Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by hetman on Monday April 27, 2015 @11:50AM
(#9447059)
Complex systems exhibit all sorts of interesting emergent behaviours. Many things in living systems, like the way proteins fold, can be incredibly intricate. There are thousands of complex chemical pathways that need to work in synchronicity. We don't even fully understand all the factors influencing the appearance of cancers, many new exciting discoveries are still being made. Even things like resonance in certain circumstances could bridge some of the gap in power levels discussed.
It is the height of hubris to suggest there was never even any point in checking if mobile phones could cause cancer. Those studies were not a waste; science is full of surprises and empirical evidence is still the loudest voice science has.
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by gregonicus on Monday April 27, 2015 @02:07PM
(#9448072)
Looks like ionization is not the only criteria for health impact. See "DNA is a fractal antenna in electromagnetic fields"
and the conclusion: "The wide frequency range of interaction with EMF is the functional characteristic of a fractal antenna, and DNA appears to possess the two structural characteristics of fractal antennas, electronic conduction and self symmetry. These properties contribute to greater reactivity of DNA with EMF in the environment, and the DNA damage could account for increases in cancer epidemiology, as well as variations in the rate of chemical evolution in early geologic history"
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by brador on Monday April 27, 2015 @02:45PM
(#9448343)
Fascinating stuff! Could it be possible the phone near the ear that was on muted call was causing static electricity in the hair in the ear canal, causing the spike in brain glucose in that region as the brain senses it?
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by rrss1122 on Monday April 27, 2015 @11:45AM
(#9447013)
The particular model chosen in the article reflects physical reality, and the physical reality of it is that cell phones do not produce ionizing radiation. There is no debate as to whether this is correct, because this is how we see the world operating.
As the article states, you only start running into ionizing radiation at much higher energy levels, the kind you are exposed to just walking outside in sunlight. The link between sun exposure and skin cancer is well-established. The link between cell phone exposure and any cancer is non-existent.
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by justinsb on Monday April 27, 2015 @11:53AM
(#9447072)
I agree with you as to the conclusion: I don't believe that cell-phones cause notably higher rates of cancer. I believe that based on the studies, as I think you do.
The problem with the article, and perhaps the reasoning in your comment, is that it assumes that ionizing radiation is the sole cause of cancer. The article implies that cancer studies that consider anything other than ionizing radiation are a waste of time and money.
I believe the debate as to whether there are non-radiation causes, catalysts or contributors to cancer is very much open, and I appreciate the work that people do to investigate these possibilities.
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by rajadigopula on Monday April 27, 2015 @11:51AM
(#9447062)
"For instance, a Danish study followed 420,000 people over 20 years and found no link between cancer and mobile phone use "- Studied Mobile phone use for over 20 Years!?
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by rajadigopula on Monday April 27, 2015 @12:02PM
(#9447134)
It's not when they were invented. It's about - when is the relation between cancer and mobile phones established and studies started in that direction. My best guess it's definitely not before 20 years!
Re:Why Cell Phones Can't Cause Cancer, but Bananas Can
by ceejayoz on Monday April 27, 2015 @12:09PM
(#9447174)
The first mobile phones were demonstrated in the 1970s, so there was plenty of time for someone to go "huh, I wonder if that'd cause health problems" over the course of a couple decades.
It is the height of hubris to suggest there was never even any point in checking if mobile phones could cause cancer. Those studies were not a waste; science is full of surprises and empirical evidence is still the loudest voice science has.
I do however tend to agree with the author that cell-phones causing cancer is hokum.
and the conclusion: "The wide frequency range of interaction with EMF is the functional characteristic of a fractal antenna, and DNA appears to possess the two structural characteristics of fractal antennas, electronic conduction and self symmetry. These properties contribute to greater reactivity of DNA with EMF in the environment, and the DNA damage could account for increases in cancer epidemiology, as well as variations in the rate of chemical evolution in early geologic history"
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21457072
As the article states, you only start running into ionizing radiation at much higher energy levels, the kind you are exposed to just walking outside in sunlight. The link between sun exposure and skin cancer is well-established. The link between cell phone exposure and any cancer is non-existent.
The problem with the article, and perhaps the reasoning in your comment, is that it assumes that ionizing radiation is the sole cause of cancer. The article implies that cancer studies that consider anything other than ionizing radiation are a waste of time and money.
I believe the debate as to whether there are non-radiation causes, catalysts or contributors to cancer is very much open, and I appreciate the work that people do to investigate these possibilities.