News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by kwarwick on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:16PM (#9248805)
It feels like there's an impending crunch in the luxury dumb watch industry. When there is productivity to be had by buying a smart watch, how can expensive dumb watches compete?
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by manicdee on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:27PM (#9248830)
Battery life. Aesthetics. Heirloom status vs planned obsolescence.

That's three right off the bat, and I haven't worn a watch for 20 years. I am sure an actual watch owner will have more.

To paraphrase Darth Vader: Do not be too proud of this battery powered wonder you have rented. The ability to diagnose medical conditions is insignificant next to the dark side of a month-long international trip.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by robotresearcher on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:22PM (#9248817)
Expensive watches are not about productivity or any technical functionality. They are a signal of wealth to others. A $30 Casio keeps better time than a handmade mechanical watch at 1,000 times the price.
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by count on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:27PM (#9248833)
They're no different than earrings or bracelets for women (generally).

I keep time accurately with my GPS time synchronized cell phone. The watch is for show, literally. Some of them are amazing.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by throwawaymsft on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:39PM (#9248878)
Are luxury watches about productivity? Are expensive restaurants about nutrition?
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by flinty on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:13PM (#9248962)
They are not, but technology gadgets are driven to improvement with speeds and design, a luxury smartwatch will be just as prone to being out of date a year later as an entry level smartwatch
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by count on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:24PM (#9248823)
Because some people buy the luxury dumb watches because they're amazing mechanical engineering. I don't WANT a 'smart watch' at all, but I love my TAG that has no battery or other electrical components as a piece of engineering jewelry.
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by jjoonathan on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:37PM (#9248875)
Out of curiosity (not hostility or snark, I swear) what is it about mechanical engineering of watches that draws such admiration? Is it because the components are large enough to see but small enough to look complicated? Is it a symbol of an idealized past?

It seems quite difficult to make the case that the mechanical watch is superior in terms of human ingenuity, manufacturing / supply chain sophistication, or sheer number of "clever tricks," but I'm not entirely comfortable with the explanation that it's just a status symbol that gains its value from exclusivity or brand.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by ericd on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:53PM (#9248915)
Have you ever seen a naked mechanical watch? It's wonderful to watch it work, with continuously moving/oscillating pieces driving discrete mechanics, all of it tightly packed, all of it delicate, with some pieces apparently the width of a hair, flexing this way and that. Watching a nice mechanical watch is like watching a tiny ballet of parts.

Your microprocessor is obviously much more complex, but there's no observable operation to marvel at. There's no visceral awe component.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by lmm on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:24PM (#9249004)
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by ericd on Monday March 23, 2015 @03:48PM (#9252969)
That's pretty amazing looking :-) I wish he had a video of it in motion, though!
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by marincounty on Sunday March 22, 2015 @10:07PM (#9249133)
I would never use Tag as the benchmark of mechanical watches--in terms of aesthetics, nor machining(they use ETA movements).

That said, after getting into repairing watches, a well made mechanical watch is something to admire. Plus, it's the ultimate recyclable. It is something you can pass down to your kid. A rose gold Rolex bubbleback from the 50's looks and feels great on the wrist--even if bought second hand off ebay. My only concern when wearing a nice watch is theft these days. I guess it's like driving a Olds 442 convertable vs. a Tesla? I can't compare the two. (I have never driven a Tesla though, but I have been in expensive cars)

That said I don't see much difference between the quality of older watch movements. I can honestly state that I can't see any difference on quality of a Rolex vs. Benrus from the 40-70's.(comparing just movements, not the case or straps)

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by flinty on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:14PM (#9248968)
https://vimeo.com/66671255 - The Road To Basel Episode 2: Inside The Atelier With The Legendary Philippe Dufour
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by kaolinite on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:13PM (#9248964)
I too am a watch enthusiast and thought I'd give my take in case count doesn't respond with his. There are a few reasons for me.

First, check out this video. Personally I think the watch is ugly as hell, but if anything shows you some of the craftsmanship that goes into a watch, this would be it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIXPplShtg0

Another reason is that I'm a programmer and clockwork is a form of programming. I don't know much about watchmaking (I'm hoping to eventually go to watchmaking school - not for many years though I imagine) but I read quite a bit about it and it fascinates me. It's similar to how the idea of programming on an incredibly old computer with practically no resources fascinates me. Complaining about only having 2K of memory? At least you've got electricity!

