News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by mironathetin on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:17AM (#8996422)
I am happy that an expert without a bias reports about this. What you noted down came back into my mind immediately. These were the reported risks for professional athletes (back in the days when I decided to study physics instead of taking more of this junk and go pro).

There are also natural ways to keep your own T level high, like healthy food, enough sleep, everything that increases your muscle mass (weightlifting), not too much stress, staying lean, and of course the most enjoyable thing you can do with your partner ;o). All this desn't cost a 1000$ a month, its free and its good for you too. No enhanced risk for cancer, no bad wakeup after 20 years of taking it.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by golemotron on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @07:52AM (#8996504)
I don't think so. If testosterone is the culprit for increased risk of coronary artery disease, prostate cancer and sleep apnea, then doing things that naturally increase testosterone will increase risk also.

Don't succumb to the naturalistic fallacy. The body doesn't care where it gets its chemicals from.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vannevar on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:51AM (#8997494)
Don't succumb to the reductionist fallacy. The body is complex, and more than the sum of its parts, including its hormones. It's entirely possible that the process that produces testosterone naturally also has other effects that mitigate the downside of testosterone.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dsjoerg on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:36PM (#8999117)
Are you referring to the reduction fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_of_the_single_cause)? I looked around for a "reductionist fallacy" but couldn't find anything. Or are you instead saying that the reductionist view is wrong, and you like to call things you disagree with fallacies.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vannevar on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:52PM (#8999242)
The latter.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dsjoerg on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:02PM (#9004325)
I like your honesty and your brevity.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by wavegeek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:05PM (#9001658)
Another factor often forgotten is that HRT very poorly mimics the natural testosterone fluctuations in the body.

Testosterone fluctuates on a regular daily cycle, the reason for which is not known. Therefore it is not reproduced in treatment. The assumption is "we don't know why, so it mustn't be important".

Also the typical cycle of quarterly shots of T undecanoate or other similar regimes produce unphysiological fluctations from one injection to the next of over 110%. The patient goes from very high levels of test (close to 1000ug/dl) to very marginal levels (around 350).

Perhaps because of this, side effects from taking T supplements, such as hematocrit (excess red blood cell volume) are far greater with supplements than with those experiencing the same level of T from endogenous sources.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by loucal on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:51PM (#9001797)
In which country is quarterly undecanoate typical? I know the US FDA hasn't approved it and here the standard esther and frequency of injection are cypionate and once per week, as far as I can tell.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by delecti on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:49PM (#8998299)
It's perfectly reasonable to assume that the healthy living things that drive up T result in a longer lifespan, but I also don't see any conflict in thinking that it would make you live even longer still if not for that higher T.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by pyre on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:08PM (#8998445)
True, but this:

> If testosterone is the culprit for increased risk of coronary artery disease, prostate cancer and sleep apnea, then doing things that naturally increase testosterone will increase risk also.

states that the result of higher T through natural processes is increased risk. It discounts the possibility that there is a net decreased risk due to the processes themselves decreasing risk to the point that it offsets the increased risk due to increased T.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by ScottBurson on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:35PM (#8999111)
It also overlooks the fact that when you're taking hormone supplements, it's both tempting and very easy to increase your levels above what you would get through natural means.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by delecti on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:39PM (#9004973)
That quote is from a comment, which was speculation. I'm not sure it has enough support to be used as counter-evidence to what I said.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by kingmanaz on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @01:00PM (#8998384)
>Don't succumb to the reductionist fallacy. The body is complex, and more than the sum of its parts

The above needs to be repeated more often, particularly on HN.

Tech culture is overdue for an epistemological yin to its empiricist yang.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by FreshlyMinted on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @02:56PM (#8999276)
>Tech culture is overdue for an epistemological yin to its empiricist yang.

What a wonderful sentence. I grew glasses reading this.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by scribu on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:14PM (#9000360)
Upvoted for the fun "growing glasses" phrase.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by pbowyer on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:48PM (#9000551)
Can you put the yin bit into layman's speak please? How does it differ to empiricist?
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by Perceval on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:13PM (#9007057)
Empiricism (especially in its behavioralist variety) is premised on the ability to collect data and draw inductive conclusions from the data.

Epistemology is the study of how things can be known, what can be known, or what the limits to knowability are. How can we justify a belief based on a collection of observations?

davak began with the assertion that testosterone is linked to a number of health problems.

mironathetin notes that studies of the negative health implications of testosterone were often performed on professional athletes, who are going to have high baseline levels of testosterone naturally, and who have in all likelihood supplemented with large doses of testosterone at various points in their career/training. But, mironathetin notes that positive lifestyle changes can increase your body's natural production of testosterone without the need for supplementation.

golemotron is skeptical that naturally increasing testosterone will lead to different health implications than the studies indicated. They posit that there is a direct relationship between testosterone levels and health risks.

vannevar responds that because the body is a system, non-linear and feedback effects are much more likely to control the health effects of testosterone than a simple linear relationship between testosterone and health risk.

kingmanaz agrees and calls golemotron's position reductionist, which means that golemotron implicitly believes that one can understand a phenomenon by understanding and measuring each of its component parts (empiricism). An epistemological critique of golemotron's position would begin with an assertion that the whole is different from the sum of the parts, because the parts interact with each other, producing non-linear effects. One must understand the gestalt, not just the parts. Induction straight from data will often miss things that holism might not.

