News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by dsp1234 on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:26PM (#9058681)
Whenever a question like this comes up among the people that I am mentoring, I like to show them the "T-Shaped Employee" section of the Valve Employee handbook [0]:

"We value “T-shaped” people.

That is, people who are both generalists (highly skilled at a broad set of valuable things—the top of the T) and also experts (among the best in their field within a narrow discipline—the vertical leg of the T). This recipe is important for success at Valve. We often have to pass on people who are very strong generalists without expertise, or vice versa. An expert who is too narrow has difficulty collaborating. A generalist who doesn’t go deep enough in a single area ends up on the margins, not really contributing as an individual."

[0] - http://www.valvesoftware.com/company/Valve_Handbook_LowRes.p... page 46

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by boomzilla on Monday February 16, 2015 @04:11PM (#9059041)
This is exactly why a lot of people want to do a start up, or at least start a side project that solves a specific problem. You get to to be the expert in that domain, and in order to get the complete product out, you need to be a generalist.

Another meme that's been thrown around is: "You are not the complete developer if you've not written a compiler." I don't necessarily buy that, but there is some merit: there is a lot of different skills required in a compiler, from domain modelling and DSL design, to theoretical CS like grammars and parsing, to very practical software engineering such as IO handling, string manipulation, encoding, documentation, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by atmosx on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:17PM (#9070026)
> This is exactly why a lot of people want to do a start up, or at least start a side project that solves a specific problem. You get to to be the expert in that domain, and in order to get the complete product out, you need to be a generalist.

Hm, funny thing you mentioned startups. Apart programming related startups, I don't think that startup-ers are "great programmers". I get the feeling that most startup programmers (not all of them, but most of them) are somewhere between average and novice level.

I get the feeling that most "great programmers" are not that interested in startup (making money, living the thrill or whatever).

Most famous programmers, work in big corps for medium-to-huge salaries and (most of the times) even getting paid to work on their side-projects (Dropbox pays G.V. Rossum for Python-dev, Heroku pays Matz for Ruby-dev, etc.).

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by ankitml on Monday February 23, 2015 @04:44AM (#9093403)
FYI : Heroku and dropbox are not big corps.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by meric on Monday February 16, 2015 @08:11PM (#9060086)
It is a necessary truism at every abstraction layer there is at least one developer (dead or alive) who has the ability to rebuild the abstraction layer from one layer down. Speaking from a society point of view: The meme thrown around ensures developers learn to do exactly that and keeps the developer work force well trained and skilled, to rebuild things where necessary.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by j42 on Monday February 16, 2015 @11:03PM (#9060605)
You hit the nail on the head.

Beyond the scope of HR, in my experience it's the mix of both breadth of knowledge (context) and the depth of understanding (skill + experience) that is most useful.

Having a high-level understanding allows you to step back outside of the 'work' to instead focus on the objective, and someone with significant background knowledge and experience can utilize that to first conceptualize the optimal approach before hammering the nails.

Knowing what to apply, where, and when is equally as important as how. And there are fantastic programmers & hackers on each end of the spectrum, but in my experience developing that contrast is more intrinsically valuable.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by calinet6 on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:40PM (#9058777)
I think this is the key. It's more wise than it may seem at face value. It's important to recognize the importance of both deep specialization and a broad understanding and ability to connect the dots at the same time.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by mollerhoj on Monday February 16, 2015 @03:59PM (#9058973)
I figure that a degree in CS + some curiosity would give one the horizontal knowlegde, and x years of employment in a specialised field would give the vertial knowlegde.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by malkia on Monday February 16, 2015 @11:54PM (#9060724)
It's different horizontal
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by vitd on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:42PM (#9058787)
It just sounds to me like they're saying they only want engineers who already know everything about everything. Sure, I'd want that too if I were hiring, but it doesn't seem very realistic.

It also makes me wonder about their ability to manage people with different skill levels and areas of expertise. And of course, having used Steam, I'm not at all surprised.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by d23 on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:48PM (#9058816)
Not to me. It sounds like they want people who have a wide variety of shallow-ish knowledge (but still an actual understanding of whatever area it is), while also having very deep knowledge in one or two areas in particular.

> It also makes me wonder about their ability to manage people with different skill levels and areas of expertise. And of course, having used Steam, I'm not at all surprised.

Weird that that's the conclusion you come to. Valve is an incredibly successful company with over a billion dollars in the bank. They've produced some of the most influential games of the past two decades (Half-life, Counter Strike, TF2, Left 4 Dead, Portal, DoTA2... it's actually hard to name them all).

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by jarcane on Monday February 16, 2015 @03:43PM (#9058879)
They also haven't put out an entirely in-house game since the Orange Box.

The management failures at Valve have been pretty spectacular, and expensive, of late, it's just that because they are a private company, and because Steam makes all of the money, they can continue to have large expensive failures like the VR or the Steambox until doomsday.

Valve is not other companies, and their position is such that it's not advisable to take any too serious advice from how they run things into the real world.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by katbyte on Monday February 16, 2015 @04:06PM (#9059009)
Any links describing the management failures?
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by jarcane on Monday February 16, 2015 @04:29PM (#9059161)
Jeri Ellsworth has been quite vivid about the actual, rather than the idealized, version of how Valve actually works; there's some thoughts here: http://www.develop-online.net/news/valve-s-perfect-hiring-hi...

