News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Zikes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:28PM (#9192746)
If the revenue generated from an act isn't enough to even qualify a passing mention on your tax return, I don't see how it could be considered commercial.

It's like if someone saw me pick up a quarter on the sidewalk and cited me for operating a business without a permit and being improperly zoned.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by DanBC on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:35PM (#9192795)
> It's like if someone saw me pick up a quarter on the sidewalk and cited me for operating a business without a permit and being improperly zoned.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3171665

http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2011/08/03/the-inexplic...

> In Coralville, Iowa police shut down 4-year-old Abigail Krstinger’s lemonade stand after it had been up for half an hour. Dustin Krustinger told reporters that his daughter was selling lemonade at 25 cents a cup during the Register’s Annual Great Bicycle Race Across Iowa (or RAGBRAI), and couldn’t have made more than five dollars, adding “If the line is drawn to the point where a four-year-old eight blocks away can’t sell a couple glasses of lemonade for 25 cents, than I think the line has been drawn at the wrong spot.”

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Zikes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:37PM (#9192807)
I think it's safe to say now that there are no remaining government institutions that have not jumped the proverbial shark.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by sentenza on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:09PM (#9193036)
Honestly, this is not a thing exclusive to governments. I wonder what would have been different, had this been a FIFA event.

I guess they probably would have sued her parents on top of closing the stand.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by jes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:32PM (#9193176)
Governments have the legal right to use force against individuals. Individuals, and individuals that band together into organizations, have no such right.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by mindslight on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:13PM (#9193519)
First, there aren't many large scale bands of individuals that don't also obtain special privileges from the government (aka incorporating).

Second, while these organizations theoretically "have no such right", there are plenty of instances where they do directly wield force yet escape justice, abuse the force-wielding functions of government to harm people, or use their concentrated power to buy off parts of the government (principle agent problem). Insisting that these are ultimately government problems because a perfect minimalist government would not succumb is highly wishful thinking. It's falling into the classic political trap of addressing one half the problem while drumming up full-speed-ahead support for the other half.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by shit_parade on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:52PM (#9193821)
It's rather difficult to defend yourself against an organization that can use it's wealth and influence to leverage the government to make it a crime to fight against them, or to make it so expensive to compete that unless you're already rich you cannot, or to sick FBI or police or military on you.

A company would not be nearly so dangerous if it could not in turn influence the government to destroy you. It is much cheaper to give campaign donations to a US senator and then hand him laws to pass or ask for subsidies or for no-bid government contracts than is it to actually compete in an open market where you have to provide a better service for a better price than everyone else.

I find it amazing that people clamor for the government to protect them and yet day after day we see examples of the government crushing the helpless, confiscating their property, throwing flash bangs at their children, torturing them, or just straight up murdering them, and all without consequence, at most you get a pretty speech than it s back to business as usual handing out billions of tax payer wealth so companies can give some of drippings back to our 'elected' representatives.

And when you bring this up, what do people say? They tell you it's just bad luck, there really are some good people in government, try contacting your your congress critter, try getting into public office. The definition of insanity is to repeat the same action over and over again and expect a different result.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Zikes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:45PM (#9193288)
Tell that to the RIAA and MPAA.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by adventured on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:50PM (#9195070)
Both of which rely on and aggressively use (via bribes) the government's legal right to use force against individuals as their means to implement their policies.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by baddox on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:43PM (#9193751)
I don't think FIFA would exercise any authority except over contracted players/employees or on FIFA owned or rented land.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Loughla on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:54PM (#9192951)
That's a nice line, but it's always more complicated than that. Do the actions of one town's government speak for the entire county, state, or country? Do the actions of the federal government speak for each state, county, or town?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Domenic_S on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:16PM (#9193074)
Do they need to? This is dangerously close to a No True Scotsman.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Loughla on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:41PM (#9193258)
What I'm saying is that you cannot, across all sectors, in all areas, in all ways, claim that government, every piece of it, has jumped the proverbial shark.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by shit_parade on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:06PM (#9193017)
When numerous examples can be found of abuse by government at the township, county, state, and federal levels what else can you say besides the parent comment? Is your defense the usual 'few bad apples' argument because at this point the orchard is rotten and crawling with worms.

It would be humorous except non-government, non-corporate individuals have no way to redress grievances.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Loughla on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:48PM (#9193315)
You have several ways to address grievances. You can speak to your local representatives. Write to the local press. Contact your State and National Representatives, and then contact them again when a staffer takes your call the first time. Write letters, e-mails, radio ads, television interviews, poems, songs, plant trees in the shape of your own face, you can use the power of hate on 4chan or the hug of death from Reddit.

You can protest, is what I'm saying.

