News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by davmre on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:14PM (#9239524)
It's large when you present it as a single-day payout. If you imagine it might have taken a year of work to discover and exploit these vulnerabilities, with no guarantee of success, then the money is actually relatively low compared to standard tech benefit packages. Tons of respect for anyone who does this and avoids the urge to go to the black market (or NSA, etc).
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by criley2 on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:34PM (#9239704)
>225k is standard?

100k income per year + 33% for employer taxes, medical/fringe benefits, etc, so 133k.

1.5 years of work at 133k/yr = ~200k payout.

I wouldn't call that low since it already hinges on massively inflated salaries due to massively inflated cost of living for developers in hubs.

That 100k of buying power in SF would come from about a 55-60k salary in my area. (1)

(1) http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=moving+from+San+Francis...

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by VieElm on Friday March 20, 2015 @03:56PM (#9240334)
> massively inflated salaries

Why would you say that's inflated? Engineering is a professional occupation that requires a high degree of skill and education. Much like lawyers, doctors and other forms of professions. Many of the companies that employ software engineers at those salaries are highly profitable. From big names like Google, Oracle, Facebook, Apple and Amazon to smaller companies like FrogCreek, Atlassian, and New Relic. So why would you say they're inflated? Software engineers are employed by companies with real products, that provide real value. Salaries have been at these levels for over a decade now, in fact there was a big dip after 2000 when pay actually was hugely inflated, but within a few years pay rose again to current levels. I'd say when you've been earning a salary long enough at these levels to buy a home and raise a child that it's a stable market rate and not inflated.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by freehunter on Friday March 20, 2015 @05:31PM (#9240792)
They're inflated due to the extremely high cost of living in the areas where these jobs are common: Austin, San Francisco, Seattle, Vancouver. If someone at Google in SF is making $250k, their peer in Ann Arbor, MI (a small city with a Google office) could have the same purchasing power with maybe $80k. If the companies weren't located in SF, the salaries could be a lot lower for the same work, and the employees wouldn't really be making any less even with a lower salary.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by sbov on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:36PM (#9241063)
Actually, I sort of think the cost of living is high because tech workers make so much money. So you have your cause and effect reversed. They do seem to be the primary reason why rents and housing prices are going up so much in the bay area.

E.g. I've read about landlords who raise their rent because of the presence of a google bus stop nearby.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by simoncion on Friday March 20, 2015 @08:15PM (#9241407)
> [Tech workers] do seem to be the primary reason why rents and housing prices are going up so much in the bay area.

In 1998 (at about the height of the dotcom bubble) a 1-bedroom apartment in my apartment building was renting for ~$500/month. In 2010 (shortly after the real-estate bubble collapse) that same apartment rented out for ~$1500/month.

Does it seem to you that tech worker salaries explain that 3x increase? Remember that as of last year, tech workers made up ~8% of SF's population.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by bsder on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:00PM (#9241507)
> In 1998 (at about the height of the dotcom bubble) a 1-bedroom apartment in my apartment building was renting for ~$500/month.

That is very low according to my memory. I was in Santa Clara in that time and my rent was over $1000/mo.

Now, I wasn't down in SF with all the cool kids. I do remember that SF in that time frame was right at a gentrification inflection where there were really expensive places right next to buildings that should have been condemned, so I'm willing to concede your point.

> Does it seem to you that tech worker salaries explain that 3x increase? Remember that as of last year, tech workers made up ~8% of SF's population.

Yes. That one is easy. Nobody wants to rent to the 92% combined with highly restricted supply.

Even back in the DotBomb days, there was a reason why people were commuting from the Fresno area. (152 would be bumper to bumper at 4:30AM in the morning!)

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by 91bananas on Friday March 20, 2015 @10:27PM (#9241660)
I could not imagine a worse fate than commuting from Fresno to the bay daily, let alone doing so in bumper to bumper traffic in the middle of the night.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by bsder on Saturday March 21, 2015 @04:11AM (#9242160)
You forgot 40-60mph wind gusts because those are passes through the mountains.

