News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by panarky on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:35PM (#8951262)
How can Zuckerberg say "Je Suis Charlie", and then censor the very kind of content that Charlie Hebdo published?

https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10101844454210771

If you take the position that it's necessary to build censorship machinery into Facebook, then say that.

But when you build tools that enable surveillance and repression, and when you collaborate with autocratic regimes to limit free expression, you can no longer claim "I am Charlie".

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by prawn on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:43PM (#8951285)
In the post you linked, he specifically says:

"We follow the laws in each country, but we never let one country or group of people dictate what people can share across the world."

And in the submitted link:

"The company acted to comply with an order from a Turkish court..."

They're blocking access to the material from users in Turkey.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by jessaustin on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:58PM (#8951311)
No one is surprised when corporate reptiles act like corporate reptiles. The remarkable circumstance is that they act like themselves, but talk as if they are courageous paragons of the Enlightenment. The complaint is not that Zuck attempts to maximize revenue from the Turkish user base, but that he simultaneously highlights a conflicting "commitment" to free expression. The net impression is one of an odd, misplaced pride in a complete surrender of ethics to pragmatism.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by pdabbadabba on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:07AM (#8960593)
I don't think it's right that only "corporate reptiles" should bother to comply with the laws of the countries in which they operate.

Your position seems to be that the only moral thing to do in the face of an ethical commitment that conflicts with a legal commitment, is to either disregard the legal commitment or realign your business so you are not subject to it. But, when the conflict is sufficiently limited (see below), and dodging the legal obligation would also compromise your ethical commitment, what's wrong with, say, complying with the legal commitments while agitating to have it changed?

Is it your view that the people of Turkey would be better off, from a free expression perspective, with no Facebook at all than with a Facebook that obeys domestic laws requiring it to remove a very limited amount of content? The situation might be different if we were talking about a government that required Facebook to drastically and systematically distort the discourse on its service (as in China, by many accounts). But here we're just talking about removing a few imagines deemed to be highly offensive to the dominant religion.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by jessaustin on Monday February 02, 2015 @12:06AM (#8982806)
Zuck is the one claiming to value the dissemination of various images of Mohammed, by parroting that slogan. It isn't a stretch to find his simultaneous censoring of such images to contradict that claim. If all he cared to do was lament violence, he could have said something inoffensive like "why can't we all just get along?" That's not what he said.

The "people of Turkey", like all people, would be better off if they valued free speech more than religious sensibilities. Eventually they will, but that's probably a few decades off, and at any rate it's unlikely to be the result of "agitation" by a rich Western asshole like Zuck, or the judgment of assholes like us on HN. In the meantime, I find public dishonesty unethical. If Zuck felt that way, perhaps he'd stop advocating this position while simultaneously working against it.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by santacluster on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @03:02AM (#8951961)
> we never let one country or group of people dictate what people can share across the world

That's even more hypocritical, given that Facebook itself enforces its own prudish values on the rest of the world by systematically censoring harmless and completely legal content because "omg, boobies!".

Zuckerberg saying "Je suis Charlie" makes me want to throw up. If there is one other force besides reactionary muslims that has a chilling effect on the freedom of expression and liberal values in progressive Western countries, it's the dominance of reactionary American tech companies like Facebook.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by adamnemecek on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @12:39AM (#8951413)
> How can Zuckerberg say "Je Suis Charlie", and then censor the very kind of content that Charlie Hebdo published?

Oh that's easy when you become a hypocrite.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by conradfr on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @08:13AM (#8952830)
> How can Zuckerberg say "Je Suis Charlie", and then censor the very kind of content that Charlie Hebdo published?

Did you see which politicians and world leaders where at the Je Suis Charlie march ?

Did you see what laws are currently passed in France in response to the killings ?

It's just posture and hypocrisy.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by nothrabannosir on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:11AM (#8953060)
Yes, that's why he's calling it out. What's your point? Should we not care about this case, because others are abusing it as well? Two wrongs don't make a right. Two hundred wrongs neither.

It sounds trite, but you're changing the subject. And when every post like OP's has a reply of the tone "Pff why do you even bother naming and shaming one guy who did wrong; don't you know everybody's making a farce of Je Suis Charlie?", it conveys hopelessness. It's demoralizing and it's a conversation killer.

