News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by colund on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:27AM (#9290132)
Why the obsession of economic growth? In Sweden we currently have negative prime interest rate and people have higher salaries than ever and housing prices are all time high.

This greed doesn't lead to less global warming or happier people. I think politicians and economists should start thinking about what actually makes people happy. Economics is efficient management of resources nothing else. Giving the population ability to stay healthy with affordable health care, moderate taxes and stability should be a main priority.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jseliger on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:17PM (#9290514)
Why the obsession of economic growth?

One alternate question might be, "At what point in time do you consider the economy to have become 'big enough' that you don't care about growth?" Today? 2000? 1990? 1970?

The people who might think today is "big enough" might also have thought that say 1990 was big enough, and yet very few people would want to be limited to 1990's tech / culture. It seems reasonable to imagine that people in say 2050 will look back on benighted 2015 and marvel at the shit we had to put up with. What gets us from today to 2050? Economic growth, which is likely tied into lots of other things (like science, production, entrepreneurship, etc.).

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by enraged_camel on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:39PM (#9291120)
You can have technological, scientific and cultural advancement without economic growth.

Building more shopping malls out in the suburbs leads to growth, but it doesn't advance society.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mcguire on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:36PM (#9292013)
Can you? How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in?

(For some reason, I'm reminded of the Superconducting Super Collider and the western invention (discovery? reverse-engineering?) of porcelain.)

I'm going to leave the idea of "cultural advancement" alone, 'cause I can't easily and convincingly define it or figure out where it comes from. And I don't believe anyone else can either.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by marcosdumay on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:54PM (#9292875)
Some advancements just redistribute money from an older incumbent to a new one (that will want to research it).

Anyway, there are plenty of technological developments that bring money to their creator, bring positive overall wealth to the population, but counts as a negative at the GDP accounting. I guess that's the cause of lots of the "let's not care about growth" cries. Well, let's fix our GDP measurement first! (And yes, I know there are several people working on it.)

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by freyr on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:14PM (#9292660)
> How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in?

Value is not the same as growth. We may pursue technological advancement because we think it will provide more value than whatever assets we have on hand. Continual reward is not the same as continually increasing reward. Continually increasing reward might be good, but at some point that goal may come at too great a cost.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by boomlinde on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:49PM (#9292501)
> Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in?

Perhaps no one, in that sense limiting technological advancement to things that would benefit people.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ethbro on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:34PM (#9292772)
Which leaves us in a fair quagmire when you have substantial gaps between discoveries and engineered products (e.g. quantum theory -> semiconductors -> the computing revolution).
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:02PM (#9291321)
I have discussed this with friends recently. Why do we need growth?

I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I honestly don't see my life being any better for the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices).

I would quite like to relax and coast a bit in life, but with the constant chasing of growth by everyone else, standing still means you will get left behind (i.e you will become poor).

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by enraged_camel on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:39PM (#9291594)
I think you're simply demonstrating that it's incredibly easy to take technology for granted and not realize how much it has improved our lives just within the last ten years.

Very simple example: back in 2005, most people had to print or memorize directions when they were traveling somewhere they didn't know. A few tech enthusiasts had discrete GPS gadgets, but navigation was a manual and tedious (not to mention dangerous) process for most.

Today, almost everyone carries a device that can quickly and reliably find directions, and dynamically re-calculate them. I don't know about you, but I do a lot of driving on my own and this has improved my driving experience considerably.

Now, you could argue that incremental improvements in technology (e.g. faster CPUs, more RAM, etc.) don't actually improve quality of life that much. As someone who is still rocking an iPhone 4S, I agree. It's sufficient for my needs. But incremental improvements tend to be "placeholders" while more significant technology is in development, so it's fine that they happen.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jdmichal on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:22PM (#9291911)
Also, those "incremental" improvements often lead the way for more advanced applications of the device. To carry your example, at some point GPS is not feasible because, off the top of my head:

* Screens are not good enough.

* Processors are not fast enough.

* Radios are not sensitive enough.

* Data storage isn't small enough.

* Batteries aren't dense enough.

It took these things all converging with "incremental" improvements to allow the major advancement of consumer GPS.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by pdonis on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:15PM (#9293791)
> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech.

Maybe you don't, but lots of people do, as evidenced by the fact that they pay for it. If you don't need it, then don't pay for it.

> the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices)

This is true, but faster iPhones and other tech weren't what did that. Investment banks did that, by playing risky zero-sum games with other people's money.

> with the constant chasing of growth by everyone else, standing still means you will get left behind

Really? You need a faster iPhone just to keep up?

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Retra on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:53PM (#9293919)
>Maybe you don't, but lots of people do, as evidenced by the fact that they pay for it. If you don't need it, then don't pay for it.

That's not really how it works. I will get a new phone when mine dies because (A) I need a phone and (B) the phone I have isn't being made anymore.

Does this means I am paying for 'more tech'? If you do not keep buying new stuff, you don't stagnate, you regress. If I don't want new technology, I have to go with no technology, not the same-old technology.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by pdonis on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:03AM (#9294625)
> I will get a new phone when mine dies because (A) I need a phone and (B) the phone I have isn't being made anymore.

But you'll still have a pretty wide range of choices; last I checked, not every phone available was a smartphone, let alone an iPhone. Granted, the exact model you had before won't be there, but that's true of just about anything. My car is a 2002 model; I'm going to have to get a new one pretty soon, and I certainly won't be able to buy the same model. But I'll still have a pretty wide range of choices; it's not as though I'll either have to buy a luxury model or go without.

> If you do not keep buying new stuff, you don't stagnate, you regress.

Well, of course; stuff wears out and dies, so you have to get new stuff, and the new stuff won't be the same as the stuff you used to have, because stuff is always changing. Everything wears out eventually; that's just a fact of life. But nobody is forcing you to get the fanciest phone available, or the fanciest anything else.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @04:08AM (#9294920)
I got mine because it cam with the internet.

"How much is internet?" "40 euros" "How much is internet with a phone contract bundle?" "40 euros"

I was perfectly happy with my Nokia. Battery lasted a week. I could bounce it off the ground.

The smartphone can be useful at times, but at other times it is so frustrating to use it cancels out the benefit. And since everyone else is using whatsapp, I might as well join in.

I take my pleasure in life from things outside a 4 inch screen.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jdmichal on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:18PM (#9291877)
So you'd be happy without the last 10 years, with your iPhone that was initially released 8 years ago -- and which promptly increased the cell phone market from race-to-the-bottom "dumb phones" to high-margin "smart phones"?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by NickM on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:45PM (#9292825)
As someone who owns an iPhone, I don't think it's really substantially improved my quality of life. It makes some things more convenient, but doesn't really enable me to do anything I couldn't do before with other separate devices, and it can be a major source of distraction at times.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by beambot on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:50PM (#9293913)
Would you be willing to test that...? I.e. Would you be willing to give up the iPhone for a dumb phone for 12 months? What if we collectively donated to a charity to make it more enticing?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Qu4Z on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:13PM (#9294165)
Not the GP, but I'd be happy enough to do that. Then again, my personal computer is a ThinkPad T41 I bought online for like $100 recently when my T420 died, so maybe I don't count? But honestly, so little of my quality of life comes from tech advances (though I do love me some computer science, and work with computers every day).
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by steveklabnik on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:51PM (#9294270)
I did this a year or three back, and the only thing was that with the amount of travel I did, the mobile maps were too useful. If I didn't travel, I'm pretty sure I'd be fine without a phone.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by gmays on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @08:25AM (#9295687)
> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I honestly don't see my life being any better for the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices).

