News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by footpath on Friday February 06, 2015 @04:55PM (#9011818)
Here's a nice thread about Jonathan Blow's view on investing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2198255

you are better off taking the mental energy you would have expended on "investing" and subsequently worrying about your money, and instead funneling it into your creative endeavors. You will make more money that way, especially when you take a long-term view.

...

If creative endeavors are profitable, you can use the resulting money to fuel more creative endeavors, thus making the world a better place. Keeping money in a bank account or publicly-traded stock does not particularly make the world a better place.

Once I got approximately into the f-you money level of income, it became crystal clear how fictitious money is in the first place. I wake up one morning, and bam, I am wealthy! Why? Because someone said so and typed a number into a computer. Okay... that's kind of weird.

Given that money is so fictitious and somewhat meaningless, it is a shame to give into primal hoarding impulses, just so one can see the number in one's bank account go up like a high score in a video game. It's much better to make like Elon Musk and use your money for what it is: a way to wield influence to make the world more like you would like it to be.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by vortizz on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:12PM (#9011901)
Sure, money is fictitious and meaningless once you've moved into the f-you echelon. By definition. Perhaps for that segment piping it into creative endeavors is fulfilling and worthwhile.

For everyone else for whom money is a meal, rent, or essential good instead of an expletive, who cannot afford to take an ethereally long-term view, this advice is out of touch with reality if not plain dangerous.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by seanflyon on Friday February 06, 2015 @06:39PM (#9012307)
You and I read his advice quite differently. Once you quite your job to pursue your dream you have a finite runway determined by your savings and minimum expenses. He is suggesting you use that runway to build you dream instead of using it to try to get funding for a longer runway.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by quanticle on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:18PM (#9013036)
But what if your dream isn't profitable?
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by kordless on Saturday February 07, 2015 @11:14AM (#9014348)
Then you had the wrong expectations.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by seanflyon on Monday February 09, 2015 @04:51PM (#9023989)
A dream that cannot pay for itself is not a business. Do not seek venture capital for your hobbies.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by ap3 on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:45PM (#9013095)
Then it was just a bad dream
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by themartorana on Saturday February 07, 2015 @03:10AM (#9013432)
This is a bad statement.

Without your "bad dreams" we wouldn't have the Red Cross, Kiva, Linux (or a majority of *nix releases), GPG (or lots of other OSS projects), One, Doctors Without Borders (or any number of other non-profit organizations), immense amounts of historically important art, music, documentaries, museums...

Some of the best, most important dreams in human history weren't profitable.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by officemonkey on Saturday February 07, 2015 @08:33AM (#9013894)
One would argue that "social profit" (ie: where society profits) is where all those not-for-profit "bad dreams" go.

The Red Cross movement especially brought forward the Geneva Conventions (which improved the conditions of prisoners of war), successfully fought epidemics, and (in my opinion) began a tradition of humanism that combats extreme fundamentalism in a practical non-violent way (which is why the worst fundamentalists target Red Cross/Red Crescent workers.)

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by baddox on Saturday February 07, 2015 @06:02AM (#9013655)
All of those things are profitable in the sense that's relevant to this context. In this context, "profitable" is clearly being used to simply mean financially viable. Nonprofit organizations produce surplus revenue, they just happen to use that surplus to further invest in the official (and legally-approved) goal of the organization.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by nasmorn on Saturday February 07, 2015 @01:24PM (#9014788)
The Red Cross was built with fck u money. Dun ant was already wealthy
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by JamesSwift on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:52PM (#9013112)
I agree with you in that I think Jonathan is speaking a bit too idealistically. But I agree with Jonathan in that I personally don't put a lot of 'value' on holding on to money. I would rather spend my (minimal amount of) money enriching others lives, doing small things like tipping well or picking up friends meals. I think ultimately it is up to the individual how they derive their happiness, and ultimately decide what value they assign to monetary wealth. Maybe rather than categorizing money as meaningless, it would be better to describe money as a tool whose utility is determined by its owner. And then the key is that we must avoid judging others when they place a different value on their money than we do.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by hiou on Saturday February 07, 2015 @12:37AM (#9013198)
The point more is about how money isn't actually a thing. It's one of many ways to obtain something. Just one of them. For example if you are a high profile game developer, no matter what you release for a long time you will pay your basic bills, not because you have money now, but because you can get it relatively easily. It's not the money anymore since once you are enough in demand you can essentially print money by working so it really is meaningless in that context. It's very very different from someone who has no money and no real way to obtain it. It's not the money but the ability to get it easily that matters.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by beachstartup on Friday February 06, 2015 @10:47PM (#9012983)
that advice isn't meant for poor people. it's meant for rich people.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by adam74 on Saturday February 07, 2015 @07:45AM (#9013801)
No kidding. I could use some that Blow money right now ...
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by nsxwolf on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:00PM (#9011839)
This is good advice for a very narrow segment of creative people and not everyone at large. It's terrible advice for people with children, for example.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by pyrocat on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:12PM (#9011900)
I think reaching "Fuck you" levels of wealth has a very slightly different (3% higher?) definition for people with kids, but otherwise the advise is the same. Once you (or, you and your family, if you have one) are financially safe, don't hoard.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by underwater on Friday February 06, 2015 @06:24PM (#9012244)
It's also easier to say when you have a lot of money. Telling someone living in poverty that money is fictitious would be pretty tactless.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by droopyEyelids on Saturday February 07, 2015 @10:09AM (#9014152)
I have to disagree. Someone in poverty already knows money is a proxy for what they actually want. They understand perfectly that barter work or a gift can provide the same things without the control and authority structures around money.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by mesh on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:14PM (#9011911)
Why do you feel it is bad advice for people with children?
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by rifung on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:42PM (#9012060)
I imagine it's because you need to save for your kids to go to school, college, and to generally ensure their well being, and those things have a pretty set timeline. That being the case, taking the risks of pouring all your money into creative endeavors doesn't appear to be a particularly responsible thing to do as a parent.

