News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by andybak on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @08:49AM (#9032786)
Smart TVs are a terrible idea for the same reason that combined printer and scanners are a bad idea but with the negative aspect magnified many times. The cost and life expectancy of each part is very different and you don't want their replacement/upgrade to be tied together.

A display panel should last you more than a decade and probably costs many 100s or 1000s. The 'smart' bit is probably worth less than $200 and is probably going to be obsolete in a couple of years.

EDIT - another thing. I want the people that make my 'smart' box to be nimble, forward looking new media companies - not box shifters like Samsung, LG, Philips et al. Most Smart TVs have awful software (LG's purchase of WebOS might lead them to be an exception here)

I've been asked by non-tech friends and relatives about SmartTVs many times and my answer is always "don't touch them with a barge-pole" and a link to a Roku/Chromecast/AppleTV etc.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:48PM (#9034265)
> Smart TVs are a terrible idea for the same reason that combined printer and scanners are a bad idea but with the negative aspect magnified many times. The cost and life expectancy of each part is very different and you don't want their replacement/upgrade to be tied together.

I think combined printers and scanners are a much better idea than Smart TVs because (1) you get more benefit (footprint savings) from the combination with all-in-one printer/scanners than with Smart TVs, and (2) IME, printer replacement is desired more often than scanner replacement, and the printer is also the more expensive part; so you lose less by tieing replacement schedules together compared to Smart TVs, where the "brain" is the more frequently replaced part when replaced separately, but the display is the more expensive part.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by linker3000 on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @01:13PM (#9034442)
If my MFC ever starts printing random ads every 'n' scans or pages printed it's going in the bin.

IF I consider buying a Samsung 'Smart' TV in the future, it better have clear abilities to disable this kind of adserving crap. In any case, I forsee some appropriate rules being added to the house firewall.

Additional thought:

Is there a Web site where you can list products or services you HAVEN'T purchased, giving the value lost to the supplier, and why you didn't buy? Might generate some interesting stats?!

Hmm...'whyididntbuy.com' is on sale for over $2K...where can I document my non-purchase of that!?

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by lozf on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:11PM (#9034906)
Nice idea, but then the money grabbing corporates will just use the "freely submitted user data" to shaft the rest of us by jacking up the price of any simpler / less-smart products. Unfortunately telling 'them' why they lost a sale is unlikely to help 'us' in the long run.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by danudey on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:33PM (#9035120)
I had a friend whose printer wouldn't scan because it was out of ink. Needless to say she threw it in the bin and bought one that was slightly less worse.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by comex on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:32PM (#9034168)
That's true to some extent, but I think that in part, smart TVs are a terrible idea for the same reason that combined music player and phones are a terrible idea. Er, that is, were widely considered a terrible idea, thanks to ubiquitous clunky software, until 2007 when Apple did it right. And ever since then it's been considered obviously beneficial that you don't have to deal with two separate physical devices.

With TVs you're not usually lugging the devices around, but the TV has to be turned on and have volume (and sometimes other settings) managed with a separate remote. Since they typically have multiple HDMI ports, while the set-top boxes you mention don't have HDMI passthrough, you're encouraged to multiplex devices from the TV too, which requires manually selecting between numbered inputs with only a dumb OSD to help coordinate things. (If you have external speakers you might use a receiver to multiplex instead, but now you have a third remote and another dumb UI, not to mention potential latency issues for gaming.) In practice, the result is that among regular users, nobody can use someone else's TV without first being coached on their particular idiosyncratic combination of remotes, let alone try to play their own content by plugging a device in or wireless streaming or something shocking like that. Supposedly HDMI CEC helps with this somewhat by letting the device control the TV; I haven't used a setup with it, but there's only so much a standard for connecting disparate devices can do.

I want one remote - with the option to use my phone or voice control if I lose the remote - and a single, good UI that controls everything. That's only going to happen with a smart TV, but maybe the right device has yet to be made.

(One potential solution to obsoletion is for a manufacturer to make the brains of the TV a separate detachable part that fits into the design, like a laptop battery. Another would be to standardize on one HDMI port per TV, with CEC support and no UI when something is plugged in, so that you're basically required to plug in a box that then takes over the experience. Yeah, like that's going to happen.)

