News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by engendered on Saturday January 31, 2015 @01:48PM (#8977581)
The whole bit on loss aversion (which is a tactic to undermine people's opinions by ascribing them to unproductive emotional reactions, rather than objective evaluations that have people liking Windows 8 less than 7), and then the "I don’t really see anything positive about going back to an interaction design originally devised in 1995", undermine the piece and do make it seem more like a rant than an unbiased evaluation: Someone with a touch screen tablet likes Windows 8, and doesn't like some of the changes in Windows 10. Welcome to the party the rest of us have lived in.

Windows 8 on the desktop was objectively terrible. The charm bar, the weird interactions, the gigantic click points that completely undermined the benefit of a highly precise mouse. It was a step backwards as Microsoft tried to force touch metaphors and designs on a mouse world. Now this user is complaining that they're forcing mouse metaphors on his tablet.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by Mikeb85 on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:08PM (#8977650)
> Windows 8 on the desktop was objectively terrible.

Not a chance. IMO, not only was the the best Windows from a technical perspective, I quite liked the interface. I use Linux mostly for philosophical and technical reasons (much easier to program in Linux), but Windows 8 has great UI.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by Springtime on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:22PM (#8977702)
I could go on about the things I strongly disliked (hated, frankly) about the changes to the desktop after I first installed 8.1. An enormous amount of customization was removed from the Appearance and general UI, the ability to change File Type icons and add custom context menu commands was removed [1], the Ribbon UI is the standard File Explorer toolbar and unchangeable without additional hacks [2], and more.

They dumbed down the desktop from a customization perspective and it was most annoying, and that's before the removal of the Start menu and addition of hotcorners and other Metro/Modern features.

[1] See Types for a tool that brings this feature back: http://izt.name/apps/types/

[2] OldNewExplorer for a regular toolbar: http://www.msfn.org/board/topic/170375-oldnewexplorer-make-y...

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by guard-of-terra on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:18PM (#8977686)
Wi-fi connection dialog painting over keyboard layout indicator immediately disqualifies UI from 'great'. Great UIs are not like this. Maybe it's novel, an eye candy, but not great.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by jqm on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:21PM (#8977698)
I wouldn't even say eye candy. More like eye abuse.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by con-templative on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:49PM (#8977827)
> Windows 8 has great UI.

This usability expert disagrees, and explains his position in detail: http://www.nngroup.com/articles/windows-8-disappointing-usab...

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wfunction on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:18PM (#8977684)
No, it was terrible, unless you installed a classic shell.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by arthurfm on Saturday January 31, 2015 @07:32PM (#8978621)
I wouldn't go that far. I manage perfectly fine without it.

I like the fact that the Start Screen makes full use of my 27" 2560 x 1440 LCD. With the Windows 7-style Start Menu all of your shortcuts are shoved into a tiny corner of the screen.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wfunction on Saturday January 31, 2015 @08:19PM (#8978764)
Or you can look at it another way: I can comfortably fit more on my 1600x900 monitor with Classic Shell's start menu than you would on you 2560x1440 LCD with the Windows 8 start screen.

In other words, it's both modal and it wastes real screen estate.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by arthurfm on Saturday January 31, 2015 @10:01PM (#8979006)
> In other words, it's both modal and it wastes real screen estate.

The Windows 7-style Start Menu is modal too in the sense that you can't interact with the desktop at the same time you are interacting with the Start Menu.

The other thing I don't particularly like about the Start Menu is that shortcuts and folders with long names get cut off due to the width of the menu itself.

Screens are a bit like RAM in my opinion. There to be used.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wfunction on Sunday February 01, 2015 @12:36AM (#8979273)
> The Windows 7-style Start Menu is modal too in the sense that you can't interact with the desktop at the same time you are interacting with the Start Menu.

Huh? If you define it that way then everything is modal because you can only ever interact with one window at a given time (one mouse, one keyboard, etc.)

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by AndrewDucker on Sunday February 01, 2015 @09:19AM (#8979911)
No, Windows 7 Start Menu is different.

