News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by jobvandervoort on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:33AM (#9451712)
As far as I understood that was a value set by Bethesda, not Valve.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by jonlucc on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:40AM (#9451756)
The latest I've seen is that Valve gets 30%, then the publisher decides what the rest of the split looks like. If they had released the exact same system, but said the modders get 75%, I think this whole ordeal would have been avoided. It's interesting to me that it was apparently better to give modders nothing than to give them 25%.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by lsaferite on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:10AM (#9451952)
I personally found Bethesda getting any split quite distasteful. They produced the game and made their money on game sales. If they continue to be responsive to bug reports and/or adding new features to the game then perhaps I can see a small amount going to them.

Valve taking a cut I understand as they handle the sales and distribution platform. I'm not sure I think 30% is fair, but that's a different issue.

As a revenue split I'd be much more on board with the modder getting 75% and the rest being to everyone else.

Of course, then you need to consider how mod dependency is handled. And you have to look at how long term mod support is handled. What happens when the modder goes away or Bethesda releases an update that breaks existing mods.

The whole thing is a big nasty ball of problems.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:21AM (#9452069)
> I personally found Bethesda getting any split quite distasteful.

So, you agree that Valve should get some part of the sales, because they are the ones (Steam) actually taking the payment and assuming some of the upfront risks of processing payments (fraud) and, because of the network effect and the customers they bring (read ... marketing)

But Bethesda who developed the actual game that brought the modders and gave them a platform to derive their work on, not to mention creating the actual game and game engine and putting it in the hands of the actual customers; they should just get nothing out of this whole deal?

I agree that the whole thing is a big hairy mess, and as a developer and an underdog myself I agree that the split should be approximately reversed, but I'm not sure there's much else we agree on.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by Already__Taken on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @04:53AM (#9457098)
What about mods that the publisher can't do?

I played GRID a lot and found the "any car any track" mod which was awesome. Codemasters didn't do that for some reason. There are mods that add Ferraris, Codemaster aren't licensed to include those cars. They were even in the trailer for the game and got pulled.

There's mods to include stuff the publisher couldn't even care[1] to sort out. Why should they get any cut of money for that. Would they even be allowed to take a cut? I assume this kind of stuff sits in a grey zone at the moment.

I think this will always be a problem if you couple the distribution and the day-to-day service in the way steam does.

[1]:http://www.moddb.com/mods/8-ball-prestige-packs-dlc-pc

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @07:33AM (#9457518)
If you think about it, those mods probably wouldn't be able to be sold either (forget anyone taking a cut)

Unless a deal could have been worked out with Ferrari. But good on you for asking something different!

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by Already__Taken on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @08:25AM (#9457746)
I agree maybe not the best example, but it illustrates about problems than can come up from combining services in the market. Hypothetically if steam was _just_ a package manager and the mods payed to for the convenience of users to install it. It shouldn't matter about the content.

Maybe a better example is Red Alert 2, I still occasionally LAN play that and there's a community patch to replace the IPX stack with TCP/IP so it can still work. as IPX is completely gone from windows 8+ I think.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @01:09PM (#9459810)
That's a great example of a mod that just plainly repairs a deficiency in the original game! I was in fact struggling to think of one.

It's clear that this game is abandoned and there's no further support coming from Westwood Studios for it, not to mention that it won't be coming available on Steam any time soon. As troubled as this analogy is, ...

I think it's still clear that in a hypothetical scenario where Steam gets the rights to distribute RA2 and Westwood (EA? who owns the rights to C&C series now?) has still washed their hands of support for it long ago, it would make sense for Steam to give the mod authors the option of sending back some percent of the gross (1-10%) to the rights holders for the game. Sort of a "vote with your dollars" kind of thing.

Of course if we are really talking about sending "extra money" to EA to say thanks, as a mod author or gamer I'm probably going to need to vomit right away, but replace EA with some other hypothetical not-shitty company (the ghost of Westwood) and I think you've got a deal.

This whole scenario just makes me reflect on the relatively recent development of Apple deciding that they can't allow any apps in their phone store that mention support for any products competing with Apple Watch (misfit, fitbit, etc)

The way this played out just goes to show who really owns the greatest share of the attention of Valve and Steam (it's the game companies, not the mods or the community.)

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by talmand on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:49AM (#9452292)
Well, if Bethesda gave the game away for free and wanted a source of revenue from mod makers, sure. But it's quite established that a strong mod community results in continuing sales for the game beyond a normal product lifespan. In some cases, the price of product remains higher than normal because of the strong sales due to the mod community. Bethesda has already made money on the backs of mod makers.

A proper response to this is to give all the remaining money after Valve's cut to the mod maker as a thank you to the community.

