Now, the naive assumption of 50% odds of beating the market is a little dangerous, since there are plenty of investments that are highly likely to beat the market but suffer occasional catastrophic losses -- i.e. without being particularly clever one can trade probabilities for magnitudes.
So at the end of the day, there's no substitute for understanding how a fund manager actually thinks and operates. It is possible to beat the market, and to do it consistently and for reasons other than luck. And it's possible, with diligence, to pick a fund manager to do it for you. But merely looking at the history of returns is not diligence, it's laziness, unless the fund has a truly astounding statistical record, which very, very few funds do, even the good ones.
One consequence of this is that the probability of outperforming each day over 40 days is the same as outperforming each year over 40 years. The latter sounds more impressive, but it actually isn't. The former would be impressive too if the null hypothesis really is a series of coin flips (but again, it's not).
Anyhow, half the point of a hedge fund isn't even to beat the market, but to hedge against market downturns. The ones beating the market are prop traders and the like...
another problem is, what is the proper benchmark? say he beat S&P 500. Ok, but we know that small stocks or value stocks outperform S&P 500. Did he beat a small stocks index? My guess is once you construct a proper benchmark, it becomes even less likely that he really did beat it.
In the real world insider trading is everywhere, and people pay big bucks to get data faster and trade faster than everyone else.
The main reason most people lose money on the stock market is because it is a zero sum game baring inflation, not because of EMH.
I know you can create "value" when currency changes hands, but we're talking about beating the average returns. And for someone to do better than the market, someone else will obviously do worse.
> And for someone to do better than the market, someone else will obviously do worse.
While it's true someone will do worse (especially when 'trading'), that 'worse' could just be a lower profit. After all, the stock markets do generally go up over time. Inflation helps, and of course economic growth too.
One post isn't enough to explain the entire monetary system, however investing isn't a 'zero-sum' game...