That means 300,000,000 Americans (and billions of foreigners) are having their rights violated and wallets emptied via taxation every day to save 5400 lives over the course of 14 years.
Admittedly, it's 55% more likely than getting struck by lightning, but...
And that's probably still a vast overstatement of the likely fatalities for any given plot, given that 2103 of the 2381 recorded by the GTD have 0 fatalities.
[1] http://www.start.umd.edu/gtd/search/Results.aspx?chart=fatal...
That's my assumption though and it could be completely off base.
For example, some estimates of the cost of 9/11 (I think including the costs of Iraq and Afghanistan) suggest that each American is out to the tune of $10,000 [0]. If the NSA were able to prevent one 9/11 style event, they'd in one step justify their budget for 300 years (if you ignore Iraq and Afghanistan, it goes down to 75 years, but in many ways at least Afghanistan was very much caused by 9/11).
[0] - http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011/09/08/us/sept-11-rec...
As other commenters pointed out, it's only efficient at disrupting a nation if the nation itself decides to disrupt itself.
The right way to react to a terrorist attack is to ignore it. Simple as that. You chase the perpetrators like ordinary members of an organized crime group. Anything above that is achieving the terrorists' plan.
All the money America spends on "War on Terror", including NSA, is actually the cost of 9/11. If the US wanted to really effectively prevent further terrorist attacks, it would defund the NSA. Right now all that counterterrorism measures are only actively inviting further attacks - everyone can see that it takes only a bunch of civilian casualties to make the nation go completely nuts and drive itself to destruction.
And to say that Afghanistan was caused by 9/11 is a total reversal of what actually happened, 9/11 happened because of CIA involvement in Afghanistan.
To your second point, it's clearly a very complicated blame game, but trying to distill it down to fit your own point is not helpful. We can easily follow the chain of events backwards - for example had the USSR not invaded Afghanistan, this might have all been avoided.
Certainly the trigger point was the Taliban refusing to hand over Bin Laden, thus providing a safe haven for him and other like minded folk.
This all seems to be besides my original point, which was that terror attacks clearly cost far more than the lives of the people killed, and so arguing that the benefit of the NSA is minimal by considering only a tiny fragment of its potential benefit is fallacious.
It's indeed fallacious because there is no benefit of the NSA at all - its current activities are the very cost of 9/11 attacks. Civilian deaths are not the goal of a terror attack, they're just collateral damage, means to an end. The goal of an attack is to, as you wrote, "disrupt a nation" - which is not something that the bombs do, it's something that the nation does to itself by having a crazy overreaction.
I hope you realize that this means the spending on it is quite high, indeed.
The reason Osama bin Laden wore that united states military jacket is because it was given to him during the CIA armament of the afghanis against the russians...
Only if a nation builds a domestic spy program, and intrusive and expensive domestic security apparatus, and starts multi-trillion dollar wars in places that say Graveyard of Empires right on the label. Who would be such idiots?
But they're unlikely because the Norwegians kept their heads cool, didn't turn him into a martyr but showed him for what he is, a deranged sociopath.
edit: it's occurred to me there's a huge flaw in this claim:
Preventing the cowardly, panicked response
isn't the NSA's department.
The NSA has lied about the effectiveness of its mass data collection, claiming that it foiled terrorist plots. The claims don't actually hold up under investigation.But in the process of exaggerating the effectiveness of this particular alleged solution to terrorist danger, they also exaggerated the pervasiveness of that danger, which probably did make the panicked, cowardly response in question both more panicked and more cowardly.
How many people could have been saved from heart disease with the same amount of money?
If petrol usage efficiency in the US went up by 10% for example (should be easily achievable for not much cost), in principle the money saved overall would be over $10 billion in 2014.
That'd save a lot of lives, too.
You're right, though, the impact of each successive event is less.
I'm not saying that wasn't a bad play of words.
You may be willing to give up your liberty, but I, and many with me, are not. Terrorists are trolls; dear people of US and the world, please stop feeding them. The same goes for war mongers of all stripes.