But this doesn't even address the other problems that people have been pointing out.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by random28345 on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:11AM (#9452898)
> But Bethesda who developed the actual game that brought the modders and gave them a platform to derive their work on, not to mention creating the actual game and game engine and putting it in the hands of the actual customers; they should just get nothing out of this whole deal?

Mods represent value added to the game that wasn't provided by the original publisher. Each mod "fixes" a deficiency in the game, adds, changes, or removes something the original developer did not do from the baseline game. The changes add value to the publisher's bottom line by increasing the value of the game, thus stimulating additional sales.

Thus the idea that modders both increase demand for the game, increasing the publisher's sales, AND want the lion's share of the money paid for mods is repugnant.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:31AM (#9453063)
I don't see how the idea that Steam should get a share approaching 30% is any less repugnant than that. Visa gets less than 4%, and they are the ones that are really processing the charge. Valve eats that much, and whatever they get paid over that is simply for their role in facilitating the transaction

If any of these three parties declined to provide their own involvement, a sale does not happen. So all of them are reasonably entitled to a share. But not necessarily a whole third.

I agree that Half-Life developers should not be the ones getting the majority of the sticker price of CounterStrike, insofar as those people are disparate parties and the popularity of CounterStrike drives sales of HL and even surpasses Half-Life in popularity. But it is impossible to deny that CS does not have a game to sell at all without HL.

They did sell "CS-Only" discs without the ability to play Half-Life in single-player mode, didn't they? And, Valve still got a cut? (What's that? They never did? Hmm...)

Edit: There is obviously some risk for Valve, too. Maybe more than Visa in the long run, but I think they will pass on the risk to those who they pay, just like Visa. They do get to hold the money, and they can decide who gets paid.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by random28345 on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @02:57PM (#9454428)
> I don't see how the idea that Steam should get a share approaching 30% is any less repugnant than that.

If you don't understand they 30% is reasonable, then you haven't tried to sell a game in the last 5 years.

That 30% you're paying increases your sales by a factor of 50x, and game developers are quite happy to take 70% of a much larger pie.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @03:48PM (#9454695)
> to take 70%

We were talking about the mod sales. Nobody is taking 70%, unless you counted the original game sale as part of the pie. Maybe we should.

The split as I understood it to be defined was: Valve takes 30% (arguably OK, but I'd argue for less), Game dev gets 45% (passive income hacker, woo!) and the Mod dev gets 25%.

I think it would be perfectly reasonable for Mod devs to get 45% of the sales of their own mods, but Valve asked Bethesda to define the split. What self-respecting PIH is going to give themselves or their own company less than 50%, really, if they are unilaterally the one making the decision about who gets paid and how much?

You are also right about one more thing, I don't have the first idea about selling games. But I would argue it's more work to build EITHER or BOTH a game engine and a mod than it is to sell it. In other words, Bethesda's cut should not be less than Valve's, in my humble opinion, and those mods would NOT have been for sale (or for free) without Bethesda and their game engine.

(Or at least, we would have entirely some other developer and game to thank for their share in this controversy.)

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by lsaferite on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:48AM (#9452282)
Bethesda did get something. They got my purchase of the original game plus all of the DLCs. All at initial sale prices to boot.

Do they deserve more than that?

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by yebyen on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @04:30PM (#9454959)
I don't know about deserve, but if you want to talk about incentives for behavior, you really can't go wrong with something that provides both "increased sales volume and lifetime" and "an ongoing share of the grosses".

If you want game developers to promote a helpful environment for mod developers, grab some money and pay them something out of it. Definitely!

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:20AM (#9452057)
> I personally found Bethesda getting any split quite distasteful. They produced the game and made their money on game sales.

They produced the game engine, and are letting people develop on it for free. And them getting a cut from people piggybacking on their work and making money from it was distasteful to you?

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:21AM (#9452065)
'Piggyback' is a loaded word. Its something we all do when we use a compiler or desktop machine. Yet those folks don't stick their hands into our revenue stream.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:38AM (#9452210)
> Yet those folks don't stick their hands into our revenue stream.

Game engines do. And they used to tack on $100,000 up front, to boot.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by talmand on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:57AM (#9452348)
Not all game engines, some are free to use.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @10:18AM (#9452510)
Some are, true. But the ones with lots of features, that everyone really wants to use—the ones that you can make games for multiple platforms, and that big development houses use—those... are not free.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by llama052 on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @01:06PM (#9453768)
[0] Actually if you look at some of the big engines, they are becoming free, or require a small royalty to use, and it sure as hell isn't a 75% cut.