Of course, there's a balance to be had.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by fulafel on Saturday February 07, 2015 @03:25AM (#9013458)
Lots of places have free education and healthcare. Even the US seems to be be slowly approaching the western median safety net level there with the path started by Obamacare and plummeting bang for buck of college education... Increased risk tolerance helps on many fronts.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by rifung on Saturday February 07, 2015 @07:29PM (#9015921)
I'm from the US so I can only comment on the situation here, but the reality is that despite public education being free till college, it is for the most part terrible.

So, if you want your kids to get a proper education you'll either have to pay for a good school or get a house in a nice neighborhood; both things which require one to constantly be paying a substantial amount of money, whether it be for the mortgage, taxes, or tuition.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by wtbob on Saturday February 07, 2015 @12:06PM (#9014553)
Even with free education, food and healthcare, the parents who save more resources for their children will do better for them than those who don't.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by anonbanker on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:14PM (#9011913)
Your mindset is exactly why pg refuses to invest in anyone over 35; they've become unable to take risks due to commitments.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by SwellJoe on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:54PM (#9012136)
I believe my co-founder and I were the oldest founders ever funded by YC at the time (in 2007) and I was 33 and my co-founder was, I think, 34 with a wife and two kids. The batch after ours had a couple of folks in their 40s, and I think the average age has crept up a bit over time, though the founders do tend to still be quite young.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by sillysaurus3 on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:24PM (#9011960)
I don't think pg would behave like that, let alone say that. He was 29 when he started Viaweb, which is not far from 35. YC has funded people over 35 as well.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by anonbanker on Friday February 06, 2015 @07:54PM (#9012569)
I love that I'm being downvoted for quoting pg.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by dang on Saturday February 07, 2015 @02:50PM (#9015090)
It wasn't because you quoted pg; you didn't quote pg.

The downvotes were more likely because the comment was false (pg and YC invest in plenty of founders over 35) and unduly personal ("your mindset is exactly why...").

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by anonbanker on Saturday February 07, 2015 @10:55PM (#9016362)
I know what I read, and I accept that I'm being downvoted for not citing a source, but not for misquoting pg.

I am tempted to see if blind devotion to pg leads to downvotes, but I doubt HN would care. :-)

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by kbenson on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:36PM (#9012707)
You didn't exactly quote him, you stated his opinion and reasoning, without clarifying if it was your interpretation or his direct statement, and included no reference.

That said, I generally agree with the sentiment. People with commitments are less free to play with their resources, at least if they are responsible. An who wants to invest in someone who's not responsible. There are, of course, exceptions, and even times when the opposite holds true; commitments can force a level of responsibility and drive because the stakes may be higher.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by noblethrasher on Friday February 06, 2015 @10:13PM (#9012924)
The closest thing that I can find that pg has said on the matter is that good hackers between about 23 and 38 should start a company. He said 38 was the upper bound because the simple reality is that the affordability of risk declines with age. But, even then he said that there was a lot of play in that number.

Source: http://www.paulgraham.com/start.html

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by nsxwolf on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:30PM (#9011996)
Perfectly fine by me. Running a business the way pg wants you to would probably make you a pretty lousy parent.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by Kurtz79 on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:54PM (#9012750)
Funny then that this whole discussion is about a 40+ years old guy risking his fortune on a single project.
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by ChuckMcM on Friday February 06, 2015 @05:39PM (#9012043)
In general I agree with that, although having enough money "hoarded" such that you can collect a monthly stipend to cover basic necessities (like food, shelter, and utilities) makes spending all your time on investing your creative energies a lot less stressful :-)
Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by jasonvolpe on Friday February 06, 2015 @09:21PM (#9012805)
Though his point is not lost, the use of "primal" in "it is a shame to give into primal hoarding impulses" isn't fully accurate.

Would not primal hunter gatherers have spent it while they had it - resources being plentiful for those skilled to find and kill? Didn't hoarding only become necessary when humans transitioned to farming?

In fact it _is_ a primal urge to consume what you've earned, spending it on improving yourself/project.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by TheMagicHorsey on Saturday February 07, 2015 @08:38AM (#9013907)
This is good advice for smart and creative people who have good taste.

I have friends that plowed their savings into their dream projects, but they lacked good taste. Nobody bought their shit.

Now they are back working a 9 to 5.

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by anon4 on Saturday February 07, 2015 @06:14AM (#9013675)
You know why I want money? Why I always demand a lot of money as payment? Because money can replace everything - house, food, happiness, love - you can buy it all with money. Money is extremely important and yet, it is completely replaceable. I hate people who say "I cannot live with this or that". Your life is more important than any possession. All you need is money.

-- some guy I used to know

Re:‘Braid’ creator sacrifices his fortune to build his next ... by sixQuarks on Saturday February 07, 2015 @08:34AM (#9013896)
f-you money to me is having $100 million or more. Did this guy get anywhere close to that figure?