News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by digitalzombie on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:19AM (#9432497)
Did they fix the reliability and oil consumption for Rotary? The rx8 ate a lot of oil cause the oil lubricating it evaporates. Also the Rx7 rubber hoses tends to wear down over time.

While the rotary did won Le Man 24 hr endurance race, it is still plagues with problem. These problems isn't because Pistons are better but because Pistons had tons of time refining it. Rotary so far have been neglected and it seems like EV/battery technology will be the future while hybrid is just an intermediate step between oil and electric.

Another interesting engine that GM tried was Turbine, jet engine for cars. It sound like a vacuum cleaner.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by brc on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:30AM (#9432541)
Mazda rotary engines are designed with oil injection to lubricate the seals - they are designed to consume oil.

Rotaries, properly cared for, are a reliable engine with fantastic power delivery and small size. It's a shame they are plagued with high fuel consumption which limits their usefulness in anything but sports and racing applications.

If you read the article this is not a conventional wankel rotary - the rotor design looks like a wankel housing, so it's flipped around.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by watmough on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:47AM (#9432607)
Reputedly, if you own an RX-7 or RX-8, you should spin the engine up to 9k revs at least once every trip... lest carbon deposits build up and wreak havoc.

I can't imagine a technology like this is that well suited to constant and relatively low power delivery.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by busterarm on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:06AM (#9432707)
Not entirely accurate. The 5th and 6th ports don't open up until 3800 and ideally you want to slightly redline it for a few seconds, but you definitely want to at least open up those ports. You can also get away with not doing it for a while, but you shouldn't.

on a pre-89 that (factory) redline is at 7k, 8k on 89-. RX8s you have to hit 9k.

This does make it hard not to speed in an RX7, especially if you've done a little bit of work to it - not so much in the RX8.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by brc on Saturday April 25, 2015 @03:59AM (#9437617)
Rotary engines make good constant speed engines because the intake and exhaust ports can be tuned for that constant running.

They're also ideal for alternative fuels like natural gas because the combustion chamber is in a different location to the intake/compression, which makes it easier to limit uncontrolled ignition (detonation). And the oil injection makes them suitable for adding specific lubricants to the intake charge.

On the topic of giving engines a good dose of WOT and revs, all modern direct injection cars need this as the loss of port injection means that the intake runners and valves are no longer given a constrant stream of fuel to clean them. As some exhaust gases enter the intake runners when valves overlap, over time this leads to massive carbon buildup in the intake side. Google some pictures of Audi engines with carbon deposits - makes your eyes water.

So if you have a modern direct-injection petrol injection make sure you give it a good 'italian tune up' on frequent occasions as well.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by gsnedders on Friday April 24, 2015 @04:30PM (#9435840)
> While the rotary did won Le Man 24 hr endurance race, it is still plagues with problem.

Well, they were given dispensation to run 170kg lighter than any other car in the class (830kg v. 1000kg). It's likely that that made the deciding difference in their win.

Also, it's worthwhile remembering a lot of the fuel efficiency problems with rotaries are avoided by running at a constant, relatively low RPM. For a generator motor, they make a hell of a lot of sense. Sealing the chamber is also a lot easier at a constant RPM, which should help with oil consumption and reliability.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by pkulak on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:34AM (#9433568)
Rotary engines still have a lot of potential as range extenders for EVs.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by seanp2k2 on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:09PM (#9435031)
Why haven't there been any diesel-electric hybrids yet? It seems like the perfect application for a small, 2-4 cylinder efficient diesel driving a light and compact neodymium generator. Trains and ships and submarines have been using diesel-electric hybrid power for over 100 years now [1] , so it blows my mind that this technology is still considered novel / new / and isn't totally refined yet.

1. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_locomotive#First_funct...

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by zackmorris on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:13PM (#9435060)
One thing to consider is that with so few moving parts, the engine could be made of ceramic and use the fuel and exhaust gases for lubrication directly. I saw a documentary about it in the 90s and remember a guy holding a ceramic piston and discussing it but never heard anything else about it.