I'd be careful not to confuse the limits of your imagination with the limits of reality.

I've seen this sentiment many times in many different ways and it has never been accurate. It's easy to feel like now is different and we've never been here before, but we have. The key isn't that you don't need a faster iPhone or faster computer, it's that you need them. There will always be another iPhone/computer, whatever that will be.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by beamatronic on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:34PM (#9291559)
I'll take "peace" over "growth" at this point.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cmdkeen on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:21PM (#9291898)
The world as a whole is in one of its most peaceful periods ever. The 1990s saw a genocide in Europe, horrific civil wars in Africa, before that you had the Cold War with all of its attendant problems.

Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ethbro on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:36PM (#9292782)
> Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims.

Indeed, I'd offer that Economic Stagnation and Peace might be mutually incompatible situations.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by angularly on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:19PM (#9293555)
"Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims."

No shit, almost all wars start with economic discontent. So all things equal, growth will mean less wars.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @04:03AM (#9294911)
There has been a lot of growth in the States and the UK over the last 40 years. yet within both of those countries inequality has grown a lot. Few people under 40 can afford to buy a house in the UK these days, as opposed to 20 or thirty years ago.

Maybe I am just more politically aware than I used to be but I feel discontent is rising.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by sliverstorm on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:40PM (#9292035)
If you want to freeze on ten years back, there's nothing stopping you from getting an old flip phone.

Or if you want to freeze on 8 years back, nobody will prevent you from buying a iPhone 2G.

It sounds like you are saying you won't do that because you don't want to be "left behind", so you'd like everyone else to stop moving forward to accommodate you. But that's their choice, just like using an iPhone 2G is your choice.

"We have too much progress, can everybody just slow down a bit here!?" - first world problems :)

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ido on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:58PM (#9293190)
There was actually no iPhone 2g, although there were iPhone and iPhone 3G.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by sliverstorm on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:16PM (#9293540)
The "iPhone" worked on 2g networks, so I call it the 2g to be clear. The same way the "Xbox" is now called "Original Xbox", to distinguish it from the others, esp. the Xbox One.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by deciplex on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:49PM (#9294255)
> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech.

I need computing power equivalent to several thousand million human brains within the physical space of my home by 2050, and fitting in my pocket by 2075.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by pbreit on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:35PM (#9291563)
And that is why you need growth.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by branchless on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:25PM (#9291935)
IMHO we need more growth because the more growth we have the more the establishment can skim off and the more they can then consume.

If we all stopped producing a surplus how will movie stars and bankers get the energy to run their private jets?

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by nickff on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:11PM (#9292636)
Growth and technology are actually reducing the difference between rich and poor in almost every aspect of life.

Between 1920 and 1960 the only people who could travel quickly around the world were the super-rich. With the advent of the turbofan engine, and the widebody jet, quick and comfortable travel became accessible to the general public.

Cell phones and the internet are another paradigmatic case of this. It used to be that only people with a great deal of resources could get quick answers to uncommon problems, but now everyone can get those answers from a device they carry in their pocket. You can communicate more easily than the ultra-wealthy were able to only 20 years ago. Most Americans have access to communications technology on par or above that of the president.

There are many different examples of this, and the best description of it may be the following quote by Schumpeter:

>"Electric lighting is no great boon to anyone who has enough money to buy a sufficient number of candles and to pay servants to attend them. It is the cheap cloth, the cheap cotton and rayon fabric, boots, motorcars and so on that are the typical achievements of capitalist production, and not as rule improvements that would mean much to the rich man. Queen Elizabeth owned silk stockings. The capitalist achievement does not typically consist in providing more silk stockings for queens but in bringing them within reach of factory girls in return for steadily decreasing amounts of effort."

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by enraged_camel on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:54PM (#9292878)
>>Growth and technology are actually reducing the difference between rich and poor in almost every aspect of life.

It seriously annoys me when people say this, because it's so incredibly short-sighted. It's only in terms of physical, tangible standard of living factors. Travel, as you noted, is one of those. And yeah, everyone has refrigerators in their homes nowadays. Yay!

But being ultra-rich gives a tremendous amount of intangible perks, such as the ability to greatly influence public policy and the ability to afford top-notch legal representation, which lets them get away with serious crimes that would put normal people like you and I in jail for decades. There's also inter-generational perks. For example, children of ultra-rich parents can afford excellent education and are much more likely to get into the top schools.

I can go on. The fact is, the differences between the haves and the have-nots today are vast, and they are getting bigger every day as wealth inequality increases. Yes, it is good that we have the basics covered for most people but beyond those basics things look pretty grim.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by nickff on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:10PM (#9292961)
I agree that the rich still enjoy many advantages over the poor, but still believe that the difference is being reduced by growth and technology.

Up until the 19th and 20th centuries, only the very richest few could afford to learn to read, write, do math, and understand history. The increases in productivity and technology we have enjoyed have helped to reduce the differences in level of education, and any number of other aspects of life. You contend that the ultra-rich "are much more likely to get into the top schools", but you are missing the historical context which demonstrates that the level of education available to the middle and lower classes has been steadily increasing.

With regards to public policy and legal representation, we probably agree to some extent with respect to the issue, though we likely differ in paradigm. I would surmise from your comment that you believe the government could 'solve the problem'. The way that I see it, these are the areas where goverment has been most active in disadvantaging the poor and middle classes, and a reduction in the size and scope of government is the only way to systematically help level the playing field.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mseebach on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:31PM (#9293351)
I think you're the one being short sighted here. You pull out the very few area where the rich still have an edge, but the fact is that in the vast majority of areas, the rich have lost insane ground.

First, these physical, tangible standard of living factors you so arrogantly dismiss. Cheap, ubiquitous travel means freedom to live where you want, even if that's more than a few hundred miles away, without sacrificing your family and friends. That was rare 20 years ago and almost unheard of 50 years ago. Except if you were rich, of course. Today, the rich can buy somewhat more comfortable and convenient flights, at extreme expense, but not faster ones.

As for refrigerators in every home? The alternative is shopping for fresh ingredients daily, or doing without them. You can't save leftovers for very long, so you need to cook daily. And speaking of cooling? 100 years ago, the king of England couldn't get an A/C unit at any cost, today they're perfectly ubiquitous.

Education? Yeah, there is some real differences here, but the bottom has gone up tremendously: in living memory, kids were pulled from school to help in the fields. Poor kids, obviously, the rich didn't go in the fields. Today, thanks to the mechanisation of agriculture, all kids can stay in school uninterrupted. And even the poorest kids can read by almost free electrical lights. Even 100 years ago, the rich would have to read by candlelight.

The rich can buy marginally better cars than you and I, but not by a lot. Fancier, but not really better clothes. Their houses might be bigger and fancier, but not more capable at keeping you and your family warm (or cool) and dry. Certainly, the rich have more luxurious options, but not really a lot better.

The richest man on earth can't buy a better smartphone than me or get a better signal than me - that's why those ghastly diamond-encrusted phones exist. But their text messages don't arrive faster than mine and they like the exact same cat videos as me on the exact same Facebook.