It was stupid, but that demonstrates how bad things are in the central valley.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by ssalazar on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:15PM (#9241528)
In the case of San Francisco it is the combination of high salaries for tech workers and incredibly limited supply.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by davmre on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:01PM (#9240922)
The marginal cost of living in the Bay Area vs Ann Arbor is maybe 40k/year, most of which is housing. It's reasonable to compare $80k in Ann Arbor to $120k in SF, but $250k is ridiculous.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by VieElm on Friday March 20, 2015 @05:48PM (#9240874)
Inflated implies bubble, deflatable. I think it's just the market rate for living in those places. There's no bubble to pop here. Yes, it's true the cost of living are high in these areas, but I don't think that means the wages are inflated. How would you derive a non-inflated base pay eliminating cost of living?
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by freehunter on Friday March 20, 2015 @08:08PM (#9241385)
Inflated implies larger than normal. "Bubble", when it comes to tech, has a negative connotation. SF could totally deflate. Imagine if Google and Apple moved away. Boom, there goes the neighborhood. If those people are gone, the prices go down.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by nitrogen on Saturday March 21, 2015 @03:45AM (#9242127)
Imagine if all those people abandoned by Google and Apple stayed put and started new companies.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by freehunter on Saturday March 21, 2015 @12:26PM (#9243177)
Imagine if all those people were paid by Google and Apple to move.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by evgen on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:20AM (#9246484)
Yes, I can imagine them then going to have a friendly lunch with their friends working for Facebook and Twitter. Offer letter by end of week, problem solved.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by JohnBooty on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:04PM (#9240938)
Okay, so salaries in developer hubs aren't inflated. They're correct.

So then developer salaries in other parts of the country that are 40-50% lower due to correspondingly low costs of living on this areas are what, then?

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by mattnewton on Friday March 20, 2015 @08:10PM (#9241390)
While I don't doubt that they pay more because of the Bay Area, the best developers are worth more money, and I think the best developers tend to flock to the Bay Area for the network effects.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by seanmcdirmid on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:03PM (#9240932)
This is patently false. Some things cost a lot more in SF, like rent; most other things are slightly more expensive or the same in price, like a car or a trip to Europe. So really, a $250k salary in SF is like a $225k salary in Michigan, allowing $2k more a month for rent, which I think is generous, but I don't know the market right now.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by cma on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:17PM (#9240985)
Is rent tax deductible now? :P

Also remember all your local services are done by employees that have to pay rent too, and businesses have to pay rent (that one actually is tax deductible).

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by seanmcdirmid on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:43PM (#9241586)
I've lived in the bay area, it was more expensive than say SLC, but not incredibly so. Your food, your clothes, much of what you need to live, is actually sourced outside of the area. Starbucks was cheaper than SLC, for some strange reason I can't really understand. Maybe competition?

These days, I visit Seattle and Spokane a lot. Seattle is of course, a lot more expensive than Spokane, or it is supposed to be. But restaurants are much more expensive in Spokane than Seattle. Heck, across the border in Idaho where minimum wage is a lot less than WA, they are even more expensive than Spokane.

I've lived in Switzerland and now live in China. These places are much more expensive in some goods (like cars, clothes, china is cheap in eating out at least). The differentials are much greater than anything you would encounter in the states.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday March 22, 2015 @03:40PM (#9247954)
In New Jersey, at least up to a couple years ago, you could indeed deduct part of your rent (10%?) on the presumption that it had already gone towards property taxes.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by dustcoin on Friday March 20, 2015 @07:14PM (#9241234)
$250k/yr doesn't allow for $2k/mo more spending than $225k/yr after factoring in federal taxes.