If I open it, start typing, and switch to a different window, then it loses all of its state, and has to restart from scratch if I go back to it.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by mSparks on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:21PM (#8977699)
+1 on the classic shell.

Totally unusable without it.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by LukasMathis on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:32PM (#8977739)
I like Windows 8 on the desktop. I agree that it has issues, but I also point that out in the article.

As for "undermining people's opinions": while I have no doubt that there are plenty of people who genuinely gave Windows 8 a chance, and found it severely wanting, I think it's fair to say that there are at least as many who never did, and just joined in on the bashing. Personally, I've seen a number of people who made jokes about Windows 8, but changed their opinions once they actually saw it on my Surface. It's a bit like Windows Vista, which people suddenly quite liked, once it was renamed to Windows 7 :-)

The actual point of the loss aversion thing, though, was to point out how Microsoft failed when it introduced Windows 8. I write this blog for designers, and learning from other people's mistakes is one reason why I write it. Loss aversion is an important concept in design; a conclusion to draw from this is that design changes should occur gradually, and not be forced upon people with a single, sweeping change.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by chrismcb on Sunday February 01, 2015 @07:03AM (#8979697)
Windows 8 is horrible on the desktop, I think you even mention this. But then you ignore that and talk about how great it is on the surface. You talked about loss aversion, but I don't see how you tied that in to the windows design. I thought you were going to discuss things that were removed from win 7, like the start button. But it just seems like the topic of loss aversion was another article that you included in this one. The real issue is trying to resolve both a touch screen environment with a keyboard and mouse environment. Win 8 is the former, with win 7 the latter. I don't know much about 10 but it seems to be more of a mouse and keyboard and less of a touch.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by bjmarte on Tuesday February 03, 2015 @01:07PM (#8991957)
He ignores it because it is tangential to the point. The point is that windows 8 (or at least 8.1 imho) had a great ui for a touch interface and there is no reason to destroy that while trying to fix the desktop experience.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by stcredzero on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:42PM (#8977785)
> The whole bit on loss aversion (which is a tactic to undermine people's opinions by ascribing them to unproductive emotional reactions, rather than objective evaluations that have people liking Windows 8 less than 7)

I am writing this on a recently purchased Windows 7 Lenovo x220 convertible tablet with a Wacom stylus and a multi-touch screen. (Primarily to use it as a poor man's Cintiq.) With only a few specific failings, Windows 7 seems to be a great OS for such a device. One of the big failings is requiring the user to keep precise track of window focus. The other one is rejection of finger input in contexts where everything but the stylus should be ignored except certain specific exceptions. I've used an AutoHotKey script to compensate for the latter. Other than these (very glaring) few points and others, I think Windows 7 does a very good job of capitalizing on the strengths of the input devices and form factor. I can transition between laptop/workstation, touch-tablet, and Wacom stylus type inputs to best suit the particular context I am working in with reasonable rapidity. As a workman's toolbox, this thing is pretty awesome!

Comparing this to the mess that's Windows 8, it's clear that Microsoft lost a cohesive overall vision for how everything should work together. It's also clear from the glaring problems that they never quite had a cohesive overall vision firmly guiding the whole product in the first place.

A consumer-oriented tablet and a kitchen-sink/swiss-army knife device for coders/creatives are two very different kinds of devices. It's just not clear thinking to try and mix the two. (OS X seems to be facing a similar dilemma.)

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by higherpurpose on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:51PM (#8977835)
And he's probably right. The issue remains that Microsoft is trying to mash two radically different usage paradigms into one.

So the obvious outcome (perhaps not to Microsoft) is that either the desktop mode will get worse, as it tries to get more "tablet-y" or the tablet mode gets worse as it tries to get more "desktop-y" - or both.

The author does say something with which I disagree. He says something along the lines "Windows 8 was the simplest desktop OS". Not it wasn't. Windows 8 - the desktop part - was probably made worse by the removal of the Start Menu, but not better. The Metro part is not "desktop". That's for tablets. So he can't say "the simplest desktop OS", because the whole Metro paradigm was intended for tablets, and it was much worse than the desktop paradigm on the desktop.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by sliverstorm on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:17PM (#8977678)
... a tactic to undermine people's opinions by ascribing them to unproductive emotional reactions, rather than objective evaluations...

