Re:A Math Geek's Ride to the High Court in Landmark Patent F...
by jacquesm on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @03:53AM
(#932707)
I think it argues the exact opposite, if your device can simply be reverse engineered by observing the inputs and outputs then it shouldn't be patentable.
That means you can treat it as a black box without any knowledge of what is going on inside and produce an identical black box with a possibly completely different implementation on the inside.
These guys are essentially trying to patent something that can be expressed as a mathematical formula, and in my opinion that should not be possible.
Reduce it to an absurdity, imagine the patent on 'Pi' or a patent on calculus. Does it seem 'right' to you that such a thing should be patentable ?
If any group of mathematicians skilled in the art could come up with it that alone should have been grounds for dismissal, just being the first should not give you an automatic entitlement.
That means you can treat it as a black box without any knowledge of what is going on inside and produce an identical black box with a possibly completely different implementation on the inside.
These guys are essentially trying to patent something that can be expressed as a mathematical formula, and in my opinion that should not be possible.
Reduce it to an absurdity, imagine the patent on 'Pi' or a patent on calculus. Does it seem 'right' to you that such a thing should be patentable ?
If any group of mathematicians skilled in the art could come up with it that alone should have been grounds for dismissal, just being the first should not give you an automatic entitlement.