Still too vulgar and consumerist? How about the environment? Once, the rich enjoyed clean air, clean water and safe disposal of sewage by living in the country. But do you know why they dusted all the time in old books? Indoor coalfires are messy affairs. If you lived in the city (rich or poor), there would be no clean water, smoggy, dirty air and literally shit flowing in the streets. Today, even the worst tenements in the densest cities have clean, running water, flushing toilets and smogless radiators. The air might not be quite as clean as it could be, but it's a far cry from the smog-hell it once was - and a lot cleaner than just a few decades ago, thanks to better cars.

The perks you list were always perks of the nobility, they are not recent gains - but you're making the perfect an enemy of the extremely good. The much more interesting point is all the perks they've lost and are losing, and those are extremely numerous.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by baddox on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:04PM (#9291342)
Lots of people love living in suburbs and visiting shopping malls. You'll have to define "advancing society."
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by enraged_camel on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:16PM (#9291430)
>>You'll have to define "advancing society."

Actually, if you follow the discussion, it has already been defined in the comment I responded to:

>>The people who might think today is "big enough" might also have thought that say 1990 was big enough, and yet very few people would want to be limited to 1990's tech / culture.

What is being implied here is that we want economic growth because we don't want to be limited in tech / culture. I simply pointed out that this is a false association.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Retric on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:37PM (#9292017)
There are several examples of ethnic cleansing over the last 5 years.

But, I guess as long as it’s not "in Europe" then it’s ok....

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflicts

Yes, WWII saw 10+ times the number of dead per year, but that's not such a huge gap as you might think.

PS: Many of those conflicts have far more civilian deaths than that link suggests.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by randyrand on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:15PM (#9292993)
No you can't. If I invent a self driving car, economic growth is inevitable. What is the difference between now and 1800 other than technology and growth (hint, technology is growth).

Of course, there is also growth that doesn't come from technology. Like building shopping malls, employing people, and letting the economy operate at full tilt, producing things that we can then either consume, save (a form of growth), or spend on investment (another possible form of growth).

You might not think building a shopping malls advances society, but it's second order effects 100% do.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by anigbrowl on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:40PM (#9292795)
That's backwards; your example is one of economic growth without technological, scientific, or cultural advancement. By contrast, the invention of the laser didn't yield much economic growth for a long time because nobody was too sure how to commercialize it, but once the ability to produce an intense light at a single narrow wavelength got some utility, economic growth resulted automatically.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by siculars on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:33PM (#9298247)
I donn't think that is actually the case. You may think, and I might have agreed with you, that at first blush building yet another insipid shopping mall does not necessarily yield any enhancement to society but after further thought I would tend to disagree. The "market" is where society comes together to mingle and it is also where goods and services are presented to the people who may not have had an avenue to receive them previously. The modern day mall is the modern day town square market of yesteryear. It is yet another avenue for ideas to germinate and goods to be exchanged. Someone will buy something that allows them to free up time which will allow them to spend more time thinking about something new or caring for someone who will think of something new.

Expansion is the only way forward and often everything can be measured in economic output.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by xorcist on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:53PM (#9290795)
That's not an answer. You could just as well ask "at what point in time do you consider interest rates low enough"? 0%, -1% or -10%?

There's no clear answer for either question, of course, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't discuss them.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cloakandswagger on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:11PM (#9290908)
How is it not an answer? He's saying that the "greed" described by the original commenter is the same source of innovation that's given us all of the modern amenities we enjoy today.

Conversely, I would say outright dismissing the pursuit of growth is not an answer.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Mikeb85 on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:39PM (#9291127)
> He's saying that the "greed" described by the original commenter is the same source of innovation that's given us all of the modern amenities we enjoy today.

And is life any better today than in 1990? Are we happier?

I think he's arguing that material possessions don't necessarily correlate to 'quality of life' and happiness.

I would personally be pretty happy without a car or computer. But I live in a ridiculous city that is sprawled out over hundreds of square kilometres with terrible public transportation, and live in a society where electronic communication is basically a requirement to do anything.

My happiest childhood memories where on my grandfather's farm. My wife's happiest childhood memories where in her small village in an 'under-developed' country. Today life in Canada is stressful as hell, and her country has been consumed by violence and corruption.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by aetherson on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:59PM (#9291306)
Things that you can do today that you couldn't do in 1990:

* Survive much longer with many types of cancer.

* Live a pretty normal life, more or less indefinitely, despite being HIV+

* See your grandkids that live in a different state via a high-quality video connection.

* Enjoy television shows that offer multi-month and multi-year arcs and are designed to be consumed by dedicated fans in order, rather than principally for syndication in random order.

* Vacuum your floors with a robot.

* Survive more car crashes dues to a variety of safety features.

Is life "better" today than in 1990? Sure, of course it is. Does that make us happier? I genuinely don't know. Most hedonic research strikes me as obvious bullshit. Maybe people's happiness levels reset to the norms around them regardless of what those norms are. Maybe you'd literally be just as happy if you lived in a medieval village with open-trench sewers and a pretty decent chance of your wife dying in childbirth and you doing hard labor for your adult life to a brief, decrepit old age. I mean, seriously, maybe you would! It's not outside the realm of possibility.

It's hard for me to argue that that kind of happiness means that there's no point to increased material prosperity.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by xorcist on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:38PM (#9292020)
While all those points are true, they are mainly because of advancing science, rather than economic growth. Those are partly interconnected, but there are also important differences.

The Internet as you know it is also a direct product of its academic background. That's why we have had network neutrality so inherent in its culture. That's why there are only peers, not producers and consumers. If it had been designed as a product, the network itself would never have been designed to be dumb with smart endpoints. (And there are countless examples of this.)

If Tim Berners-Lee designed the web to be a product, there would be a marketplace of competing web-like products, which in turn would have given us other features, but it would never have become societal infrastructure in the way it did.

Sometimes we need academia and science, sometimes we need products.

The question here is how to optimize between the two.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by anigbrowl on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:52PM (#9292865)
No. Advancements in science are where you show that it's possible to do something in particular, like control the level of HIV in someone's bloodstream or make a better airbag. Wonderful! But turning that knowledge into a technology that can be deployed to the people that need, and then actually deploying it, involves a lot of resources - both material and and labor - and those resources come with a price tag.

It's not like once we learn something in the lab we can just make it available to everyone for free. I mean, you could go to Wikipedia right now and read about, say, aeronautics and all the theory of how air flowing over a wing can provide lift, and articles on structural engineering and so on. But having that knowledge is not the same thing as having a plane, or having access to a plane ticket. If you would like to fly from A to B, you need a functional aircraft first.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by aetherson on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:35PM (#9292393)
No, they aren't. Those are all products, all produced for profit. They may depend on basic research, but basic research does not get products into people's hands, and basic research does not make people wealthy enough to pay for new products.

I am obviously not arguing against research, and I think your whole deal of arguing that there's some kind of tradeoff to be made between them is wrong. You can have more research and more economic growth. In fact, if you don't have more economic growth, it'll be harder to have more research, and to some extent vice versa.

This isn't to get embroiled in a real tangent about network neutrality. Nobody is advocating for any kind of particular regulatory framework for the internet, here.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jobposter1234 on Monday March 30, 2015 @07:25PM (#9293328)
The "academic internet" wasn't nearly as impressive as today's internet.

I am (un?)fortunate to have my first memories around the time of the first private networks being connected to the internet (late 80s).

Back then, the internet was run by academics.

It wasn't until the 2nd or 3rd round of commercialization efforts that it really became compelling.

