them do actually have colon cancer (this is more or less consistent with statistics telling that 0.23 of them will be diagnosed with colon cancer before turning 50). You will get a true positive result in 9 cases (out of 25) and a false positive in 1297 (out of 9975). So only 0.7% of the positive cases are real, and you missed two thirds of the cancers.
I would consider tests comprehensive if tests all major internal organs (kidney, liver, heart, spleen + common cancers depending on gender/age), you can come up with one after talking to a physician. Because I am based in India, I can only recommend India specific one, https://www.apollohospitals.com/preventive-health-care-check... are generally good.
If some or all of these are "no", it's not a comprehensive exam.
http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/Page/Topic/reco...
You don't really have a doctor girlfriend, do you? :)
Start by NOT asking random people on the internet.
Ask your doctor about what tests to do and he'll tell you based on your age / history, and you can trust him better than a random stranger or some web post.
If I met a community of strong critical thinkers about Chemistry or Civic Engineering I wouldn't ask them advice for my software stack.
Besides, with the exception of a 20% or less who knows what they're talking about (and those only for narrow Computer Science or Engineering fields each), the others might as well be on Reddit. You can find tons of uninformed opinion about anything here. Plus a huge tendency to go with the latest fads (Rails, then JS, then Go, then Rust, etc).
>Doctors aren't mythical beings
No, just trained professionals.
Law and Medicine are two of the things most likely to precipitate a lot of online commentary by people who don't have the first clue of what they're talking about.
http://healthblog.dallasnews.com/2015/04/mark-cuban-is-wrong...
It's 2015, and there's still no general agreement on which tests to run to tell if you are healthy or not. We don't even have firm evidence whether your annual physical with a doctor is a net positive or negative.
Meanwhile, people are dying decades prematurely due to uncaught illnesses that we know how to fix.
We have a check engine light for our car engine. Why on earth don't we have one for our bodies yet?
If your car starts easily and runs well, has no changes in fuel economy, and you have been keeping up with basic maintenance, it's probably fine.
Same with people. Sure there are some people who just drop dead out of the blue. But most people have symptoms. Unexplained weight gain or loss. Fatigue. Difficulty sleeping. Changes in bodily functions. For most people, if you have no symptoms and feel healthy, you most likely are. If you have family history of certain problems, of course be more vigilant about that.
We can't possibly continually test everybody for everything that might possibly be wrong with them, at least not until we have Star-Trek style medical devices. Unjustified testing in the absence of symptoms will simply further drive up the cost of medical care for those who really need it. One could argue that it already has.
Sometimes, thanks to technology, we don't know who has access to our data and whether this is going to be used against us: for example, will we have an impossibly high insurance premium attached to us for life - with the data in our hands, we lose the right to use insurance to even out that risk.
Sometimes, in medicine, there are ethical considerations, that the eventual treatment for a screened condition presents its own risk that people may not wish to decide and the healthcare system might not be well-equipped to manage.
Nonetheless, I still personally prefer to have the data than not. I want to decide my own healthcare needs based on my own knowledge and understanding of my own risks. This is "data driven".
> I fail to see how screening of healthy, relatively young, people would be "data driven".
So just by looking at yourself, you don't know if you are healthy, only that you look healthy. The tests are to ensure that you are, and to give you time and flexibility of treatment if you are not.
Thanks for sharing! Having known and worked with you for years I could not agree more. I ran the startup life for 6 years and it'll eat you alive if you let it.
Regards, Lane
I wanted to add my thoughts about false positives and executive health checkups, which fall under the larger umbrella of screening. I conduct executive checkups fairly regularly, but i’m not promoting anything here. I just want to share a personal philosophy that you, as a patient, could adopt to reduce risk.
Firstly, it should be stated that the utility and performance of any diagnostic test that has a binary outcome (eg. diseased/healthy) depends on 1) its intrinsic test characteristics 2) the prevalence of the disease in the population being tested[1], 3) the available diagnostic/treatment options for positive people, and 4) the threshold chosen to call something ‘positive’ since you are virtually always measuring a continuous variable.
People talk about false positives often, but you should know that there is some room for judgement here. The typical threshold for PSA has historically been 4.0 ng/mL. Above this is considered a positive screen, and you are recommended further testing to confirm prostate cancer, which can be invasive and lead to complications (bleeding, nerve damage, etc). This kind of two-stage testing is a common theme. The issue is that PSA values in people with cancer and people without cancer are normally distributed and have some overlap. A value of 4.0 is in the overlap zone, and the vast majority of people with 4.0 will not have cancer. However, lets say hypothetically that guidelines changed and we now use 20. At this level, most people who test positive probably have something bad, and the risk:benefit ratio is in favor of confirmatory testing and probably in favor of treatment too. I won’t bother going into it, but there’s a fair amount of liability, psychology and economics at play when choosing thresholds. Biochemical tests like PSA do have some variance, but are mostly reliable. It’s more complicated with imaging and amorphous things like mammograms that have some operator variability in judgement (and hence more liability).
This was a long-winded way to say that information is not necessarily bad, but it’s what you and your doctor choose to do with it. There’s room for discussing probabilities, and the various available pathways. Trust is huge. Your doctor will act in your best interests when he feels safe from lawsuits, otherwise he'll be focused on not missing anything regardless of likelihood or cost. The financial misalignment of our system doesn’t help in building trust either. Most first-stage screening tests have very minimal risk involved. Things like checking your blood pressure, cholesterol, glucose, doing a treadmill stress test, reviewing your meds, vaccinations, etc which are part of these annual checkup programs are, on balance, usually good ideas.
In January 2009 I was Stage 5 chronic kidney disease, in July 2009 I had a kidney transplant. Looking back there were so many telltale signs that I had over the last six months, which I was ignoring as I was busy building my startup. A regular health check has the potential to catch a problem like this. I now nag each of my friends and family in having an annual health check.
Its the best time you can spend.
This was not the first time I made a mistake like this. When I was a kid, I had trouble seeing my teacher's blackboard. I just kept moving closer to the blackboard. I saw a doctor when I had trouble understanding what the teacher was writing from the first row.
Problems like this creep up on you over years, and they are so gradual you don't realize them.
You wont run your site without a Google Analytics/Pingdom. Dont do it with your life. If you haven't had a health check, get it done today.