Isn't "liking" Windows 8 less than Windows 7 an emotional reaction?

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by divegeek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:37PM (#8977757)
I like a $20 bill more than a $10 bill. Is that an emotional reaction? No, it's an objective value judgement based on the fact that the former is more useful (roughly twice as useful) as the latter. The word "like" merely expresses preference. It's neutral as to the basis of the preference, which may be emotional, rational or some combination.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by skynetv2 on Saturday January 31, 2015 @04:18PM (#8978124)
> Windows 8 on the desktop was objectively terrible.

spot on and I always thought it will work well on a touch screen tablet.So I got a Windows tablet and boy! was I wrong!!

Its terrible on a tablet too.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by izacus on Saturday January 31, 2015 @01:59PM (#8977622)
I think you entirely missed the viewpoint of the author: He's trying to use Windows 10 as a tablet OS not as a desktop OS and from that perspective they threw away everything that made Windows UX on tablets good to reintroduce all the hideous cluttered desktop patterns.

They just basically reinvented an ugly version of Windows 7 while throwing away what made Windows 8 a genuinely good OS on tablets - essentially instead of separating the desktop and tablet experience they went back to pushing desktop UI on tablet users.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by engendered on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:11PM (#8977661)
I think you entirely missed the viewpoint of the author

When people say that someone missed the point on HN, most of the time that means that they want you to read it the way they read it, and ignore those annoying bits that say something different.

Only this author not only undermines any disagreement with Windows 8 (just loss aversion), criticizes "old" interfaces (cars had 4 wheels in the 20s....give me my new style 3 wheel car), they specifically hold up its advantages on the desktop.

Not once do they mention the obvious solution -- that Microsoft should have gone separate directions on the desktop and the tablet -- but instead hold this as a cowardly backtrack.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by izacus on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:20PM (#8977690)
> When people say that someone missed the point on HN, most of the time that means that they want you to read it the way they read it, and ignore those annoying bits that say something different.

Hmm, you're commenting from entirely desktop machine perspective. He's talking only about tablet use perspective. I would say those are totally different viewpoints and more importantly, usage patterns?

>Only this author not only undermines any disagreement with Windows 8 (just loss aversion), criticizes "old" interfaces (cars had 4 wheels in the 20s....give me my new style 3 wheel car), they specifically hold up its advantages on the desktop.

I think saying that those interface elements are objectively bad on tablets is not far from truth, so again, see my first point.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by LukasMathis on Saturday January 31, 2015 @03:09PM (#8977900)
I specifically point out in the article that it is not just loss aversion, but that there are valid reasons to dislike Windows 8.

I also don't criticize old interfaces because they are old. I specifically point out that the desktop metaphor was created for use cases that are very different from how we use computers nowadays. Desktops are not problematic because they're old, but because what we use desktop PCs for has changed a lot.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by ptx on Saturday January 31, 2015 @05:00PM (#8978254)
> I specifically point out that the desktop metaphor was created for use cases that are very different from how we use computers nowadays. Desktops are not problematic because they're old, but because what we use desktop PCs for has changed a lot.

Are you referring to the "launching applications and managing files are two different things" part?

Another explanation for the move to applications like iTunes that manage files outside the file manager could be that Microsoft's particular file manager is just terrible and unusable. (As is Apple's modern incarnation of the Finder, in mostly the same way – see Siracusa's explanation[1] for details.)

In OS/2's Workplace Shell, applications and files were just two among many of the kinds of objects you could manipulate. For instance, you could drag a document to a printer to print it, or to the shredder to delete it. You could drag template objects to create new files. You could drag colors to windows to assign that color to the window. (Some of these things are possible in Windows as well, but it's not emphasized and doesn't work as well.)

