News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by ryandrake on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:04AM (#9296208)
And, it's only going to get worse while [1] 39% of Americans either believe they are already among the top 1% or believe that they one day will be. If your mentality is one of "Don't tax the top because that's me (or will be)", you're going to constantly vote against your own economic self-interest, and continue to support policies that help the real rich get ultra-rich.

1. http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hop...

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by blfr on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:09AM (#9296252)
39% of Americans either believe they are already among the top 1% or believe that they one day will be

And how many people will actually be in the top 1% of earners at least once?

EDIT: 12% http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-t...

What’s more, 39 percent of Americans will spend a year in the top 5 percent of the income distribution

Not that far off.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by Retric on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:22AM (#9296357)
Lots of things can temporarily boost your income by consolidating several years’ income into one big payment. Sell a flower shop you built up over 40 years for 150k and you are clearly not doing that well. Gamboling can be a net loss over someone’s lifetime and give them one very good year. Even just swapping jobs and seeing getting a few months of saved vacation in one big chunk.

The point is for the 88% of Americans never see the top 1% even after their biggest windfall that's a vast gap. And nothing says 1% is defined by their annual tax returns lifetime earnings adjusted for age are a much better link to someones finances than what they made last year.

PS: Sure, in theory Bill Gates was not in the top 1% while at Harvard, but his nominal income had little to do with his status. Don't forget his Mother was friends with the CEO of IBM that's serious connections.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by warfangle on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:06AM (#9296715)
Wait, where can you save vacation and receive that time as paid as one big chunk?
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by gkop on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:22AM (#9296883)
California state law.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by whybroke on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:58AM (#9297278)
And non-competition clauses are unenforceable in California. Yet other states wonder why no mater how many tax incentive they give business, silicon valley remains stubbornly in CA.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by warfangle on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @04:19PM (#9299599)
Huh. That's pretty awesome.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:54AM (#9297239)
Illinois state law as well.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by ryandrake on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:40AM (#9296497)
Those figures include people who had a lucky year. I'd like to see data showing what percentage of people who start out in the bottom 99%, and end up at any point in their lives spending at least 10 consecutive years (or until their death) in the top 1%.

When we talk about "the 1%" we are not talking about that one hit wonder salesman or small business owner who cashes out and technically has >$1M income in one particular year. We are talking about year-after-year sustained income.

EDIT:

There's no question that there are problems with the phrase "among the top 1% of earners". It's not well defined. I think, though, it's safe to say that when the Average American talks about "the 1%" as a class, he's not talking about the person who had a single good year and went on to have a normal income for the rest of his life. He's talking about the class of people whose income is high and sustained. When the average person says, "I'll be among the top 1% of earners" he's imagining himself as attaining continuing membership in an economic class, not predicting a single-year windfall.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by ghouse on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:19AM (#9296328)
There is about a 10x difference between the top 5% and top 1%. So, that's sorta far off.

And then again a 20x difference between the top 1% and top 0.1%

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by blfr on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:21AM (#9296339)
Yeah but few people when asked think like that. It's just a type of "rich".
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by sp332 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:30AM (#9296416)
To consider yourself in the top 1%, you just have to be richer than 99 other people you know. Humans are not good at avoiding sampling bias.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by Taek on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:42AM (#9297094)
That's not true. Most of my friends and aquaintences are software engineers or masters+ in some other STEM field. (Or are students of a similar caliber). The people you know aren't a good random sample. The top 1% tend to have more friends who are also top 1%.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by netrus on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:26AM (#9296378)
The only way I can explain myself these numbers is heritage: Many people will at some point in their life have a heritage above typical yearly salaries. That information doesn't help much. We should find a mid-way between income, wealth and earning potential. Maybe "currently-expected-lifetime-earnings"?
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by theorique on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:47AM (#9297163)
Well, if we all work hard enough, we can all become members of the 1%...
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by was8309 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @04:21PM (#9299611)
an admittedly cynical view is that we can be sycophants and cowards, and so we want to feel that we belong in the most powerful group. I think this is why some of us bash welfare, even though there isn't much evidence of fraud. if a little steals my one dollar bill and runs one way and a big guy steals my hundred bill and just stands there laughing, I turn and run after the little buy screaming 'Thief'! we know we've been robbed, but we're too afraid to confront the big guy
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by brador on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:18AM (#9296317)
You honestly believe that people think "Don't tax the top because that's me (or will be)"?

I suggest people believe their jobs and technological innovations we all enjoy are on the line if the rich are taxed more. If that is true or not is a separate conversation, but I don't think it's 39% of Americans think they will reach the 1%. That's absurd and the kind of thing you hear in mass media sound bites.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by kjjw on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:22AM (#9296349)
I'm quite sure it is completely true. In aggregate it is an absurd view for so many people to hold, but that doesn't mean it isn't held.

