News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by modeless on Monday November 09, 2009 @12:51PM (#931357)
"Our revenues are down millions of dollars because we don't have the patent" and the royalty stream that would have resulted, he said. "We have no market power. That's the essence of it. You can't protect your interests." He said competitors have entered the market, and utilities themselves have "reverse-engineered" WeatherWise processes

You mean you can't get a government-backed monopoly on your product, so you actually have to compete?! With competitors who charge lower prices?! Cry me a river.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by ovi256 on Monday November 09, 2009 @01:20PM (#931408)
With competitors that do not have their liability of having funded years of research to advance the field, but have simply copied the idea after, often by reverse-engineering, as the TFA states.
Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by jacquesm on Monday November 09, 2009 @01:30PM (#931432)
Which is proof positive that it does not warrant a patent, since apparently having access to the input and the output data is enough to re-create the box in the middle.

Besides that, such a big fuss over being able to 'bill a constant amount' month-to-month, it really is nothing but a business method, no matter how intricate the computations behind the scenes.

It's a convenience at best, and one that I would assume would be re-creatable by any number of mathematicians given the assignment.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by timwiseman on Monday November 09, 2009 @05:07PM (#931849)
It's a convenience at best, and one that I would assume would be re-creatable by any number of mathematicians given the assignment.

But just about any patentable idea is recreatable by experts in that field if they are given that assignment. I do not claim to know whether or not this particular patent should have been granted, but I do not see why the fact that it can reverse engineered should be relevant.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by jacquesm on Monday November 09, 2009 @05:16PM (#931865)
Reverse-engineering and writing a spec is one of the ways you can legally get around trade secrets and copyright infringement claims, so if the patent does not stand it is very relevant indeed.

Clean room development is usually (but not always) not enough to get around a patent though.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by timwiseman on Monday November 09, 2009 @06:02PM (#931958)
I must be misunderstanding something.

I know that clean room implementation has been used to avoid trade secret and copyright claims, but that seems to have little relevance in this case. If anything, it seems to somewhat show the need to have a patent protect developments like this.

Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F... by jacquesm on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @03:53AM (#932707)
I think it argues the exact opposite, if your device can simply be reverse engineered by observing the inputs and outputs then it shouldn't be patentable.

That means you can treat it as a black box without any knowledge of what is going on inside and produce an identical black box with a possibly completely different implementation on the inside.

These guys are essentially trying to patent something that can be expressed as a mathematical formula, and in my opinion that should not be possible.

Reduce it to an absurdity, imagine the patent on 'Pi' or a patent on calculus. Does it seem 'right' to you that such a thing should be patentable ?

If any group of mathematicians skilled in the art could come up with it that alone should have been grounds for dismissal, just being the first should not give you an automatic entitlement.