Some manufacturers only offer 3 years though with no option to extend so the value proposition is not nearly as good IMO if you're buying a vehicle with only a year left on the warranty.
Things worked out well for me. The Corolla was a tad scruffy but otherwise presentable, and my mechanic gave it a clean bill of health (except for two of the tires being over-worn, which Hertz replaced). It's been a while, but I remember the price being ~$11k (4dr sedan, 43k miles, about 1.5 yr old), and all said and done came to ~$12k (taxes, titles, fees, what-have-you). The car was young enough and under-mileage enough to still be under manufacturer's warranty. The Hertz warranty was 60 days.
The 3-days rent is not much risk (maybe $200) versus $500 deposit most used car dealers want. This is probably not an easy way to go if you need to do this on a car loan. But if you can raise the cash, I think this is a good way to go.
Q: Who drove this car?
A: Oh, whatever random people wanted to pay me money.
Q: What kind of maintenance did you do?
A: The bare minimum to get it to last a year.
Q: What options did you get?
A: The lowest ones the manufacturer would sell us.
Does that appeal?
Also, if you buy a car thats 2 or 3 years old you can actually figure out what is likely to go wrong with it, something you generally don't get with new cars (unless you're buying a model is about to be refreshed)
I generally find the maintenance required to keep the warranty generally exceeds the cost of repairs that might actually happen. It's not exactly rocket science to change air filters, oil, transmission fluid, and brakes.
The other thing about cheap used cars is when they break, you get a new one. I'm not going to spend $2k on a new engine, I'm going to buy a new car for $2000-4000.
And many manufacturers offer an extended warranty on used cars. Buy a 1 year old "certified" car many times has a longer warranty than an identical new car at a lower cost.
This x100. My wife and I recently bought a new car. We went into the process assuming that we'd buy a car that was a couple of years old. After 3 months of casual browsing and research, we bought a new car with a few modest upgrades.
We even live in a place with plentiful public transit. We've only put 4000 miles on our 10 month old car - and that's _a lot_ of driving for us.
The reason being is that we recently had our first child. We have to get him to daycare somehow before we can go to work. Any time our car is in for repairs, one of us simply stays home with him, as relying on the bus schedule to get us to an from the daycare reliably is a pain. Moreover, we're lucky we can do that on a moments notice. If we worked in jobs where we couldn't work from home, we'd be even more incentivized to buy something reliable.
We had an 14 year old car before. We got a new car specifically to avoid having to think about it. As long as we find time for a regular oil change, everything keeps running smoothly.
I know plenty of people who are reasonably frugal who still go for the new car, though I think they view it as more of a slightly risk-averse heuristic than an optimal decision. I think most of them recognize that with planning, effort, and a bit (but not a ton) of luck, they probably would do better used.
The risk averse heuristic goes like this: identify a car with a reputation for value, purchase under a buyer's plan, take very good care of itfor the useful life of the car. These aren't the people who show up in a shiny new car every few years - they often keep the car for 15 years or more.
Like I said, it's a bit risk and effort averse, since with a lot of research, careful evaluation (including a mechanic inspection), and a bit of luck (more the absence of bad luck), you can definitely beat the above strategy by going used. It's a lot of effort, though. Personally, I did all the things you're supposed to do, and still ended up with lots of $$ repair bills, so I'm no longer interested in used cars. I understand that I got unlucky, but I'm just done.
I suppose I'm also particularly convinced by the argument that people generally don't sell good used cars, since I'm one of those people who hangs onto a car until it costs me more to own it than replace it.