For an accessible critique of data and inductivism, you might pick up a copy of Nassim Nicholas Taleb's Fooled by Randomness. If you are interested in systemic non-linearity in political science, check out Robert Jervis's System Effects.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vadman on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:01AM (#8997557)
"The body doesn't care where it gets its chemicals from"

Sometimes it does, or maybe the supplements are not formulated quite right. E.g. I saw this at LessWrong: "turns out that fish oil pills suck, and you’d need to take approximately 9 times as much to have the same effect as eating fish, at which point they’d have dangerous blood thinning effects." Link to the study: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12848287

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by threeseed on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:59PM (#9000619)
Even more concerning with supplements is what has been seen in New York. A significant percentage of herbal supplements sold contained large quantities of bulking material and in some cases that was all they contained.

Which means everyone out there taking supplements would likely be less healthy than people eating food in a balanced manner.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by rsync on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @03:28PM (#8999499)
Can you provide a link to the lesswrong discussion where you learned this ?

Thanks.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by blaabjerg on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @03:41PM (#8999594)
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dhimes on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:02PM (#9000633)
Interesting article. However, this early sentence did set off my detectors:

Mental and physical performance are strongly correlated, meaning maintaining your body will help maintain your mind.

Of course, the conclusion is not supported by (only) the correlation.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by tcfunk on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:33AM (#8996957)
> Don't succumb to the naturalistic fallacy. The body doesn't care where it gets its chemicals from.

Even if that's true, our bodies are also great at offloading tasks. If you train your body to think that Testosterone (or anything else, for that matter) will come from external sources, it will stop producing it naturally, and will become worse at regulating it's own T levels.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by sanoli on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:40PM (#8998234)
This. Pro bodybuilders take a bunch of other stuff to regulate what their bodies regulated naturally, before they jacked up their levels with external stuff.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by atlantic on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:28AM (#8996651)
It's not the chemical. It's the dosage, and the way the body knows how to regulate it.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by voidlogic on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:15AM (#8997639)
>I don't think so. If testosterone is the culprit for increased risk of coronary artery disease, prostate cancer and sleep apnea, then doing things that naturally increase testosterone will increase risk also.

True- BUT many of those things mentioned to be thought to improve Testosterone above are also known to reduce risks that are associated with Testosterone itself (heart disease, etc). So there may be some net balancing at play here?

>Don't succumb to the naturalistic fallacy. The body doesn't care where it gets its chemicals from.

This is true in the immediate, but consuming things your body synthesizes (ex. testosterone, cholesterol) will often reduce the rate at which your body synthesizes it... Your body is a complex system with many feedback loops.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by wavegeek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:55PM (#9001624)
There is no evidence T causes prostate cancer. If you have it, T may speed the growth. But that's all.

The by far dominant cause of sleep apnea is obesity. In marginal cases or in high doses T can exacerbate it, but it is not the main cause.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by nick_urban on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:27AM (#9002040)
The naturalistic fallacy is not the idea that "natural things are better". It is a criticism of deriving ethical principals from natural/physical facts.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by dreamweapon on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:03AM (#8997112)
There are also natural ways to keep your own T level high, like healthy food

Specifics? Evidence?

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by woofyman on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:29AM (#8997322)
Zinc, magnesium and vitamin D are essential for the production of testosterone.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by repsilat on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @10:44AM (#8997441)
The fact that they're necessary conditions for its production doesn't mean they're sufficient, though. It doesn't follow that you can just take a vitamin pill and get some sunlight and you'll naturally have high levels of testosterone.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by cgh on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @12:23PM (#8998124)
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21154195

The evidence is strongly suggestive that vitamin D supplementation has an effect on testosterone levels in men.

On a purely anecdotal, personal level, I had my free test checked some years back, before I started vitamin D supplementation. After supplementing with 10,000 IUs a day for around a year, I had it checked again and it was significantly higher (I don't have the numbers now, sorry).

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by igrekel on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:50PM (#9000886)
10 000 IU a day? Was that a typo? How did you got that target?

Just asking because I was considering 10 000 IU a week following my MDs advice (which is already higher than what it the normal off the shelf dose: 1000 IU a day).

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by vldx on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:13PM (#9001181)
I'm also taking 10,000 UI daily. Anything below 20,000 UI daily is fine and non-toxic. References - pubmed.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by kangax on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:09AM (#9002797)
Although safe, according to current search, there's no benefits from supplementing 10,000 UI daily (2,000-5,000 being recommended dose) — http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+D/

This doesn't prove that 10,000 is unnecessary, but there's no proof that it's necessary either :) (or is there?)

On the other hand, just recently a Polish study showed 6,000 IU improving rowers metabolism and performance — http://suppversity.blogspot.com/2015/02/6000iuday-of-vitamin...

However, it's unclear if lower dose would lead to similar results or if this is due to any other factors.

Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by collyw on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:46AM (#8997841)
The original post describe a healthy lifestyle, not just eating a few vitamins, but exercise, sleep and others.
Re:Testosterone is the drug of the future by driverdan on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:38PM (#9000076)
If you're deficient you'll have lower test levels. That doesn't mean you can megadose vitamin D to get high test levels, just that if you don't have adequate supply you'll have lower than normal levels.