News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by lordlarm on Sunday April 19, 2015 @08:11AM (#9402860)
Although this perhaps makes sense from a technical, maintenance and cost perspective it's, contrary to the NRK owned radio.no's opinion, an absolute horrible deal for a large part of the users.

«55 per cent of households have at least one DAB radio, according to Digitalradio survey by TNS Gallup», which leaves 45% not currently having access to a DAB radio. Many of the having _one_ radio has this in their home and perhaps not in their most important place: the car.

In order to elegantly implement a DAB radio in your car you need to attach a dongle to your window and run cables into a (sometimes) new radio altogether. Whilst this may be a simple procedure for _some_ it's for the vast majority a huge burden - both in terms of time and money (often costing around 3000NOK - 380USD).

It's well and fine that they started the implementation of DAB in Norway in the mid-90s, but it's just in recent times that we've seen cars come with DAB reception by default. They should at least wait until 80-90% of all cars have access to DAB before switching over - which could take I'm guessing up to 10 years.

This is like only supporting Chrome on important governmental sites - which would rightly cause an uproar on HN. Radio should be about accessibility and content, not the medium - which should change naturally and over time.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by goodmachine on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:24AM (#9403033)
Bad luck, Norway.

The UK is in a roughly similar position, but our govt is unlikely to switch off FM until 2020-ish at the earliest (was 2015, then 2018... now "whenevs").

It's sad to consider how governments foisted DAB on listeners exclusively for the benefit of state broadcasters - the list of fails is extensive here: DAB gives you demonstrably worse reception, poorer sound quality, more expensive hardware, added costs to replace old hardware, added costs to run (4x power consumption), etc.

The magic carrot of 'more channels/ more choice' thing never happened either: thus, a bum deal all round.

I would guess the upside for broadcasters (cheaper infrastructure, more listeners) may have been significantly overstated too.

http://www.theguardian.com/media/2014/sep/25/digital-radio-s...

http://www.theguardian.com/media/2013/dec/16/digital-radio-s...

24 problems with DAB (2010)

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2010/apr/12/dab-r...

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by rootsofallevil on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:57AM (#9403366)
I remember a few years back being dismayed when I plugged my brand new DAB radio into my Kill-A-Watt and rather than register nothing like the FM radio that it was substituting, it was showing ~ 4 W, going up to ~ 6 W when playing.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by synx508 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:05AM (#9403399)
Not enough is being said about this, there are still no really energy efficient receivers and on a per-station basis DAB is also a lot more expensive to transmit. DAB only becomes energy efficient at the transmitter end because it's always transmitting a multiplex of many stations.

A few years ago I bought a battery-powered DAB radio so I can listen to Radio 4 in the bath. It will zip through a set of high capacity AA NiMH cells in around 2-3 weeks, the old FM radio used such a small amount of power that Alkaline cells made more sense and would consume around two sets per year.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by kristofferR on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:32AM (#9403059)
Thankfully the "more channels/ more choice" actually happened in Norway. However - apart from that, DAB is a bad deal.

Right now it's become a typical "we can't stop right in the middle, so let's continue forward full speed"-situation. So much has been invested in DAB in Norway that stopping the transition would be just as expensive, if not more so.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by scholia on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:47AM (#9403108)
If DAB was a modern technology that might make sense. However, it was developed in the 1990s around the MP2 codec. It's roughly as old as the web.

You'd not choose DAB if you were doing digital radio today.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by kristofferR on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:52AM (#9403119)
Norway is using DAB+, which is based on the modern HE-AAC codec. We were going to use the old MP2-based DAB, but switched to DAB+ pretty quickly.

Right now most channels are being transmitted in either DAB or DAB+ (DAB+ devices can receive both), but DAB+ is the future and DAB is going away. It's going to suck for the early DAB adopters though, who's soon going to be left with incompatible radios.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by justincormack on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:19AM (#9403208)
Early DAB adopters is the UK - we do not have DAB+ and no plans to introduce it. It is a mess.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by mbrutsch on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:36AM (#9403073)
DAB vendors and implementors should profit nicely, though.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by caf on Sunday April 19, 2015 @08:33AM (#9402917)
Right - I think this stat is the killer one right now:

  - 20 % of private cars are equipped with DAB radio
Surely the car the last redoubt of radio.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by scholia on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:42AM (#9403098)
Not just the car but the mobile phone.

Most phones in Europe* (not just smartphones) can get FM radio, because including it adds nothing to the cost. DAB, by contrast, costs too much and uses too much power to be included in phones.

So, Norway is not just giving up on car users, it is also giving up on mobile phone users, ie the next generation of potential radio listeners.

* Most US smartphones also include FM radios, because it's a standard element of radio (FM, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth) chips. However, FM is often disabled by the manufacturer (eg Apple) or by the carrier.