Look at where we are! Hacker News - 10,000s of people talking around start ups! Pretty much none of us will "make it." Yet here we are.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by icebraining on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:09AM (#9296752)
Hacker News is far from just talking about startups and/or for people who expect to start one. I'm here to talk about tech. Startups are cool and all, but I wouldn't come here just for them.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by kjjw on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:16PM (#9297468)
To be fair, an arse and utterly pedantic, I didn't say it was just talking /about/ startups.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by venomsnake on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:37AM (#9296479)
Not sure why you are downvoted. Even pg admitted that their ROI are absurd, so they must (and can afford to) fund thousands of startups to have success at the current winner takes all digital economy.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by sp332 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:27AM (#9296386)
The most telling polling result from the 2000 election was from a Time magazine survey that asked people if they are in the top 1 percent of earners. Nineteen percent of Americans say they are in the richest 1 percent and a further 20 percent expect to be someday.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by happyscrappy on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:36AM (#9296467)
They are certainly in the richest 1 percent worldwide.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by metaphorm on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:54AM (#9296610)
irrelevant. the discussion here is about wealth and equality within the United States.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by happyscrappy on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:23AM (#9296898)
You could not peacefully sustain such a disparity in wealth if the citizens were not living comfortably.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by metaphorm on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:38AM (#9297041)
famous last words.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by happyscrappy on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:36PM (#9298302)
Almost the same disparity exists in Europe and they are imposing austerity so are they doomed?
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by brador on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:28AM (#9296399)
Time magazine readers are not an unbiased sample of America. Not even close.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by sp332 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:35AM (#9296456)
In terms of income it's not that bad though. In 2011 the average Times subscriber had somewhat higher household income than average, but not that high. http://stateofthemedia.org/files/2012/01/25-Mags-Datablog-20... But they are also 45 or older, so they'd have less time to look forward to being in the top 1% "someday". http://stateofthemedia.org/files/2012/01/26-Mags-Datablog-20...
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by adaml_623 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:40AM (#9296500)
Your arguing style is very sad. You make a suggestion and then when it is rebutted you don't try to refute it very well at all. Find the data and then you can make arguments.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by usefulcat on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:46PM (#9297756)
How do you know the sample was limited to readers of Time?
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by mason240 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:36AM (#9296457)
This is a total strawman that advocates of higher taxes tell each other.

It's a pretty effective one because it allows those people handwave off anyone who disagrees with them.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by kbenson on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:01PM (#9297317)
> It's a pretty effective one because it allows those people handwave off anyone who disagrees with them.

Sort of like accusing someone of a strawman argument with nothing to back it?

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:32AM (#9296429)
There is an equality in possibilities, not in results. You can't blame anyone because you are bad in investments or can't do business. If you tax people who reach success, why not tax those who was failed? Let's redistribute bankruptcy, depression and suicides.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by cgearhart on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:00AM (#9296654)
That's the problem though -- there is not equality is possibilities. Analysis [1] of a study from the Pew Research Center on economic mobility [2] found that you are 10x more likely to be in the top 20% if you're born there than if you're born in the bottom 20%. Someone born in the top 20% who doesn't go to college is still 2.5x more likely to have an income in the top 20% as an adult than someone from the bottom 20% who does go to college.

Moreover, it's worsened because life is more expensive in subtle ways as you move down the income bracket. [3] Even municipal fines -- as emphasized by John Oliver recently -- contribute to the problem.

[1] http://mattbruenig.com/2013/06/13/whats-more-important-a-col... [2] http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/reports/00... [3] http://www.slate.com/articles/life/family/2014/12/linda_tira... [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UjpmT5noto

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by walod on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:33AM (#9296995)
Doesn't anybody else find the "equality of opportunity" and other phrases way too abstract for analysis? There are many facets to how an economy functions and how individuals navigate it, and I think a proper analysis of the action on the ground is needed. For example how individuals learn skills and what prerequisites are needed in terms of access to information, ability to focus and think abstractly, and how one trains those abilities. This affects competition in the market, who gets rich, who gets an opportunity and so forth, and yet all the articles I see talk in these distant abstract terms, like they're appealing to someone in the government to fix it or something.