So the structure of the internet is because of the academic beginnings, but the actual content (data, apps, etc.) are IMO b/c of desire to acquire wealth.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Gurkenmaster on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:51AM (#9294732)
> Enjoy television shows that offer multi-month and multi-year arcs and are designed to be consumed by dedicated fans in order, rather than principally for syndication in random order.

This has nothing to do with economic or technical limitations. It has cultural reasons. SDF Macross aired in 1982 in Japan with 26 episodes in order and I'm sure there are even earlier shows.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by brandonmenc on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:53PM (#9292872)
> My happiest childhood memories where on my grandfather's farm. My wife's happiest childhood memories where in her small village in an 'under-developed' country.

Those are happy memories because you had a happy childhood, not because there was less "stuff."

Some of my happiest memories are of biking through the suburbs to go hang out at the mall. Why? Because I didn't have a care in the world back then.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by gamerdonkey on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:30PM (#9291049)
I would say that outright dismissing any concept is not an answer.

I do have a problem with equating greed to innovation and cultural growth. Greed, in economic terms, optimizes only for the accumulation of wealth. Many technological and cultural advances would do nothing to amass wealth and would be missing in a society focused solely on economic growth.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by xorcist on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:28PM (#9291960)
No, the commenter asked a specific question about why we optimize for growth at the apparent cost of a negative interest rate, and rapidly rising salaries as well as housing prices.

"When do you consider the economy big enough?" is rhetorical question which doesn't even touch on the trade-offs apparent to what's being asked.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by colund on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:44AM (#9297138)
Amazingly well written replies everyone! Wonderful community!

I agree that the economy might not be "big enough" yet. And yes I agree that we need more progress and probably more growth. But do we need to be in a hurry?

It surprises me that none of the commenters has mentioned global warming - a side effect of economic growth.

So, what do HN readers think about the correlation between economic growth and global warming? Should monetary policy not bother about including global warming side effects due to increased co2 pollution due to economic growth into their economics equations?

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by chonoo on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:12PM (#9298040)
What you are grappling with here is not "have we got a big enough economy". Global Warming does not come from value creation, or the statistical proxy that we call Economic Growth. It comes from burning fossile fuels.

In terms of value, what we have learnt from the last two decades is that a few people with computers can create a lot of it, with negligible impact on our planetary ecosystem. Clearly it makes our lives easier, and gives us more "stuff".

However, our physical existence still depends on fossilised energy to an alarming extent, and policymakers are still unable to wean us off it (witness the fuel subsidy debates in Egypy and Indonesia), or simply unwilling to. You can even say that we use so much of it due to lack of effort, i.e. an unwillingness to actually grow the economy enough by finding substitutes. Because that would involve people doing more work to learn the right technical skills, and that's unreasonable to demand, right?

In fact, it might lower the environmental inpact, since an app with driving directions can make our car journeys more efficient.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by gcb0 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:58PM (#9298504)
sorry to sound like the hippie, but doesn't the official metric is mostly influenced by monetary institutions? which generate none of your grandiose example (science, production, etc)
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by drzaiusapelord on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:53PM (#9290793)
>Why the obsession of economic growth?

Unemployment in the US is around 5.5%. Growth is correlated with jobs, expendable income, etc. So its important if you want to lower real unemployment.

>In Sweden we currently have negative prime interest rate and people have higher salaries than ever and housing prices are all time high.

France went, roughly, this route a decade or two ago. Now they have riots in the streets because young people can't find jobs. Youth unemployment in Spain, UK, Greece, Italy, etc are also scary. The socialist style government does a good job governing the problems of today it seems, but the capitalistic styles does a better job of taking care of the future and the young trying to enter the workforce.

Those nations saw their economies as 'good enough' at one time. They were paying out big salaries and pensions to their public sector unions and overtaxing their corporations and made their budget. Now they're in hysterics about employment, real estate bubbles, youth riots, and lack of growth.

>>In Sweden

I'd also be concerned about your .8% GDP spending on military, which is fairly low, especially in an age of a Russia that routinely sends subs into your territories and annexes lands not too far from you guys. Its weird that we're still applauding the welfare nanny state when its been shown to be fail past a certain point, especially in a country with near 8-9% unemployment. Also your GDP has been raising steadily, so I find it hard to believe that growth isn't' a contributing factor to what you perceive as success:

https://www.quandl.com/c/sweden/sweden-economy-data

If that was a flat graph you wouldn't be chiding us on the internet. You'd be selling shoe shines for gruel or your poor parents would have elected to not birth you.

Also, are you an older established person? Wonderful, but please don't throw down the very ladder that you climbed: Today:

http://ycharts.com/indicators/sweden_youth_unemployment_rate...

Still almost 22% youth unemployment. Countries that care about growth, like the USA, have half that level. So yeah, maybe you should care about growth.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jack9 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:42PM (#9300107)
> Unemployment in the US is around 5.5%

That's an official statistic (US Bureau of labor statistics) that is, in all reality, fiction. Might want to look at ANY other analysis, other than the announced statistic. Like simply comparing the (est) population to the (est) jobs. Turns out it's more like 10% at best, but that's not the end. Yahoo, Experian, Amazon, etc. The vast majority of the tech employed have become contractors. At least be reasonable enough to do your research.

Saying GDP has increased is another statistical mischaracterization. There has been some very clever manipulation by the USG (http://seekingalpha.com/article/1368001-u-s-governments-new-...).

You seem to be woefully glib about topics you haven't been following. Growth hasn't helped the situation as there hasn't been much at all, if any. Rigid financial systems have failed and will do so again if the interest rate (inevitably?) spirals out of control. The executive branch talking heads and investing-in-debt schemes have been paying off for the last few years. It's been increasingly difficult to determine what lengths the fed will go to, in stabilizing the economy and maintaining a positive spin.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by drzaiusapelord on Thursday April 02, 2015 @10:44AM (#9310966)
>That's an official statistic (US Bureau of labor statistics) that is, in all reality, fiction.

and the Swedish one is 100% honest? Oh okay. If you bothered to understand this topic you would know that there are different categories of unemployment (U6, etc). I chose the one that best fir the comparision with Sweden.

>You seem to be woefully glib about topics you haven't been following. G

and you're yet another anti-US HN "expert" unwilling to accept the facts or understand how national economies work. That attitude will get you precious upvotes here (I see you got your token anti-fed comment in, so on HN bingo you're doing pretty good), but its not remotely tied to reality.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by dualogy on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:30PM (#9290619)
> Why the obsession of economic growth?

Easy. Essentially unknowable/unpredictable future growth expectations/extrapolations were already baked into present-day voter promises, welfare obligations and many bank/insurance/pension calculations, plus current "financial asset" valuations. Now the big scramble is on to will said growth assumptions into actually happening, lest "all bets will be off", literally.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by dgregd on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:58PM (#9290828)
> many bank/insurance/pension calculations

It will also clearly show how big banks, HFT companies are making huge profits. They are slowly pulling money out of your pension fund.

Banks do not produce, they have no income from dividends, so how they earn?

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cmdkeen on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:27PM (#9291949)
HFT are making huge profit margins - their entire industry profit is estimated at around $1bn, or a percentage of what a single large financial institution will make in a year. It's all relative - they can only make so much profit before they move the market too much themselves, they are limited by their size.

Your pension fund is not trading in a way which is significantly adversely affected by HFTs, the CEO of Vanguard is even on the record as saying that HFTs make his traders more efficient. Fund managers employ their own dealers to ensure best execution, if HFTs were causing significant losses you can be sure they would be raising hell - and that regulators and governments would listen.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by zo1 on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:41PM (#9291138)
>"Banks do not produce, they have no income from dividends, so how they earn?"

