Re:“Sierra… well, it was the poor victim of a hostile takeov...
by protomyth on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:16PM
(#9197937)
I would say a comic book movie is a combination of forms with the best being made by folks who love both. Loving only one does not disqualify you from trying to combination. Just as some people make movies and hate TV. TV viewing is not a prerequisite for being a competent film maker.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:“Sierra… well, it was the poor victim of a hostile takeov...
by bryondowd on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:04PM
(#9199227)
I'm not sure I would agree with you there. I suspect these movies are far more movie than comic book, and that the target audience is far more moviegoer than comic book fan. If anything, I think being a big comic book fan could actually be a detriment for such a filmmaker, as they would have to resist doing things that work for comic books/comic book fans but don't really work for movies/moviegoers. But more likely, if it is a good filmmaker, whether they like comic books will have little or no impact on whether they can make a good film, even if it is based on a comic book. The mediums are just too different.