News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by MollyR on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:35PM (#9133448)
Is it strange that people defend Mayer so much ? I find it a little strange. I'm having a hard time figuring what the baseline of criticism is for a tech ceo, and how much they get defended from it.

I know Jobs, Gates, Ballmer, and Zuckerberg, have a crazy amount of criticism, and usually the (if it ever comes) defense comes later after the company/project gets huge or financially successful.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by Shenglong on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:09PM (#9133651)
There's a good amount of criticism as well as praise for her, and I'm not entirely sure your question is entirely fair.

The reality of it all is that transformations take time, especially when things at Yahoo had been so Scott Thompson'd. Marissa has been rebuilding a sinking ship from the inside out - where most people would've just tried to patch it up as it slowly sank, or sold it off for parts; I think that's what's admirable. I think that's why people defend her. She dared to defy the status quo. She dared to employ the same dedication as founders do day in and day out, and she demonstrated over and over again, the audacity to take risks.

I find it stranger that more people don't defend her. All of us should know that technology companies thrive or die from the inside; it's why startup founders spend such a disproportionate amount of time hiring great people. To anyone who actually bothered to pause and compare Yahoo's culture today to yesterday's, it would be obvious that Marissa's conviction and aptitude is heralding a new era of prosperity; the transformation is apparent - and even if not yet absolute, it is still miraculous.

Remember: people -> product -> profit

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by will_brown on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:28PM (#9134116)
>That’s why she has spent $2 billion on acquisitions, most notably the $1.1 billion for Tumblr, which instantly gave Yahoo a credible entry into social networking and user-generated content. (It was, in fact, a Tumblr post that was Patient Zero in “The Dress” contagion that ate the Internet last week.)

I think the above excerpt, is a good reflection of what I believe the OP means by defending MM.

It may be unfair to try to sum up MM's time as CEO in terms of acquisitions, but its simply what the media has highlighted and I am sure Yahoo wants the media banging that drum for all its worth. Therefore, if the biggest argument for the $1.1B Tumblr acquisition is pointing to the latest viral post, I consider that running to her defense. From the tone of this article, the stockholders are demanding cost savings (sounds like less employees), new revenue streams and a general direction for the company. For better or worse the CEO is responsible for making the stockholders happy, I personally think Yahoo's niche could be in privacy - give users alternatives to Google, Facebook, Gmail, cloud storage with a focus on what people want...privacy. IMHO Yahoo has always had a respectable focus on the cross section of technology, privacy and human rights (maybe one of the first in tech to create a human rights program).

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by spydum on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:30PM (#9134459)
privacy typically does not drive revenue up, unless you are violating it. this might be something your social circle claims to want, but if you look at the "average" person, they have next to zero concern for their privacy.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by ccvannorman on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:55PM (#9135262)
New startup idea: convert existing privacy-apathetic customers of big companies like Google/Yahoo into privacy-aware customers who fear their data or identity being stolen, then sell conversions to a Google/Yahoo competitor who values privacy more highly.

If fear mongering works for wars, it should work for tech company privacy concerns meets mass consumerism!

/s .. or is it?

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by will_brown on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:06PM (#9135523)
>this might be something your social circle claims to want,

Professionally I practice law so yes, myself and my colleagues are concerned about government entities violating not just privacy but the attorney client-privilege...though I digress and this is not what I am talking about, but it does happen.

>but if you look at the "average" person, they have next to zero concern for their privacy.

The "average" person isn't using Yahoo, that's why it would be a niche. I'll leave you with a interesting quote: "A search engine whose users consisted of the top 10,000 hackers and no one else would be in a very powerful position despite its small size, just as Google was when it was that search engine."[1]

[1]http://paulgraham.com/ambitious.html

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by spydum on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:32PM (#9135600)
It's an interesting thought for sure, I just don't see how you sell it to shareholders. If I had to make a baseless assumption, I'd say the bulk of yahoos users are seniors who moved on from AOL, and don't know any difference.

