I agree with op; the anti-vax debate is not only the parents' failure to vaxinate their children, it is also ours for failing to convince them.
The confrontational tone of this debate achieves nothing but making people defensive. And that's not good for anyone.
Science and satire are woefully inadequate means of persuasion for many people. Empathy is typically well worth a try.
You probably can't convince hard-core antivaxxers. They are likely lost causes. At this point, probably the best we can do is to so relentlessly ridicule the position that it becomes an embarrassing opinion to hold. For example, could you imagine your neighbors learning that you were a Flat Earther? No; you'd be the block laughingstock. That's what needs to happen to the antivax delusion.
I'm so sad that this is a solution for so many things these days. Science isn't the social justice movement, we have evidence. If people want to bully others for being racist or homophobic, whatever, but that's not how science works. All we have to do to "win" the argument is deescalate it emotionally and make it about calmly and rationally looking at the evidence. That's how science wins, not by marginalizing anybody who disagrees with us.
And when people ask how we know that science works, point at all the technology of the modern world. The phone in their pocket, the airplanes they fly in, the toilets that make their poop disappear, the International Space Station floating around the earth, the electricity in their wall sockets. We don't place blind faith in science, we believe in it because it works.
The problem with being a good empiricist is that you start to find that your reasons for believing certain things differ very widely from those of other people.
Public health does not have the luxury of waiting centuries for naysayers to die out. Whooping cough won't do us the favor of not striking while we build consensus.
I strongly believe in the correctness of your approach. I just don't think that's an option here.
But I also think it's important not to poison the long-term approach in the process. I know a lot of anti-science people and for many of them it stems from a few really bad experiences where somebody just beat them over the head with science. Then they latch on to any crackpot who claims they're about to revolutionize science and do away with "scientism."
I think most people who smoke now know this but choose to do so anyway because it's a trade off. They enjoying smoking enough to accept the risks. As long as that doesn't hurt me, fine. Anti-vaxxers are causing problems for the rest of society. In fact they aren't hurting themselves at all, they are hurting their children and other people's. With smoking we could minimise the negative externalities for non-smokers (ban on smoking in public places etc.). With anti-vaxxers that's difficult without excluding them from society completely.
Changing your point of view in spite of your ego requires some form rationality; no amount of empathy can make up for this lack.
No, I believe that the correct answer is a well funded marketing campaign. Every Jenny McCarthy needs to be countered with two Angelina Jolees. Every study published in a scientific magazine needs to be countered with one each in Time, Newsweek, and the WSJ. Every commercial needs to be bought out with prime time, big budget commercials.
Doing it this way ensures that the proper message gets to a person in the method they prefer, and in a way where they can use their standard values to pick the answer, as opposed to having to protect their ego against someone else.
Empathy and education may help, but in the end, no deviation from the scientifically proven right way can be allowed, lest children be threatened by diseases we've conquered decades ago.
So inform and educate to the extent possible. Then if that fails, sue them for parental neglect and passive biological warfare or whatever.
This is creationism/"intelligent design" all over, but with real consequences in the real world. I'm prepared to accept a lot of relatively harmless idiocy, but this is where I pull the line. And I think John Rawls (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Rawls#The_Original_Positio... ) would agree with me.
Clearly, endangering people's lives like this in reality is more like drunk driving: a serious punishable offense, but not even remotely in the same range as "passive biological warfare".
It took a lot of evidence to convince anyone that Vikings visited America before Columbus. There is at least a small amount of evidence to suggest that crossings and even a trickle of trade pre-dated the Vikings:
http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~legneref/ethnic/mummy.htm
Other circumstantial evidence includes architecture and burial customs among South American native civilizations that could be interpreted as Egypt-influenced. Yet the majority of scientists greet these claims with extreme skepticism. How could the ancients have crossed the Atlantic? With what? Long boats?
When a great, almost mythic feat is not repeated for a very long time, people will begin to doubt it. That's not new and it's not because "people are stupid." It's because people lie and exaggerate a lot, and thus people respond to that by being skeptical of grandiose claims. It also doesn't help that governments often lie as a matter of standard policy, a fact that very rationally leads people to be generally skeptical of what they say.