In BeOS, the Tracker, thanks to its support for arbitrary file metadata, could integrate with a mail or music application and allow you to manage its object hierarchy exactly the same way you managed your other files.

So, in my opinion, the old interface was just a half-assed implementation of a basically good idea. The new idea is to give up, throwing away the simplicity and flexibility of the old design, and reimplement file management in every application.

[1] http://arstechnica.com/apple/2003/04/finder/

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by darklajid on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:04PM (#8977640)
> Windows 8 on the desktop was objectively terrible.

No, it wasn't. It isn't.

(I liked the improvements in 8.1 but that blanket statement from you is false)

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by zamalek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:12PM (#8977665)
> No, it wasn't. It isn't.

Disclaimer: Emphasis on SUBJECTIVE before you indicate my opinion is wrong because you have a different opinion. That's pretty-much what subjective means. I thought HN was smarter than this.

Agreed, it's subjective. This is change aversion, not loss aversion. Humans don't like change, even if it is good for them.

People don't like Windows 8 UI because it was a change, and they don't like that they are changing it back. The Windows 8 interface was scientifically superior[1] to the old one: people just didn't like the change. The Windows 10 one is closer to the older interface, people just don't like it because it's change.

The big interaction areas (including the infinite one at the bottom left for the start menu) provided good mouse control. People would have found the keyboard control far superior if they had taken the 10 minutes to learn it, instead of complaining.

Something is not "objectively terrible" if at least one person like it and, including myself, I know people who like the Win8 interface. I haven't tried Win10 yet but I'll probably like the interface because Microsoft are terrific at interface design.

The only thing that Microsoft get wrong is that people don't like their cheese being moved. The Windows 7 interface was good, the Windows 8 interface was good and so will be the Windows 10.

The very reason that people praise Apple interface design is because they keep feeding you the same junk over and over again and you all love it, the innovation there is that innovation is avoided in order to not rile up change aversion.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitts%27s_law

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wvenable on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:18PM (#8977681)
> People don't like Windows 8 UI because it was a change, and they don't like that they are changing it back.

No, people don't like the Windows 8 UI because it's terrible on the desktop. Comparatively, the classic Windows UI is terrible on touch-screen devices. Even combining both interfaces on one OS isn't terrible. But in Windows 8 they both bleed into each other in a way that is not good. Windows 10 combines them even more but I'll reserve judgement until I've tried it.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by ubercow13 on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:25PM (#8977711)
I only use W8 on the desktop, but how does Metro bleed into the desktop experience? The only part of it I ever see is the start screen, which is great
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wvenable on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:30PM (#8977730)
The charms bar, hot corners, the Wifi setup panel, the login screen, the start screen, the associated app selector, the metro apps with associations to common file types, etc. I've personally turned off most of it and replaced the start menu with ClassicShell but it took a while. It's a pretty nice OS if you can completely hide metro.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by zamalek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:43PM (#8977791)
> hot corners

I hate that too. Disabled it. That's my opinion of the feature. However, that in addition to:

> charms bar

(Which I never use) is technically good UX design. Corners are super easy to position your mouse in. 100 out of 100 times you try and put your mouse cursor into the corner you will achieve that without fail. Both corner gestures (really hate them) and charms bar use that extensively.

> Wifi setup panel, login screen

Never had a problem with these, they do the job just fine. Just different. The Wifi panel is actually great UX because the process of setting up Wifi does not bounce all over the screen (as it did previously).

> start screen

Fitt's Law, look it up. If you don't like using the mouse you don't even have click anyway. WINKEY -> N -> O -> T, oh, notepad is up, ENTER. Done. Windows 8 taught me to let go of my mouse.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wvenable on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:51PM (#8977833)
> (Which I never use) is technically good UX design. Corners are super easy to position your mouse in.

I have 2 24" monitors, 3840x1080 pixels. The corners are actually pretty far from where ever my mouse is right now, and not all that easy to hit on purpose. Accidentally, all the time. With a touchpad it's even worse -- they were always being activated when I didn't want them to be. And there is literally nothing in that bar I need to use.

