News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by mitchell_h on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @12:31PM (#9421579)
Could someone point out where what this guy did was illegal? The guy simply outsmarted the algo traders by acting like he was going to push his chips in, than yanked them back. How exactly is that illegal? And if it is illegal why is the FCM allowing it? Even more so, how is it legal for people to see what he MIGHT do?

This feels like a whole lot of sour grapes by the big boys. They're pissed because someone figured out their weakness.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by ikeboy on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @12:41PM (#9421654)
The complaint http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/opa/press-release...

lists which exact laws he's accused of breaking on the first page.

See also http://www.law360.com/articles/622358/feds-say-spoofing-law-...

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by bko on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @12:42PM (#9421666)
Spoofing was made explicitly illegal under Dodd-Frank and is placing orders with the intent of cancelling them before execution.

Generally its hard to prove intent. You can place an order and cancel it after new information becomes made available or your needs change.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by tptacek on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:18PM (#9421929)
Placing orders that can't execute has apparently been verboten long before Dodd-Frank.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by jonpaine on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @12:48PM (#9421692)
There's a technical answer, but more simply, you answered your own question: you can't push your chips in and then yank them back.

Try that at a poker table - yes, you'll "outsmart" the other players by being able to see their reaction. You'll also instantly break the integrity of the game, because you're not outsmarting them, you're breaking the rules that allow the game/market to actually function.

For a market to function properly that integrity that an order on the books is in good faith is vital. Of course, it's up to the SEC to enforce that.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by ryandvm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:16PM (#9421917)
I think he was making the point that if something is permitted by the "rules of the game", then by definition, it cannot be a violation of the rules. And in the case of financial transactions APIs, the rules should exist as application logic. So if you're not supposed to place and immediately cancel an order, it should simply not be possible.

I could certainly believe that if it was one of the large HFTs doing this, they would have had the necessary wheel-grease to not get in trouble...

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by kasey_junk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:38PM (#9423382)
Placing and immediately canceling an order is fine and allowed (though doing that too much is penalized for other reasons).

Spoofing is pulling them out in a coordinated fashion before they can be put at risk with no intention of them ever trading.

The problem is that an api that prevented that would also prevent legitimate cancels that would have side effects that could be bad (ie making it riskier to make markets and therefore increase the bid/ask spread).

Spoofing is about intention. Intention cannot be determined by algorithm (yet).

Also to your point about a big HFT not being subject to this. Allston trading is a large HFT market maker that is currently in arbitration over spoofing.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by tptacek on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:20PM (#9421948)
You can totally push your chips in and yank them back. What you can't do is pretend to push your chips in, such that it is almost impossible to ever lose them, to bluff other players without taking any meaningful risk.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @03:55PM (#9423116)
And these were real orders with real risk, so...
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by kasey_junk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:34PM (#9423359)
So we only have a pattern of behavior and any communications about said behavior to determine intent.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by loup-vaillant on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:26PM (#9421991)
But but but, how come it is even possible to yank your chips back? It would be so easy to force those orders to stay for a minimum amount of time.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by kasey_junk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:35PM (#9423365)
That wouldn't prevent spoofing. Lots of spoofers put orders in over the course of a long time. Its when/why they pull them out in coordinated fashion that the intention becomes clear.
Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by loup-vaillant on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:29PM (#9423709)
Still: if someone tries to buy an order, the transaction is automatically accepted, and the seller can do nothing about it.

Right? Right?

Don't tell me one can withdraw an order after it has been established that someone else is trying to buy it? That would be way too easy to abuse. "Oh, someone actually wants my stuff? Sorry, I just happened to change my mind."

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by kasey_junk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @06:26PM (#9423984)
No you can't do that.

Spoofing is really nuanced and analogies make it difficult. Usually spoofers will put orders in the back of the order book where they feel they can cancel them before anyone can realistically get to them. But they are in the order book, so they are "technically" at risk of being fulfilled.

Thats why intent is so important.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by timdaub on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:10PM (#9421874)
Thanks for pointing out. I feel the exact same way about it.

What is wrong in tricking stupid bots in the market? Lets not forget, it was a flash crash, meaning that if only emotional, slow humans would have been trading this thing, it would probably have never happened (at least not in these proportions).

Pretty far fetched to make one small guy responsible for a conceptual problem in the system.

Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010 by neurotech1 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @01:32PM (#9422036)
I think it was that this guy traded to "cause" instability, by placing bogus futures trades that were basically the value of the entire order book for those futures.

If you have a Level II stock data feed, you can view the order book for particular stocks, and similar data is available for futures from CME group.

As an example, a friend of mine day trades Tesla stock (& options) and basically a swing trade, has figured out if the stock cycles down by a few cents, and they put a relatively large order at a certain price. The market sees the trade with a higher price and the stock increases. This has resulted in some large profits for swing trades, somewhat due to believing in Tesla's fundamentals and in Elon Musk. Some institutional investors don't share my friends views, and trade Tesla stock down. It is legal because the trade was made in good faith, and not trying to "deceive" the market using bogus trades.

In traditional HFT, the legal justification for fast trades that in some cases were never intended to be filled, is murky at best. As long as the market stays reasonably stable and the big boys profit, the complaints are somewhat muted.

A friend in the same group, who also trades Tesla, was on the console during the flash crash. It was "obvious" that these automated trade bots were unloading, and there was not major news (eg. GM bankruptcy) to justify the sudden price drop in specific stocks. Her console showed "black swan" type data, and she switched to an option trade as stocks caught up in the flash event wouldn't stay down for long. The options that were "out of the money" (almost worthless) became valuable when the stocks rebounded.

What caused the actual flash crash (triggered by futures trades or not) was a phenomenon called "exponential backoff" with a large automated trading bot closing out its trades, triggered by stocks below a certain price, causing downward pressure on the stocks, and the market. Another automated trade bot sees this, and also closes out its position. This automated close out then occurs exponentially, and the market goes into a "death spiral" crash.

Note: I do not own stock in Tesla. I'm not a stock broker and this is not investment advice.