News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by pavlov on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:50AM (#9061394)
Both the product and the ad are highly representative of '70s Nordic social ethics and aesthetics. A single product line called "Universal Building Sets" is an almost Platonic ideal of democratic creativity.

Today's Lego has 33 product lines: http://www.lego.com/en-us/products

When your Legos are branded as "Chima", "Bionicle", "Ninjago", "Marvel(tm) Super Heroes" or "Disney(r) Star Wars(tm)", it's expected that you play within the existing marketeer-created universe. Less blank canvas, more coloring book with product placement.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by DerekL on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:30AM (#9061491)
Actually, even back in 1981, there were multiple lines, though not nearly as much as now.

Here's a list of the sets released in 1981: http://brickset.com/sets/year-1981 . Out of 58 sets, 16 are designed for generic use. Much of the rest are buildings and vehicles from the modern world, like houses, fire stations, tow trucks, ferries, helicopters, dune buggies, etc. But there are also sets with medieval knights and space themes. Plus, Lego created their own characters for a theme they called "Fabuland". There was even a tie-in series: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keJua4D2Ymg

In summary, back in 1981, there were generic sets plus four different themes.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by xenophonf on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:26AM (#9062327)

    it's expected that you play within the existing
    marketeer-created universe
Maybe that's how you or your kids play with them, but here we have no problem kitbashing the branded sets. Their parts end up in the color-sorted bins along with all the rest, and the kids build crazy stuff out of whatever. The last round included parts from a city, a dinosaur, and a submarine, and those were just the ones I recognized. We even mix Megabloks and Duplo with our Legos. Now, if I could only get the kids to pick up the parts when they finish...

Kitbashing is _the_ plot driver of the Lego movie, in that it's what Master Builders do.

Notice how the Lego Club magazine highlights people's creative builds.

I want to postulate that Lego's endpoint is not static sculpture, but active imagination. Consider fan fiction. Sometimes we want to create stories inside someone else's universe. Hasn't your imagination been sparked by some favorite movie or book or artwork? Have you ever wanted to tell the rest of the story? I know I did! That's why I flew my Duplo Millenium Falcon around the living room. I don't see how a more realistic version would have been less fun, or less imaginative. And that's the point of the branded sets. They're fun! With any luck someday soon I will be able to build model rockets that look a lot like what explodes on my launchpad in KSP, only my kids and I will be able to fly those around the living room, pretending the sofa is Planet Klystron, home of the savage (but peaceful) race of Mer-mole-men (Lego people with frickin' sharks heads!) Meanwhile, Superman arrives to rescue our stranded Kerbals, whose ship (naturally) blew up upon launch.

And so on.

It's about the stories we can tell ourselves and each other. In-universe. Something wholly new. It doesn't matter. Do whatever it takes to get you or your kids' imaginations jumpstarted.

Or at least that's what I'm after when I buy a Lego set (branded or not). It looks cool, and it sets my imagination racing.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by cben on Saturday February 21, 2015 @04:48PM (#9087128)
> We even mix Megabloks and Duplo with our Legos.

Is there any way/adapter to connect Duplo (or Lego) on top of Megabloks? I sometimes manage to usefully mix them but always feel it'd be more useful the other way around if Megabloks could provide large-scale structure with Duplo providing fine(r) detail on top... Though I might be biased by having tons of Megabloks and not that much Duplo.

[There is of course the kludge of hanging a protruding duplo under:

    MMMM
    MMMM
    MMdddd
    MM
    MM
    MM
but it's flimsy and requires too much overhead.]
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by munificent on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:33PM (#9064063)
> We even mix Megabloks

Heathen!

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by legoisbest on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:15AM (#9061459)
This does crop up all the time.

You should also mention though that Lego still make and sell a lot of universal building sets.

In Lego stores there are walls of bricks where you can select any bits you want.

Yes, there has been a big rise in themed and licensed sets, and yes, some of them have specialised building parts that you can only really use in the set.

But that's just part of the trend over the last few decades from generic products to branded products. Everything has to be branded... I even saw a "frozen" branded loom band set. I guess the loom bands are just colors associated with the movie? Even buying kids shoes these days they're mostly branded with superheroes, princesses, etc

You can enjoy building predefined models, and creating your own from buckets of bricks though. Both can co-exist nicely. The best thing is that Lego is still going strong.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by pavlov on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:31AM (#9061497)
Sure. I wasn't exactly criticising Lego, just pointing out that the appeal of the ad is inextricably linked to the ideal behind the product.