[0]https://www.unrealengine.com/what-is-unreal-engine-4

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @02:22PM (#9454238)
It's much less than 75%—but then, you only get the engine, you don't also get the multimillion dollar award winning game to build on top of. If you make a mod for Skyrim—say, a new dungeon—you're adding that to the existing game and assets and dungeons and all that. You don't have to build everything from scratch, and you don't need your new content to be enough by itself to get people to buy it. A game with 1 dungeon, who would buy? But a mod that adds 1 dungeon to Skyrim, sure.

So yes, 75% is high, but the conversation should be, what cut should everyone receive, not, why does Bethesda deserve a cut at all, which most of the conversation actually is.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by talmand on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @09:48AM (#9458200)
Well, I could say that the fact the assets already exist in the game that I paid for, then the assets have already been paid for whether there's a mod that makes use of them or not. The other factor is that the game assets the modder is using is only available to players who have purchased the game. The assets have been paid for once, what this system is asking that the assets be paid for more than once. Mind you, not paid for by the modder, but by the player who has already paid once for those assets. To expand that to an obvious conclusion; let's say there is a sword asset in the game I paid for. I pay for ten mods that make use of that same sword asset in different ways. Which means I have paid for that same sword eleven times. Which is free money to the developer for doing absolutely nothing beyond providing the initial game I already paid for.

Also, are they going to have different percentages based on amount of usage of game assets? So far I haven't seen an indication of that.

As I have said before, if Skyrim had been free then I could understand the position. In this case I feel it is in the best interest of the company and game to let the modders go forward without interference. But hey, that's just my opinion, it's their company and their game so they can do whatever they want.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by lsaferite on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:26AM (#9452110)
LOL, exactly.

Hell, why don't musical instrument makers get a share of royalties for music made with their instruments?

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:39AM (#9452224)
> Hell, why don't musical instrument makers get a share of royalties for music made with their instruments?

Hell, why don't game engine developers get a share of royalties for games made with their engines?

...oh, right, they do.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by paulmd on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:37AM (#9453092)
Microsoft doesn't get a cut of Jetbrains' IDE "mod" revenue, though, despite the fact that Reshaper and similar products "piggyback" (what a loaded term) onto Visual Studio and other Microsoft products. Microsoft already got their cut up front.

Same thing for Bethesda - it's not their value-add and they don't have a moral right to take a cut. On the other hand Steam is providing a value-add here - a market and financial transaction services.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by lsaferite on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:24AM (#9452096)
Yes.

I paid full price for the game and all of the DLC.

Part of the reason I did this was due to the ability of the game to be easily modded. I knew with modding the lifetime of the game was much greater.

Why should they get 40% of mod sales for doing nothing? They already got paid for making the game.

Now, if they are still providing good customer support with timely bug fixes around the mod system, then perhaps I can see a small portion going to them. Otherwise, why do you think they are entitled to a share of the mod revenue?

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:55PM (#9456416)
> I paid full price for the game and all of the DLC.

> Part of the reason I did this was due to the ability of the game to be easily modded. I knew with modding the lifetime of the game was much greater.

So you paid full price for the game because you knew people would spend their time and effort making things for you for free... and now that there was an option for them to get paid for their work, you get pissy?

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by lsaferite on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:12PM (#9460918)
I knew the mod community around the game would provide value long past the original game.

Did I say I never donated to mod authors? Did you ask?

I'm not pissy, but it sounds like perhaps you are.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @10:37PM (#9463029)
> Did I say I never donated to mod authors? Did you ask?

What difference does it make? Even if you were a good citizen and donated, there aren't enough people donating for it to be a dependable income stream.

> it sounds like perhaps you are

133,000 people who claim to represent gamers signed a petition saying that modders should work for free, how dare they think they should get paid. I'm not a mod author. I'm not even a mod user. But I'm someone who believes in paying people who make the things I like, so that they can keep making more. This was an opportunity for a new marketplace, a new way for people to start making content for games—and for some, support themselves by making that content. An opportunity for anyone to use the IP of another company—which I don't think exists in any other industry. Can you imagine what it would take for Disney to allow anybody to legally make and sell their own Mickey Mouse cartoons? But no, it had to get shat on by entitled assholes who want people to make and make and make and give nothing back. You say it sounds like I'm pissy? Damn straight I'm pissy.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by XorNot on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:58AM (#9452355)
The part where they also got to sell the game engine to customers, the developers, and then take a cut of the developers profits too?

You don't buy the mod, and get the game to run it. You have to buy the game, then buy the mod. If they want more money for the game, they can increase the price.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @10:56AM (#9452796)
> If they want more money for the game, they can increase the price.

That still doesn't get the mod developers any money.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by paulmd on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:40AM (#9453115)
Also, I wasn't aware that Bethesda had released their game engine for free. Care to give a link as to where they've done so? As far as I'm aware you still need to pay for a copy of it.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:58PM (#9456423)
Their game isn't free; nor did I claim that it was. What is free, however, is they don't charge you any licensing fee to create a mod for it.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by draugadrotten on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:01AM (#9451892)
> It's interesting to me that it was apparently better to give modders nothing than to give them 25%.