I'm not saying that a few bad apples spoil the bunch. What I said was that it isn't true that all parts of every government office are abusive. I implied that issues in Idaho's state government aren't the same as those in Miami's Precinct Alderman's offices, and those are different than those in Washington, D.C.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by shit_parade on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:05PM (#9193464)
Do you have a designated freespeech zone for me to use?

Where shall I gather the money to run radio ads? You actually believe planting trees is a way to address grievances?

My state and national representative will not care one iota for my opinion if it isn't attached to either A: a large check or B: a large constituency.

I wrote there are numerous examples of government abuse on all levels, how is it then not true that every government office is abusive? Yes, perhaps this particular ranger in this particular state park is clean as a whistle -- in our orchard of rotten apples there are still a few good ones if you pick through the garbage.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Loughla on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:12PM (#9197914)
Freespeech zone: nope, not sure how that's relevant.

Radio: any type of fundraising that you believe would work, or try to get free air time on local broadcasts or regional programs. It helps if you have an interesting topic to talk about.

Trees: If it gets your message across, yes. It would be a good news story.

"My state and national representative will not care one iota for my opinion if it isn't attached to either A: a large check or B: a large constituency."

Have you ever tried? This is the kind of statement made by someone who has nothing but second- and third-hand knowledge of the process, usually garnered through biased news organizations (they all are).

My experience has been that very few citizens are involved in politics as lobbying goes. I'm convinced that if every private citizen got as involved in the actual process as they are in complaining, actual, paid lobbyists would be driven out of business. They only speak for us because we do not speak for ourselves.

I have successfully lobbied my state representative. I wrote to the local paper, I arranged an interview with compelling stories for local television. I made a nuisance out of myself until I got airtime on local radio stations. I made such a stink that my federal representatives even called me to discuss the issue and ask for my thoughts (albeit not too much in depth). I spoke for myself, because the people who were doing it full time didn't have my best interests at heart.

But, I felt passionately about the topic. You're right, it's easier with money, but you can also spend time and energy for nearly as good of a return. Not everyone has these things to spare, and I appreciate that (I was lobbying against cuts to low-income early childhood in my area; the exact kind of people who have neither time, money, nor energy to fight the fight). But, if it's something you truly feel is right, just, and good, you'll figure out how to make it happen.

Finally, to bring it back around to the original argument; it may be that several government entities are abusive. It is probably true that a majority are corrupt. But to say that ---all-- government is abusive or corrupt is just ridiculous. Those type of arguments add nothing to the conversation other than noise.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by jimktrains2 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:14PM (#9193063)
USGS and Census bureau are pretty decent?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ethbro on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:36PM (#9193209)
Aside from the Bureau of Indian Affairs, most of Interior is fairly innocuous.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_federal_agencies_in_the...

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ecdavis on Thursday March 12, 2015 @06:30PM (#9194400)
A similar incident happened in Australia:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-12-23/bunbury-girls-lemonade...

It includes some great quotes from the council spokesperson.

> An 11-year-old girl's cupcake and lemonade stand has been shut down by Bunbury city council officers over health and safety concerns.

> "The city applauds her efforts in trying to be entrepreneurial, but it is important to seek professional advice in relation to legal requirements."

> "If she can look at manufacturing food in a commercial kitchen, then there is a possibility that she will be able to do it in the future," Ms Upton said.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by mattm on Thursday March 12, 2015 @07:56PM (#9194843)
Wow, this sounds like it should be an article in The Onion.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Someone1234 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:37PM (#9192806)
> If the revenue generated from an act isn't enough to even qualify a passing mention on your tax return, I don't see how it could be considered commercial.

Is there such an amount? As far as I know all income is taxable, there is no "minimum amount per source."

If you're talking more "real world" (e.g. pick up a quarter so fail to declare) then why would the FAA care at all about that? You cannot cite some fictional minimum income per source and then expect the FAA to adhere to it.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ghaff on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:48PM (#9192903)
I believe you are correct. Note that this is different from the minimum income you need to make to file a tax return. Now, if there's no paperwork, it doesn't matter in practice. However, I receive Amazon forms for some minimal royalty and other revenue and if I don't include those on my tax returns there's a good chance it would trigger something. I've had Interest 1099s(?) for literally pennies for small dollars in some account that paid minimal interest.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Naga on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:59PM (#9192983)
In Canada, you are required to report all income, whether from employment, business or from property, but in practice for small amounts it is sometimes left out. For example, interest on deposits in bank accounts is taxable, but the bank won't send you a form unless you made over $50 in interest that year, so you don't have to claim that dollar you made.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by adekok on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:32PM (#9193175)
> Is there such an amount? As far as I know all income is taxable, there is no "minimum amount per source."

In Canada, if you owe the government less than $2 in taxes, they don't want the money.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ars on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:54PM (#9193359)
> Is there such an amount?