I believe the carbon residue acted like graphite. The hardness of the components was so much higher than metal that it was like comparing the lifetime of ceramic bearings like silicon nitride (Si3N4) to metal bearings.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by specialist on Friday April 24, 2015 @06:09PM (#9436275)
Do you know the state of the art for ceramic engines?

IIRC, it wasn't feasible to make large parts with available sintering tech.

This rotary engine being smaller, perhaps its feasible to use ceramics.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by acomjean on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:40AM (#9432582)
fwiw the article linked from the article talks about oil, no word on reliability:

"Where the rotor holds the seals in a normal Wankel, the housing does that job in the X1 engine. This allows significant reduction in oil consumption over a regular rotary motor."

http://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/a8174/liquidpistons-hyp...

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by busterarm on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:52AM (#9432639)
As someone familiar with Mazda's (incomplete) Wankel, that sentence reads more like marketing speak and is nearly meaningless.

Something about this design smells to me but I can't quite pinpoint it yet.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by acomjean on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:45AM (#9433653)
You are right to be skeptical. We've been down this road of lots of promises for new technology before. If there was an problem with the design the company isn't letting us know. Maybe its durability? Torque? repairability?

Reminds me of the "orbital engine" out of australia last century that had some challenges it couldn't overcome. There are lots of other attempts to make different engines.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_engine

Alternative engines are always interesting though, and who knows?

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by Toast_ on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:08PM (#9434621)
These guys have been around since 2005, if I'm not mistaken. So I dunno if I'd call them new.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by markbnj on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:15PM (#9434664)
Agreed, but I think for me it's that the apex seals were always the weak point in the Wankel design. So the apex seals are moved to the case, but what material advancements have made them more robust and resistant to wear and leaking?
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by brc on Saturday April 25, 2015 @04:02AM (#9437622)
Apex seals were eventually solved by Mazda, though. You can still kill the apex seals through neglect, but to be fair you can do that to piston rings and valves as well.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by aidenn0 on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:14PM (#9434282)
I know the intent for this engine isn't for road-legal cars, but...

This runs on Diesel, and advertises a low-temperature exhaust; can someone who knows more tell me if diesel's need hot exhaust for emissions reduction? I know that they tend to use EGR for NOx, but every car with a diesel I've seen still has a catalytic converter to do something.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by mattlutze on Friday April 24, 2015 @05:05AM (#9432126)
The benefit and trouble with rotary engines is their reliability -- fewer moving parts means they'll generally fail less during their life cycle, and running them under higher loads / higher output, within their specifications, will generally not reduce the life expectancy (as in, run a 100HP rotary continually at 30 or 100, nearly the same running life).

But they will have a shorter overall lifespan. That large moving inner chamber and the outer chamber walls around it will wear down, and when they fail you replace a significant amount of that combustion chamber (or just junk the entire motor).

It's a neat application of the technology, and particularly in contexts where either the motor is going to run for long periods at a specific speed or not be used all the time, it could make a great option for power generation.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by busterarm on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:32AM (#9432548)
2nd Generation Turbo RX7 owner here. Rebuilt 13B engines before.

The reliability of the engine itself is way misunderstood. They aren't more or less reliable than any other engine (okay, they're way more reliable than Subaru engines...).

The problems are with heat and lubrication. The early RX8s had a flawed design. 2nd and 3rd Gen RX7s had problems with their OMPs and terrible electrical problems. 2nd gens have really weak alternators stock. Turbos usually fail before engines do.

Honestly the engine itself is awesome. Yes, if you lose a seal it will screw your engine (but usually the housings & rotors are salvageable). Piston engines throw rods and screw your whole car. If you bypass the OMP and run premix and actually do proper maintenance on your car, they will last. My 10AE has over 110k miles on it and has not blown up yet -- probably has another another 40k on it before it'll be ready for a rebuild. I still am on the stock OMP (it's an S4).

