Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by chriskanan on Sunday April 12, 2015 @12:23PM
(#9363816)
Jones and Weinberg noticed that even though scientists are beginning their careers at a later age, they’re ending their careers at about the same age as their predecessors. Today's great minds are productive for a shorter period of time than they were a century ago.
I wonder what hypotheses there are for why scientists a century ago were able to be productive earlier. The paper has a few hypotheses that they think are plausible:
(1) Distance to the knowledge frontier is rising. Older scientists only needed to know fields A, B, and C to attack D, but to attack E, newer scientists needed to know A, B, C, and D. This is the hypothesis they think is most likely, and they give evidence showing that the age of patent holders and the team size involved in patents has also been increasing.
(2) May be harder to get resources to do research now. One has to establish a reputation to win grants to do innovative research, and that takes time. Did research cost less a century ago?
My own question: How often does the student that does the Nobel prize winning work win the prize versus it only going to the PI? The involvement of the PI varies wildly. For example, Jocelyn Bell and Antony Hewish wrote the paper that revealed pulsars, but only Hewish (Bell's advisor) won the Nobel prize, although Bell made the initial discovery (Hewish had her looking for quasars with the radio telescope).
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by caseysoftware on Sunday April 12, 2015 @03:55PM
(#9364542)
Maybe I missed it, but I'm surprised the article didn't go into the fact that the process for getting into the field is getting longer. I don't just mean the time to acquire facts & context (that is mentioned).
I mean specifically the fact that earning a PHD takes longer now and postdoc programs eat up quite a few more years. And both are trending up.
This was mentioned in an article a couple months ago pointing out that many of the best & brightest miss the common childrearing years in favor of their professional development.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by streptomycin on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:06PM
(#9363969)
Watson and Crick were a young postdoc and a PhD student. If credit went to the PI in that case, it would have gone to Bragg who was the head of the lab they worked in.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by ninguem2 on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:18PM
(#9364027)
"Head of lab" is not appropriate. The Cavendish Laboratory (which Bragg indeed headed) is/was the equivalent of a whole department or institute (of experimental physics, chemistry and biology). The head of the actual lab that they worked for, who was Watson postdoctoral mentor and Crick's PhD advisor, was Max Perutz.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by hga on Sunday April 12, 2015 @12:46PM
(#9363889)
This is one of the critical details:
Still, there is hope. “New ideas sometimes serve as revolutions,” Jones and Weinberg comment. Revolutions tend to favor the young. The average age-at-discovery, in physics, took a dip at the beginning of the century. This is where Einstein came in, who published his general theory of relativity at 26, and Dirac, who wrote the “fever chill” poem. They attribute this to the impact of quantum mechanics at the beginning of the century, when “the entire worldview of physics changed”
There's a highly recommended books, Thirty Years that Shook Physics: The Story of Quantum Theory (http://www.amazon.com/Thirty-Years-that-Shook-Physics/dp/048...) that in part explains what's happened in the last century and a quarter or so. That amazing 30 years of course produced a rash of Nobels, and in the other Nobel fields then enabled further Noble research, e.g. the 20th Century's preeminent chemist, Linus Pauling, got his Ph.D. at an opportune time for him to do his postdoc work in Europe, and then apply the developing quantum theory to his field.
Molecular genetics, particularly the elucidation of DNA, also resulted in a truly wild ride for a few decades, something I got a feel of when I started doing it in 1977.
Now, a lot of scientists are in Feynman's position, in a time where there's lots of known stuff out there, but achievable Nobel worthy research is less obvious to everyone, including those awarding the prizes.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by littletimmy on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:25PM
(#9364056)
Let's say that nobel prize winning scientists are getting older because scientists need to accumulate much more information to be productive.
Doesn't it follow naturally that there will come a point where science will practically be limited by the human lifespan? As in, there is so much one has to learn before being a productive researcher that there simply isn't enough time to learn it?
His finding was that science works by accretion of facts, except that over time, a number of facts that don't fit the established theory build up. Eventually, this reaches a crisis point where you realize that the current models are unable to explain reality, and then they get thrown out (a "paradigm shift") and everything needs to be figured out again from first principles. At this point, younger scientists have the advantage, because the "knowledge frontier" contracts back to nothing (almost...the new theory still has to account for old experimental results).
The last major paradigm shift in physics was a century ago, with the twin discoveries of relativity and quantum mechanics. You could probably argue that we're due for another one soon - the weight of evidence that our understanding of the universe is flawed has been building up, with unexplained results around dark matter/dark energy/cosmology and the failure of superstring theory to make accurate testable predictions. It's pretty likely that within our lifetime physics may become a hot place for brilliant 20-somethings again.
But in the meantime, most of the action has been in computing. The field of practical applications of computer science has been undergoing a paradigm shift approximately every 10 years (wasn't yesterday's top Hacker News story about that?), hence why we see so many young tech billionaires.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by nostrademons on Sunday April 12, 2015 @09:14PM
(#9365441)
Tesla's battery technology arguably represents a paradigm shift in how batteries work. At least, they reportedly re-envisioned it from first principles. Tesla has chosen to keep this technology proprietary and make lots of money off of it rather than publish it, but it's not unlikely that it represents some serious original research.
