I agree in the sense that we shouldn't let unvaccinated kids go to school and risk the health of other kids.
But I also think it's important not to poison the long-term approach in the process. I know a lot of anti-science people and for many of them it stems from a few really bad experiences where somebody just beat them over the head with science. Then they latch on to any crackpot who claims they're about to revolutionize science and do away with "scientism."
Public health does not have the luxury of waiting centuries for naysayers to die out. Whooping cough won't do us the favor of not striking while we build consensus.
I strongly believe in the correctness of your approach. I just don't think that's an option here.