If our civilization fell and another rose in thousands of years, I'd expect that many would respond with tremendous incredulity to the idea that the ancients visited the Moon with primitive metal tubes full of fossil fuel and discrete component computers. How absurd. Instead, they would reason, this was obviously some sort of national myth and a part of the American cult of state -- the rocket is an obvious phallic symbol and it being full of oil represented petroleum as the basis of American power, etc.
The only way to disabuse people of the moon hoax theory is to go back to the Moon (or further).
I happen to think we went to the Moon. I also happen to think it's at least possible that ancients (Egyptians, Phoenicians, etc.) crossed the Atlantic. But I guess I'm a bit of an optimist about what humans can do when they really put their minds to it... with tubes full of fossil fuel, or long boats. :)
I do often wonder if things like the pyramids had some actual function. I'm not talking about the far-out sci-fi speculations like landing pads for aliens, but some function other than to look awesome and store mummies.
When I talk to my relatives, they remember when vaccinations were dangerous, when we switched from "global warming" to "global cooling", and now to "climate change" which lets science claim any old change as forwarding their cause.
To be clear, I side with science on this, but for people who don't follow science all the time, I can see how it's easy to get tired of the "no, we have the right answer now, ignore that previous answer". See also basically everything to do with eating/fats/etc.
LATER EDIT: I was not clear in this post. By "science which told them" on the first line, I meant to say "The version of science as portrayed by much of the media". The media blew the autism/vaccine issue hugely, and kept the controversy going for a long time.
That's 100% false. The scientific consensus has always been that vaccines are safe and effective, and do not cause autism. One individual paper that said otherwise was an outlier, and was relatively quickly debunked.
It's important to differentiate between a single paper written by a scientist, and the scientific consensus, which is what the bulk of scientists agree is right. It's not that the consensus is never wrong, but it is wrong a lot less often than a individual paper is wrong.
The consensus on vaccines has never changed and to desribe it as such is misleading.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Wakefield
That's the publication process failing to catch the fraud, not science being wrong.
I guess there are probably other things that happened, but that one person is a source of an awful lot of the nonsense we see today.
It really wasn't. One doctor with an enormous conflict of interest told them, and all other evidence both then and now contradicted his claims.
Please be aware of the hindsight fallacy.
Looking back now - now we know he had developed his own single measles vaccine and had been paid to find flaws with the MMR vaccine for a lawsuit and we know he took samples without permission and falsified data - now it's easy to say "oh but it's all nonsense!"
It really wasn't that easy at the time. That's why many of the people who declined MMR didn't reject all vaccination - they took seperate vaccinations for measles, mumps and rubella.
If those tactics don't work for you and operating systems why do you think they'll work for anything else?
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/ct-measles-chicago-...
We have to understand the position that there were people that respected the opinions of a friend or loved one. When it came to their own child it was a difficult decision to make considering that herd immunity was making it a non-issue for so long. Satire can be an excellent approach to limit the numbers of those opinion makers.
For the parents that decided against immunization I think it is important to remember that we can disagree but still be respectful. At the other extreme calling those parents privileged or gullible will not go as far. It all depends on audience.
Anti-vax, anti-chemtrail, anti-this-and-that is popular, and it is "intellectual" to be against, a dissident.
Does it really have to be more complicated than that?
(edited for clarity)
It is, because by choosing not to vaccinate, you compromise herd immunity and put others at risk. An unvaccinated child in a school would impact the right of a kid with leukemia to go to school, for example.
Are we going to force people to make the same decision as you or not? If you don't want to to that, then you're actually agreeing with me.
When it comes to vaccinating children who are medically sound to be vaccinated? Yes. Without hesitation, yes.
That's the difference between taking a vaccine and paying your taxes or buying car insurance.
You don't get to drive 100 mph on the highway because it entails risks to other people. Same situation here.
That's why "life, liberty, and happiness" is in the order that it is. Life before liberty before happiness.
Understand that some people can not get the vaccine. They are protected if everyone who can get the vaccine gets it. Now that a bunch of healthy people are note getting the vaccines, the ones that can not get it are at serious risk of not only illness, but death.