I would be really interesting to see yahoos audience demographics to confirm or deny that though.. Perhaps they have a larger international audience I'm not aware of.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by MollyR on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:27PM (#9133758)
I think that makes sense. It would also explain the articles I see about Microsoft's new ceo Nadella. Thanks
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by refurb on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:24PM (#9134096)
To anyone who actually bothered to pause and compare Yahoo's culture today to yesterday's, it would be obvious that Marissa's conviction and aptitude is heralding a new era of prosperity;

That is the complete opposite of what I've heard from those still at Yahoo.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by pjwal on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:47PM (#9135209)
Yes her mandated Quarterly Performance Review system in which managers were forced to put a % of employees in under performing buckets single handedly damaged the moral more than anything in the companies history.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by ajays on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:27PM (#9135583)
> in which managers were forced to put a % of employees in under performing buckets

... except other managers, of course! ;-)

I'm an ex-Yahoo, and I feel that Yahoo has too many layers of management. Marissa would be well served by reducing the ratio of managers to engineers to something like 1:10 (currently I've heard it's close to 1:3, but that's just rumor and speculation).

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by ccvannorman on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:57PM (#9135277)
Didn't Microsoft do something similar to this in past? Heck there's a Wiki about this type of screwup:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitality_curve#Companies_utiliz...

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by acangiano on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:47PM (#9133515)
> Is it strange that people defend Mayer so much? I find it a little strange.

One possible reason is that she is a woman. This, seemingly irrelevant fact, has a couple of potential implications.

First, criticism towards one of the few female tech CEOs could be viewed as misogynistic. Most people would shy away from such controversy.

Second, as a woman in tech she is the underdog, and people love to root for the underdog.

Just a theory, I could be way off of course.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by Crito on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:59PM (#9133589)
Another possible explanation is the state of Yahoo in years preceding her. Basically a company that everyone was kind of surprised was still around. For as much as people dislike Microsoft or Facebook, I don't think many people think "why does this company still exist?" (There was definitely a time when people thought that of Apple though...)

(In particular, I remember a lot of this sort of anti-Yahoo sentiment in the months prior to Marissa Mayer, particularly around the time that the Yammer CEO made some announcement that he would not be hiring ex-Yahoo employees because of Yahoo's patent stance. People decried that CEO as being ridiculous, but there were also a lot of people expressing anti-Yahoo sentiments.)

Probably some combination of both, as well as a few other factors.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by zem on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:06PM (#9133998)
she also represents the seductive (at least for techies) narrative of an efficient, engineering-focused ceo coming in and cleaning up/revitalising a moribund "suit-driven" company, and hopefully returning it to its glory days when technology was king.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by area51org on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:34PM (#9133798)
Another possible reason is that she has not actually done anything significant. Her time at Google was not spent working on any projects that produced notable success or revenue. Many think she was hired at Yahoo simply because of voodoo logic: she'll somehow bring Google Magick with her because she happened to get hired at Google early on.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by k3n on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:13PM (#9134045)
> Her time at Google was not spent working on any projects that produced notable success or revenue.

Her CV begs to differ: she was VP of Search Products and User Experience, and then held key roles in Google Search, Google Images, Google News, Google Maps, Google Books, Google Product Search, Google Toolbar, iGoogle, and Gmail.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by freyr on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:39PM (#9134172)
Mayer is no doubt smart and talented, but she was also at perfect place at the perfect time and rode the Google rocket ship straight to the top. So it's hard for outsiders to really separate talent from circumstance.

That said, you're very wrong. She had a defining impact on Google Search from the start, a project that did in fact produce notable success and revenue for the company.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by freyr on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:31PM (#9134132)
> Is it strange that people defend Mayer so much ?

I've found just that opposite, that people generally seem critical of her time spent at Yahoo so far. Common targets are her seemingly haphazard app acquisition strategy, or how she frequently is late to meetings or misses them entirely, or how she has hired the wrong people high-profile positions. And often the conversation steers more towards her personality quirks.

Here was a particularly damning article published in the New York Times in December:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/21/magazine/what-happened-whe...

It's very critical and I didn't see many people rushing to her defense after it was published.

Here's another one:

http://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/yahoos-dynamic-ce...

Where do you see all this defense of her?

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by spenrose on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:39PM (#9134516)
This is a Steven Levy interview. He gets access in exchange for allowing the VIP to tell her story her way. (I happen to be anti-anti-Mayer, but that's a different issue.)
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by Shorel on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:41PM (#9135979)
She was hired to save an already doomed company. I don't think it is fair to judge her without seeing all the harm the previous CEOs did.