They provide a service. Just because they don't "produce" something by processing raw materials, or less-processed goods, doesn't meant they're not providing something of value to someone.

But, additionally and simplistically, they make money from giving out loans at higher interest rates than what they give out at in deposits.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jsprogrammer on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:48PM (#9292494)
They don't just give out loans, they create brand new money. They also have a state-enforced and -backed monopoly on this creation of new money. So they do "produce", it's just that what they produce is more or less "fictional" violence tokens.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by sumedh on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:01PM (#9291765)
> Banks do not produce, they have no income from dividends, so how they earn?

They provide capital without which you cannot produce anything.

They make money by difference of rates between deposits and lending.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by logfromblammo on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:38PM (#9292790)
They provide currency, which can be used to acquire capital.

Do not confuse this with providing capital. The person who gives you a fence-painting robot is providing capital. The person who gives you 10000 coupons for a free fence-painting robot is not providing anything, if the person who issued the coupons does not actually have any robots.

Banks lubricate the machinery of business, theoretically making productive work more efficient. To the extent they do so, they can reasonably capture a share of those gains.

But once they are trusted in that capacity, they are now in a position to take money by less-honest means, in a manner largely indistinguishable from their legitimate functions by the casual observer.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by curun1r on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:52PM (#9292126)
That's the theory and few rational people would argue that those services are necessary. But we've been in a tail-wagging-the-dog situation for a while now. The industry seems to believe that they're entitled to an increasingly large share of the world's wealth. They've seemingly forgotten that they're a facilitator of progress and don't represent progress in and of themselves. They recruit the best and the brightest to create ever-more-complicated financial instruments robbing society of the contributions those engineers/scientists would have made elsewhere.

Much like the same cellular mechanisms that sustain life become cancerous when there is unchecked growth, the same financial apparatus that we need to facilitate progress becomes cancerous when its growth is unchecked and it loses focus of the purpose that it serves.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by dgregd on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:02PM (#9292183)
1. Banks do not need deposits to lend money to ordinary people. They lend money from FED, which 'prints' them.

2. If interest rates are low then Banks profits should be also low because of small difference between deposits and lending rates. Am I right?

3. Just like casinos in Vegas need capital donors, the ultimate casino also needs capital donors. Don't want to play on Wall Street? No problem, your pension fund (dumb money) is more than enough.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by hnnewguy on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:31PM (#9291052)
>HFT companies are making huge profits

Were. Regulation and competition are chipping away at those profits. The days of obscene profits in the Wild West are done.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jsprogrammer on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:45PM (#9292468)
Commercial banks in the US receive a 6% annual dividend from the USFRB.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:28PM (#9291033)
We have nonnegative gains in efficiency and we have population growth. If those are not reflected in the monetary base, then the result is a trend in the direction of deflation. That presents a set of problems, challenges to very deeply established assumptions about things like government, business and personal debt. Deflation leads to instability, as people who want to work cannot - and not for a good reason, but because of monetary "evils".

Happiness is rather a dangerous standard to use - it varies widely. Material comfort is more appropriate for discussions involving economics.

Low interest rates also contribute to income inequality - if the market interest rate is 0.5% and your business produces returns of 5%, you're now a "rock star" business, and will attract "too much" investment. As there evolves winners and losers in that game, income inequality rises.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mark_l_watson on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:20PM (#9292689)
You might enjoy reading the Austrian Economics take on this at the mises.org web site. Their front page has a few articles on how (sometimes) deflation is just fine.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:49PM (#9293150)
This ( plus nearly all of Rothbard ) is where I disagree with the Austrians. I don't think specie-fever is particularly an Austrian .. opinion but they're also highly correlated - Austrians tend to be fond of gold. If I win my bet, specie is pretty dramatically a bad idea, as the interwar stories show well enough for me. Austrians in general don't seem to grasp that flows matter as much.

When I want to be hyperbolic, I will accuse deflation of being a big contributor to WWII.

I just don't like the idea of the level of currency in circulation being a drag on transactions. Throw in that how debt can be a real problem for people, and I just can't go there. I rather giggle at the "Hayek and the suit" story, although I admire Hayek greatly.

I'm closest to Friedman/Fisher/(these days)Sumner. Mainly because the story is one of poor instrumentation leading to policy that doesn't do what we want, which suits my biases.

"Interfluidity" did an ( I think ) brilliant piece titled "Depression Is A Choice" in which they mused that deflation may well reflect our revealed preferences.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by madman86 on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:39AM (#9290219)
It is a large part of how people in the US make money. Most people have their retirements tied to the stock markets (401k, 403b, and other options are basically just a huge collection of stocks, commodities, and bonds). If growth doesn't occur, the markets don't do as well and may even fall causing a LOT of people to take a hit in retirement funds.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by hnnewguy on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:34PM (#9291074)
>If growth doesn't occur, the markets don't do as well and may even fall causing a LOT of people to take a hit in retirement funds.

It isn't just about "markets". There are actual businesses underlying those financial assets that require economic growth to expand, hire people, pay wages and provide an economic return to their owners (including shareholders).

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:34PM (#9291557)
Patagonia outdoor clothing company recently announced they were aiming for no growth.

http://www.greenbiz.com/news/2013/03/01/patagonia-founder-ta...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by aranazo on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:38PM (#9293636)
It is also a benefit corporation and thus insulated from normal business incentives.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by bwanab on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:34PM (#9290649)
You make a very good point. However, the obsession with economic growth itself isn't the problem - it's how economic growth is measured. As an example, if a hurricane sweeps through Florida doing billions in damage, Florida is surely worse off, but because of the rebuilding activity that follows, it will register significant growth.

As you state, we need to think about what makes people happy. Economics is a great tool to do that, but it will require a rethinking of how the economy is measured.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by rohansingh on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:15PM (#9291415)
The example you gave about Florida is actually very old, and is summed up in the "parable of the broken window": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

As you can see in the Wikipedia article, there are actually many different interpretations and views on whether or not that rebuilding adds value to the economy.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by TeMPOraL on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:36PM (#9292780)
I disagree. The economic growth is very much the problem. You can multiply abstract integers all you want and everything will be fine, but unfortunately the economy is coupled with the real world. Exponential growth means exponentially increasing resource use and energy needs, which is simply unsustainable. We need to cut off that exponent, or else the only singularity we will hit will be the brick wall of "oh shit, we just run out of habitable planets".
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:31PM (#9291056)
I think (macro) econ is a lousy tool for measuring happiness. Micro might be. Now, some parts of the various econs - like the theory of revealed preferences* - may well be useful in measuring or talking about happiness but taken as a while, it is IMO incumbent on economists to be humble about this.

*which teaches us that what people say and what they do are two very different things.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:05PM (#9291346)
This reminds me of when Windows Vista (or was it Windows 7) came out, Microsoft claimed it would lead to more growth, through all the upgrades that would need done. So more work needing done leads to more "growth". There is something backwards in that thinking to me.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by adventured on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:49PM (#9291663)
To acquire the high salaries you're talking about, Sweden had to grow substantially at some point in the past.

The 1970s and 1980s were terrible times in Sweden economically. You had to grow out of that through economic reforms.

http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2009/0803/international-invest-...

From 2001 to 2014, Sweden's GDP per capita went from $26,000 to $60,000. Surely you didn't need any of that growth, right?