The vast majority of society has decided that your freedom is not worth the risk to other people. There was a minor exception for religion, and few people used it so it didn't really impact public health until very recently. Now a lot of people are abusing that provision, it is having a public health impact, and that provision and your freedom of choice on the matter need to be eliminated.
Your position is only defensible if you don't believe that there are diseases that can kill or cripple you. While I wish that were true, that's not the world we live in.
Can you cite a number of deaths that took place from the latter?
I agree with you on the things you are trying to distract with. You want to smoke? Great, that only impacts you. I want you to be able to make that choice for weed and heroin too. I'm with you on the wars, but that's so far from what we're talking about here it's not worth getting into.
I was a registered capital-L libertarian for many years. I campaigned for Ron Paul before the words "Tea Party" were anything other than a chapter in a history book. I get it.
But the libertarian (small-L) philosophy is let someone have the freedom to do anything they want, as long as it doesn't impact other people's freedoms.
This is one of those things. Anti-vax people are impacting my life, are impacting my kids life, impinging on my safety and well being and my kids well being.
If society isn't going to enforce a law about that, then what's the point?
A more reasonable approach would be to bar non-vaccinated kids from public school and let private schools and home schooled children decide for themselves. That's the only law that I support.
We've regulated cigarettes to the point where they're mostly a threat to those who choose to use them. We let you trade your own health/safety for your own liberty.
Choosing not to vaccinate doesn't benefit anyone and does cause harm to other people. We're letting you trade our health/safety for your own liberty.
If you want to harm yourself, that's okay. If you want to put people at risk for society's benefit, that's okay. If you want to put society at risk because you don't believe in science, that's not okay.
Granted, war sucks.
WHAT?!
Let me fix that for you so that it actually follows the scenario:
"If you want to put society at risk because you don't want to [potentially] harm yourself (it happens with vaccines), that's not okay."
And that is crap. Society (as government) has the right to force every individual to play Russian roulette?
And the risk from not getting it effects not just yourself.
So, yeah, were the odds in Russian Roulette were such that playing it dramartically increased your health and safety and the health and safety of those around you, yes, the government should require it. But since those aren't the odds of Russian Roulette, it seems like a pretty dishonest analogy to use.
Vaccines are a great example of a personal choice that does hurt other people, despite seeming like something that impacts only you.
Why? In short, because herd immunity is far more powerful than individual immunity, and protects even people who cannot be vaccinated. By choosing not to vaccinate, you chip away at herd immunity.
Actually, a couple anti-vaxxers would be OK. Herd immunity, as I said, allows for some people to safely be unvaccinated, and that is why it is powerful. The problem is when anti-vax'ing became a movement with the goal of convincing as many people as possible not to vaccinate.
I wonder if this would even be an issue if we would flip the equation a bit: you don't have to get your kids vaccinated, but then they have to go to a school filled with other unvaccinated kids. This wouldn't solve the overall problem, but it would do some 'fear aikido', redirecting them to see that they are trading a nebulous risk for a very real one.
You don't get the sense the author condemns the practice. It's a strong statement from an anarcho-syndicalist like Traven. At least he was aware of the fact that everyone lives downstream of someone. With today's libertarians you get the strong notion that they imagine each of them living in their own bubble in Low Earth Orbit.
I think that's both a more effective and humane approach to the danger posed by non-vaccination than the also-defensible alternatives of allowing people to make that decision but then legal prohibiting them from most public intercourse, or just punishing anyone who is found to have, as a responsible adult, chosen not to vaccinate themselves or their child to a disease where they knew, or reasonably should have known, an effective vaccine was available, without a valid medical reason, and where the person so unvaccinated then transmitted the disease to a third party, for battery or, in the event that death results, murder of the depraved indifference type (as well as, of course, allow civil damages against those responsible adults for the resulting harms.)
This isn't limited to anti-vaxxers either. The number of people who believe we haven't visited the moon is growing year over year. There are also people who believe that the Holocaust did not happen, despite having survivors and well documented photographs.
As unfortunate as it is, there's little we can do for some folks, other than treat them as we do children who don't understand why sticking their fingers in outlets are bad, and say "Because I said so".