I wonder if this concept of total information awareness justified by terrorism is in fact primarily a way to set up information warfare capabilities in a way that is palatable to the public. E.g. PRISM is a way to monitor network traffic globally, very useful in a war. NSA and the executive branch clearly believe they are doing something so righteous that it justifies excessive breaches of civil liberties, lying to congress, and more. While I strongly disagree with them, I am beginning to suspect that these are preparations for some kind of global cyber war. If the preparations are good, the executive branch would be convinced that history would vindicate them, otherwise I'm fairly sure without sufficient justification, historians would see this as a 1984 scenario and punish their legacies harshly.
[1] http://www.amazon.com/War-The-Rise-Military-Internet-Complex...
But instead of increasing security requirements or making software vendors somehow liable for bugs they produce, they're still going with lowest common denominator tactics for defense contract procurement.
Because of this, I have a hard time seeing this as preparing for cyber war in any way other than aggression tactics. I see little evidence of increased defense focus at home.
Fix a bug and keep the fix in reserve (to be applied via a latency-privilidged backdoor and/or traffic filter if a large-scale attack is detected) and you've parried the first blow in a cyberwar. This has the added advantage that you don't have to nag people to install the fix.
Declaring that software vendors are liable for these mistakes does a few things: 1) Requires that an explicit threat be identified to justify the economic hardship 2) Depending on how the policy is applied, can slow the development of the golden goose US internet industry 3) May not be that effective in actually closing security holes (hard to say) 4) May not be politically possible (hard to say). Additionally, in this framework, the executive branch would consider PRISM and related programs components of a national defense strategy that they can exert direct control over rather than relying on civilians.
I'm not completely sure of my theory. The world situation is complex and I think it's a little from column A and a little from column B (state aggression and terrorism respectively). However, assuming it's somewhat correct, the politicians have been trying to keep the heat down for obvious reasons (not causing a trade or actual war). South-east asia has been kind of uppity lately but there are plenty of other states to worry about as well.
You do see politicians talking about elements of cyber war in the news from time to time, but they rarely make it a centerpiece. I don't know if that's because it's not that consequential or because making it a huge issue is aggressive. Very often you see it reported that a high level US defense, state, or executive official, as part of a larger package of talks, speaks to heads of state or their generals about cyber war but the details of that are not disclosed. This makes it seem as though the issue is small as much more ink is spilled on the other parts of the talks. However, it's hard to know just how large a component it is. Could be huge, could be small.
My premise is in part based on the concept that administration officials are acutely aware that we're having an incredible peace dividend right now. Every time we have a war the public has to get invested in, it is insanely destructive. This is somewhat undercut by the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, but it's widely commented on how that although they cost over a trillion dollars and a scary number of lives on both sides, the public has been mostly disengaged and it's been basically peacetime over on US territory. That gives politicians freedom to basically do what they want without much pushback and without substantially hurting the economy.
If war spending is ~1.5T over 14 years (https://www.nationalpriorities.org/cost-of/) (~107B/yr), and the current US GDP is ~17.55T/yr (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_United_States) this amounts to 0.6% of US GDP (and shrinking). In comparison, US GDP growth ranges between -2% to 5% over the past 15 years and is more often positive (it was only negative during the sub-prime mortgage crisis years). A war with significant damage on the home front would not simply reduce growth, but could set us back decades in economic and human damage (drawing comparisons to the damage done to China, Europe, Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia, and Japan in 20th century, some of them have caught back up, but it took decades and they still are emotionally scarred over it). Fwiw, these numbers also emphasize how insanely mind bogglingly rich this country is.
Would a cyber war be damaging enough to force the sorts of measures NSA has implemented to be taken? Would cyber war effectively complement other kinds of tactics on the part of an aggressor? Overall, I'm not sure, but it seems plausible if you think a major act of aggression is likely. How likely is that right now? I don't know. I do know that over a long period of time (decades, a century), acts of war have historically been a near certainty though the particular actor is hard to foresee.