Yes. When the income exceeds your expenses it becomes commercial. That's seems like a very clear and bright line to separate the two without worrying about youtube ads.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by baddox on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:44PM (#9193763)
I'm not legal expert, but surely there is some legal distinction between selling an old jacket on craigslist and operating a large used clothing store.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ars on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:59PM (#9193866)
Your expenses for the old jacket are the cost of the jacket when new, your computer, the time it takes to post it, etc.

That makes it not commercial. The IRS has rules about "hobby" which are basically the same: If you don't [eventually] make money after expenses and deductions, it's not a business.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by baddox on Thursday March 12, 2015 @05:11PM (#9193954)
What if my jacket has since become a collectible, and thus sells for much more than what I paid for it?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ars on Thursday March 12, 2015 @05:21PM (#9194003)
Then technically you have to pay taxes on the gain. You would be able to deduct expenses though.

For example there are exemptions written into the law about gain on selling a house, if you don't make too much extra.

Are you trying to ask me about making something commercial retroactively? i.e. you did not buy the jacket with the intent to sell it for more, and now suddenly it's worth more?

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by baddox on Thursday March 12, 2015 @05:39PM (#9194114)
The taxes you pay on the gain is just the normal personal income tax, right? Isn't that a separate issue from being regulated as operating a business or commercial venture?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ars on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:05PM (#9195315)
No, they are capital gains tax.

Or you can put the earnings inside a business, and then offset it with expenses. The business could pay you salary, or you can keep the money inside the business and realize it as capital gains tax later when you want.

You have many choices on how to organize the money.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:40PM (#9193251)
>Is there such an amount?

You could possibly use minimum wage as a threshold for whether something realistically counts as commercial. That might be too high though.

Would it be inappropriate for the FAA to make up a line below which things are blatantly not real income in their eyes?

Who would be responsible for a national guideline anyway?

But I wouldn't imagine huge objection to saying that anything below a tenth of minimum wage per hour of work is a noncommercial hobby.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Zikes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:38PM (#9192815)
I'm 99% certain there is an amount, and much less certain that the amount is $5,000.

Edit: Or $400.

http://www.freelancetaxation.com/the-minimum-freelancers-nee...

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by nostromo on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:47PM (#9192891)
That's 400 cumulative.

So if you make $20,000 a year and find $1 on the street, you're supposed to declare that dollar.

Another fun fact: if you crash at a friend's house for a few months without paying rent, you're supposed to count the amount you didn't pay in rent as gift income.

I think it's safe to say that everyone that has filled their taxes has does something wrong. Sometimes it's not even clear to the IRS what a person should do.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by HillRat on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:05PM (#9193453)
[I]f you crash at a friend's house for a few months without paying rent, you're supposed to count the amount you didn't pay in rent as gift income.

You're fundamentally correct, but it's worth unpacking the logic here. First, the donor pays the gift tax, unless an agreement is in place for the recipient to do so. The controlling case is Dickman v. Commissioner, 465 U.S. 330 (1984), and the basic idea is that, if you have a recognizable property right, foregoing the commercial use of that property in favor of providing it at a discounted rate creates a recognized gift. The gift amount is determined by the fair market rental value of the property. (This gets around the concern of the poster below about how you're supposed to declare income you didn't receive.)

Gift taxes are really just a method of checking large-scale tax evasion schemes where someone gifts assets to family members; to ameliorate the effects, there's a $14K/person/year exclusionary zone (plus other exemptions and methods to reduce liabilities) where you don't have to declare or worry about gifts.

Technically, couch-surfing probably wouldn't trigger the IRS' interest (not sure even they would try to figure out the fair-market value of a couch and a blanket), but giving someone a room (let alone the full use of a rental property) would in fact be a taxable event. However, it's unlikely, even in the Bay Area, that the value of that would rise above the $14K/person gift exclusion. In Dickman, the parents had to give a lot of interest-free loans to trigger the IRS' interest.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by balabaster on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:32PM (#9193185)
So how much didn't you pay in rent? That's like trying to explain how much money you didn't make this year and being taxed on it. I didn't make a billion dollars... do I get taxed for that?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:54PM (#9193361)
The obvious answer is fair market value, but now you have me wondering if you're supposed to pay for taxes on someone giving you a ride, even in a way where paying for that ride would be illegal...
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by FireBeyond on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:39PM (#9193727)
My employer gave me a loan. Whilst they were happy to do so interest-free, the company accountant advised that it would then be subject to income tax.

They had to give me the loan at at least the prime rate (which was fine for me, since at the time there was no way I was getting a loan at that rate).