How much of that is done by Musk himself is debatable. One of my pet peeves about the Musk fan-club is that he tends to partner with some very brilliant engineers and then get all the credit for the work they do. However, people high up in his companies (more than one of them) have said that he involves himself very extensively in discovering the technology itself, and his bachelors and the first couple years of his Ph.D were both in physics, so it seems likely that he does at least know the science behind what his companies do.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by amit_m on Monday April 13, 2015 @05:56PM
(#9370778)
That's engineering, not physics. There is a lot of chemistry research that goes into battery technology, but AFAIK Tesla's batteries use tried-and-proven lithium ion tech.
Also, he dropped out of his Ph.D. on the first week. So it appears that he didn't learn too much physics in academia. Rocketry and electric cars don't involve too much advanced physics and he has top notch experts working for him in all the relevant fields.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by drawkbox on Sunday April 12, 2015 @03:43PM
(#9364512)
> Doesn't it follow naturally that there will come a point where science will practically be limited by the human lifespan? As in, there is so much one has to learn before being a productive researcher that there simply isn't enough time to learn it?
It already happens and I think this is where AI and robotics play a big part. They will essentially evolve us in thinking as our lives will become too short to gain all the knowledge needed and they will pass the information better while connecting many more dots that can only be seen from a higher macro perspective from a longer life.
A 500 year old AI knowledge bank and study (evolving with time) will be no match for a 70-80 year life in the field. AI will be the great thinking age even though we won't be doing most of it. Yes we have this now with records and digital data but correlation will get more difficult and so much gets lost from age to age. Additionally, a single lifetime will be throttled with AI that can really match or exceed human capability. AI and smarter computers will be our turbo button on science.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by alan-crowe on Sunday April 12, 2015 @06:30PM
(#9364980)
I imagine it working the other way round. There is a great deal to learn before you can make progress on general purpose artificial intelligence. Humans may be unable to code up a general purpose AI because the human life span is too short.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by Jochim on Sunday April 12, 2015 @08:45PM
(#9365342)
I disagree that we'd be limited by human life span. I think rather that we'd see us moving away from individuals making "breakthrough discoveries" to progress eventually being something that might take multiple generations of work and research by large numbers of people working together on a problem.
We also have to keep in mind that once something has been discovered, it generally takes a lot less time to learn than it did for the person discovering it.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by rifung on Sunday April 12, 2015 @02:00PM
(#9364182)
This is a good question, but I don't think this will necessarily happen for two reasons.
1) With more scientific advances we will hopefully be able to live longer
2) The better we understand a field, the more we can compress and simplify it and have an easier time teaching it. At least this appears to be the case in mathematics, where I can only imagine many years ago something like trigonometry was not well understood and the greatest mathematicians of the time did research to further our understanding of it, but now it's something we're expected to learn in high school. I can only imagine this will happen as well to the current topics of research as well.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by pa5tabear on Sunday April 12, 2015 @02:31PM
(#9364293)
Yes, but perhaps computers can also accelerate the rate of learning in the right hands. Especially as we become better at interfacing with them, the knowledge of the cloud can be viewed as an extension of the mind and only the most key concepts need be learned in detail.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by cflyingdutchman on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:56PM
(#9364166)
Yes. (If a number of big assumptions hold). I've written this blog post in my head a bunch of times and will write it for real soon. There's a fun (very loose) parallel with the expansion of our physical universe.
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by Someone on Sunday April 12, 2015 @07:05PM
(#9365075)
Specializing earlier would help more. Does a would-be physicist need to spend time reading Shakespeare, learning piano playing? A would-be football player spend time learning to read, other than the code of playbooks? (Yes, truly optimizing for career intensity may imply making choices that do not feel right, ethically)
Also, being better at predicting talent will help in the sense that more people will manage to reach the frontier of science. Having some strong driving force that forces children to take the necessary tests and follow their predictions will further increase that number.
However, neither would help to lengthen one's career substantially. The best one can win is 25% or so (20 years on a 80 year life span)
Re:Why Nobel-Winning Scientists Are Getting Older
by MisterBastahrd on Sunday April 12, 2015 @07:28PM
(#9365133)
They're also getting older because we've had ground-breaking discoveries that took years, if not decades, before we had adequate technology to do anything with them.
I wonder what hypotheses there are for why scientists a century ago were able to be productive earlier. The paper has a few hypotheses that they think are plausible:
(1) Distance to the knowledge frontier is rising. Older scientists only needed to know fields A, B, and C to attack D, but to attack E, newer scientists needed to know A, B, C, and D. This is the hypothesis they think is most likely, and they give evidence showing that the age of patent holders and the team size involved in patents has also been increasing.
(2) May be harder to get resources to do research now. One has to establish a reputation to win grants to do innovative research, and that takes time. Did research cost less a century ago?