See http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2015/04/16/400178... and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7DoPkkDFjM

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by legulere on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:57AM (#9403134)
Most of the time the antenna is missing for the fm radio
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by izacus on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:08AM (#9403169)
Um, no, the headphones act as an antenna.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by narrowrail on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:47AM (#9403319)
The relevant pin still needs a trace from the chip to the headphone port, which is what I think was meant.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by scholia on Monday April 20, 2015 @09:07AM (#9407766)
Which is almost always there, because phones need to sell in -- and to work in -- hundreds of different countries. The US is not typical of the rest of the world.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by Tomte on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:55AM (#9403356)
Nope, most mobile phones here don't have FM reception. Not the iPhone, not most Android phones. Mostly the Lumia ones and few select others.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by userbinator on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:07AM (#9403404)
Actually the vast majority of unbranded/generic Android smartphones - which make up a significant userbase in East Asia - have FM radios. Some of them have FM transmitters too.

As the grandparent comment says, it's because the combo IC includes the functionality; here's an example of one that's quite common:

http://www.mediatek.com/en/products/connectivity/wifi/mobile...

Many of these handsets are based on the MTK reference platform, and since that includes the FM radio app, the companies that produce them see no reason to remove it - after all, it allows them to have "FM radio" as one of the bullet points in the feature list.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by mason240 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:21AM (#9403465)
Actually most android phones DO have FM radios, but they are disabled by the carrier-branded versions of the OS.

I'm pretty sure the reason they do it is because they have deals with iHeart Radio.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by Tomte on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:04PM (#9403632)
Honestly, the customer doesn't care if the chip supports it. The out-of-the-box experience of´the vast majority of mobile phones (excluding Lumia and some dumb phones – I forgot those) is simply: no FM radio.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by scholia on Monday April 20, 2015 @09:14AM (#9407802)
Actually, the vast majority of mobile phones do have built-in FM. That might not be true in the US, but it is certainly true of the the vast majority of mobile phones worldwide.

More likely: most US mobile phones not made by Apple also have FM, but the carriers block it. Hence http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2015/04/16/400178...

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by thrownaway122 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:19PM (#9403682)
Android user here (with a carrier phone). It has FM radio. As does every one I've ever seen. It's so basic that it's a widget for the homescreen rather than an app. This may be why you missed it...
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by ptaipale on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:23PM (#9403700)
That is strange. Fairly close to Norway, the market is different: I would say almost all phones in Finland have FM radios, except iPhones. Lumias have them, most Androids have them (except Galaxy S4), and all the Nokia S40 and Symbian phones have them.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by reitanqild on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:58PM (#9403832)
Just checked my Z3. It has.

My old Note II had too.

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by kristofferR on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:37AM (#9403077)
Actually not, only 23% of the time spent listening to the radio in Norway is while driving:

http://radio.no/2015/03/en-fjerdedel-av-lyttingen-skjer-i-bi... (Norwegian article)

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by acjohnson55 on Sunday April 19, 2015 @08:19AM (#9402881)
Yeah, it's kind of surprising that they didn't mandate inclusion of DAB-capable radios in cars years earlier. Had they done that, it seems like the consumers would be much more prepared for a hard switch. This sounds like it's going to be pretty disruptive.

Also, why do the radios require a dongle?

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by scholia on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:29AM (#9403047)
Some of the converters essentially receive DAB and then convert it to FM to rebroadcast it to your current car radio.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by legulere on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:55AM (#9403129)
That seems pretty similar to the situation when analog sattelite TV was shut down. You always have a big amount that will only switch over when the old standard gets shut down. Why else should they if the old standard is good enough for them?
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by izacus on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:07AM (#9403165)
Do you actually think people will buy a new 15.000+EUR car just to get a digital radio in it? Most of reasonably modern cars don't really have user replacable headunits (and even if you do replace it, you usually lose all stalk and display functionality).
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by jkot on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:16AM (#9403198)
Plus many people wont upgrade, because internet is just fine. It is replacing obsolete technology with slightly less obsolete technology.
Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by kristofferR on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:21AM (#9403024)
> Radio should be about accessibility and content, not the medium - which should change naturally and over time.

That is actually the main argument in favor of DAB. The FM space in Norway only has space for 5 nationally broadcasted channels, DAB has space for 40 (22 already used).

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by keenerd on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:07PM (#9403863)
> The FM space in Norway only has space for 5 nationally broadcasted channels

This is not correct. Norway has just as large an FM segment as every other country in the world and could have just as many channels. They simply manage the spectrum questionably. DAB+ will not help that.

http://eng.nkom.no/technical/broadcast/analog-radio/fm-radio...

Re:Norway to switch off FM in 2017 by cagenut on Sunday April 19, 2015 @09:16AM (#9403009)
This isn't like a full blown counter-argument, but a pattern I like to look for whenever there's debate on some kind of public policy change is if the 'anti' side is predominately an argument for the status quo of car culture.

To me this is the real climate change denial-ism. Not the abstract argument over whether its real or not, but the steady stream of personal and political decisions people make to prioritize car culture over X.