Miyamoto doesn’t see himself as a storyteller, and worries that the video game business is now so hung up on providing film-like experiences, with grand themes and complex storylines, that the essence of play is being lost.
In films, he explains, the director and the creator are one and the same person, dictating what happens, carving out the story’s arc. But in games, he believes the director should be the player – his job as a designer is simply to equip them with the toys to direct. As a creative philosophy it’s pretty much the opposite of auteurism – though ironically, it’s one that has made him the best-known games designer on the planet.
“These younger game creators, they want to be recognised,” he sighs. “They want to tell stories that will touch people’s hearts. And while I understand that desire, the trend worries me. It should be the experience, that is touching. What I strive for is to make the person playing the game the director. All I do is help them feel that, by playing, they’re creating something that only they could create.”
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/film-news/11201171/n...
There's room for a huge amount of variety along this scale and there is a lot of room at both ends of the spectrum. Often these different game types even address totally separate target markets.
I do not have a current-gen console so I'll concede that I don't have direct experience, but the reviewers I trust to tell me whether a AAA game sucks or not (i.e., neither giving automatic 8/10+s because they're big advertisers nor automatically slagging things simply because they're "sellouts" or something) have all been telling the same story lately on things like Destiny and The Order: 1886, which is that the gameplay is often OK to good-ish but it's increasingly obvious that the games are so gosh-darned ambitious and expensive now that they're getting brutally cut down to even be able to ship anything, where simultaneously the story is obviously supposed to be very important because vast, vast resources are dedicated to the cut scenes, set pieces, and the "set" (another frequent complaint being "incredibly beautiful skyboxes behind a linear corridor with chest-high walls"), yet at the same time it's obvious that huge holes have been blown in the stories by cuts and once you factor out the cut scenes, the games are almost insubstantial. In the case of Destiny, perhaps still quite fun, but not very substantial.
The "previous gen" showed the trend pretty strongly and many of us thought the gaming companies would be forced to pull out of the current trends, but so far into the current gen it really does seem that AAA will literally sacrifice everything to be "cinematic". Absolutely everything, including even good cinematic storytelling, because many of these games have been so shredded in editing that if they really were a movie they'd seriously make Uwe Boll movies look coherent by comparison. Everything must be sacrificed to good-looking cut scenes. It's getting quite absurd.
"even GTA belongs in this end, since the most fun is to be had just playing with the game mechanics, rather than in completing the story."
And this is a great example of what I mean, albeit in the previous gen... here's an interesting video where someone explores the incredible tension between the fun little mechanics in GTA IV that it goes to great efforts to create, and then how much of them it sacrificed on the altar of a "cinematic story": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E32j9ufrpoE
How much of that is a product of circular reasoning, though? What is a "AAA game"? Is Civ 5? Are the games in the Total War series? Is this a case where, because of perception, in order to be considered AAA a game needs to reach for the "cinematic"?
"In the video game industry, AAA (pronounced "triple A") is a classification term used for games with the highest development budgets and levels of promotion"
Civ 5 and Total War are awesome games, but I don't think they reach the same amounts of sales and gross as the AAA titles (they might be more profitable, I don't know).
Only Minecraft cracks the list of top 10 bestsellers in 2014:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2015/01/19/the-top-ten-...
www.ign.com/articles/2015/01/15/these-are-the-best-selling-games-of-2014-in-the-us
1. Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare (360, XBO, PS4, PS3, PC)
2. Madden NFL 15 (360, PS4, XBO, PS3)
3. Destiny (XBO, PS4, 360, PS3)
4. Grand Theft Auto V (PS4, XBO, 360, PS3)
5. Minecraft (360, PS3, XBO, PS4)
6. Super Smash Bros. (3DS, NWU)
7. NBA 2K15 (PS4, XBO, 360, PS3, PC)
8. Watch Dogs (PS4, XBO, 360, PS3, PC, NWU)
9. FIFA 15 (360, PS4, XBO, PS3, Wii, 3DS, PSV)
10. Call of Duty: Ghosts (360, PS3, XBO, PS4, NWU, PC)A lot do, but then you have to think about what it means to be a AAA game. Basically, what is it that causes a game to require a huge budget?
A huge budget is generally due to a lot of assets. A lot of assets is generally very high detail models and cinematics, the tools to tell a story.
The other thing is technology, things like creating an MMORPG is technologically expensive. But look at your average MMO and note how they generally lack on the story side of things.
