News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by mangeletti on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:01AM (#9144188)
The thing that boggles my mind is how there seems to be concern about this concept of charging 5% (like Unreal 4 does).

In my mind (not a game developer - tell me if I'm way off here), the framework gives you about 90% of the work up front (10s of thousands of man hours). Then, once you finish your game and it's a success (sales-wise), you pay only 5% of your revenue. This seems like a wonderful deal, right?

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by pertinhower on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:35AM (#9144414)
Absolutely. In the 2000s the Unreal Engine had a price tag of half a million dollars up-front plus royalties (I don't remember the percentage) on the back end. That these companies are giving their engines—even their source code—away essentially for free indicates either that (1) engine sales was never a very lucrative line of business or that (2) the promise of establishing your technology as a defacto game engine standard—the Panavision of games—is even more appealing than immediate revenue.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by maaku on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:54PM (#9146000)
Licensing engines was insanely lucrative, until Unity. Then everything changed -- you could go out and get a good engine with decent framework tools for a few hundred bucks. Why pay six figures up front and X% of revenue when a few hundred bucks for Unity did the job just fine?
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by Zenst on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:35AM (#9144819)
I suppose once you've done all the big sells then not that many come along and gradually scaling the price down to increase base of users comes naturally one way or another in whatever market. This and competition gradually edge each down.

Still, it takes one company of note to make that big move and the rest end up following in the same direction.

But today it is not all about having great tools, it is about users knowing how to use those tools that drive demand and establish standards.

As for Steam, well, most games will also be sold upon there store, so win win.

Either way, maybe schools can now expose students in tools that are not just for games but have users and functionality that transcend many fields from modeling, CAD like mock up's and a level of detail and control a bit more than the popular Minecraft, which is in many ways a much simpler form of what these game-engines are today.

So demand is there and opportunity as well. Be interesting how this pans out for game prices long term. As with anything, when supply at a comparable quality hits a level then the only way to stand out is price and lower running costs to get started and investment. Impact upon established studio's could be interesting, if anything it makes what they do more competitive and beyond franchise work, which your cheap startup is not going to be grabbing, then not much will make them stand-out if they stay as is. I see many opportunities for consultancy work and also a increase in the talent pool. Solely due to increased numbers of people able to learn the tools and sue them.

As for which one becomes a standard, well, once we settle down upon one operating system for everything is when such matters are close, but far from today on so many levels that there will always be competition for a long time to come.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by talmand on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:46AM (#9144485)
Engine sales used to be lucrative, quite a few companies have been based solely on that business model for years. But just like most things, the market changed over the years. High quality alternatives started to appear, big publishers started making or buying their own tech, and easier entry to market are among some of the reasons.

In my mind, the biggest contributor is simply competition.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by stevehawk on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:00AM (#9144550)
This is a very good point. In all honesty, id Software really moved from 'making games' to 'making tech demos' with Quake 2 and Quake 3: Arena. The same is pretty much true for Epic and the Unreal Tournament games.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by benologist on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:10AM (#9144630)
I think non-game development is accustomed to taking tools and giving nothing back, particularly with open source. GPG provided a sharp wakeup call around this recently.

http://www.propublica.org/article/the-worlds-email-encryptio...

Game development does this but I think less as game architecture can require significantly fewer tools. Rovio were once called out at a GDC convention for giving nothing back to (the port of) the physics engine they use, stuff like that can form the majority of third party code in a game:

http://www.geek.com/games/box2d-creator-asks-rovio-for-angry...

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by dietrichepp on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @01:14PM (#9146164)
For development tools, we all remember paying for development environments in the 80s and 90s. But then GCC was everywhere, Visual Studio had a usable free version, and Borland went up in smoke for various reasons. Platform owners realized that they were in a race to make development as easy and cheap as possible for their platform, except for a few odd cases where that wasn't in the best interests of brand image (game consoles, iOS).

Libraries are a different story, but if you look at e.g. C# development tools you'll see that they're subsidized to drive adoption of Windows and SQL server licenses. Java was an attempt to drive people to Sun hardware, and now Oracle is monetizing it with the Ask toolbar (I guess?).

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by SoMuchToGrok on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:21AM (#9144312)
I agree that 5% to the engine developer is a wonderful deal - however, having a working game engine in no way means 90% of the work is done. That's when the really difficult work begins.

Video games need to trigger an emotional response in order to be successful. From visual design, to audio design, game rules/logic, controls, testing, marketing...this list goes on. It's far more than raw tech resources; psychology is a huge factor in game development.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by ChikkaChiChi on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:23AM (#9144717)
Yes and no.

Consider that an engine are all the resources that go into cutting down trees, gathering materials, making pigments, etc. that all go into the resources of painting a masterpiece on an easel. You could certainly do all those things, but you don't need to if you want to create a new masterpiece.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by corysama on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:13PM (#9145702)
IMHO, 5% works great for indies and small devs. It lowers the downside risk of an unprofitable game and only gets expensive after you can afford it.

