News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:14PM (#9069616)
The way it was closed was suspicious enough for me to wonder if they were driven to close by the government because it was one of the methods they couldn't crack efficiently.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by dark12222000 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:16PM (#9069630)
This is the general assumption I've been under. When someone goes from "This is a secure product being actively developed" to "USE THIS PRODUCT FROM MICROSOFT INSTEAD OF THIS. THIS PRODUCT IS BAD. BAAAD", then well, yeah. That's sort of the canary.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:19PM (#9069654)
No, it's not.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:58PM (#9069894)
So do you know more about the sudden "TrueCrypt is not secure" thing (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/05/28/truecrypt_hack/) and can say definitively why the creators did that?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:01PM (#9069913)
You can see elsewhere on this thread where I'm coming from and what I think about the project.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by hackuser on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:29PM (#9070082)
I appreciate the time you spent on the project (and on this thread!). However, I don't see this issue specifically addressed: The following was posted on TrueCrypt's SourceForge page [1]; I don't see how it's not a 'canary' (well, technically it's not because it's a direct message) and how users can trust TrueCrypt. Until this is resolved, every other discussion of TrueCrypt's future seems moot.

WARNING: Using TrueCrypt is not secure as it may contain unfixed security issues.

The development of TrueCrypt was ended in 5/2014 after Microsoft terminated support of Windows XP. Windows 8/7/Vista and later offer integrated support for encrypted disks and virtual disk images. Such integrated support is also available on other platforms (click here for more information). You should migrate any data encrypted by TrueCrypt to encrypted disks or virtual disk images supported on your platform.

[1] Discussed here:

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7828107

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7812133

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7814725

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ghostly_s on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:34PM (#9070478)
Seconded. I was quite puzzled by this whole issue when it happened and surprised to see that there hasn't been much clarification since. The developers who posted this message are real people whom others have been in contact with since, correct? (such as https://www.grc.com/misc/truecrypt/truecrypt.htm ). There was a very unambiguous claim of _existing_ security vulnerabilities in the EOL announcement. Have the developers explicitly refused to elaborate on this? Is there no reference to these concerns in the dev mailing list or elsewhere? Have they refused to take ownership for the statement?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:40PM (#9070509)
People involved in the TC audit project have talked to the developers. They developers do not have an ideological investment in Truecrypt. They're just developers. They built Truecrypt to scratch an itch, found that supporting it was a largely thankless task, and then watched their software get at least 80% obsoleted by modern operating systems.

They don't owe anyone on HN or anywhere else any kind of "ownership of statements" or explanation. The published some source code. They got sick of it. They've moved on. It's over.

I understand the urge people have to synthesize a soap opera narrative out of things on message boards --- that's fun, after all, and the alternative is boring. But that's all the conversation about the TC project abandonment really is: a synthesized soap opera.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ghostly_s on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @07:46PM (#9071848)
As I re-read your response it is seeming stranger and stranger. It seems you, too, are refusing to answer the straightforward question put forward. If no-one has asked the devs to explain this claim of potential vulnerabilities, so be it. But if everyone related to the project is recusing themselves from this question I think it's quite reasonable for observers to be interpreting that as a red flag.

(Also to clarify, when I said 'take ownership of this statement' I was referring to the earlier conjecture that the message was written by people other than the original developers.)

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ghostly_s on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @07:39PM (#9071831)
I appreciate your response, but I think also you are misrepresenting the events here. If the developers simply moved on that would be one thing, but what actually happened is they also made this claim:

   Using TrueCrypt is not secure as it may contain unfixed security issues.
I don't think the developers owe anyone anything, in terms of supporting this project or even justifying their decision not to support it. But they did make this claim, which they didn't need to, which casts the entire project in doubt. You're saying they are refusing to elaborate on this claim? Or has no-one asked them to? Because I think this thread is evidence enough that plenty of people want to know.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by Throwaway90283 on Thursday February 19, 2015 @02:32AM (#9072878)
I don't see anything wrong with that quote. They're simply saying it's no longer being developed, and therefore security issues could arise in the future and go unfixed.

However, I still use TrueCrypt because I'm familiar with it, don't believe it has been compromised, and I trust a random pickpocket will be unable to break it.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by thrownaway122 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:35PM (#9070760)
You mean to say, "Move one everyone nothing to see here"?

The circumstances were fishy - in a way that says don't trust the software to anyone that has anything to hide.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:40PM (#9070784)
More or less yes, that is what I think. If you don't want to trust Truecrypt, I certainly wouldn't argue that point. I don't use it either.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:41PM (#9070151)
I read your other comments on the project. And most of what you are conveying seems to be about the audit project specifically, which you're involved in.