Of course, I'd like to reiterate that I'm still not convinced that these spying measures are required and it is very scary that such large scale changes to the nature of our communications have been done with little public debate. It's very anti-democratic in so many ways and I appreciate what Mr. Snowden has done for the public.
Gen. Keith Alexander said these programs enabled the United States to disrupt 54 "events," 42 of which "involved disrupted plots."
Of those 54:
12 involved cases of material support to terrorists; 50 lead to arrests or detentions; 25 occurred in Europe; 11 were in Asia; 5 were in Africa; 13 had a homeland nexus. Forty-one of the terrorist activities did not involve events in the United States, Alexander said.
Alexander went on to say that in 53 of the 54 cases, data collected under Section 702 provided the initial tip to "unravel the threat stream." He said that almost half of terrorist reporting comes from Section 702, ...
... and the associated infographic: [2]. Your own link states that the NSA claimed 42 plots and 12 instances of material support. Senator Leahy's quote speaks more to both the media game of telephone than the NSA's claims and the fact that the figures from the Section 215 program (bulk phone metadata) were being conflated with the Section 702 program (PRISM).
As a result, this article and a whole slew of other articles try to tie the 54 plots in with the Section 215 program, when right from the beginning General Alexander was stating that the overwhelming majority came from Section 702 collection. Draw what conclusion you may want from those numbers - three commissions have done so over the last year and concluded that PRISM was incredibly valuable[3], but the bulk phone records not so much[4][5] - but, that doesn't say much about the 54 number.
[1] http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/06/27/19175466-nsa-chie...
[2] http://www.propublica.org/documents/item/802269-untitled0001...
[3] http://www.pclob.gov/Library/702-Report-2.pdf
[4] http://www.pclob.gov/library/215-Report_on_the_Telephone_Rec...
[5] http://www.lawfareblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Final-...
But you're saying one unconstitutional, immoral, wasteful program has been deemed useful by a corrupt and inept body, and the other hasn't. That's a really great idea I'll consider carefully.
This group of political appointees presided over the genesis of the largest surveillance/propaganda program in the history of the world. Corrupt and inept seems fair.
That's the wrong date. Again, it doesn't seem you know anything about the PCLOB. Basic information is on Wikipedia, if you ever look.
Do you have any point besides making endless discursive asides about how much you simultaneously believe and disbelieve the PCLOB? I'm starting to think conversing with you is a complete waste of time.
First member was appointed in January 2008. Go reread it.
> Do you have any point besides making endless discursive asides ... I'm starting to think conversing with you is a complete waste of time.
My thoughts exactly - It's not worth my time conversing with someone whose argument is basically "No, you're wrong. You obviously don't know anything about the subject." It's been fun - I'm not going to waste any further time on this thread.
Formed in 2004, first meeting in March 2006 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privacy_and_Civil_Liberties_Ove...).
My point is that the government cannot be expected to competently judge itself. That is our task as citizens, if you want to use those reports as the basis of your ill-informed opinion, go ahead.
You'll note that I even "Draw what conclusion you may want from those numbers" in my original post. I offered those three reports because out of everything I've read on the subject, those were the most comprehensive. So far, you've offered a whole lot of ad hominem, a Wikipedia link and an argument that boils down to "it's a government agency, therefore corrupt and inept". If you're going to make a point, try backing it up with an actual argument and ditching the insults.
From Sen. Patrick Leahy, after reading the full classified list:
“We've heard over and over again the assertion that 54 terrorist plots were thwarted” by the two programs, Leahy told Alexander at the Judiciary Committee hearing this month. “That's plainly wrong, but we still get it in letters to members of Congress, we get it in statements. These weren't all plots and they weren't all thwarted. The American people are getting left with the inaccurate impression of the effectiveness of NSA programs.” (http://www.propublica.org/article/claim-on-attacks-thwarted-...)