Gates, Ballmer and Zuckerberg have never been in such dire straits.

Jobs did, and he succeeded, but he was truly exceptional.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by discardorama on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:08PM (#9134330)
Sure, every CEO faces some criticism. But the criticism directed at her is often petty and "gossipy". People pick on her fashion sense; but no one criticises (or praises) Zuck for his sweatshirts.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by trentmb on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:38PM (#9134506)
> but no one criticises (or praises) Zuck for his sweatshirts.

https://www.google.com/search?q=zuckerberg+hoodie

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by jazzyk on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @10:23AM (#9138081)
Because he did not waste time on Vogue fashion spreads?
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by mc32 on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:23PM (#9134414)
Well, I think if you compare her to the previous string of unsuccessful CEOs, it's hard to see her in a bad light. So in the context of Yahoo I think she's done well.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by IndianAstronaut on Monday March 02, 2015 @02:48PM (#9133882)
I definitely think she deserves criticism for stopping the work from home policy. This industry had a huge chance to move away from traditional office work to a much more flexible type of work environment. Her move put a significant dent in that.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by freyr on Monday March 02, 2015 @03:52PM (#9134238)
No! Her job as CEO was to fix Yahoo. If the work-from-home program was a problem at Yahoo, it was her responsibility to address that.

You speak as if it's a foregone conclusion that working from home is a good idea, but not everybody agrees with that. So you're suggesting that she should have made a decision she felt was bad for her company to advance your personal agenda, and that's a little bit crazy.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by Natsu on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:02PM (#9135508)
I'm honestly not sure if Yahoo is "fixable." I don't use any of their products and I can't see any reason to change that. Everybody else does everything they can do better or is utterly irrelevant to me. But even nobodies can get people on board with a compelling product--I still remember abandoning Infoseek for the then-unknown Google--so it's up to them to create a reason to use it.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by gtaylor on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:13PM (#9134368)
I've worked from home for over three years now, 100% of the time. Having done it and seen how big a difference it makes in feeling connected and involved, I can understand her rationale. It makes tons of sense for Yahoo specifically.

That's not to say a highly or fully remote team can't work. Clearly it can. It's probably not ideal for a sinking ship like Yahoo, though. You really do need all hands on deck, top to bottom.

Don't like it? Don't work for Yahoo. It really is as simple as that. I like the move, though, given their specific situation.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by IndianAstronaut on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @04:14AM (#9136803)
>Don't like it? Don't work for Yahoo. It really is as simple as that

Not so simple. First, jumping jobs for a lot of people is difficult. Second, it also set a trend in the industry. HP soon after started a program to make people come into the office.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by gtaylor on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @06:22AM (#9137125)
> Not so simple. First, jumping jobs for a lot of people is difficult.

It really is that simple. If you want to work for Yahoo, you'll need to relocate. Otherwise, there exists a full world of other possibilities out there for you to pursue (many of which embrace remote working).

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by frio on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:04PM (#9134311)
Having worked in a couple of teams with prevalent work-from-home policies, it can mask (or even encourage) some really unhealthy behaviour in depressed teams. While we might want the industry to move that way (eventually), it was probably the right move for Yahoo.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by ajays on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:29PM (#9135590)
The WFH policy literally impacted about 1% of the people. And of those impacted, many of them got an exemption (based on performance) and continued to WFH. It really was made out to be a much bigger deal in the media, than it really was.
Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by killface on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:53PM (#9134594)
because people are desperately wanting her to be successful, not because they love yahoo, but to prove that women can run companies.

also, any criticism of a woman in tech is automatically labelled "misogynist" by the internet hate machine known as Tumblr (which Yahoo owns), so where she might get more criticism, people are giving her a free pass.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by idbentley on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:06PM (#9135323)
I have trouble believeing that you can back any of this up. It seems extremely unlikely to me that the number of people who want to "prove that women can run companies" outnumbers the number who want to prove that women can't.

Anyone who has any background in the subject knows of the many women who do successfully run companies - they know that there is no need to prove anything of this sort.

Re:Marissa Mayer Has Completed Step One by foobarqux on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:04PM (#9134651)
There are other companies that have already proven that (GM, HP, eBay)