My particular curiosity is about that announcement, and whether or not it was a government attempt to discredit a likely very effective product.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by 0x0 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:26PM (#9069704)
There was some talk about how BitLocker in newer versions of windows removed an "elephant diffuser" component or something, was that ever explained properly?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:30PM (#9069724)
The "diffuser" was an attempt to provide last-ditch data integrity for a system that is fundamentally incapable of providing real data integrity. XTS doesn't provide integrity either.

Long story short: that change does not matter much.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @05:55PM (#9071482)
Oh, the diffuser matters a lot actually. Your former colleagues (I think?) proved this by blindly popping calc on a bitlocker-protected Windows 8.1!

https://cryptoservices.github.io/fde/2014/12/08/code-executi...

With the diffuser, we have ~9 years of conjecture and speculation, with no one overly certain that attacks are possible. Without it, we have calc.exe fairly quickly after someone got the idea to try. You can't say these are roughly the same in practical terms.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by LLWM on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @04:28PM (#9071065)
If you're not going to trust the developers when they tell you that's not the case, why would you trust them enough to use TrueCrypt?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by hayksaakian on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:10PM (#9069585)
Perhaps this is a naive question:

What is the connection between truecrypt and windows xp?

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by tptacek on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:19PM (#9069651)
Just that it's the last mainstream operating system for which there is no credible alternative to Truecrypt. What Truecrypt does has become a basic feature of modern operating systems.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by kngspook on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:59PM (#9070892)
As far as FDE goes, yes. But TrueCrypt was rather unique in that it provided (then) trusted cross-platform encrypted containers, not necessarily encrypted disks.

I spent several hours last night trying to find a trustworthy, free tool to encrypt some files that would make them accessible across all my OSes (I use Windows, Linux, _and_ OS X). After looking at Ciphershed and Veracrypt, I didn't find confidence in them, so the closest thing I could come up with was one-off style encryption -- eg. GPG. And I just don't see a good workflow wherein every time I want to access a 3 Mb file I have to unencrypt, untarball, access, retarball, reencrypt 100 GB of files. Or write a script that's going to sort through a couple hundred files to ensure they're all encrypted without tarballing.

So yeah, now I jump through hoops using one OS's encryption mechanism, and then kinda-sorta sharing the porn to the other OSes in a way that I hope is semi-secure and I try to make sure I clean up after myself.

Edit: In the time I wrote this, I see a huge discussion has blown up around TrueCrypt's containers/block encryption. If anyone has a tool that can encrypt a collection of files and make them transparently accessible to other apps in a cross-platform way, I'm all ears.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by aw3c2 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:32PM (#9069748)
Not as an open-source feature though. I am happy with dm-crypt on Linux, but surely the Windows and MacOS built-in encryption methods are not to be trusted by people who might be targeted by the state?
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by pakled_engineer on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:44PM (#9070169)
Considering all the proprietary firmware on a standard laptop/desktop/router/modem you're pretty much screwed if targeted by a state. States build SCIF rooms with armed guards to protect against other states. We have FDE and PGP to protect against thieves.

Was looking forward to a cryptanalyst's ripping apart of the "cascading ciphers" TC shilled to see if it was snake oil or not.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by larssorenson on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:14PM (#9069617)
Some people think it's a warrant canary of sorts, trying to convey a message that the project had been compromised and was subsequently shut down. But that's all speculation without any evidence to back it up so we may never know.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by compbio on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:07PM (#9070323)
Like tptacek said, versions of Windows after Windows XP shipped with their own disk encryption functionality. XP needed TC for that.

Next to that: the announcement to discontinue the product was very close to the MS end-of-life announcement for XP.

Remotely related is the difficulty researchers had compiling TC from source and matching the official binaries. The original devs used Visual C++ 1.52 (1993) leading some to believe that the build system for TC still ran on Windows XP and was not up-to-date enough anymore.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by nateguchi on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:11PM (#9069599)
I think windows vista introduced encryption on NTFS volumes
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:32PM (#9069739)
I think the key was full disk encryption. I _think_ XP supported individual file encryption.
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by nathantotten on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:26PM (#9069703)
Newer versions of Windows include BitLocker which provides full disk encryption. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitLocker
Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by r3bl on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:57PM (#9069880)
The first sentence says it all: it is _not_ available in all of the versions after Windows XP. Combining that with the fact that it is not open source and it is not cross-platform, it's basically useless to me.

For now on, I'm sticking with TrueCrypt 7.1a version which I downloaded from https://truecrypt.ch/ on all of my machines.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by ghostly_s on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:37PM (#9070124)
So, an open-source product which the developers have publicly declared as insecure, and on which a major code-audit has stalled inconclusively, is superior to closed-source _how_, exactly?

Not saying you're wrong, per se, just that it seems like all the choices are wrong, here.

Re:Ask HN: TrueCrypt audit status? by atmosx on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:14PM (#9069613)
The target platform for TrueCrypt was probably windows because of lack of alternatives? This is what transpires from his last email.