Gameplay on its own is pretty lean. You can't put a team of 100 designers together and get a great game in 1% of the time, but you can do something (with good direction) somewhat similar with artists. You can have one guy doing the rocks, and one guy doing the hair, and a few guys doing architectural stuff, and some people doing monsters, and they can all fit together.
With gameplay though, it's too much the essence of the game to be split across too many roles and still work well.
So you look at something like The Order: 1886, and you complain about how cut down it is because it's so expensive to make. But think about what that game is. It's a game to sell PS4s essentially. Each new generation of console gives access to great new graphics and performance. But when you have the ability to render the movement on the hairs on your characters arms, you have to hire someone to put hairs on peoples arms and make sure they act correctly in the wind.
You can certainly make games with lower detail, but then what is the point of the new generation of console? This is why I think the majority of games out there for the next gen consoles are either cross-releases with current gen consoles with some moderate performance or upscaling, or they are pretty but underwhelming.
The best stage to be creative is in the small teams of the 80s, and the more recent indie resurgence. When you employ a battalion of creative people to make your game, you absolutely need to sell it. You can't take a risk. And not only do you have to sell it, you have to sell big.
On the other hand, if you're a team of 4 people, sure you don't want to go broke, but you can afford to make something that you think might be niche. The especially cool part about that is that sometimes these teams discover something that we never knew we always wanted. Take minecraft, little hobby project that can be done only because it's a little hobby project, but ends up earning millions and being sold for billions.
And now it's on the PS4 too.
The problem isn't the game industry. It's the AAA game industry and the pressure to sell consoles with more power than people need to play a fun game. The more detailed the games are, the more expensive they are to make. The more expensive they are to make, the less risks they can take creatively.
This (and the internet) is the reason the Indie scene is pretty forefront right now.
And the game side of things.
Along with the ones you mentioned, there's been Wolfenstein: The New Order, BioShock, Uncharted, Alan Wake, Heavy Rain, Red Dead Redemption, Catherine, Deus Ex: Human Revolution, Enslaved, Fallout: New Vegas, Life is Strange, Mass Effect, Tomb Raider, Spec Ops: The Line, Dishonored and many more just in the last five years, all with excellent stories in a variety of genres. There have even been some recent adventure games that can hold their own against the best of the golden age, like Broken Sword 5 and Tesla Effect.
I think a lot of this perception comes from how the most popular video games present themselves: as mindless diversions. Think Call of Duty, League of Legends, Candy Crush, and so on. They can still be fun, but the story components are afterthoughts, hopelessly generic, or entirely non-existent. If you aren't participating in the market and seeking out new experiences, you don't know what's really out there.
I do miss classic adventure games, and a lot of what Al talks about does ring true to me. They were the AAA games of their era, and yet Sierra and Lucas and Revolution never put out a generic or cash-in game. Even though these games were heavily sequelized (far beyond modern standards), they retained a unique voice. It would be amazing to see a modern publisher crank out games as often as Sierra did while matching their level of quality and innovation.
The problem isn't really the narrative, but rather the lack of a well-developed, deep setting. All of the games you listed have very good stories, but those stories make you the Center of the Universe and everything revolves around you. Even the parts of the setting that are explained give a very strong feeling that, at the end of the day, they were developed to justify and validate your goals and missions, either by hampering you or aiding you.
In direct contrast, I'd like to point to the Baldur's Gate games. They don't just have an excellent narrative. They also take place in a very strong, well-established setting. This setting successfully conveys the feeling that, while you are an important character and what you're trying to do is important, at the end of the day the world (of Faerun) is chock full of people and organizations and nations with their own agendas. The epic saga you experience is simply one strand in a massive tapestry. And in the end you don't save the world or some such nonsense. You simply conclude your own story, and life goes on.
Compare this to Mass Effect, where you literally save the entire galaxy from ultra-powerful robots who literally want to wipe out all life. Okay, fine. But the series does so little setting development that you end up caring more about destroying the bad guys than understanding and learning about the galaxy you are trying to save.
Now contrast this with Mass Effect, when you have a team of (just throwing a number around) 10 people writing the story and the setting during it's 4/5 year development in secret. You can't possibly expect the same level of detail or complexity.
And don't forget that The elder scrolls is known for it's "flexible" and uncertain lore (Who/what is really Talos?) and big retcons (Cyrodill's forests).
But I agree with what you say about Mass Effect. I just think that they are different things for different tastes. On the Mass Effect side you have highly developed characters and character interactions and a high focus on emotional and memorable setpieces. There is a great effort to provide an emotional story, and making the player experience it in the best way possible.