My own question: How often does the student that does the Nobel prize winning work win the prize versus it only going to the PI? The involvement of the PI varies wildly. For example, Jocelyn Bell and Antony Hewish wrote the paper that revealed pulsars, but only Hewish (Bell's advisor) won the Nobel prize, although Bell made the initial discovery (Hewish had her looking for quasars with the radio telescope).
I mean specifically the fact that earning a PHD takes longer now and postdoc programs eat up quite a few more years. And both are trending up.
This was mentioned in an article a couple months ago pointing out that many of the best & brightest miss the common childrearing years in favor of their professional development.
The whole "publish-or-perish" game, the difficulty to get a foot in the door at all levels, etc.
Still, there is hope. “New ideas sometimes serve as revolutions,” Jones and Weinberg comment. Revolutions tend to favor the young. The average age-at-discovery, in physics, took a dip at the beginning of the century. This is where Einstein came in, who published his general theory of relativity at 26, and Dirac, who wrote the “fever chill” poem. They attribute this to the impact of quantum mechanics at the beginning of the century, when “the entire worldview of physics changed”
There's a highly recommended books, Thirty Years that Shook Physics: The Story of Quantum Theory (http://www.amazon.com/Thirty-Years-that-Shook-Physics/dp/048...) that in part explains what's happened in the last century and a quarter or so. That amazing 30 years of course produced a rash of Nobels, and in the other Nobel fields then enabled further Noble research, e.g. the 20th Century's preeminent chemist, Linus Pauling, got his Ph.D. at an opportune time for him to do his postdoc work in Europe, and then apply the developing quantum theory to his field.
Molecular genetics, particularly the elucidation of DNA, also resulted in a truly wild ride for a few decades, something I got a feel of when I started doing it in 1977.
Now, a lot of scientists are in Feynman's position, in a time where there's lots of known stuff out there, but achievable Nobel worthy research is less obvious to everyone, including those awarding the prizes.
EDIT: I have put in first 10 Turing awards in the sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fTaSlme8EBJAAYWWjBh_... In case someone wants to join to complete the rest :)
Doesn't it follow naturally that there will come a point where science will practically be limited by the human lifespan? As in, there is so much one has to learn before being a productive researcher that there simply isn't enough time to learn it?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Rev...
His finding was that science works by accretion of facts, except that over time, a number of facts that don't fit the established theory build up. Eventually, this reaches a crisis point where you realize that the current models are unable to explain reality, and then they get thrown out (a "paradigm shift") and everything needs to be figured out again from first principles. At this point, younger scientists have the advantage, because the "knowledge frontier" contracts back to nothing (almost...the new theory still has to account for old experimental results).
The last major paradigm shift in physics was a century ago, with the twin discoveries of relativity and quantum mechanics. You could probably argue that we're due for another one soon - the weight of evidence that our understanding of the universe is flawed has been building up, with unexplained results around dark matter/dark energy/cosmology and the failure of superstring theory to make accurate testable predictions. It's pretty likely that within our lifetime physics may become a hot place for brilliant 20-somethings again.
But in the meantime, most of the action has been in computing. The field of practical applications of computer science has been undergoing a paradigm shift approximately every 10 years (wasn't yesterday's top Hacker News story about that?), hence why we see so many young tech billionaires.
How much of that is done by Musk himself is debatable. One of my pet peeves about the Musk fan-club is that he tends to partner with some very brilliant engineers and then get all the credit for the work they do. However, people high up in his companies (more than one of them) have said that he involves himself very extensively in discovering the technology itself, and his bachelors and the first couple years of his Ph.D were both in physics, so it seems likely that he does at least know the science behind what his companies do.
Also, he dropped out of his Ph.D. on the first week. So it appears that he didn't learn too much physics in academia. Rocketry and electric cars don't involve too much advanced physics and he has top notch experts working for him in all the relevant fields.
It already happens and I think this is where AI and robotics play a big part. They will essentially evolve us in thinking as our lives will become too short to gain all the knowledge needed and they will pass the information better while connecting many more dots that can only be seen from a higher macro perspective from a longer life.
A 500 year old AI knowledge bank and study (evolving with time) will be no match for a 70-80 year life in the field. AI will be the great thinking age even though we won't be doing most of it. Yes we have this now with records and digital data but correlation will get more difficult and so much gets lost from age to age. Additionally, a single lifetime will be throttled with AI that can really match or exceed human capability. AI and smarter computers will be our turbo button on science.
We also have to keep in mind that once something has been discovered, it generally takes a lot less time to learn than it did for the person discovering it.
1) With more scientific advances we will hopefully be able to live longer 2) The better we understand a field, the more we can compress and simplify it and have an easier time teaching it. At least this appears to be the case in mathematics, where I can only imagine many years ago something like trigonometry was not well understood and the greatest mathematicians of the time did research to further our understanding of it, but now it's something we're expected to learn in high school. I can only imagine this will happen as well to the current topics of research as well.
Also, being better at predicting talent will help in the sense that more people will manage to reach the frontier of science. Having some strong driving force that forces children to take the necessary tests and follow their predictions will further increase that number.
However, neither would help to lengthen one's career substantially. The best one can win is 25% or so (20 years on a 80 year life span)