There's a hell of a lot of invention and, well, hacking that goes into watchmaking too. Take the perpetual calendar, for example - a type of watch that only needs to be adjusted once every 100 years because it tracks leap years. Moon phases that are accurate for 5400 years[1]. Planetariums on your wrist, all powered by clockwork[2]. Dials that take a century to complete a rotation.

I also love the human aspect of watchmaking. The level of craftsmanship in a high end watch, such as the Patek Philippe you saw in the video, is incredible. I love the attention to detail and the care that goes into every single component: even components that are buried deep inside the watch are still polished and decorated by hand. Pointless? Yes! But I can't help but love it.

You mention supply chain sophistication and you might be right - but don't think that the supply chains for watches aren't sophisticated. If you're interested, Hodinkee.com recently published an article about their tour around the Rolex manufacture. You might be interested in the level of complexity: http://www.hodinkee.com/blog/inside-rolex It's a long article but if you search for "Parachrom Hairspring", that section will give you a bit of insight into the kind of invention that goes into modern watchmaking.

However, after all of that justification, I'll fully admit that it's pointless. A $100 quartz watch is typically more accurate than a $10,000 mechanical. It's pretty much all about emotion, similar to how some people can become attached to paintings where all others see is paint on canvas.

[1] http://monochrome-watches.com/a-worlds-first-christiaan-van-...

[2] http://www.vancleefarpels.com/us/en/article/10935/midnight-p...

(Hm, I wrote quite a bit more than I intended to and must have given you at least an hours worth of reading/watching material! Perhaps I should write this up as a blog post sometime.)

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by 2muchcoffeeman on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:09PM (#9248951)
I always saw mechanical watch collecting more like art collecting.
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by charlesdm on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:03PM (#9248936)
Expensive watches are indicators of wealth. As are boats/jets/sports cars/etc. Tech might be a bit of an outlier, but non tech entrepreneurs/executives/businessmen often wear good watches. They're like hidden handshakes, in a way. They close deals (or at least get the conversation started).

I doubt existing "dumb" watch buyers will switch over to a smart watch. All smart watches I've seen so far look horrible (incl. the Apple one), in comparison to properly constructed mechanical watches. They also don't act as a status indicator.

(Not that I care much about watches. I do however appreciate the craftsmanship that goes into building a proper mechanical watch.)

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by Spearchucker on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:27PM (#9249012)
They're an indicator of wealth, yes. That is not (always) why people buy them. Some (like you, and I) like the craftsmanship, and the quality that comes from it. Nobody sees my hand-woven Egyptian cotton sheets, but I have them. The watch, because of how it was made, and because I like to look at it. The bed linen because of how it feels. I drive a 1972 BMW 3.0CSL because (no particular order) of how it looks, how it drives, because it doesn't have a single chip in it, and because of how it sounds. Not because it turns heads (which it certainly does).

All of this leads to expensive smart watches - I have a Microsoft Band for the SDK (I want to try multi-factor authN with it, based on this - https://www.wittenburg.co.uk/Entry.aspx?id=69e92695-f6eb-42e...). Beyond that, nothing. The (few) nice things I have are because they please me - not for their ability to impress others. But then, I'm not wealthy. Maybe when you get there, the outlook changes.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by Liuser on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:28PM (#9248840)
There is no crunch. People who buy watches buy them for their own aesthetic appeal, fashion, and analog engineering. They are also pieces of jewelry that can be passed from generation to generation.
Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by ForHackernews on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:32PM (#9249024)
Here's an interesting article discussing the high-end watch market: http://www.theverge.com/2015/3/9/8176049/apple-watch-edition...

The point is nobody buys a $176,000 watch for "productivity" reasons.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by Mikeb85 on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:49PM (#9249074)
High end watches are about either status, or bought because they're mechanical art.

That's why some cost more than your house or car... Its not about 'function'.

A Picasso doesn't compete with your TV, nor does Viannay Halter or Felix Baumgartner compete with Apple.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by kendranash on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:19PM (#9248986)
Everyone is worried that this will be the next iPhone, and do not want to be left behind this time. So they are exploring projects at this stage. Not a bad thing.

The same thing happened with the plethora of tablets a few years ago.

Re:Tag Heuer unveils smartwatch venture with Intel, Google by bri3d on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:21PM (#9248994)
With the productivity / efficiency to be had by buying a quartz watch, how can mechanical watches compete?

This question was answered in the 1970s "Quartz Crisis" : watches aren't about functionality.