Lego is a business, of course. Those ABS plastic blocks are practically indestructible, so they're not going to grow by selling replacements for universal blocks...

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by legoisbest on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:48AM (#9061544)
It's so impressive that I can take out a 30 year old Lego brick, and it "works" exactly the same as it did 30 years ago. Sure, the white ones have faded a little, but they still function just as they should.

Not to put the knife in too hard, but megablocks and other competitors don't even function properly when they're new out of the packet.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by hvidgaard on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:24AM (#9061818)
If I remember correctly, LEGO was in a bit of a financial crisis not long ago, and as a way to deal with it was more focus on LEGO based on existing and popular franchises. That said, you just take pull the sets apart and children being children will build things, just as they always have.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by freshyill on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:01AM (#9062905)
My stepson is 11 and we've bought many sets for him over the years. We have one of those 5x5 Ikea shelves just packed with sets that never get touched. They're more like models than toys. But some of them are also my old pirate lego sets from when I was his age, which I also never touched after putting them together (hence the fact that they're still intact today, though some have been disassembled and reassembled).

A few years ago, however, we decided to just buy him a few of the big bucket sets. So he's got buckets of bricks that get played with, and shelves full of models that collect dust.

We also have a pretty big collection of Duplo blocks, which my 2 1/2 year-old daughter has little interest in, although she loves the Lego.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by agumonkey on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:53AM (#9061406)
They had no choice, the "univeral building blocks" patent ended not long ago, facing competition now, they had to find sustainable cash flow.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by legoisbest on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:49AM (#9061552)
The competition is terrible though. Have you tried assembling any other "compatible" building set?

The bricks aren't finished properly, some just pop off, and it all falls to bits easily.

I'd say the nearest competition to Lego is probably 60% the quality of Lego.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by kristiandupont on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:23AM (#9061811)
Lego is expensive. As a former employee, I've heard this complaint many, many times. The thing that people don't realize (because hey, it's just plastic) is that Lego is really really high quality. Getting the right stickiness requires very high precision in those little bricks. Also, if like me you have Legos from your childhood you will probably notice that they last long.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by xanderstrike on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:10AM (#9062968)
The quality really cannot be understated, they last forever. When I was growing up, my brother and I had a mix of "modern" (early 90s) kits and my dad's legos he had growing up in 1950s and 60s Germany. Now my cousins' kids have inherited both and are mixing them with 2010s kits. The 50 year old blocks fit precisely with the blocks made in the past year, and when you throw them all in a bin together you can hardly tell the difference.

It's rare to think of a toy that you can play with as "heirloom quality," but I have no doubt my kids will inherit a portion of the family set when it becomes time, and their kids just might too.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by agumonkey on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:45AM (#9061680)
No I'm just telling what I read from an article a few years back when new brands started to pop in stores. I wonder if parents/kids may see the quality rightaway. LEGOs were an expensive gift in my days. If I was asking for more toys, I'm sure my parents would be tempted to buy a lower priced brand.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by zeusk on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:17AM (#9061790)
I grew up in India during the 90s when Lego had no proper establishment here. There was a very similar kit called 'mechanix' which I fondly remember to date. Would surely recommend still if can't find Lego or on budget.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by timjahn on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:51AM (#9062844)
I never believed this until I experienced it myself with my 4 year old. LEGOs are damn expensive but the competition simply just doesn't work.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by jacquesm on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:35AM (#9061653)
Given how long ago it expired and how terrible the competition is I think Lego is the poster company for showing that execution quality is crucial.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by agumonkey on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:53AM (#9061704)
That's weird, I read about it really not long ago. Maybe they tried to delay things through legal means. That said yes, the LEGO company put a lot of thinking in their 'toys'. I think it's also the way things were done in those days, now it's all ship often, ship cheap.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by jacquesm on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:12AM (#9062258)
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lego_Group

Heading 'trademarks and patents', the last patent expired in '89.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by agumonkey on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:58AM (#9062506)
Aight, so I heard about the post 2000s lawsuits but didn't understand the grounds on which LEGO was able to sue.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by ptaipale on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:41AM (#9061526)
Actually, it expired quite a while ago, in 1989.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by laurent123456 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:58AM (#9061423)
Looking at the two boxes on the poster, they don't look that "universal" - it's a truck and the other one a house. Today's boxes I guess are just better categorized, but not that different.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by eloisant on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:21AM (#9061469)
These boxes only have standard pieces, which is why the truck and house look boxy.

