News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by smackfu on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:29PM (#9279133)
If the jury doesn't understand the rules properly, it's pretty common for the judge to send them back to figure it out.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:42PM (#9279202)
How difficult is it to understand the rules and what does it say about the jury if they don't?

Edit: I really don't understand HN's obsession with downmodding legitimate questions. Either provide an answer or move on.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by raldi on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:07PM (#9279348)
> HN's obsession with downmodding legitimate questions

"What does it say about the jury?" is not a legitimate question; it's a patently loaded rhetorical question. Or really, an insinuation disguised as a question. "What does it say that X?" is code for "X is a red flag."

If you want to make an accusation, come out and make one.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:13PM (#9279373)
That's, just like, your perception, guy.

Do you start with the presupposition that juries are infallible? Surely their actions must leak information about their constitution?

If a jury cannot follow (what is assumed to be) basic rules, then how can one be assured that they capably analyzed the facts and case issued to them and then appropriately applied matters of the law (written rules) to them?

Edit: Since you edited after my response: I am not making any accusations. Strange that you assume so. I just don't know enough information about the specifics to make any judgments. That's why I asked the question(s) in the first place.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by alain94040 on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:56PM (#9279586)
If a jury cannot follow (what is assumed to be) basic rules

That's why you got down voted: you assumed something, without knowing, and you were completely wrong. Read a jury's instructions just once, and then let us know how basic it sounds then.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:20PM (#9279895)
This is why I started with the question, "How difficult is it to understand the rules[?]".

I haven't seen the rules posted anywhere, or any real discussion on the rules or how hard they are to follow. Have you?

Also, I'm not sure what is wrong with the assumption that jury rules should be "basic", as in, understandable to a jury member. Do you assume that jury instruction should be complex, complicated, and not understandable to a jury member?

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by alain94040 on Friday March 27, 2015 @09:05PM (#9280040)
A quick Google found the actual jury instructions for this trial: http://www.scribd.com/doc/260138329/Jury-Instructions-for-El...

14 pages of fairly dense legalese. How difficult can it be to understand them all?

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by raldi on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:44PM (#9279986)
The way you phrased the question makes it sound rhetorical. "How difficult is it to understand _______?" is almost always a rhetorical question; if you genuinely want to inquire about the difficulty, you kinda have to bend over backwards to make that clear to readers.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Saturday March 28, 2015 @07:14AM (#9281109)
I guess I just don't see it ("How difficult is it to understand _____?" being a rhetorical question). It sounds like a pretty straightforward and legitimate question to me. Of course, your perceptions may differ.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by raldi on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:16PM (#9279392)
A jury of one's peers is, by definition, imperfect.

However, after studying millennia of history, we as a people have decided that this is still the least bad model yet invented.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by Lewton on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:40PM (#9279513)
Legitimate question, does any other country use the "jury of your peers" model? Afaik most european countries don't
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by dragonwriter on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:47PM (#9279546)
> Legitimate question, does any other country use the "jury of your peers" model?

The concept originates in another (European, to boot) country -- it comes from the Magna Carta.

It is, at a minimum, common among the coutnries whose legal system descends from that of England, which are somewhat numerous.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by Lewton on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:55PM (#9279577)
Cheers!
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:37PM (#9279502)
This is completely dodging the (hard?) questions and deflecting to historical actors.

Also, I didn't decide anything (and I doubt you did either). This is the system I was born into and it as been operating without my input.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by raldi on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:58PM (#9279602)
What questions did you have in mind?

P.S. Note that I'm not asserting that the current system is perfect. Just that we (again, as a society; not me and you specifically) decided long ago that the drawbacks of letting 12 schlubs decide a person's fate were exceeded by the drawbacks of letting only the well-educated do so.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:19PM (#9279887)
>What questions did you have in mind?

How about the 4-5 I already posted in the direct ancestors of this thread (e.g. the the one you originally responded to [but did not answer]).

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by raldi on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:48PM (#9279993)
> Do you start with the presupposition that juries are infallible?

No; I answered that immediately in my first reply.

> Surely their actions must leak information about their constitution?

That's not actually a question, but even if the answer is yes, that's what I mean about juries being only the least-bad solution we've invented so far.

> If a jury cannot follow (what is assumed to be) basic rules, then how can one be assured that they capably analyzed the facts and case issued to them and then appropriately applied matters of the law (written rules) to them?

One can't. See previous answer.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by nazgul on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:56PM (#9279288)
I was on a jury once. Many, many people can't follow simple jury instructions, figure out the difference between an argument and a statute (seriously), etc. And most of them had an education level beyond college. It was the most eye opening experience of my life.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by PhantomGremlin on Saturday March 28, 2015 @01:57AM (#9280646)
Yeah, the jury system is scary. It's also better than any other alternative that anyone else has come up with so far.

Much the same criticism can be applied to representative democracy in general. It sucks but it beats, e.g., the plutocratic cult-of-personality that Russia currently has. And what about Somalia? Rule by warlord?

FWIW my jury experience differs from yours. I have been on a number of juries in my life and I wound up with a relatively good opinion of most of my fellow jurors. There was only one juror (out of IIRC about six juries) that, it was immediately obvious, was very close minded and basically unclear as to her civic responsibility. But most of my experience is 15 or 30 years old. Perhaps jurors have gotten dumber since then?

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by epistasis on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:49PM (#9279246)
The rules may be poorly communicated to the jury. On the one jury that I was on, they were perhaps cryptic, and by the time I figured them out I found an error in the way that we were supposed to address all the counts that we were considering.

Such clerical errors are a part of any sort of human process. It's not the end of the world as long as there are processes in place to correct the errors.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:02PM (#9279322)
That's what I'm asking. How often does it happen? What makes the rules so difficult to understand? Do most juries understand and this is just a poor jury?

Can we look at the rules in this case? Or do we just have to go off NYT reporting and uninformed HN spectator speculation?

You'd assume a centuries old institution (jury trial) would have worked through what seems like a very basic problem: how do you communicate to the jury (which is the ultimate object of the trial) what exactly they are supposed to do?

How can you judge whether a jury is incompetent (or the judge and/or the lawyer(s))?

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by cowsandmilk on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:21PM (#9279421)
(a) one case I sat on in Massachusetts, the statute was written very obtusely and the judge said she was not allowed to give us the statute in writing. The jury literally went back in 3 or 4 times to ask for the instructions and statute to be read again.

There was the statute, which then referred to other places for definitions of 4 or 5 terms, which also had to be read. Keeping a statute and the definitions in your head is not simple. Lawyers don't make their arguments in the absence of being able to reread the written law. Appeals courts can read the law when making judgments. But for some reason, as a jury, we were expected to keep it all in our head.

Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by jsprogrammer on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:41PM (#9279517)
It is my understanding that juries are empowered to do pretty much anything they please. I'd guess in your case that the judge was operating under a technicality of the language (per usual), he may personally not be able to give you any written thing except for the rules agreed to. However, the jury should be able to request that the actual statutes be delivered to it. If words are not defined in that statute, then the jury can request that the appropriate definitions be delivered to it.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by wj on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:03PM (#9279329)
Same thing happened to me on a jury I was on. We found an error in the jury instructions and had to be issued new ones.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by rosser on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:51PM (#9279262)
It's even more fun when people downvote objective, verifiable facts with which they apparently disagree. I will never stop shaking my head in sadness at seeing that happen.
Re:Ellen Pao Loses Silicon Valley Bias Case Against Kleiner ... by fixermark on Friday March 27, 2015 @05:51PM (#9279258)
Having sat on one case: More difficult than one might anticipate.