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by Evolved on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:44PM (#9034244)
Hardware combinations are mostly a terrible idea unlike software combinations that can be patched with updates. If your music player on your phone malfunctioned it shouldn't be a difficult remedy to push out an OTA update. Try that when your printer won't align thus relegating it to a bulky and expensive scanner (if that part still works).

There isn't a solution to devices becoming obsolete because manufacturers would sell less of a new product if the old one worked fine in perpetuity. Not only this but old iPhones, for example, run worse with new iOS versions because new versions are coded for new hardware. Hence the need to upgrade periodically. How many of us have a 486 that will run Dragon Age?

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by comex on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:08PM (#9034878)
That's why I suggested making the brains of the smart TV separable - in other words, somewhat similar to the current situation, but with tighter integration between the TV display, speakers, and ports and the box. Samsung seems to be doing something like that:

http://www.samsung.com/us/2013-smart-evolution/

It being Samsung, the hardware upgrade was apparently offered after a single year and completely redid the UI, but there's no reason the same principle can't be executed competently.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by Evolved on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:42PM (#9035182)
If you're the real Comex of iOS JB lore then I very much appreciate your work and you have my utmost respect.

So from what I understand about the Evolution Kit, it attaches to TVs 2012 and later and provides them with a boost to put them almost on par with 2013/2014+ TVs? Doesn't this cannibalize sales of new Smart TVs?

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by Vendan on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:31PM (#9037217)
They already did that kind of thing, but it seems to have died off. My TV has an MHL port, and I've got an MHL roku plugged into it. One remote controls both the TV and the roku. Specific buttons get passed through to the roku. It's actually really nice.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by fps on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @04:33PM (#9035856)
I have a 2014 non-smart LG TV and a FireTV at home and have been fighting the "I only want a single remote" fight for quite a while. The FireTV is able to switch on the TV using HDMI CEC (and shut it off after 30 minutes of inactivity) but I'm still using the TV remote to control the speaker volume.

Funny enough, I had a single remote setup for one brief shining moment in 2008 with the second generation Apple TV; the AppleTV would switch on and off my HDMI TV using some precursor to CEC - the same sleep/wake function that modern PC monitors use - and could also control the volume using the up/down buttons on the remote by modulating the sound going over the HDMI connection. Unfortunately, Apple ripped this audio control functionality out with a software update a few months after the product was released and I was forced to break out the second remote again and eventually replaced the AppleTV. But the point is it is possible to have only one remote with an HDMI connected set top box, but that feature isn't a priority in the world of cable boxes and audio receivers.

Anyway, my experience with smart TVs is that they're a waste of money and incredibly frustrating compared to set top boxes like Roku/Chromecast/FireTV/AppleTV. On top of that, my experience with TV remotes is that I don't want manufacturers like LG, Samsung or Sony making my primary remote control. They invariably feel cheap, slow and clunky whereas Amazon/Apple and even Roku do a very good job.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by dnm on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @11:10AM (#9033636)
The software on my 2011 Samsung "smart" TV has always sucked and is unusable. My initial reaction was that they went cheap on the processor (the network connection is hard-wired). It's just too slow to be usable and Youtube never played properly. I just want more HDMI ports at this point. I don't mind the external devices. With the revelation of the ad delivery, I have no interest in doing a software upgrade.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by a3n on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @09:31AM (#9032992)
I haven't bought a TV for five years (a Samsung, as it happens, plugged into a Roku). Can you even buy a TV that isn't smart these days?
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by rsync on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:23PM (#9034102)
Yes. Look for "commercial displays". You know those industrial looking NEC monitors with the tiny bezels that are turned sideways to be departure/arrival boards in airports ?

I use one of those as a TV. Is wonderful. Will probably last 20 years. Prior to that I used a panasonic commercial plasma. Still running after 10 years.

Neither of them have any smarts whatsoever. They're not even that expensive, which makes sense because many installations use 8 or 12 of them at a time as screenwalls.

http://www.necdisplay.com/p/large--screen-displays/p462?type...

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by burger_moon on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:02PM (#9034804)
The NEC P462 46" is on Amazon for ~$2k. Plus you still need speakers. That seems like quite a bit to spend on a 46" tv.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by anon4 on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:23AM (#9033305)
Yes, it's called a monitor. There are plenty of monitors that have hdmi inputs and a standard audio jack output for connecting to a set of speakers.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by Roboprog on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:58AM (#9033552)
Like how you think. I'm not sure what the biggest monitor you can get is, though.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by jpindar on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @11:13AM (#9033659)
The largest monitor I am aware of is the one in the Dallas Cowboy's stadium, which is 72 feet by 160 feet and 1920 x 1080 resolution.

