Re:Debian: Transition plan to systemd by default
by jjoonathan on Monday February 23, 2015 @08:53AM
(#9094240)
The fact that it did many things easily and correctly that init/cron/monit only did after navigating a minefield of gotchas, reinventing the wheel, and employing obnoxious hacks to do things that ought to be simple (parallel init). Init scripts are easier to tweak, no doubt about it, but I'm equally sure that if I was actually throwing together a distro I would want a modern init system.
Also, remember that launchd on OSX has been around for a decade. People from the linux world who encountered it tended to think "hey, this is kinda nice, I wish we had something like it." Perhaps launchd itself had a predecessor somewhere, I dunno. But the point is that people had seen these systems in the wild, so when someone showed up who was serious about seeing the project through there were a bunch of maintainers whose reaction was "about damn time" rather than "what is this?"
Re:Debian: Transition plan to systemd by default
by XorNot on Monday February 23, 2015 @08:59AM
(#9094274)
I've found service files much easier to tweak then init scripts. When 90% of all init scripts become a single line exec command, there's not a lot to go wrong.
Also, remember that launchd on OSX has been around for a decade. People from the linux world who encountered it tended to think "hey, this is kinda nice, I wish we had something like it." Perhaps launchd itself had a predecessor somewhere, I dunno. But the point is that people had seen these systems in the wild, so when someone showed up who was serious about seeing the project through there were a bunch of maintainers whose reaction was "about damn time" rather than "what is this?"