News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by hayksaakian on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:10PM (#9069585)
Perhaps this is a naive question:

What is the connection between truecrypt and windows xp?

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:19PM (#9069651)
Just that it's the last mainstream operating system for which there is no credible alternative to Truecrypt. What Truecrypt does has become a basic feature of modern operating systems.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by kngspook on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:59PM (#9070892)
As far as FDE goes, yes. But TrueCrypt was rather unique in that it provided (then) trusted cross-platform encrypted containers, not necessarily encrypted disks.

I spent several hours last night trying to find a trustworthy, free tool to encrypt some files that would make them accessible across all my OSes (I use Windows, Linux, _and_ OS X). After looking at Ciphershed and Veracrypt, I didn't find confidence in them, so the closest thing I could come up with was one-off style encryption -- eg. GPG. And I just don't see a good workflow wherein every time I want to access a 3 Mb file I have to unencrypt, untarball, access, retarball, reencrypt 100 GB of files. Or write a script that's going to sort through a couple hundred files to ensure they're all encrypted without tarballing.

So yeah, now I jump through hoops using one OS's encryption mechanism, and then kinda-sorta sharing the porn to the other OSes in a way that I hope is semi-secure and I try to make sure I clean up after myself.

Edit: In the time I wrote this, I see a huge discussion has blown up around TrueCrypt's containers/block encryption. If anyone has a tool that can encrypt a collection of files and make them transparently accessible to other apps in a cross-platform way, I'm all ears.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by aw3c2 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:32PM (#9069748)
Not as an open-source feature though. I am happy with dm-crypt on Linux, but surely the Windows and MacOS built-in encryption methods are not to be trusted by people who might be targeted by the state?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by pakled_engineer on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:44PM (#9070169)
Considering all the proprietary firmware on a standard laptop/desktop/router/modem you're pretty much screwed if targeted by a state. States build SCIF rooms with armed guards to protect against other states. We have FDE and PGP to protect against thieves.

Was looking forward to a cryptanalyst's ripping apart of the "cascading ciphers" TC shilled to see if it was snake oil or not.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by larssorenson on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:14PM (#9069617)
Some people think it's a warrant canary of sorts, trying to convey a message that the project had been compromised and was subsequently shut down. But that's all speculation without any evidence to back it up so we may never know.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by compbio on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:07PM (#9070323)
Like tptacek said, versions of Windows after Windows XP shipped with their own disk encryption functionality. XP needed TC for that.

Next to that: the announcement to discontinue the product was very close to the MS end-of-life announcement for XP.

Remotely related is the difficulty researchers had compiling TC from source and matching the official binaries. The original devs used Visual C++ 1.52 (1993) leading some to believe that the build system for TC still ran on Windows XP and was not up-to-date enough anymore.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by nateguchi on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:11PM (#9069599)
I think windows vista introduced encryption on NTFS volumes
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:32PM (#9069739)
I think the key was full disk encryption. I _think_ XP supported individual file encryption.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by nathantotten on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:26PM (#9069703)
Newer versions of Windows include BitLocker which provides full disk encryption. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitLocker
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by r3bl on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:57PM (#9069880)
The first sentence says it all: it is _not_ available in all of the versions after Windows XP. Combining that with the fact that it is not open source and it is not cross-platform, it's basically useless to me.

For now on, I'm sticking with TrueCrypt 7.1a version which I downloaded from https://truecrypt.ch/ on all of my machines.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ghostly_s on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:37PM (#9070124)
So, an open-source product which the developers have publicly declared as insecure, and on which a major code-audit has stalled inconclusively, is superior to closed-source _how_, exactly?

Not saying you're wrong, per se, just that it seems like all the choices are wrong, here.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by atmosx on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:14PM (#9069613)
The target platform for TrueCrypt was probably windows because of lack of alternatives? This is what transpires from his last email.