Isn't that what is happening now, with some of the bright people who work at the NSA?
You're stuck with another guy. You're both better off if you both cooperate. But individually you're better off if you betray the other guy. In that situation it's really, really hard to arrange cooperation.
The US and USSR would have been better off if they could have put a halt to the madness. But if one stopped, that gives huge incentives for the other to betray.
The thing is, betraying the other is the rational thing to do. It's the worst outcome, but it comes from purely rational actions.
It appears that because of MAD, sovereignty between Nuclear armed countries is pretty much ensured.
I mean I'm scared to death by Nuclear weapons (intellectually scared, similar to say Global Warming being a gigantic threat), but I can't help but wonder if these things don't prevent a WW3, and force conflicts to be resolved diplomatically, through economic sanctions, cyberwar, through export of ideology or comparatively smaller 'cold war' type conflicts.
e.g. Yemen today is essentially Iran fighting Saudi Arabia for a bit of regional influence in a way without Iran & ally Russia/China actually fighting with Saudi & ally US/West. Conflicts that are all preferable in scale to an all out WW3, which wouldn't happen (on paper) because of MAD due to Nuclear Weapons.
Nukes makes zero sense if it is a resource war, and those are the oldest ones there is.
A influence war also has little use for nukes, as you want those friendly to you to live and thrive afterwards.
As best i can tell the only time using nukes "make sense" is when faced with a enemy that is committed to your total elimination, and that are completely unified in this goal.
How can, then, some of the smartest people on Earth be involved in something as stupid as this.
Many scientists realise the grave consequences of their stupidity, after the fact. Both Sakharov and Oppenheimer realised this, but it was too late. The genie was out.
The mirage of power, respect, titles, prizes and access to unlimited resources for their experiments is too strong to resist, I guess. :Carrot
Then there's the patriotism thing - do right for you country, protect it from the enemies. Fear. :Stick
This is how the devil works, after all :).
Beware of the stupid as he knows not what the implications of his activities are. Be scared of the smart working for the stupid, as he very well knows the implications, but is too weak to resist the temptation. He has sold his soul.