It's easy to soap-box about greed, when ~90% of the world is far worse off than you are.

Sweden also has a consumer debt vs disposable income ratio of 180%, one of the highest on earth, and it's brewing into a crisis. Without the high salaries, courtesy of past growth (since Sweden's economy hasn't expanded since 2008), Sweden would currently be in a crisis economically due to the very high individual debt levels. Most likely in the future to deal with those debts, Sweden will have to slash its standard of living, or boost its growth. Nobody likes to go backwards in comfort, and that's why the 'obsession' with growth - you can't stand still for very long, you either have to go forward or you will go backwards.

http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/11/09/sweden-economy-idU...

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-01-13/nordic-cri...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cgh on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:33PM (#9291067)
"housing prices are all time high."

This is not a good thing and I'm not sure why you seem to think it is. You talk about happiness - one way to help the "happiness quotient" is affordable housing.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by colund on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:05PM (#9291348)
It's true that all time housing prices is not a good thing. But low interest rates helps keep the Swedish housing bubble growing. Low interest rates encourages people to invest big but when the interest rates go back up people risk getting in financial trouble.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mcguire on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:53PM (#9292127)
That would answer my question about the availability of loans: there is too much money available. Sounds like Sweden is going to join the rest of us in the Twenty-first Century soon.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by anigbrowl on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:36PM (#9292785)
Because of population growth, which is slowing but far from finished. If the population is getting larger and the economy is not, then there are fewer economic resources available per person. Also, even in a stable population, if there is no economic growth then there tends to be an increase in economic inequality, because then economic transactions are zero-sum in the aggregate (by definition) and so the people who have more money at the beginning have leverage in any economic negotiation, ie they are more likely to be price makers than takers.

Economics is efficient management of resources nothing else. Giving the population ability to stay healthy with affordable health care, moderate taxes and stability should be a main priority.

Those things are economics problems. 'Efficient management of resources' is really quite complex, even if everyone were agreed about what we consider efficient, which we're not.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by wvenable on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:30AM (#9290151)
In the US and many other places, economic growth is essentially the retirement plan.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cmdkeen on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:18PM (#9291880)
Because not everyone has a Swedish lifestyle, and you seem to be stretching the upper bounds of immigration. So how do you propose dealing with the 1 billion+ people in the world who need their stands of living increased?

Capitalism has worked wonders at relieving poverty across the globe. It may have led to wage stagnation in outsource-able jobs in the West but it has led to a huge global poverty reduction. Even in Europe it has led to mass improvements in jobs that can't be outsourced, including plenty of blue collar jobs.

Maslow's hierarchy of needs is 72 years old now, it isn't rocket science, people can only be happy in their circumstances if their more basic needs are met.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by vasilipupkin on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:36AM (#9290197)
economic growth, albeit imperfect, is a measure of things getting better for society. So, we should worry about worldwide economic growth, but not necessarily Swedish economic growth. Another point is, lack of growth is a leading indicator of the situation getting worse in the future, even if it is pretty good now. So, yes, economic growth is an imperfect measure, but we have few if any alternatives to economic growth in terms of assessing how things are going in an objective way
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by TheOtherHobbes on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:23PM (#9290567)
Not so much imperfect as deceptively irrelevant.

"Growth" has absolutely nothing useful to say about "things getting better for society."

Things get better for society when jobs pay well, high quality education is freely accessible, talent and creativity are rewarded, cost of entry for entrepreneurship is low, and ecological support systems are stable.

There's nothing even remotely difficult about measuring these factors.

"Growth" is just a convenient way to disguise increasing inequality and decreasing economic freedom for the majority of the population.

If the growth is never distributed it's a useless metric.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by vasilipupkin on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:57PM (#9290819)
try to think in terms of statistical models, rather than absolute statements. Imagine a continuum in which things you mention receive a numerical score. Growth is a number. It is a number which will have a non-zero correlation with the numerical scores of the things you mention. You can also build models that try to forecast growth based on those scores, and vice versa, forecast those scores based on growth. Once you think in those terms, you can dispense with terminology such as "irrelevant", "useless", "absolutely nothing", etc.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:35PM (#9291081)
Inequality seems to be mostly inversely proportional to growth.

Low interest rates are fertile soil for inequality. If I can just buy Certificates of Deposit and live off the interest, instead of having to invest directly, that seems to me to be more egalitarian than less. Low interest rates brighten the line between us ordinary people and professional investors.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mikeash on Monday March 30, 2015 @10:00PM (#9293963)
One big reason I want economic growth is because I want to live a lot longer than the standard 80-90 years in perfect health, and I want the same for my loved ones. Affordable health care is great, but what you get for it right now frankly sucks. No matter how affordable your health care is, or no matter how rich you are and how much money you pour into it, you're going to die fairly soon, and probably go through a lot of horrible problems on the way.

I want health care that's so advanced it's "perfect." I want people to routinely choose when to die rather than having it thrust upon them. I want forgetting the names of your children to be as weird and old-fashioned as dying of smallpox. The research and development needed to get there has a high economic cost, and growth is how you can pay for it.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by randyrand on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:25PM (#9293048)
Giving the population ability to stay healthy with affordable health care, moderate taxes and stability should be a main priority

You can only do this with growth. In 1700 you couldn't afford good healtcare even if you were king. It simply didn't existed. In 2015 you could't travel on roads without the constant threat of death. In 2017 you couldn't use VR to keep in touch with loved ones. In 2030 you couldn't live in old age independently because of fatigue and weakness. Now in 2100, we have solved all of these problems. People are healthier, taxes are low and declining. People are happy, safe, and free to do as they want.

This is why I am thankful for progress. What a time to be alive.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ci5er on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @09:01AM (#9295829)
> In Sweden we currently have negative prime interest rate and people have higher salaries than ever and housing prices are all time high

To which I say: Good for you!

> Why the obsession of economic growth?

There are many reasons. Here is one:

http://ourworldindata.org/data/growth-and-distribution-of-pr...

Our work is not here done. Except, maybe in Sweden.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Bootvis on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:04PM (#9290870)
The economy needs to grow as quickly as the population because otherwise there would be a reduction in wealth on the individual level.

Also, if inequality remains the same the lives of those on the bottom of society see their lives improve.

Less essential, but the people here should appreciate it, growing the economy means that young people have the opportunity to develop themselves professionally, e.g start start-ups.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by avn2109 on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:16PM (#9290944)
>> "The economy needs to grow as quickly as the population..."

In countries with declining populations, ought the economy to contract?

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by adventured on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:37PM (#9291581)
That can be avoided through productivity gains.

Germany's population essentially hasn't increased in 40 years. Their nominal GDP has increased by 15 fold in that time (even after accounting for inflation it's a significant expansion, all due to productivity gains).

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Bootvis on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @04:43AM (#9295028)
Well, it probably will if a large number of people leave and that doesn't have to be bad news for the ones that stay. Of course, that will depend on the specific situation. I can't come up with an example where there was a large decline in population in an area on a voluntariy basis.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:38PM (#9291115)
Possibly. It depends on how well they do exports.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by throwaway43 on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:50AM (#9290296)
Because otherwise we'd have a revolution over the inequalities in our societies.