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by yason on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:42AM (#9433629)
My 10AE has over 110k miles on it and has not blown up yet -- probably has another another 40k on it before it'll be ready for a rebuild.

That's really low. I don't think I've ever bought a car with only 110k miles on it...

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by busterarm on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:44PM (#9434864)
Yeah, I really lucked into a low mileage car when I got it. Somebody had already restored it from being in bad shape before me -- saved me about 3 years of work and a lot of money.

The 10AE year was 1988...

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by snowwindwaves on Friday April 24, 2015 @11:58AM (#9434190)
in canada it is unusual to see cars with more than 300,000 km on them, so a vehicle with 176,000 km is more than half way to being really well used, not "really low" mileage.

I had a toyota land cruiser with 365,000km on rebuilt engine and 800,000 km on the body though.

Where do you live that 110k miles is low mileage? How many miles is a lot to you? How/why are people driving that much?

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by eric_h on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:26PM (#9434350)
> in canada it is unusual to see cars with more than 300,000 km on them

That's largely because of the need to salt roads in the canadian winters - yearly, excessive exposure to salt water drastically limits the possible lifetime of a car. The further away from cold weather requiring salted roadways you get, the longer cars last.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by snowwindwaves on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:39PM (#9434412)
So in developed countries that don't have icy winter roads most people are driving cars with more than 300,000 km on them?

I'm really curious where the parent lives that people are investing so much in the longevity of a vehicle. By the time they get to 300,000 km even if they aren't rusty they are usually 20 years old and things like drivetrain start to go and the vehicle is not worth the cost to keep up the required maintenance.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by rinon on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:33PM (#9434782)
I can attest that this is not unheard of in southern california. 1995 cars are driving all over the place. Cars seem to have a lifecycle where they get sold to poorer owners with more and more miles piling on, and only get junked when they are beyond repair. Even a 150-200k miles car is worthy of selling on craigslist (for super cheap of course, but there are plenty of buyers).

Now to be fair, SoCal has a rather unique and essential car culture, so this is probably an outlier as far as "most" cities go.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by mattlutze on Thursday April 30, 2015 @03:32AM (#9463735)
Yup. Even in snowy places -- my folks, siblings, friends all have cars running in Wisconsin that have at one point or another hit or crossed the 300,000km threshold. We had a Grand Caravan that looked pretty good when we finally traded it in at 350,000km.

Older cars, you keep them relatively clean and knock your boots before getting in so that the salt doesn't grind your carpets away, and replace things as they start to fail. A lot of older cars will just keep on chugging along.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by jccooper on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:32PM (#9434777)
Here in Texas, where the roads are clean and we drive a lot, cars with 300,000km (or, let's say, 200,000mi which is a similar milestone) certainly exist, but are somewhat unusual. But they're not worth much and likely nearing the retirement point from sheer age.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by leetNightshade on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:33PM (#9434786)
Even in developed countries people are driving their cars way over 300,000 km. Some cars are capable of over 482,803 km without major repairs needed. The Ford Crown Victoria comes to mind, the one used for police cars and taxes. I just read in a forum that police cars are used up to 643,738 km, at that point they're passed off to a taxi service for continued use. http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=show...

Not all places use salt, and even then if you get your car washed and underbody cleaned it should help the longevity of the car.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by eric_h on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:11PM (#9434637)
Certainly not most, but definitely more.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by leetNightshade on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:27PM (#9434749)
I live in the US, have lived in the following states: CT, NY, LA, and now CO. Almost all of my parents cars have over 210k miles on them and they're still going. My car has 114k miles on it and it runs perfectly, if all goes well it should easily hit 200k and beyond. Also, the next car I buy, if it's for under $3k used, I wouldn't mind it having 140k miles if it's a reliable car.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by msandford on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:13PM (#9434274)
> okay, they're way more reliable than Subaru engines...