California state income tax is also more than double that of Michigan's at those income levels.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by seanmcdirmid on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:41PM (#9241584)
Fine, then increase that to $4k/mo (so your Michigander is making $200k vs. SF $250k), which doesn't pan out in my experience but we are still far away from $80k.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by voronoff on Friday March 20, 2015 @04:44PM (#9240575)
With major players having coordinated to suppress wages, it's an even more suspect statement.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by andrepd on Friday March 20, 2015 @07:01PM (#9241163)
There's absolutely no reason to go on that kind of rant. We all know that. What the parent post was referring to was only the inflation due to the cost of living in developer hubs like SF.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by EpicEng on Saturday March 21, 2015 @06:46AM (#9242373)
>Why would you say that's inflated? Engineering is a professional occupation that requires a high degree of skill and education.

That really depends on what kind of code you're writing. If you're gluing together web frameworks then, I'm sorry, but I wouldn't consider that engineering, and it certainly doesn't require a large amount of education and skill.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by nawitus on Saturday March 21, 2015 @07:25AM (#9242439)
So you're saying that it's easy to hire talented web developers for low salaries, and the market is wrong?
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by zyx321 on Saturday March 21, 2015 @10:42AM (#9242831)
I think he's saying that the market value for web developers is higher than the complexity of the work would justify. (i.e. their salaries are inflated)

Feel free to disagree with people, but please try to avoid misconstruing their arguments.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by EpicEng on Saturday March 21, 2015 @12:20PM (#9243149)
@zyx got it. Certainly there are always going to be people who are head and shoulders above the rest, but the context was typical/median salary. I would expect that those truly talented individuals make more. Your average web dev? I would say that 100k is an inflated salary and that it involves very little of what most would consider to be "engineering".
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by davmre on Friday March 20, 2015 @03:11PM (#9240019)
As birdmanjeremy posted below, you have to discount for risk. This year he got $225k, next year he may get nothing.

In any case I think you're underestimating the value of benefits provided by large tech companies. Free food, top-end health insurance, maternity/paternity leave, gym memberships, retirement contributions, bonuses, etc. all add up. I've commonly heard the rule of thumb that total cost-to-employer is roughly $2N for an employee making $N in nominal salary.

The point about location is reasonable: it's harder to get a six-figure salary doing remote work, which is effectively what this is. Still I think people shouldn't be shocked about the amount of money in play here. Given the risk, it's a good payout but not a great one for someone of his (clearly very high) skill level.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by riskable on Friday March 20, 2015 @05:16PM (#9240739)
The 2x salary average is very misleading. The average for all employees everywhere in the US sure, but it's a sliding scale.

The higher your salary the less your employer is paying as a percentage of your income. There's very little difference in overhead between someone making $100k and someone making $150k. The overhead difference will only be a few thousand dollars more for the person making $150k.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by mturmon on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:35PM (#9241572)
"There's very little difference in overhead between someone making $100k and someone making $150k."

Logically, you would think so, but remember that many benefits scale with salary/seniority. Things like retirement plan matching and vacation accrual rate. Also perks like better offices, parking, "training" in attractive destinations.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by josephagoss on Friday March 20, 2015 @08:47PM (#9241473)
> massively inflated salaries

Is it really fair to say developer salaries around the $200k mark are being inflated?

Developers work can have an impact on millions of people, yet we keep expecting all of this work for a $60k salary.

I've found that only developers/programmers do this self flagellation, almost all other professions complain about $200k being too low, not too high, and expect more. (Lawyers, Doctors, and even some electrical/mechanical engineers)

It's just a shame, as I find it hard finding good work as a programmer as my peers fight for lower and lower salaries.

I had a naive hope that this industry would mature and fight for higher salaries, but whenever I see programmers getting paid half that of a Lawyer or Doctor, self flagellation start to come into play.

