Re:Guy trading at home caused the flash crash of 2010
by kasey_junk on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:38PM
(#9423382)
Placing and immediately canceling an order is fine and allowed (though doing that too much is penalized for other reasons).
Spoofing is pulling them out in a coordinated fashion before they can be put at risk with no intention of them ever trading.
The problem is that an api that prevented that would also prevent legitimate cancels that would have side effects that could be bad (ie making it riskier to make markets and therefore increase the bid/ask spread).
Spoofing is about intention. Intention cannot be determined by algorithm (yet).
Also to your point about a big HFT not being subject to this. Allston trading is a large HFT market maker that is currently in arbitration over spoofing.
I could certainly believe that if it was one of the large HFTs doing this, they would have had the necessary wheel-grease to not get in trouble...