Another aspect is consumer responsibility and the way we tend to buy what we want but not think of the large scale consequences. People use gmail and facebook out of habit. They buy groceries in a big store out of habit. We use products dependent on petroleum yet expect someone else to fix global warming. Being interconnected and living in a rather fragile world where systems affect each other is not a responsibility us as individuals are ready for, and I haven't even touched on civic responsibility and the need for everyone to almost be lawyers and critical thinkers for law to function. There are so many complex interconnected parts and we always fall victim to the movements of the herd

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:52AM (#9297219)
This is analysis of results not possibilities. Having possibility doesn't means you have to use it. Having possibility to walk doesn't means you will walk same route and distance as an other person who has this possibility too.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by cgearhart on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:35PM (#9298273)
Something is "possible" if we have an expectation that it might come to pass. How should we analyze possibilities except by looking at what actually happens? The premise of my counterpoint is that there is a probability distribution attached to what's possible, and that the distribution is not the same for everyone.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by metaphorm on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:32PM (#9297626)
let me make pragmatic and ethical argument (about the ability of people to afford to pay taxes) that might help add some perspective that seems to be sorely lacking here.

we are morally justified in taxing success BECAUSE it is success. its not because we desire to punish or disincentivize success (and indeed we must take care not to tax it too harshly for this reason), but simply put, success generates surplus and we can tax surplus without causing outsize additional suffering. we are justified in taking from those who have extra because they have extra and can afford it.

on the flipside we are not morally justified in taxing failure BECAUSE it is failure. its not because we desire to reward or incentivize failure (and indeed we must take care not to make it too inconsequential to fail for this reason), but simply put, failure generates hardship and we cannot tax a person experiencing hardship without causing outsize additional suffering. we are justified in not taking from those who have nothing left bcause they have nothing left and cannot afford to have anything more taken from them.

do you understand the ethical dimensions of the argument now? what is most fair from a purely financial or economic point of view is not at all what is most fair from a humanitarian or ethical point of view. pragmatically speaking, we have need to generate revenue for the government and it makes the best sense to seek revenue from where money is plentiful, just because that's where the money actually is. its the same reason why consumer brands try to market to wealthier customers (because they have extra money that they can spend).

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:44PM (#9297737)
Taxing is not morally justified BECAUSE it is a robbery. There is not failure taxing just because there is nothing to get from people who failed.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by danans on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:35PM (#9298283)
It seems like you think that redistribution == robbery.

I'm curious what is your preferred solution for financing public infrastructure. All private? Every street and sewer line is a company's property?

Even human societies like hunter gatherers redistributed food within their groups so some of them could concentrate on child rearing and basic tool making while others acquired food. Even if duties were shared, they couldn't all be done at the same time.

Redistribution of surplus was a major contributing factor which led to the specialization necessary to develop early technology like agriculture, which ultimately led to where we are today.

It was certainly a critical part of the creation of the American middle class and consumer culture after the second world war.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @06:43AM (#9302722)
Forced redistribution == robbery. Donations and other voluntaries is okey.

> Every street and sewer line is a company's property?

Private infrastructure works good with Internet.

> Redistribution of surplus was a major contributing factor which led to the specialization

Redistribution != Exchanging. Market is okey because there are no forcing, everything is ultroneous.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by Frondo on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:56PM (#9299008)
Taxation is not robbery. Taxation is a way to pay the bill of being a citizen of a place.

Your confusion may arise from the following: In a robbery, someone takes something from you. With taxation, an organization takes something from you.

The difference is, in a robbery, you get nothing back. With taxation, you are getting something from the government, so you're actually just paying for that.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @06:54AM (#9302743)
> bill of being a citizen of a place.

I'm never sign for that.

> The difference is, in a robbery, you get nothing back.

If robber give you something back - it will not be a robbery?

> so you're actually just paying for that

I'm actually just paying for government spying me, for forcing me to not to having ownership of myself and other "government goods".

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by Frondo on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @04:56PM (#9306818)
"I'm never sign for that."

Correct, your parents chose that for you, when they chose your place of residency when you were born. As a child, your parents had custody of you and the legal right to make that decision for you.

As an adult, now, you may renounce your citizenship and move to another place with no social contract; that is how you may terminate your obligations to the government where you live.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by metaphorm on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:48PM (#9297780)
you're probably not going to convince a lot of people that taxing is robbery. that's an incredibly extreme point of view that is completely at odds with living in a developed industrial nation.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:59PM (#9297897)
Is property rights completely at odds with living in a developed industrial nation? When you're threatening to force people to give up their property - it's a robbery.
Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by Frondo on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:58PM (#9299015)
Living in a developed industrial nation, with all the benefits that incurs, and not paying for it? That's freeloading.

There's no moral standing in skipping out on the bill for something you're getting.

Re:Economic Inequality: It’s Far Worse Than You Think by nap on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @06:59AM (#9302757)
I'm paying medical, education, internet and other bills. It's okay. If I don't want paying I just shouldn't asking for this service. But with taxation I can't not pay for things that I don't want. I have to pay NSA for skying me. I have to pay police for not having ownership of myself (can't do drugs, can't commit suicide - I'm just property of the state, not myself).