It's due to perceived "fairness"

This 75/25 split by Valve reminds me of the psychology experiment the Ultimatum Game: "'Inequity aversion' is so strong that people are willing to sacrifice personal gain in order to prevent another person from receiving an inequitably better outcome." https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/your-brain-work/200911/...

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by dragontamer on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:57AM (#9452346)
Inequity Aversion only exists in America and other Westernized countries btw. We're WEIRD like that.

Different cultures respond differently to the Ultimatum Game. Be wary of those studies that only use "Anglo-Saxon American College Kids" as test subjects, which is a group of people that isn't even representative of America in general.

http://bigthink.com/praxis/are-americans-the-weirdest-people...

>>> The revelation that rural Peruvians handle the ultimatum game so differently from American respondents led Henrich on a MacArthur Foundation-funded research trip to more than a dozen more locales around the world, where he found wide variation in the average offers of player #1 and this curious result: “in some societies — ones where gift-giving is heavily used to curry favor or gain allegiance — the first player would often make overly generous offers in excess of 60 percent, and the second player would often reject them, behaviors almost never observed among Americans.”

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by crdoconnor on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:36AM (#9453090)
>Inequity Aversion only exists in America and other Westernized countries btw.

Monkeys do it:

http://www.livescience.com/2044-monkeys-fuss-inequality.html

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by talmand on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:55AM (#9452336)
That's not quite the same. That game involves two people trying to figure out who gets what from a pot of money they did nothing to deserve receiving. Mod makers did work that may deserve compensation. One example is a possible bonus for the people involved, the other is a possible shafting for the people involved.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mxfh on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:43AM (#9451770)
Yes they wanted 45% so Valve slapped on another 30% while not providing any or minimal QA from Valve or Bethesda for that other 75%?.

As with the Store or Greenlight before outsourcing tasks to the community (reviews/greenlight votes) doesn't mean Valve isn't responsible for the stuff they offer in their store. A 24h hour refund policy is simply laughable when non-waiveable EU consumer rights regulations require 14 days.

The other thing is the quite astronomic payout cap at $100 which means any hobbyist has to sell $400 ore more, depending on taxes before he see any of his efforts compensated. This further shows that Valve was not interested in amateurs but this was all about professionalizing the modding scene to a few contributors.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:17AM (#9452027)
> so Valve slapped on another 30% while not providing any or minimal QA from Valve

Valve was charging 30% for operating the storefront, handling payment, the value of having spent years building a site where people are willing to come and pay for things, the value of having built a service that would allow modders to make money building off of another company's work, and so on. Valve's 30% was well deserved.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mxfh on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @11:04AM (#9452853)
Heaving dealt with Valve customer service a few times, the 30% is definitely not going into training, hiring more or providing responsive and helpful customer service. Valve only get's away with it because they run a de facto monopoly.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mcphage on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @02:25PM (#9454259)
> the 30% is definitely not going into training, hiring more or providing responsive and helpful customer service

It should, certainly, and it's not, but I didn't claim that it was.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by Vespasian on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:59AM (#9451874)
> non-waiveable EU consumer rights regulations require 14 days

I don't think this is true in the case of purely digital products. As far as I am aware of the german implementation of this regulation it explicitly allows to waive the rights before the first download. Like many companies steam does this during checkout ("I agree..").

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by mxfh on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:42AM (#9452241)
That Steam allows it doesn't make it legally binding or compliant with current regulations which override any TOS/EULA in a given legal region.

http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/consumer_affairs/consum...

«In the case of digital content, the cooling-off period expires when the downloading or streaming starts.»

Says you can't waive it; for digital downloads the 14 day period get's annulled once you start downloading/streaming, not at checkout. Since many more things can go wrong with software(games) then compared to linear media (books/music/video) that implementation is still questionable.

Untouched by this, at least in Germany every product sold (including Software) comes with two years of warranty ("Gewährleistung") which is established between the consumer an the reseller (at point of final sale, in this case Valve SARL) which first requires the reseller to provide a working product ("Nacherfüllung") if that's not possible the customer is entitled to a refund. Not that that this is found in many online shops in Germany, but those are the regulations that Valve has to follow by when selling software (games) to German customers.

Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by grovulent on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:51AM (#9451817)
And don't forget they were trying to minimise the potential competition and challenge to their revenue streams that modding represents.
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by ekianjo on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:04AM (#9451910)
Oh so you think Valve has no negotiation power over this kind of things?
Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers by efaref on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @08:40AM (#9451751)
And okayed by Valve.