Are Subaru engines really unreliable? I was under the impression that as long as you kept the power output under about 300 wheel horsepower that the entire drivetrain is pretty reliable.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by busterarm on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:43PM (#9434857)
Everything about Subarus are pretty bulletproof -- except the engine.

But you're mostly right. They will last if you leave the car 100% stock. Just don't modify them. Ever.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by mattlutze on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:43AM (#9432898)
This book[1] on the Wankel history considered 150k miles the life expectancy for the 13B, less than for previous motors.

They're really cool motors, I'm in that boat with you. How they work means forced-induction doesn't necessarily impact engine life the same way FI on piston/crankshaft motors. That the piston motor is just going to last longer not needing or before it needs major restoration.

A mildly interesting point is that heat isn't an easily mitigated factor, unless we're talking the exact use cases in the OP article -- generators, which run in a very controlled RPM band. Same when we talk about UAV engines or other electricity-generation applications. So, you can engineer the motor to be efficient at those rotation speeds WRT heat management and fuel efficiency.

1: https://books.google.de/books?id=IB2lMFqTTl8C&pg=PA117&lpg=P...

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by caboteria on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:37AM (#9432856)
Glad to see their longevity is improved. I had a '74 RX-4 and the conventional wisdom at the time was that you'd get 70-80k miles before you'd lose compression on one of your tip seals. My dad got 80k on the first motor so we weren't too bummed. We changed the motor for a new one and it was still going strong when the body rusted away so badly it wasn't worth fixing. Fun car, though.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by geoelectric on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:23PM (#9435131)
IIRC, the turbo issue was the usual one around heat stress, and a turbo timer went a long way towards easing that.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by x0054 on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:37PM (#9435589)
From Another Article: The compact design of LiquidPiston's lab engine currently tips the scales at 80 lbs for the 40-hp model. It would weigh less than 50 lbs in production, the company claims, far less than a comparable 40-hp diesel that would tip the scale at around 400 lbs. [1]

How on earth do you get a 400lb diesel engine that ONLY produces 40HP. First, when comparing engines for power production, you should really talk about kW production capability, not HP. Engine's HP is only half the story, you also have to talk about it's torque.

I know rotary engines are a cool technology, but something about this smells like BS.

[1]http://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/a8174/liquidpistons-hyp...

Edit: citation added

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by NickNameNick on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:43PM (#9436556)
If they're talking about a generator that's expected to run at its peak power all the time, then I'd expect it to be heavier than an automotive engine that only hits peak power intermittently.

and 40 hp is 29.8kW. they're both measures of power. you don't need to know the torque to make the conversion.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by dietrichepp on Friday April 24, 2015 @05:50AM (#9432231)
The efficiency is mentioned, but I don't see any numbers telling how efficient it is, which is what I really wanted to hear. (Just numbers about how small it is.)
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by Aoyagi on Friday April 24, 2015 @06:25AM (#9432337)
The cycle, which combines high compression ratio (CR), constant-volume (isochoric) combustion, and overexpansion, has a theoretical efficiency of 75% using air-standard assumptions and first-law analysis. This innovative rotary engine architecture shows a potential indicated efficiency of 60% and brake efficiency of >50%.

From http://liquidpiston.com/technology/technical-papers/

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by aidenn0 on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:17PM (#9434299)
Linked PM article has liquid piston targeting mid-50%s for their first engine.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by negativity on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:01PM (#9434558)
This is a version of a Wankel Engine, right?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine

Originally invented and patented way back in 1929.

Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by tim333 on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:52PM (#9434910)
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by jccooper on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:09PM (#9434627)
Similar concept, different geometry. It's almost like an inverse Wankel. Perhaps this geometry is easier to handle wrt seals and lubrication. The points of the Wankel triangular rotor have always been difficult.
Re:Efficient Rotary Engine Lands Million-Dollar Darpa Contract by raverbashing on Friday April 24, 2015 @04:48AM (#9432087)
A better chance at Darpa than selling it to the doofuses at the big motor companies, where it would certainly be shelved.