Today's boxes include too many specific pieces. Car hood, top, helicopter nose, etc. Pieces that can't be used for anything else that what they're designed for, and can't be replaced if lost.

So you can't take it appart to build something different.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by gambiting on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:45AM (#9061676)
I actually think that the "Lego Movie" set is a perfect example of unbound creativity. Pretty much every set uses parts which do not match with their original use,and yet they are all used to build interesting things. The worst Lego bricks are the ones which have something painted/written on them, that usually does limit the applications.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by xanderstrike on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:21AM (#9063068)
In any given kit the ratio of custom pieces to generic pieces is still favorable. As a random sample check out the parts inventory of this kit [1] from Lego's Star Wars: Clone Wars system. When you sort by quantity, you see the vast majority of parts are generic wedges, blocks, and plates. Browse around the site, you'll see the same is true for any set over 50 pieces. The idea that you "can't take it apart to build something different," is a little ridiculous, it isn't a model airplane.

I take it you haven't played with any of the modern kits. I encourage you, if you enjoyed lego as a kid, to buy a couple and see for yourself. The model on the box is more polished, but the building blocks are very much the same.

1. http://www.peeron.com/cgi-bin/invcgis/inv/sets/7752-1?PagerS...

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by Jgrubb on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:02AM (#9061729)
Trust me, a kid the age of the one in the ad can take it apart and make something different. Mine do it nonstop.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by masklinn on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:02AM (#9061430)
Universal Building Set is actually the name of a product line: http://lego.wikia.com/wiki/Universal_Building_Set it existed alongside LEGOLAND and Trains and constituted the "basic" lego sets, differentiated because each set usually came with instructions for multiple models, and better demonstrated the role of imagination and the purpose of legos.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by ps4fanboy on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:55AM (#9061413)
Maybe if sales for these things werent so high they wouldnt have done it, whose fault is it really Lego or the consumer? I certainly dont want companies deciding for me.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by pavlov on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:13AM (#9061454)
You don't want companies to decide what products you buy? How does that work? I mean, you can only buy something if they'll sell it...
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by ps4fanboy on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:19AM (#9061796)
More to the point people argue these genderised versions of lego are bad, and that lego shouldn't sell them, deciding to not sell a product because of that and not consumer demand is an example of how a company can decide for its consumers.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by amag on Thursday February 19, 2015 @04:23AM (#9073162)
I don't see why the genderised versions are bad. My daughter is all for pink and princesses, something we have never (knowingly) encouraged. I'm pretty sure she wouldn't build legos at all if it weren't for the pink pieces, and the princesses! Now she builds and has learned that she enjoys the actual building process, not just playing with the creation afterwards. To me this is far more important than the way the minifigures look or whether or not it promotes gender stereotypes. Gender stereotypes are much more likely picked up from how ones parents behave than from toys. If it weren't for Lego Friends I'm pretty confident she would be playing with Barbies instead and that is worse in regards to all the bad things that can be said about Lego Friends, never mind the fact that Barbies lack the creative outlet that is the very foundation of Lego.

I'm pretty confident if it weren't for the Lego Friends series, there would be a lot of girls never learning that they enjoy the building process. Which would be a great shame. If girls learn building legos can be fun, then they might learn that CS can be fun as well :).

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by jamespo on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:30AM (#9061488)
Or you can buy something else and the company can go bust.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by pavlov on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:50AM (#9061555)
Still, you can only buy something else within the range of options on the market.

Ideally companies adjust their product lines based on customer demand. In reality it's mostly determined by other factors like supply chain, internal politics, competitor envy, random advice from consultants, need to meet quarterly growth goals, etc.