The largest one a normal person can afford is of course a different question.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by boobsbr on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:03PM (#9033954)
It's not even 2k? Ewww.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by nitrogen on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:33PM (#9034180)
In consumer land, 1920x1080 is 2K. 4K is 3840x2160. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-definition_televisi...
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by qanael on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:20PM (#9034992)
Newegg has a "large format display" category for big monitors. 46" seems to be a popular size. There's some pretty cheap 1080p ones in there, but I don't know anything about their image quality.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by tomjen3 on Friday February 13, 2015 @12:40PM (#9045632)
Sysadmin at work as a 40inch 4k monitor. Not sure if it has external speakers though.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by a3n on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:12PM (#9034917)
How does the viable viewing angle of a repurposed monitor compare to a TV?
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by rm999 on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:41AM (#9033424)
Sort of, but if you want the best quality TV it's hard to avoid "smart" TVs. From wirecutter: http://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-tv/

>Is there a best TV with no apps (or 3D)?

>Not really. Nearly every TV worth considering is also a Smart TV. There used to be several great midrange “dumb” TVs, but they’re all pretty much gone. You don’t have to use them, and you’re probably still better off getting a media streamer (since they have more content sources). As far as 3D goes, we’re starting to see good TVs that lack 3D

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by wil421 on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:00AM (#9033151)
There are plenty of companies that sell budget TVs without Smart features. Visio, Magnavox, and even Samsung's low end TVs dont have Smart features.

If you are looking for a top of the line TV it may be hard to find (but is the display really better than a budget Samsung, are we paying extra for Smart features?).

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by teacup50 on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:47AM (#9033453)
TVs meant for commercial installations (hotels, hospitals, digital signage, etc) often either have no smart features, or have fully user-controllable smart features (e.g., think hotel menus).
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by nicwolff on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:29PM (#9034149)
I'm still using a 10-year-old 42" Panasonic Commercial Plasma, no tuner, no "smart" features, stellar picture, totally expandable, totally reliable. They stopped making them of course.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by tomjen3 on Friday February 13, 2015 @12:39PM (#9045621)
Yes. I brought one a year or so ago (40 inches I think) and it isn't smart (that is it doesn't have an internet connection option) but it does have the ability to e.g auto tune channel discovery and play music and movies from the attached usb stick (super useful feature btw) so it isn't like a tv of yesterday either.

I imagine the televisions you tend to see ads for or that are displayed most prominently in stores are those that they want to sell (no shit) and thus those tend to be the smart tvs.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by rodgerd on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:59PM (#9034354)
I picked up a Panasonic Viera that is entirely bereft of smart features, not even a network port. About 2/3rds the price of equivalent quality screens with smart functionality, too.

That said, simply not plugging a smart TV into the network will solve most of the problems with it.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by LordKano on Thursday February 12, 2015 @11:40AM (#9039655)
Even if we get to the point that all of the available/affordable TVs are "Smart", you still have the option of not letting the thing on your network.

Well, at least for now.

I will continue to use my plain old "Dumb" TVs and Roku devices.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by rasz_pl on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @11:56AM (#9033907)
Seiki makes cheap dumb 4K TVs.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by a3n on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @02:08PM (#9034882)
Great responses, and from reading them I realized I should have qualified as "a good or high quality display." Which many responders assumed, and there's some good direction to explore here.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by pkfrank on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @09:59AM (#9033148)
Yes. Most big box retailers have an "in house" brand that is no-frills but still fairly quality. IE Insignia from Best Buy.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by pjmlp on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @09:40AM (#9033042)
In Europe yes.
Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by HeXetic on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @11:02AM (#9033577)
> combined printer and scanners are a bad idea

So, photocopiers are a bad idea? Because that's what that is.

Re:Samsung's smart TVs are inserting unwanted ads into users... by DanBC on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @11:53AM (#9033889)
Parent post is clearly talking about domestic printers that come with a scanner too, and not photocopiers.

But, actually, scanning+printing photocopiers (rather than traditional photocopiers) suck too: http://www.dkriesel.com/en/blog/2013/0802_xerox-workcentres_...?