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by jklein11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:35PM (#9193700)
Read Hillrat's comment above. Unless you racked up 14k in rides, you wouldn't have to declare it.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by jklein11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:03PM (#9193441)
Hmmm... not quite. In the case of the rent you got some resource,(ie a place to stay) that is worth x amount of dollars. Your friend who was nice enough to cover that expense gave you a gift of x dollars. The amount of money you make is a trade you made for your time. If someone were to do your work for you while you reaped the rewards... yes you would be taxed for that.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by msandford on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:50PM (#9193803)
One could (un)reasonably -- perhaps logically -- make an argument that all sex now requires filing gift taxes by someone somewhere. Obviously notionally who is giving and who is paying is going to be a thorny issue, but it has to be resolved.

Sex is monetizable in some jurisdictions (almost nowhere in the US, but neverless somewhere!) and as a result all sexual acts have monetary value; it doesn't really matter where they are performed. Given that they have value someone must be giving up income by not charging, and someone else is receiving a gift which the other party is so generously waiving.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by balabaster on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:26AM (#9197238)
So what rate do you tag that with? I mean... your partner is clearly in the price bracket of "high class escort," right? How do you justify how much your partner is worth on a tax return?

Do you let your partner see your tax return for fear that they claim you don't value them as much as you should? Or do you overvalue them and get overtaxed? Where's the fine line? Or do you agree amongst the two of you that for the purpose of your tax returns you're both "$5 blowjob on the corner for crack" material to keep each of your taxes to a minimum? Who's to argue?

Do the government have to send people around to rate you both to ensure you're not skipping out on taxes? "Well, she's a 10 who could easily score the $8,000 a night which is the going rate at Madame's High Class Escorts down the street. You've been living together for 6 years now and you've not claimed this as a taxable benefit. So you owe us back taxes on $17.52M - we don't care that you only earned $480,000 in that time. Also, we're really not understanding how she's with you knowing she could have made $17.04M more if she ditched you." and handing your partner their business card...

Even using "market rates" as this thread is suggesting is an incredibly subjective affair. Let's say you rent a room some place, at market rate for the area... what's market rate? It's 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, shared kitchen; but there's mold and clearly the roof leaks, none of the kitchen cupboards shut properly, the hot water doesn't work, the door lock is a wedge of wood in the door jam, you've seen cockroaches. It's rented out by a slumlord, but it's in a ritzy neighborhood. You're in a position where you have to rent this place, it's a dump, you're not sure if you weren't in this situation that anyone else in their right mind would rent it... the rent is $1,500 a month, because of the location.

Your friend down the street takes pity on you and lets you crash in his spare room to save you the indignity of living in this shit hole. Do you get taxed on the place you can afford or the rate your friend could get if he put his spare room up for rent? Given that he doesn't want to rent his room out to a stranger, but he's letting you crash there for free because he's your friend, what is the market rate for that room? The same as the one down the street which is only room for rent on the street? How does "market rate" get applied?

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by msandford on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:34PM (#9199451)
Thanks! You've proved my point exactly; it's very easy for it to get ridiculous to try and tax non-monetary gifts.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by logfromblammo on Thursday March 12, 2015 @06:03PM (#9194255)
A tax on thingy?!
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by nknighthb on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:55PM (#9193372)
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by ghaff on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:39PM (#9192820)
With the caveat that I consider this a pretty ridiculous government action if the facts are as presented...

Defining commerciality is difficult. It's one of the problems I have with the non-commercial variants of Creative Commons licenses. I have seen people on Flickr strongly object to NC photos being used on a blog with Adsense. And how about a large 501(c)(3) non-profit, perhaps one whose politics you disagree with? Take a broad enough view and very little is non-commercial.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by Zikes on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:14PM (#9193060)
Isn't it also outside of the FAA's jurisdiction to define commerciality?
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by waterlesscloud on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:35PM (#9193202)
They don't so much define commerciality as they define what doesn't qualify for a hobby use exemption to the rules.

Here's their rules for model aircraft, with a section on what does and doesn't count as hobby use.

http://www.faa.gov/uas/media/model_aircraft_spec_rule.pdf

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by dublinben on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:39PM (#9193234)
Not as it relates to the purpose of a flight regulated under their jurisdiction. A pilot and plane only licensed for personal/hobbyist use would not be legal for commercial flight.
Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by trhway on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:34PM (#9192786)
>and cited me for operating a business without a permit and being improperly zoned.

that wouldn't be that bad considering the alternative charge of say "money laundering" (if, say, you puff off some grains of sand from the quarter), "illegal deposit acceptance" or other money transfer/handling crimes.

Re:FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to... by sitkack on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:33PM (#9193189)
What if an Arab buys the lemonade and is later charged with Terrorism, couldn't the girl with the lemonade stand be charged with material support? Isn't the parent responsible for the income taxes on income earned by minors?