On the other hand you have The Elder Scrolls, where the story and character are not so interesting (or what makes them interesting is not thrown in your face) and the story is just a pretext to make you experience the world. The world is what is important, so it's what is developed.
There is also a different purpose in the different "levels" of the game. While in ME a design goal may be "The player should fight an old friend, after discovering his betrayal", in TES may be "The player should fight a dragon near a boiling volcano using a dwarven ballista". In the first one the writer have to focus on the emotion to be conveyed by the dialog and environment, while in the second the writers just have to justify the environment (i.e. "Why is there a dwarven ballista?").
I also belive that writers in TES are given the reedom to write what they want and if it's cool it goes into the game. That's how I believe all that trippy stuff[0] got into Morrowind.
[0] https://fallingawkwardly.wordpress.com/2010/08/29/the-metaph... (not the best explanation, but an interesting read)
Yes, but until Morrowind, not much was established about that part of the Elder Scrolls world. It was, for all intents and purposes, an almost-blank slate and was created basically from scratch.
I agree with your characterization of the Mass Effect series. And don't get me wrong, I like all three games, and am looking forward to the fourth. I was just explaining why they fall short on the narrative front, and that the "they don't make games like they used to" complaint the grandparent mentioned is quite valid.
In Arena, they introduced the provinces, the races, and some other bits.
In Daggerfall you are introduced to many of the important features of the setting, as you can see by the list of in-game books [0]: - The story of Tiber Septim and the Septim dynasty, - The Aedra, the Daedra and Oblivion - The MAges Guild, Fighters Guild, Dark Brotherhood and The Psijic Order - And you already have some glimpses into some bits that would be expanded later (Like the Dwarves and the Numidium)
Now, you can argue that more was added in Morrowind that in the any other game. I agree, and add that more was added in Morrowind that in all other entries together.
Sure, they are awesome, weird, and generate most of the modern discussions about TES lore. And don't forget that the Dragon Break only exists because Daggerfall has multiple endings.
About the "things aren't like they used to", I disagree. There is more text and fluff in modern games than before. Yes, in the 80's you has massive instruction manuals full of lore, and feelies, and other stuff. But the games themselves were many times lacking. Nowadays you have lot's on in-game logs and books. Almost every item has some flavour text associated.
And, IIRC, King's Quest has a framework pretty much similar to Mass Effect. You follow a linear path, with well crafted setpieces, but not much store about "other stuff". How big is the kingdom? What to they believe in? Who was the previous king? And the One before that? Were there any wars? etc..
There is a very real problem across many creative mediums these days (big budget movies in particular) that the stakes have been constantly raised to the point where there's very little room for smaller, personal stories. It's either the total destruction of life as we know it, or it doesn't get made. I think it's fatiguing for the audience, and always having enormous stakes makes it boring and pedestrian.
Most of the games that I mentioned do fall into this trap in one way or another, but there are still some exceptions. Red Dead Redemption is a good example. You aren't trying to save the world, you just one to do this one little thing and then get back to your family... except it keeps dragging on and on.
> And in the end you don't save the world or some such nonsense. You simply conclude your own story, and life goes on.
I guess I don't see those two as being at odds - I think it's entirely possible to have a well-developed and deep setting while still having a traditional "save the world" game.
For example, I don't think it's controversial to say that the Elder Scrolls series has a very deep and thoroughly developed setting, but in Skyrim you're the chosen one who stops a world-ending evil. In Dark Souls you're literally known as the "Chosen Undead", and people have spent months exploring the setting and lore of that game.
I'd even say that Mass Effect has a decently thorough lore and history if you want to look for it (the history of the Genophage or the Geth for example).
Rather, I think modern games do a great job of taking the "save the world" trope and inverting it slightly: you saved the world, but at what cost?
In Mass Effect you save the entire galaxy from robots, at the cost of forever losing the ability for FTL travel (and stranding a lot of people where they are in the galaxy). In Skyrim you can save the continent from the evil imperial invaders, but it's heavily implied that a third party wants exactly that in order to split the empire apart and invade while it's weak. Dark Souls pretty much bashes you over the head with the fact that saving the world is essentially fighting a losing battle.
> In Mass Effect you save the entire galaxy from robots, at the cost of forever losing the ability for FTL travel (and stranding a lot of people where they are in the galaxy).