Such as shame for an industry with the most potential to change the world.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by justrudd on Saturday March 21, 2015 @01:24AM (#9241938)
My problem with the Wolfram/Alpha numbers is they aren't realistic. I'm looking at moving to Chicago or Atlanta or somewhere back on the east coast from Seattle. And that Wolfram page shows that a 2 bed room apartment (not house) in Atlanta is $1012. Where? Duluth? Buford? Snellville? Or to the South? If you compare like neighborhoods (Belltown in Seattle to Midtown of Atlanta), rents are usually very close to each other (within a $100 from what I've found). But recruiters are fixated on the "It's so much cheaper".
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by criley2 on Monday March 23, 2015 @01:35PM (#9252163)
2 bedroom apartment in Atlanta is ridiculously easy to find, especially if you live ITP like 95% of all Atlantans. (ATL Metro population: ~5 million. ATL City population: ~500k).

I rented a 1700sq ft, 2 bed room, 2.5 bathroom, 2 story townhouse a 25 minute drive from Downtown Atlanta for $850/mo, and it had some luxury and I could have easily found lower prices than that moving a little further out (longer commute) or lowering the size/luxury.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by brianpan on Saturday March 21, 2015 @02:41AM (#9242031)
You forgot to multiply by the probability of winning. If you have a 1 in 3 chance of winning, the expected payout is only $75k per attempt.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by hueving on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:32PM (#9239686)
>the money is actually relatively low compared to standard tech benefit packages

225K is low compared to the standard? What standard are you talking about?

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by birdmanjeremy on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:39PM (#9239749)
It's risk vs reward. If he had a 50% chance of success, and spent a year on the exploits, you could equate it to 112.5k salary+benefits package (assuming it was a full time job to find the exploits). I would call 112.5 low for the tech industry, especially for someone of his caliber.

Either way, very impressive and well deserved.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by drinchev on Friday March 20, 2015 @05:08PM (#9240701)
I doubt he got one year or any deadlines in his mind. Most of the hackers do this because they know that there's an exploit somewhere.

Come on, how many bugs do you produce, while writing code? Do you bet 500$ that you are bug-free? Do you bet 500$ that the libraries that you are using are bugs-free? I don't.

In this sense I think guys like him are having a way of thinking more similar to a gamer : "I need to do this and I come to the next level, but the experience playing is more important than the next level!"

So... I doubt he thinks there's a 50% chance. He's just too good "gamer" and he knows the games so good that he actually won the four different versions of it.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by pyre on Friday March 20, 2015 @03:35PM (#9240185)
> I would call 112.5 low for the tech industry

Depends on location.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by brucedawson on Friday March 20, 2015 @03:15PM (#9240045)
Lee is clearly extremely talented. He wouldn't be making 'standard' salaries, he'd be getting paid extremely well. And, I imagine he'll be getting some pretty impressive job offers now...
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by perdunov on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:36PM (#9239732)
I think he is talking about the expected value vs a lucky chance.

It's like the stock market. In the long run there are no miracles.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by rudolf0 on Friday March 20, 2015 @02:40PM (#9239753)
Skill definitely plays a role too. If you are smart and experienced enough, you can theoretically churn out a valuable exploit once every 1-2 months on average. At a company, you're generally going to get a flat salary.

Many vuln research/development companies do offer bonuses for every effective exploit you write though, in which case it probably is better to work for such a company than to rely solely on bug bounties and competitions for income. Unfortunately, those same companies usually sell the exploits to the NSA and the intelligence agencies of other governments.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by nullc on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:32PM (#9241048)
>avoids the urge to go to the black market (or NSA, etc).

You can still sell your exploit to the black(site) market and later collect a bounty on it. You take some risk that someone else finds it or the party you sold it to leaks it.

Price accordingly.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by leereeves on Friday March 20, 2015 @06:48PM (#9241117)
> You can still sell your exploit to the black(site) market and later collect a bounty on it.

Sounds like a good way to make dangerous enemies.

Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by yeukhon on Friday March 20, 2015 @05:22PM (#9240762)
But if they are able to find it, they are probably earning enough month-to-month on various bug bounties. Heck, most of them would probably already running or hired by some of the top security research groups.
Re:All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two by cryptophreak on Friday March 20, 2015 @07:12PM (#9241218)
>the black market (or NSA, etc)

Legitimate question: What’s the difference?