News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by FireBeyond on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:05PM (#9208606)
Not sure this warrants a felony charge, but not sure this petition is particularly inspiring either.

Both parties behaved amazingly immaturely. But this petition is a heavily reality-distorted mealy mouthed justification of hand-waving away of what he did. Every action by the other party is blown up "many DDoS activities keeping him out of important business meetings", while the things he did are just hand waved away like so: "Jason decided to play a friendly prank on him in return and performed three twenty minute stress tests on one of Brian’s wifi hotspots" - not sure how one person's actions are a DoS, but another are not).

Hyperbole abounds, too: "Conviction would guarantee the rest of his life to be spent in financial insolvency and as a third-class citizen with fewer rights and only the most unfulfilling employment prospects."

Really, convicted of a felony, you're guaranteed lifetime financial insolvency?

"a conviction would spell the end of his professional career and aspirations to serve the nation's Foreign Service corps as a diplomat."

A little snarky, but I'd wager the State Department is looking for diplomats who'd avoid getting into petty situations like this in the first place...

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by lnanek2 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:52PM (#9208793)
> Really, convicted of a felony, you're guaranteed lifetime financial insolvency?

This is actually flat out true. All large companies perform background checks and none of them will hire you if have any sort of criminal charges whatsoever. You don't even have to have been found guilty. This is called the "digital plantation" by one ex-policeman who wrote a book about it: http://www.amazon.com/Arrest-Proof-Yourself-Dale-C-Carson/dp...

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by jsmthrowaway on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:10PM (#9208849)
I was employed all seven years it took for my felony charges to fall off a typical background examination by employers such as Apple. I've spoken about it on HN before. If you're talking about minimum wage or trades, yeah, a felony makes things practically impossible, but in our industry it's overlooked by many companies. Notable exceptions are Google (who fired me when their legal team "caught up" to new hires over two months after I joined, even though I disclosed it), Facebook and LinkedIn, in my experience.

Harder, sure. Impossible? Not even remotely. Just more pressure to be good at what you do.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by kevinpet on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:33PM (#9208910)
I hope you appreciate the irony on claiming here that a felony computer hacking charge is the kiss of death.

Hint: http://www.ycombinator.com/people/

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by d23 on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:36PM (#9215763)
I don't know who you're referring to, but just because one person managed doesn't make it fair for the rest who didn't end up doing as well.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by late2part on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:03PM (#9209049)
I have two friends with felonies that work in SV Tech, they each make over $200k a year for the last 5 years at reputable venture backed companies.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by alt2319 on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:02AM (#9209957)
I have a federal felony conviction, for nearly the same exact offense that Jason is being charged with. I've worked for several software companies since my conviction, before starting my own. It definitely doesn't end your career.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by sitkack on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:38PM (#9209218)
Are they for drunk and driving?
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by joshavant on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:20PM (#9208674)
IMO, you're missing the point. Is this laden with hyperbole? Perhaps.

But 'how bad life REALLY is as a felon' is not so much the issue at hand, as it is the absurdity of pressing felony charges for what is, apparently, effectively, just a silly computer prank.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by hueving on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:55PM (#9208802)
"just a silly computer prank" is exactly the downplaying outlined in the comment you are responding to. It was a ddos. Call it what it was.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:22PM (#9208889)
A small scale denial of service is "just a silly computer prank" -- it's like having a bunch of your friends stand in the street and block traffic. You're not allowed to do it, but that in no way justifies felony charges.

That seems to be the entire disconnect in this debate. It isn't about whether it was right or wrong, it's about the unreasonableness of imposing disproportionately severe penalties on someone who did a relatively minor bad thing.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by forrestthewoods on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:53PM (#9208795)
Felony convictions are a big deal. Damn near every job application in the country includes the question "are you a convicted felon?". Checking that box will cause your resume to be automatically discarded countless times.

Felony convictions are a big fucking deal. They should not be given without very good reason. This particular instance does not in any shape, way, or form warrant a felony.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by jsmthrowaway on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:13PM (#9208853)
You should probably read the indictment that I linked in my other comment before being so confident.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by forrestthewoods on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:53PM (#9209005)
My statements regarding the severity of a felony are true independent of this particular case. So I certainly stand by those.

As for this particular instance. An indictment is quite literally one side of the story. One should be exceedingly cautious when forming any opinion based on one. There's a lot more to this story than is currently clear. I would not be surprised if Jason David Miller is guilty of actions worthy of punishment. I would not be surprised if those actions are a considered a felony in the eyes of the law. I would be exceptionally surprised if those actions are worthy of a felony in my eyes. (which means exactly nothing, I know).

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by gcb0 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @07:52PM (#9208792)
regardless of calling this new, this is a plain case of two criminals. remove the freedom and computer related novelty of this and bring it down to obvious law breaking events:

person A shoots person B. person B recovers and shoots (also non-fataly) person A. Now person A goes to the police and tell on person B.

this is exactly what happened, if you call shooting someone a prank. but let's not focus on that. if the above happened, person B would be convicted for some 10 years, and then the DA would cut that to 2 years in exchange for the first crime, ending up with person A getting 10 years and person B 2 years.

...And that is why nobody starts the snitching chain.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by tomp on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:03PM (#9208828)
This is more like person A farting near person B, and then person B sticking a post-it note that says "kick me" on person A's back.

Not shooting. Not criminal.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by jarfil on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:40PM (#9208934)
The thing with a digital "prank/crime", is that a minor action similar to a prank, can have major consequences similar to a crime... or no consequence whatsoever, all of it with the same action.

I agree that in this case the consequences seem laughable, but I think that should be a matter for a judge and/or jury to decide.

Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by tomp on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:43PM (#9208952)
Every action is like that. You can put your foot down and step on the floor and keep walking, or you can put your foot down and step on a baby and kill it.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by sitkack on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:41PM (#9209231)
Waste of time. If I were a judge, I'd order $50 fine, no record, done. And then glare at the attorney for even considering this.
Re:Petition Against Felony Charge for WiFi Prank by gcb0 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:00PM (#9220929)
the FBI seems to disagree with you.

my point stands. both farts/kick me stickers can lead the person to jail if authorities want to. you can argee about reforming the laws that allow that retarded situation, but that is the situation we are in now.

both actions waranty a criminal response with the law as it is. while most people would not call the FBI, one did, so it is the same scenario as two criminals shooting each other.