Besides shelving the VR project that she was reportedly working on, there's also the Steambox which still doesn't exist (the only hardware to even pass prototype stage eventually had to abandon SteamOS and release on its own), the utter crapshoot that is their attempts at virtual economies (TF2 hats: prints money, trading cards: useless boondoggle, everything involving Counter-Strike: possibly lucrative now, but PR disaster after PR disaster with their fans).

Valve spins the utopian image, and generally keeps the veil down enough that goodwill and fandom manage to sustain the myth, but I suspect the cart's been off the rails for sometime, and if it weren't for Steam we'd have long seen a very public failure by now.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by eclipxe on Monday February 16, 2015 @07:23PM (#9059913)
Sounds like every company, ever.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by balls187 on Monday February 16, 2015 @05:40PM (#9059522)
> (Half-life, Counter Strike, TF2, Left 4 Dead, Portal, DoTA2... it's actually hard to name them all).

Actually, it's not that difficult. Of what you listed, only HL was original IP.

Valve put a lot of work into digital distribution, and have pretty much owned the PC digital distribution market.

With console and mobile gaming dwarfing the PC market, and big publishers like Ubisoft and EA getting into their own digital distribution, I'm curious to see how Valve continues to grow.

That said, I admire them as a company.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by yoklov on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:33AM (#9060950)
Speaking as someone in the game industry, Valve certainly has it's problems, but they aren't platform problems.

PC is stronger this generation than it was last generation, I'm not sure about the numbers but I suspect that it is ahead of both consoles, and it might be ahead of both of them combined, and I'd expect this to only be get more true. Porting to PC is pretty much just porting the parts that interact with the OS or GPU for this generation, due to both consoles using x86-64.

And mobile is a joke. market might be huge, there's a reason very few established game companies care about it at all. It's extremely unpredictable, and the expected price of games is far below what is realistic. Even if you make a hit, the amount of money you'll make is far from the amount of money you make from a hit on any other platform (hell, it doesn't even come close to the budget of most games). Honestly, I think the only way a company can hope to turn a profit on mobile is with IAP or shovelware (or both), and I don't see that displacing console or PC gaming any time soon.

I wouldn't mind seeing steam displaced, but I don't think it will be by EA or Ubisoft, largely due to the fact that they're both about as popular as Comcast, which seems to be due to them being massively out of touch.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by balls187 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:52AM (#9061097)
Respectfully I disagree with most of what you're written, wrt to growth.

When I see my friends 3 year old daughter playing Geometry Dash on his phone, I know that the PC can't compete with that.

PC ports are still and after thought. Games use a lobby system instead of dedicated servers. Only a few companies (Valve being one of them) target the PC market first. Pretty much every other AAA publisher looks at the PC market as an after thought.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a die hard PC gamer.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by Guthur on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:48AM (#9061393)
The problem with your original statement is that you have combined Mobile and Console together VS PC, which is a pretty bad basis in my opinion.

PC vs Console vs Mobile would be a more reasonable competition.

From some reports PC gaming market seems very healthy indeed from monetary perspective.

http://usfinancepost.com/pc-still-gaming-market-is-double-co... http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2014-01-28-pc-gaming-m...

Mobile has been predicted to reach the size of PC gaming, but not to necessary dwarf it anytime soon.

http://www.mobilemarketer.com/cms/news/research/3892.html

So certainly if you combine mobile and console it's larger than PC. Says a lot that it takes to distinct markets to overtake PC.

In my opinion all the platforms have their pro's and con's, and none of them are going to disappear anytime soon.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by balls187 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:09PM (#9063432)
> In my opinion all the platforms have their pro's and con's, and none of them are going to disappear anytime soon.

I wasn't suggesting that PC gaming will disappear. However, it's clear that PC gaming isn't a growth sector. Given that is where Valve dominates, where does that leave them?

Valve may not consider themselves a growth oriented company, but they do look for opportunities to innovate.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by vitd on Monday February 16, 2015 @06:09PM (#9059663)
I should clarify that I have enjoyed some of their games. Particularly the Half-life and Portal series'.

That said, actually using Steam is an awful experience. Literally 50% of the time, when I launch Steam, it immediately stops and gives me a dialog saying I'm not connected to the Internet, despite that I have other Internet-using apps open and working fine. Quitting and immediately restarting works just fine for no apparent reason. I have several examples of things like this that show a lack of quality in their products. In my opinion, that is usually an indication of poor management as they aren't concerned with the quality of their product.

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by lmm on Monday February 16, 2015 @03:45PM (#9058888)
> they want people who have a wide variety of shallow-ish knowledge (but still an actual understanding of whatever area it is), while also having very deep knowledge in one or two areas in particular

Sure; every employer does. But it's dodging the more interesting question, which is: faced with one candidate who has broad but shallow knowledge and another who has deep but narrow knowledge, which do you pick?

Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by jschmitz28 on Monday February 16, 2015 @03:53PM (#9058936)
If you're Valve, then neither, because you likely have enough T applicants to not have to settle for a | or a __.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by tonyarkles on Monday February 16, 2015 @07:25PM (#9059918)
I think it's more engineers who know something about everything, and everything about something.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by nostrademons on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:45PM (#9058804)
That would be a square employee, not a T-shaped one.
Re:Ask HN: Thoughts on Rich Hickey's advice on becoming a be... by chaz72 on Monday February 16, 2015 @03:55PM (#9058945)
Or perhaps "well rounded"