> The Wifi panel is actually great UX because the process of setting up Wifi does not bounce all over the screen (as it did previously).

It's an overlay which means it floats over your work while you're waiting for the Wifi connection to fail. It's just entirely unnecessary UI which doesn't fit in with anything else on the desktop.

> Fitt's Law, look it up.

Fitt's law is frankly bullshit these days. I have way too many pixels for it to make sense and I've had 20+ years of using a mouse.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by ubercow13 on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:31PM (#8977733)
Ah you're right I forgot about the metro app association dialog, that is really jarring
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by seanmcdirmid on Saturday January 31, 2015 @07:48PM (#8978669)
I use Windows 8 and it is not objectively terrible, it is actually quite OK and doesn't result in any loss of productivity for myself.

There is the whole whole screen start menu thing, but I wasn't a big start menu user in Windows 7, and I barely notice. I don't find Metro to be very useful for me, and I don't go there often, but it doesn't really bleed into the desktop so whatever.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by zamalek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:32PM (#8977737)
> because it's terrible on the desktop.

That is your opinion, as I said:

subjective

Your opinion is not the only correct one, although it is the more typical reaction to change. Any alternative change would have likely caused this exact same fallout.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by Amezarak on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:40PM (#8977775)
> No, people don't like the Windows 8 UI because it's terrible on the desktop.

I use Windows 8.1 on the desktop every day - since Windows 8 was released - and I honestly can't understand why people have such huge problems with it unless it is just about change.

I had my first impressions of it in a VM when it was RTM. At that time I did think it was pretty ugly and I got really frustrated (i.e., I was cussing up a storm) trying to figure out how to shut it down properly via the UI - in the RTM release I believe the only way to do that was to use the Charms bar, and I had to Google to figure that out. I also did not have any particular fondness for the Metro apps.

Sometime later I made it the primary OS on my laptop - which, as I purchased it in 2006, is non-touch. I use an external mouse instead of a touchpad because I hate touchpads, full-stop. And I'd say that in my opinion, Windows 8 is definitely the best Windows for desktop. The one major complaint I had, about shutdowns, was resolved by having a power button on the Start Screen, and additionally adding a context menu to the Start button on the taskbar that gives you quick access to shutdown options.

Almost everything in Windows 8 works the same. For example, I see frequent complaints about how terrible the Start Screen is for desktop users. I don't think it's very pretty, but it works almost exactly the same as the old start menu. The primary difference is that it takes up the full screen, which I don't think is too terribly a big deal since the Start Menu goes away if you take away focus anyway. Opening applications works the same way as it has since Vista: hit winkey, type the first few letters of the application, hit enter. Alternatively, click on the start button, click on the application (if pinned) or click on All Programs to scroll through all your applications. This is moderately improved in Win 8 since you can change what your programs are sorted by, unlike Win 7 (for example: Most Used, Most Recently installed, etc.)

I am not a big fan of the Metro apps, but they do now show up on the taskbar, they do have a titlebar with a close and minimize button, and you can sort-of resize them. The only one I use is Weather. By default (and maybe this has changed since I installed it), Windows does have Metro apps set to open your pictures, etc. The default app setting is easy to change, though I can't imagine many new users expecting or wanting the new Metro apps. The only one I had to change was changing images to open in Windows Photo Viewer; the rest was "fixed" by installing my usual apps (VLC, Firefox, etc.)

Other than that, there are plenty of desktop-centric improvements. Multi-monitor support is much better. There is a fantastic context menu on the Start button with quick access to various administrative functions. Various things throughout the desktop OS get slight improvements; the file copy dialog is better, task manager is better, Windows Explorer is better. For the most part, the average desktop user is almost never even going to see the Metro interface. And I have never, ever touched the Charms bar, ever since that virtual machine. It's totally unnecessary for a desktop workflow. Which I suppose could be a complaint in itself.

The only real regression I see is that the Windows 8 file search kind of blows. It works as well as Windows 7 if you know what you're looking for - hit Windows key, type part of the file name, hit enter - but for any kind of advanced search you have to open up Windows Explorer and do it from there. The Start Screen is also missing the recently-opened files list on the Windows 7 start menu - you have to pin to the taskbar to get the same effect.

