Here's an article where debian is talking about systemd in 2011 [0]. Forgive me for beign a bit shocked when people say things like 'it happened so fast!', but it's almost like people just sincerely want to hate systemd.
[0]http://lwn.net/Articles/452865/
edit: I really wanted to ignore this, but it's eating away at me.
>and, more importantly, _works_ like Unix.
Maybe I'm just cynical, but I get the feeling people who pretend their interpretation of the unix philosophy regarding systemd is the superior interpretation, probably didn't even know what the tenets of unix philosophy were before the drama.
Smarter people than me have done a great job of debating both sides of the issue and it looks like systemd has won. That doesn't mean I have to like it and thankfully I can fall back to using OpenBSD since I want a Unix that looks and feels like the Unix I've been using my whole career.
I don't care if you disagree with me but please don't assume that I "don't even know the tenets of unix philosphy" becuase I happen to view systemd in a way that you apparently do not. If all the major distributions are going with systemd than OK, but the beauty of free software is that I have choices and I've made mine.
I only read part of the Debian voting process, it's wasn't years but I admit not knowing how long systemd was discussed in Debian's ML before that. On archlinux board's, adoption was quickly reached (without too much user troubles).
Also one of the busybodies within systemd development is directly involved with Arch maintenance...
Btw, the big pedia claims that OpenSuse and Mageia(?) also use systemd. At least one of them is a fork of what used to be a RHEL fork with a more desktop orientation.
Then again, the adoption may well have happened before systemd started absorbing/reimplementing so many other functions.
I suppose one might say that this is a core component of the system and even three or so years of testing is not enough... But, I think at that point, we're off in the realm of opinion.
I love Arch too, but damn! I remember the "upgrade" process to systemd that wrecked my system (not unrecoverably, but before they released the fix path, I already reinstalled.)
I don't remember the systemd transition in Arch being too bad, though it was sort of rough around the edges. I guess that roughness is why (mentally) I hadn't expected anyone to have adopted systemd before Arch.
It is almost as if you can see the frog slowly boiling...
And nobody is even shipping a distro with networkd as the only network daemon. They are all still using networkmanager. I doubt anyone will switch any time soon either, since the faculties of networkd are a lot more limited.
And I'm wondering how a project that is meant to encompass a common base userspace OS is boiling anyone by adopting things like network management into it. That seems pretty base OS nowadays to me. I'll worry if once everyone is on systemd we start getting horror stories of the upstream systemd developers blocking contributions and fixes because they conflict with what they want in the project (a la Gnome, not like KDE).
2. It would really surprise me if networkmanager finds itself being anything more than a frontend for networkd within a year or two.
At this point in time i am starting to think that going back to pre-freedesktop Linux may be better for my ulcer than trying to keep up with the desktop (developers) uber alles threadmill.
I imagine many people might trust systemd more than the overlapping set of init/cron/at/supevisord/monit/forever/user generated SysV init shell scripts of varying quality.
But the worst part is probably init scripts.
$ wc -l /etc/init.d/smartd 653 /etc/init.d/smartd
653 lines of code to start a demon, because of the differences between all distros.
Guys, seriously ?
What you're doing is the equivalent of looking at some old Mach performance statistics and concluding that microkernels cannot possibly work... never mind there's one alongside every smartphone.
Yeah, they should give it a few decades of thought...
And maybe check out if this ANSI C thing is worth supporting over plain ole K&R C.
Who/what is driving this despite all the controverse?
Also, remember that launchd on OSX has been around for a decade. People from the linux world who encountered it tended to think "hey, this is kinda nice, I wish we had something like it." Perhaps launchd itself had a predecessor somewhere, I dunno. But the point is that people had seen these systems in the wild, so when someone showed up who was serious about seeing the project through there were a bunch of maintainers whose reaction was "about damn time" rather than "what is this?"
There is a very loud minority in the linux community that doesn't want things to change. There are a ton of linux users who's lives this improves, and they are not as noisy.
Debian is the larges distro and when the maintainers took a vote systemd won with like a 60+% majority. Almost all other distros that are going to, have switched over the last 3 years.
2/ Gnome started requiring systemd (via the dependency of GDM on logind). So, if they want to keep supporting Gnome, they have a choice between switching to systemd or developping some shims. And it's probably safe to assume other major pieces of software (KDE?) will adopt similar requirements.
Code contributions, even if controversial, pack a much stronger punch than emails, forum posts, blog posts, etc.
I miss OpenRC, for that matter. Using that is the only time I've felt something like contentment while managing init.
> but it's no longer my first choice
What is out of interest?
Other than that I've been playing around with FreeBSD and have revisited Slackware which was the first Linux I was introduced to via a book/cdrom back in the mid 90's.
Having had some success with OpenBSD on servers I'm running it on a laptop as one of two workstations at work. The other has Wheezy on it. I'm able to do most of my day to day work on OpenBSD but do find myself remoting into the Linux box for some things (e.g. mysql-workbench).
I've been a happy Debian user for many years but lately I've fallen back to using *BSD (particularly OpenBSD). I guess that puts me in the "old and afraid of change" camp but for me it's nice to be back using something that looks and, more importantly, _works_ like Unix.
Debian will remain my goto distribution when I want/need Linux but it's no longer my first choice...