There are different ways you can save the galaxy (you can also fail to do that, and the world goes on, organic life gets reset). You can just destroy the robots, along with all other artificial life forms - some of them are those for whose right to live you just fought (if you choose so). You can resolve the issue by performing what amounts to a galactic-scale rape, changing everyone without their consent. Or you can risk becoming the very force you tried to destroy, hoping that you have enough morality in yourself to not go dark yourself.
I spent something around 20 minutes just sitting there and thinking those choices through. Which one is the right thing to do?
I think they did a good job of taking the "save the world" trope and turning it into a huge moral conundrum for the player.
I disagree. First of all, you work your way to saving the galaxy through first two games. There is a lot of setting development, hidden in Codex entries, dialogues and things you overhear when you slow down for a moment and start walking around people. Especially in the first two games, the universe seems not to care much about you, or humanity at all - everybody has their own business to mind, and humanity as a race seem to be a minor and annoying nuance in the galactic community. Also, the story is quite deep in many ways, if you spend time to immerse yourself in it.
I can't relate ME to Baldur's Gate, as I haven't played the latter yet. But ME was the deepest and most complex world I have seen in a computer game so far.
BTW. Since there's ME4 coming up and the most important event of that universe has been already concluded, I wonder what the storyline be there. I don't think they can develop anything else than a "one strand in a massive tapestry" this time.
There's a reason Sierra failed - player punishing adventure games fell out of fashion. I play more than a few adventure and point and click games on Steam and rarely are the puzzles Sierra-like frustrating. That formula just doesn't work and only worked because of the lack of competition in the 80s. The early 1990s brought us stuff like Doom, Civilization, Myst, etc and killed the adventure game market. Heck, The Longest Journey and its sequels, pretty much brought back the Sierra-style game and sold a lot of copies. Compare it to what Sierra was doing. TLJ is pretty much fine art compared to the schlock-fest and hammy writing of the Sierra crew.
> I realized, anyway, by the mid-'90s that people weren't looking for deeper games with deeper puzzles and thought-provoking concepts and all these things we were hoping for.
Talk about paying yourself a compliment! Are we really saying Half-Life's or Chrono-Trigger's storytelling is more shallow than the milquetoast stories of the Sierra universe? Come on.
There's also an argument here that games shouldn't be "do some work to get to the next part of the story" visual novels. There's balance between story and game. Some lean more one way than another. There's nothing wrong with either approach. I think modern gamers lean towards a more cinematic story-telling experience, which is a questionable fad. If anything, games are too story-based right now.
That said, I feel a little sorry for Al. He and his people were on top of the gaming world in the 1980s and are now deep into irrelevancy. The sad part is, if he took on a more mature attitude like, "Hey, we had a lot of fun, but the industry changed quickly and we didn't, and we got squashed," a bit like Nolan Bushnell did about Atari, I'd have some respect for him. But playing the endless blame game (gamers suck, management sucks, but the creatives are oh-so perfect) just makes him look a primadonna.
Consider a lot of people went and saw a comic book movie done by a man who doesn't read and, it seems, hates comic books, I'm not sure that's a disqualifier of the filmmaker's opinion.
Of course. There are film theaters and Internet. You can count good films at the end of the year with the fingers of your hand.
Good film makers are going to spend lots of time making films, not watching them.
There is lots of great series now, but if you are a professional you just need one or two episodes to really grasp the entire collection. Writers of series always use the same proven structure that works. Once you know, it is kind of boring because all series look the same.
Same applies, I suspect. "I've seen it, and I don't want one"
I'm not saying I agree with the assessment, but I get it.
If that filmmaker were D. W. Griffith, I sure as shit would.
If he were French, I would. French TV is shit.
If they'd been making good films all the while, then sure. Why not? Otherwise it'd just be prejudice.
Al has been around long enough to see the trends and recognize the themes. If Alfred Hitchcock rose from the dead today and saw our current climate of remakes and benign comedies, he might enjoy them as novel. Or he might see them as knockoffs of ideas he'd seen done better a dozen different ways in his time, and for all the technical differences like format and cutting, not have a high artistic opinion of them or their methods.
Al has that sort of background and experience (although not the lasting acclaim). He's not that impressed by fps or texture sizes or other period-sensitive qualities. He may not be giving them every chance to prove themselves, but why should he? He just thinks the big industry hype doesn't match the products, and I don't disagree.
Seriously, if you were interviewing a filmaker who proundly said, "I haven't owned a TV in 15 years, because I know it's all shit", would you take their opinion seriously?