Can you go into more exactly why it's terrible on desktop? Is it just you think tiles waste space, the clash between Metro/desktop is kind of jarring, that kind of thing?

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by wvenable on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:47PM (#8977815)
> I use Windows 8.1 on the desktop every day

I also use Windows 8.1 everyday, I'm typing this message on it.

> Almost everything in Windows 8 works the same. For example, I see frequent complaints about how terrible the Start Screen is for desktop users. I don't think it's very pretty, but it works almost exactly the same as the old start menu.

My father-in-law somehow figured out he could launch applications by going into Program Files folder in explorer and running programs from there. He did that because he could not figure out how to find stuff on the start screen. I was impressed with his ingenuity; I just replaced the start screen with ClassicShell. I don't have any metro apps, I have 2 24" monitors, so the start screen is ridiculous.

> Other than that, there are plenty of desktop-centric improvements.

I agree. Those could have all been in Windows 7.1 though.

> For the most part, the average desktop user is almost never even going to see the Metro interface.

Except for the charms bar, hot corners, the Wifi setup panel, the login screen, the start screen, the associated app selector, the metro apps with associations to common file types, etc.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by agersant on Sunday February 01, 2015 @04:03AM (#8979518)
> There is a fantastic context menu on the Start button with quick access to various administrative functions.

Never heard about this one before, thanks for the tip!

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by darklajid on Sunday February 01, 2015 @12:46PM (#8980839)
Never tried that, but I'd guess that is what Win+x pops up? If you don't use that so far, it's quite useful.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by isnotchicago on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:32PM (#8977736)
There is a lot more to good design than big click targets. Even infinitely large targets are useless if the user does not know where they are.
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by zamalek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:48PM (#8977818)
> Even infinitely large targets are useless if the user does not know where they are.

That I can completely agree with. The tutorial that they introduced helps, but I think something (not sure what) would have helped.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by higherpurpose on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:55PM (#8977844)
You can't just say "Not it wasn't". You have to elaborate. That's why you got attacked, not because your opinion was "subjective".
Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by engendered on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:39PM (#8977769)
Emphasis on SUBJECTIVE before you indicate my opinion is wrong because you have a different opinion. That's pretty-much what subjective means. I thought HN was smarter than this.

Yet you spent your entire post claiming that the interface is objectively better. But people don't like it because it was change, it is "scientifically superior" (as if an interface is quantified only by the size of click targets), people just needed to learn it, people don't like their cheese being moved.

Coach your post in the disclaimer, but every other word you wrote was absolutely in conflict with that.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by zamalek on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:52PM (#8977837)
> every other word you wrote was absolutely in conflict with that.

1. People don't like it likely due to change aversion. 2. In theory it's superior. 3. It can't be "objectively terrible" if some people like it. 4. All UIs from all version of Windows are great (opinion).

How did I contradict myself? Either way this is turning into an argument which I'm not interesting in doing. If I contradicted myself, so be it.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by engendered on Saturday January 31, 2015 @02:06PM (#8977644)
Yes. It was. It is. This disagreement by you is false.

See, we can both do that. Fun.

However in my case I'm supported by this very development, where Microsoft is essentially backtracking based upon enormous customer resistance and a backlash.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by darklajid on Sunday February 01, 2015 @10:39AM (#8980226)
And the article we're looking at here is complaining about moving away from the Windows 8 direction.

The author seems to consider that a mistake and likes the Windows 8 way better. So do I. This is all subjective, just like your statements are. You just claim to speak for everyone/state facts. That's still wrong, ignoring that childish retort.

Re:Windows 10: Re-Crappifying Windows 8 by throwawaykf05 on Saturday January 31, 2015 @05:14PM (#8978299)
>Yes. It was. It is. This disagreement by you is false.

> See, we can both do that. Fun.

Which immediately disproves your original assertion that the Windows 8 on the desktop was objectively terrible. That was just, like, your opinion, man.