People don't mind that much as long as everyones pie is growing.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Mikeb85 on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:37AM (#9290207)
Because economic growth is the only way to pay off the massive amounts of debt that currently exist. The US needs to constantly grow and acquire more and more resources, labour and capital or else it will cease being the way it currently is...
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Someone on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:59AM (#9290375)
Inflation also is a way to get rid of debt. A few years with 10% inflation would do wonders for the debt of most countries, provided that their debt is in their own currency.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Mikeb85 on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:50PM (#9290764)
Reasonable levels of inflation usually goes hand in hand with economic growth.

On the other hand, growing the money supply too quickly when there's no economic growth leads to a situation like Zimbabwe...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Someone on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:08PM (#9290895)
The correlation between inflation and lower growth is not as strong as one would think. See for example the graphs on pages 22-23 in http://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/publications/98-1/15-... and the number of 'generally supports', 'probably' and 'may exceed' phrases in the conclusion.

But yes, 'too quickly' is not a good idea.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Mikeb85 on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:34PM (#9291070)
> The correlation between inflation and lower growth is not as strong as one would think.

Of course not. Inflation is a symptom and not a cause. If lower inflation or even deflation lead to growth, then a penny should still have value, and a dollar should be a good amount of money (we've abolished 1 cent coins altogether, and a dollar buys very little). But our economy has grown a lot since the 1950's, and inflation has happened.

Inflation is caused by many things. In Zimbabwe's case, they tried to print money to finance various things. With no underlying value, the money quickly devalued.

In the case of Canada, the US and other western nations, we've enjoyed economic growth, but because demand for goods and services has generally outpaced supply, prices have gone up. Right now where I live, an 'average' house costs $450K.

Anyhow, thanks for the link, but I've spent too much time looking at Solow equations for my liking (currently doing a degree in economics).

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by ArkyBeagle on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:37PM (#9291111)
Zimbabwe was a failed state before it had hyperinflation. i won't say that we get good answers on the difference between moderate and hyperinflation, but I am sure there is a difference.

Hyperinflation is just a good apocalyptic narrative device, and people (ab)use it.

edit: s/has/had

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by aranazo on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:35PM (#9293621)
Inflating a currency is likely incompatible with it being the global reserve asset.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by kardashev on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:20PM (#9290543)
Inflation would be a way to get rid of debt, but it literally takes money from the poor and working class and gives it to the rich.

10% inflation is equivalent to a person's salary going down by 10%. Also, any savings you had would be eaten up by 10%. Inflation is the same as taking people's money to pay debt. It's not some magic thing that makes debt go poof.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Someone on Monday March 30, 2015 @01:22PM (#9290990)
If you manage to combine a x% inflation with a x% rise in welfare payments and of worker's income, people with relatively little money in the bank will not suffer much. That includes the poor and the very rich (who likely will have invested a large fraction of their savings).

The clear winners will be those with relatively high debts, the losers those who have been saving, but not investing.

Is it fair to tax the ants while rescuing the grasshoppers? No, but if the country as a whole is a grasshopper, it may be the best one can do.

A side effect of this strategy is that it teaches ants to invest, rather than put money in the bank. That's another reason why many countries aim for inflation.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cmdkeen on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:32PM (#9291983)
The unfortunate side effect is that it shafts pensioners who should not be investing in equities because of the time scales involved. The UK (though a hefty dose of electioneering is involved) is offering bonds to pensioners which pay a higher coupon to offset the low gilt returns available.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by dgregd on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:05PM (#9290430)
The next question is why _developed_ countries are taking the debt.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Mikeb85 on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:52PM (#9290785)
Because we've made debt so cheap.

It's really all just a cycle that we can't get ourselves out of now...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cowsandmilk on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:39PM (#9290694)
What part of this post suggests that Bernanke is aimed at growth?

Bernanke states the goal of the Fed setting rates is full employment. Low interest rates encourage spending, which cause more people to be employed. Lower unemployment is generally good.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by EGreg on Monday March 30, 2015 @11:45PM (#9294245)
Indeed. Endless economic growth comes atthe expense of negative externalities. Companies are incentivized to produce more - or their competitors will - by using up more of the planet's resources and producing more waste, forever. This is unsustainable. At current rates, how long can this planet sustain our growth in consumption?

The main underlying cause of this is population growth. If countries can learn to break their dependency on a social security pyramid, by leveraging the increased productivity that automation enables, then countries like Japan with a graying population can in fact become nations of fewer, more affluent people.

Scientific and technological advancement does NOT have to depend on more consumer crap marketed and sold to more people.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by collyw on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:10PM (#9291390)
"Why the obsession of economic growth?"

Because the economy is essentially a Ponzi scheme.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by jedharris on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:50PM (#9298945)
There are two very different senses of "growth" here.

The good sense is that better ways of doing things is "growth" -- for example cheaper more efficient solar panels can slow global warming, reduce centralized power, etc.

The bad sense is increased GDP, more stuff, etc. There's no strong reason good growth has to produce bad growth. We can decouple them.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by nycticorax on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:44PM (#9290722)
What part of the OP do you think reflects an "obsession" with economic growth?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mcguire on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:26PM (#9291944)
"...negative prime interest rate and [...] housing prices are all time high."

Wait. How does that work?

Negative prime interest rate -> no loans available -> housing (and other credit-oriented purchase) prices fall.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by adventured on Monday March 30, 2015 @04:49PM (#9292500)
Negative interest rates doesn't mean no loans are available, it means the central bank is charging banks for the deposits they hold and typically that gets passed along to savers.

One theory behind it is to force savers to spend, by adding a cost to their savings. And to force banks to lend, by adding a cost to their cash holdings.

Something the parent comment doesn't seem to realize, is that having negative interest rates is a sign your economy is not functioning properly. If you have to resort to negative interest rates to keep assets from falling in value, and to drive consumer spending or bank loans, then you're already in deep trouble. Sweden's negative interest rates are likely an indication that a storm is coming for them; were they to raise interest rates it would cause a recession; and if they don't raise interest rates, their real estate bubble will continue to inflate until it explodes. They have to take their medicine one way or another.

Here's a good summary of how it works:

http://www.bloombergview.com/quicktake/negative-interest-rat...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by mauricemir on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:23PM (#9290570)
Ask the Japanese with a Mortgage caught in the deflation spiral.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by twobits on Monday March 30, 2015 @02:15PM (#9291419)
"Why the obsession of economic growth?"

Because central banks (CB) print money out of thin air. That "money" is debt. You print 100, you owe 110 counting interest. How can you pay the 10, if you only printed/exists, 100? You can't. You, me, everyone, is a debt slave. "Times are good" = CBs print a lot of money (out of thin air). A lot of non existant interest too, but you don't notice, cause more money/debt is printed. "Times are bad" = Enough is enough, CBs stop printing, you have to pay/give back, what doesn't exist, ie the interest. Defaults are unavoidable, and the people on top, pick up whatever they want on pennies to the dollar.

To put it simply: You print 100 out of thin air. There is no more money in the world. Next year, you owe 110. Where can you find the 10? (Spoiler: You can't.)

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by pdonis on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:32PM (#9293864)
> You print 100, you owe 110 counting interest.

Um, no. I agree that printing money has bad side effects, but this is not one of them.

Here's a better way of looking at it. You currently have a money supply of 1000. That money supply is matched up to 1000 units of goods and services. Assuming this situation has been stable for a while, there will be some set of equilibrium prices.

Now you print 100. The total money supply is now 1100. But the supply of goods and services has not changed. So the first order effect is to raise prices, since you have 1100 units of money but only 1000 units of goods and services, so the previous set of prices is no longer in equilibrium. (Plus, whoever got the 100 that you printed got to spend it first, so they got the advantage of the lower prices; in other words, printing money is a way of favoring some economic actors over others.)