We get it. Every politician is a hypocrite. Okay. Can we stop using it as a condescending dismissal of valid points, now, please?

I, for one, would love to know more about the specific details of Zuckerberg's alleged hypocrisy, so I can judge for myself.

Edit: ps: Upvoted you because I agree. I just want to highlight that your post should not be taken as a rebuttal against OP.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by conradfr on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @04:40AM (#8958940)
I didn't want to call OP out, I was just surprised that he was himself surprised by the dichotomy between Zuckerberg public stance and Facebook actions.

And yes I'm glad this kind of behavior is exposed but I also don't expect companies to be freedom warriors.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by panarky on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @09:15AM (#8953077)
That's right. Leaders who impose draconian censorship on their own populations and throw journalists in jail are literally leading the parade for free expression.

Leaders like Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry, Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu and Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov.

So add Zuckerberg to this ignominious list. He collaborates with these regimes to repress their citizens, then sanctimoniously shouts "I am Charlie" from the world's biggest megaphone.

Makes me physically sick.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by opt1k on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:22AM (#8960258)
Not letting a country 'bully' or dictate a site like Facebook is one thing but a valid legal request that has been granted by a court in a given country is something completely different.

People seem to think that Facebook is doing this just to bow to pressure from certain groups but in reality it is just that they have been legally instructed to do so, if they were to fail to do this then access to Facebook would likely be severed by the Turkish ISP's under another legal order.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by 100timesthis on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:40AM (#8960380)
Facebook doesn't have phisical presence[1] on turkey, so why do they obey Turkeys laws?

[1]https://www.facebook.com/careers#locations

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by pdabbadabba on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:01AM (#8960538)
Because they provide a service in Turkey and would like to continue signing up Turkish users. The internet, as you have observed, certainly does present interesting legal and, in particular, jurisdictional conundrums. But, for better or worse, it is well established that you do not need a physical pretense in a country to be bound by their laws.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by 100timesthis on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:24AM (#8960730)
as I am not in turkey and the content is not illegal in my country why do I have to receive the censorship as well?

[EDIT] If facebook is advocating the freedom of speech I would expect that they would show the content at least to the users that are not under censorship.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by pdabbadabba on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:33AM (#8960795)
I think this is a fair question, though it has little to do with the jurisdiction of Turkish courts. There are two very different possible answers: it could be that the Turkish order requires photos to be removed, not just hidden from Turkish users or it could be that Facebook isn't set up to hide content in some regions and not others -- censoring the images in only a few jurisdictions would take work.

If it's the former, I think there's no sense in being annoyed with Facebook. We should direct our ire at the Turkish court. If it's the latter, though, perhaps people are right to call Facebook out for not making this happen.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by nailer on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:28AM (#8960305)
I think we understand that FB access would be denied in Turkey if they didn't remove the posts. We simply disagree that this is reasonable justification for removing the posts.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by _almosnow on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:23AM (#8960266)
>How can Zuckerberg say "Je Suis Charlie", and then censor the very kind of content that Charlie Hebdo published?

Because PR.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by nashashmi on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @01:54AM (#8951721)
Zuck does not use his medium to spread anti-Islamic content. Charlie Hebdo did.

Here what Zuck did was uphold a nation's choice to block content in that country that did not conform to the views of that country. It has NOTHING to do with Charlie Hebdo.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by cbd1984 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:07AM (#8951800)
> Here what Zuck did was uphold a nation's choice to block content in that country that did not conform to the views of that country.

It isn't the nation's choice, it's the government's choice. It's a political decision to support the policies of the Turkish government.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by nashashmi on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:11AM (#8960192)
If the government was chosen by the people (as is in the case of Turkey), it is the nation's choice. Otherwise, there is little indication that the people of the nation choose different.

And it is not a political decision as the verdict came from the courts.

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by TelmoMenezes on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @05:50AM (#8952396)
If a "nation's choice" is over what individuals are allowed to see and read, isn't that just an euphemism for fascism?

What possible ethical principle could lead someone to assume that the collective has the right to decide what an individual can read?

Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by kyleblarson on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:27AM (#8960291)
The 'organized ignorance' that is religion is exactly the principle you speak of.
Re:Facebook Said to Block Pages Critical of Muhammad to Avoi... by Squarel on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:18AM (#8960240)
I am not sure, what possible ethical principle leads people to censor words and pictures which they deem unsuitable in any nation?