For example, high-fructose corn syrup has become a major ingredient of many American food products within the past 20+ years. That didn't happen because of consumer demand, and consumers don't have an easy way to vote against it.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by icebraining on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:06AM (#9061596)
For example, high-fructose corn syrup has become a major ingredient of many American food products within the past 20+ years. That didn't happen because of consumer demand, and consumers don't have an easy way to vote against it.

That's a pretty bad example, since that was in good part a result of the action of elected governments that have kept the price of sugar way above the market price, through tariffs, quotas and subsidies.

I suppose it's true that consumers don't have an easy way to vote against it, but it is a result of the US' "democratic" process.

On a related note, there was a recent Econtalk episode with Daniel Sumner, professor of Agricultural and Resource Economics at University of California, on that subject: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/02/daniel_sumner_o.htm...

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by DanBC on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:53AM (#9061707)
Don't the scare quote you chose to use around democracy make you think that actually HFCS is a good example and that everyday people actually have very little power to change the way sugar and HFCS is regulated?
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by icebraining on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:08AM (#9061751)
I think it's a bad example of a result of the type of factors that pavlov listed (supply chain, internal politics, competitor envy, random advice from consultants, need to meet quarterly growth goals, etc).

Legal restrictions in the marketplace are categorically different from internal company policies, and the lack of power that people have changing the former does not imply a lack of power changing or overriding the latter.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by maxerickson on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:46AM (#9061683)
Consumers could have demanded products without corn syrup in them. It turns out they don't care.

If people did care, those other factors probably would have had to take a back seat to consumer demand. So I don't think you can say that it was irrelevant to the rise of HFCS.

(You can argue that people are ill informed and blah blah blah, but that's still them not caring enough to demand whatever it is you think they should be more informed about)

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:47AM (#9062438)
People aren't just ill-informed - they live under a perpetual onslaught of advertising.

Try taking away the advertising if you want to give people a free choice.

Or balance it with an equivalent level of glossy but fact-based media persuasion about the true effects of HFCS, smoking, etc.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by maxerickson on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:11AM (#9062592)
I don't understand what advertising has to do with HFCS.

Sure, Coke and Pepsi blast ads all the time, but do the arithmetic, they save a couple cents using HFCS over cane sugar. They aren't advertising to get people to accept HFCS, they are advertising to increase consumption of their sugared drinks. If there was reasonably widespread resistance to HFCS they would just switch.

(The arithmetic: there's about 1 pound of sugar in a 12 pack of coke. That's ~$0.50 of cost, max: http://www.sugaralliance.org/us-sugar-prices/. HFCS saves a lot of that cost, ~$0.40 of it: http://www.cornnaturally.com/pdf/hfcs-in-the-us.pdf . So a typical can of soda could use cane sugar for ~$0.03. Note that I've picked a hostile price for cane sugar.)

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by maxerickson on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @08:34AM (#9068377)
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by olavk on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:10AM (#9061760)
Sets without any associated storyline or franchise still exist as the "Creator"-series, and seem to be quite popular.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by Marazan on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:16AM (#9061783)
The Creator series are the absolute best bang for buck line they produce. In general they are 3-in-1 kits and they have lots of interesting blocks.
Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by aerique on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:45AM (#9062429)
I can only give you an anecdotal counter point but Lego is still fine. Instead of asking for a universal building set like I did, my 5 year old old son now ask for a specific Chima or Star Wars box and then we build the vehicle on the box.

After that things get still get ripped apart and combined into new things. It's still mostly a bunch of colored brick except the modern boxes contain a couple more custom bricks which make his own creations look even more awesome.

Lego is still a good (or even better) for kids nowadays than it was 30 years ago.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by eloisant on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:13AM (#9061455)
The last box I bought for my kids was a "lego classics" box. Just blocks.

http://www.lego.com/en-us/classic

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by Ar-Curunir on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:25PM (#9064006)
I would rather have Lego around with branded lines than no Lego, and indeed the branded marketing is what's keeping Lego afloat.

And it's not like you can't buy non-branded Lego (there's plenty of it available). Even if you do have the branded sets you can still use them with 30 year old Lego bricks.

I don't see how branded sets result in less creativity.

Re:Lego’s 1981 Ad Campaign by sp332 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:40AM (#9062780)
Wasn't the whole Lego Movie about taking the kits apart and mixing them up and not worrying about it?