But there is also a second-order effect--at least there is according to Keynesians. If you print money, that makes people think there are more goods and services--i.e., that the economy is growing. So they are more willing to take economic risks--hence growing the economy. So, according to Keynesians, if you print just the right amount of money, you can stimulate just enough growth to match up with the money you printed. In the above example, if we suppose that the 100 units of money printed stimulated just enough growth to increase the supply of goods and services to 1100 units, then 100 units was the right amount of money to print to keep prices stable.

Nowhere in any of this is there any "interest" on the additional money printed. That's not the bad side effect. The bad side effect is that, in reality, the amount of money printed is never just the "right" amount to stimulate the matching amount of economic growth. It's not even clear if printing money can be counted on to stimulate economic growth at all: the Fed has been printing money at a snappy pace for a number of years now, and they are still saying the economy is stagnant.

(It's true that prices have not gone up very much, at least if you believe the CPI numbers; but that's because banks aren't lending the money that's being printed--they're hoarding it in their cash balances, because they don't want to be caught short if there's a downturn. So the actual money supply, the supply that affects the prices you and I pay for ordinary items, is considerably smaller than the total amount of money that's been printed.)

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by RobertoG on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:48AM (#9294725)
I think you are being a little unfair to Keynes here. Printing money doesn’t make people think that there are more goods and services. Money is a real thing, is a medium of exchange and there is a demand for it. If you have not enough supply of it the economy suffers. Also, it’s deserved to note that the preferred Keynesian way of stimulating the economy is by fiscal policies (investing from the government), and not by “printing” money, but that is not possible in Europe or the States because politics.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by pdonis on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:26PM (#9301172)
> Printing money doesn’t make people think that there are more goods and services.

It makes people think they are wealthier, which amounts to the same thing. I'm not saying people are logical in this respect; I'm just saying that it happens, or at least that Keynes claimed that it happens. (I actually don't really disagree with him in principle; I'm not sure the effect in practical terms is as significant as he appeared to think it was.)

> Money is a real thing, is a medium of exchange and there is a demand for it.

These are actually two different things, not one. The use of money as a medium of exchange is different from the use of money to store value over time.

Demand for money as a medium of exchange can become arbitrarily small by allowing prices to fall as economic efficiency improves. Keynes appeared to think this was a Bad Thing, but AFAIK he never actually demonstrated why, he just asserted it without proof and everyone believed him. Certainly there are examples where the price of a given quantity of some good (such as a given amount of computing power) has dropped by many, many orders of magnitude, without any discernible negative impact. So an obvious alternative to printing more money so there's enough medium of exchange is to require less of the medium of exchange for each transaction.

The use of money to store value over time is what really creates significant demand for money. However, printing money in order to satisfy this demand defeats the purpose, because it reduces the value of money.

> the preferred Keynesian way of stimulating the economy is by fiscal policies (investing from the government), and not by “printing” money, but that is not possible in Europe or the States because politics

This is a good point, yes. However, I would add that the reason why the fiscal policy "solution" is not politically acceptable in Europe or the US is that was tried (in the 1930s during the Great Depression, and again to an extent after World War II) and didn't work, because governments are atrociously bad at picking the right investments. So now governments prefer to print money and hand it to private investors, who, while they are still bad at picking good investments, are at least less bad at it than governments. (But there are still other bad side effects, such as an economic meltdown once in a while.)

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by josephlord on Monday March 30, 2015 @09:08PM (#9293753)
All banks create money out of thin air when they make loans not just central banks.

And your arithmetic doesn't quite work either at the very least if you assume that money actually gets respect with a certain speed.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevekeen/2015/03/30/the-princip...

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by josephlord on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:28AM (#9296940)
for "respect" read "respent"
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by harperlee on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:04PM (#9291792)
Assuming that you can create value of 11 or more with that 100, someone can exchange 11 of their future / current / past effort (with money), (s)he pays you, you pay your debt, and you now have 1 or more to be at the other side of the transaction.

Unless you state that all value in the world is fixed, a zero sum game, that argument of the "Money as debt" documentary doesn't really hold water.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by dismal2 on Monday March 30, 2015 @05:19PM (#9292683)
Money is absolutely debt, are you claiming that it isn't?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by twobits on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:26PM (#9291946)
Value is definitely and obviously not fixed. It increases with effort, creativity, work, inventions, etc. But you pay for value with money. And you don't control that, and someone else controls how much, or not at all, you have access to. ..ie, you get 100 to (try to) invent X. You deliver. You give a lot of value to the world. But the CBs decided to cut printing money, and tomorrow you have to pay back 110. Your work, gave (new) value. But that's irrelevant. You can't find the 10. You are bankrupt. The people on top, get your work (which is 100+50 in new value), for 20. You still owe. Have a good day.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by DeanCollinsNY on Monday March 30, 2015 @08:29PM (#9293600)
agree.....it still amazes me to this day that people don't wake up and realize that inflation is "government theft" you had 100 dollars today....next year with 6% inflation next year you have $94

idiots run around looking at their 401k's and their "property values" thinking they are rich but its really.....no you idiot the government stole from you and you are too stupid to realize.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by RobertoG on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:58AM (#9294752)
That’s a very strange way of thinking about money. Money is valuable but only in the context of an economy. Your example is true only if the economy didn’t grow that year. You could make the opposite example. You have 100 dollars today and 100 dollars tomorrow but the economy shrinks a 6%, what is the real value of your money?

A most interesting way would be see money as infrastructure. In order the economy to work you need money. In order to it work properly you need the proper quantity of money. Of course we can disagree in what is the proper quantity.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by zo1 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @08:18AM (#9295660)
What way should one think of it, if you concede the fact that the "new" money printed doesn't get equally distributed to all the individuals based on their proportion of ownership of the previous total of money supply?

I.e. if there is 1000 floating around, and 2 individuals in the population. Then if the government prints an extra 100, it needs to give 50 to each individual (not 100 to the one, but not the other). Probably not logistically feasible with a large population, but that way you can at least say it's not "theft".

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by Gurkenmaster on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:56AM (#9294748)
Deflation also causes problems because the value of your money increases over time. Should I spend it today, tomorrow or in 10 years?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by zo1 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @08:20AM (#9295668)
>"Should I spend it today, tomorrow or in 10 years?"

Whenever the "future" benefit does not outweigh the "current" benefit of said money. People do it now with the interest rates the other way around, why would it be any different with deflation? I.e. they spend now, or they invest now, or they invest in financial instruments now that will beat "inflation".

Both sides of inflation/deflation affect peoples' actions based on their time preference of money[1].

[1] Economists correct me on my usage of that term, if I'm wrong.

Re:Why are interest rates so low? by randyrand on Monday March 30, 2015 @06:17PM (#9293000)
Also because growth improves lives. In 1800 if your child contracted polio he would die, now they live. If you don't think technology and growth make lives better, then HN might not be the most like minded community for you.
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by cm127 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:20PM (#9298702)
That's a trite comparison. Why not include pollution and global warming?
Re:Why are interest rates so low? by branchless on Monday March 30, 2015 @03:18PM (#9291879)
"House prices at an all time high"

So young people are poorer - this is not good. The wealth effect will wear off for older people who have housing and then the young are left passing over more of their labour to older people and banks.