Re:Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 ...
by Mikeb85 on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:35PM
(#9248865)
A significant amount is returned to the market through buybacks and dividends...
Re:Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 ...
by codexon on Monday March 23, 2015 @01:57AM
(#9249657)
That money comes out of the company which came out of other people. It doesn't come from thin air.
I know you can create "value" when currency changes hands, but we're talking about beating the average returns. And for someone to do better than the market, someone else will obviously do worse.
Re:Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 ...
by Mikeb85 on Monday March 23, 2015 @01:52PM
(#9252295)
And it returns to the economy when those investors buy basically anything. Money will always return to the economy, except when people hoard cash (which is why inflation is key to our society - it reduces the value of cash and increases the money supply so that hoarding is a bad investment).
> And for someone to do better than the market, someone else will obviously do worse.
While it's true someone will do worse (especially when 'trading'), that 'worse' could just be a lower profit. After all, the stock markets do generally go up over time. Inflation helps, and of course economic growth too.
One post isn't enough to explain the entire monetary system, however investing isn't a 'zero-sum' game...
In the real world insider trading is everywhere, and people pay big bucks to get data faster and trade faster than everyone else.
The main reason most people lose money on the stock market is because it is a zero sum game baring inflation, not because of EMH.