It does not work well for large-budget AAA games. In those setups, only a small percentage of revenue goes to the developer after paying back publishers, marketing and distribution. Taking 5 out of that is a huge hit. That's why Epic explicitly expects large budget games to negotiate a custom deal. That's something Epic has a long history of with UE 1,2&3.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by AimHere on Thursday March 05, 2015 @03:13AM (#9149732)
The 5% Epic takes is from of the gross product revenue rather than the net. In an age where some AAA games can sell a few million copies and still not turn a profit, Epic is smart enough to pick the model that avoids losing out to Hollywood accounting.

I don't know enough about the games industry to know whether 5% of the gross is an overly large chunk to spend on the engine developer. It does sound reasonable to me, but if not, the onus would be on the dev, not Epic, to find some leverage to renegotiate a better deal.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by joshstrange on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:40AM (#9144455)
Especially when game devs are giving 30% of the sales (starting from the first $1 they make) to the marketplace where they sell their games...
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:30AM (#9144784)
I think this is the difference between big shops with big budgets and small indie developers. Lets say you make a game that sells $100,000 on steam. That's pretty impressive. What's your take home then?

Steam takes 30%, taxes take 20%, engine takes 5%, marketing costs take 10%, etc. Now you have $35,000 left. Even in the best case scenario of a solitary indie developer that's a piss poor wage for someone who can make a game in a year that sells six figures on steam. Every little bit helps.

Now compare that to a game that sells $20,000,000. That's what, 7 million take home? That's 200x the take home pay, yet it doesn't take 200x the staff or 200x the time or 200x the cost to make it. The system is geared for big shops. Smaller shops just seem to get a rougher deal.

Guys like Notch are a rare exception. For most smaller devs saving 5% is significant savings.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by ChikkaChiChi on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:43AM (#9144904)
Based on your own hypothetical, that means you would spend $5,000 (or about 15% of your overall budget) for all of the mechanics that an engine provides.

There are certainly games (e.g. visual novels) in which this wouldn't be very cost effective, but in most cases I believe that represents a huge value.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:05AM (#9145124)
Sure, this doesn't make sense for VN's, but its not surprising that a lot of indie success stories are often 2D games that don't use these pricey engines. The cost is a disincentive as well as the extra 3D work compared to what can be done efficiently via 2D.

The value argument doesn't make sense if my original vision was a 2D pixel game that I could personally do in my spare time compared to being given the hottest 3D engine and now asset creation and dev is 10x the time and cost.

The big winners here look to be mid and big shops. Not to mention the asset stores these engine companies run. Having tons of indie devs suddenly buying all these 3D assets must be nice considering whatever cut Unity or Unreal are getting.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by ChikkaChiChi on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:27AM (#9145328)
Minecraft was written from the ground up. Writing their own engine in Java has been the subject of great debate because of how poorly optimized it is, how every update shattered the mod scene, or how much work it takes to port it to all the various iterations on all the various platforms.

Terraria was written in .NET using XNA and met with huge success. But they too have seen similar problems and have to use external dev houses to get the game onto other machines.

Starbound is custom built. They messed up so badly with their initial build that it took them almost a year between releases to even release an update.

Kerbal Space Program _does_ use Unity, but even they hit a wall of shame caused by using the engine in a 32-bit variety. Mods are much easier because the platform is written using a "standard" framework, but the game will implode if you require more memory than 32-bit can address.

There are also plenty of success stories (Prison Architect might be my favorite game to watch develop) but I think the more complex the basis for the game, the smarter it might be to start with something that's proven and work your way up from there.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by nightski on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @01:09PM (#9146121)
This assumes you can just plug in the engine and all is well and good. Many of these engines are optimized for certain types of games and do not play well when bent against their will. There is a large cost of learning to utilize the engine and get the best performance out of it. You are also heavily committing yourself to something where it is possible a wall could be hit and there would be no way out of it. Moving away from one of these engines is very expensive and may involve re-writing the majority of the game. It is not something you want to decide lightly.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by forgottenpass on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:20AM (#9145273)
This seems like a wonderful deal, right?

Wonderful, yes. But I see many more "it's 5%, not free" comments than "OMG 5% is soooo expensive."

These engines are not free, you just don't pay up front. It's a great success of their marketing that news websites and internet commenters are willing to go to bat for the idea they're "free," when they're so very obviously not. If you use the product for it's intended purpose, you're paying. If they weren't going to make much money off of you in the first place, there is a free trial to get you using their platform.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by UnoriginalGuy on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:05AM (#9144215)
The article just noted that as a fact, and it is.

Unless you're an established studio I'd just pick whichever engine/environment you find most appealing and worry about the money when you actually make any.

Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by jxm on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @09:26AM (#9144346)
Very inclined to agree. Especially with such a small percentage charge, it seems pretty fair to pay for the work that goes into the framework that makes the game even possible.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by easytiger on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:55AM (#9145566)
No, if it is made a commodity, which it clearly is becoming, then that is nonsense. You wouldn't offer to pay 5% flat rate of your investment banking revenues to whomever provides your hardware. This is the kind of business model fapping that happens on HN because the audience are desperately trying to get people to pay for their unimportant services & products.
Re:Valve Announces Source 2, and It’ll Be Free by morley on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:08PM (#9145664)
Actors, directors, and writers still pay 10% to agents across the board for their services, despite the fact that there are tons of agents in Hollywood. Seems reasonable to pay 5% of revenues to an engine that does all the work rendering your game, if you don't want to write your own.