News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by TeMPOraL on Monday January 19, 2015 @04:54PM (#8914359)
> and so arguing that the benefit of the NSA is minimal by considering only a tiny fragment of its potential benefit is fallacious.

It's indeed fallacious because there is no benefit of the NSA at all - its current activities are the very cost of 9/11 attacks. Civilian deaths are not the goal of a terror attack, they're just collateral damage, means to an end. The goal of an attack is to, as you wrote, "disrupt a nation" - which is not something that the bombs do, it's something that the nation does to itself by having a crazy overreaction.

Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by CHY872 on Monday January 19, 2015 @05:16PM (#8914472)
That only works if you assume that there's only ever one attack. If it thwarts another, then it's benefiting. In any case, I wouldn't really argue that the NSA 'disrupts' the nation at all - the spending on it is only a little larger than at the end of the cold war, and apart from the recent news stories only a very small minority will actually be affected by it in their daily lives.
Re:The Whole Haystack: The N.S.A. claims it needs access to ... by deciplex on Monday January 19, 2015 @09:56PM (#8915238)
>the spending on it is only a little larger than at the end of the cold war

I hope you realize that this means the spending on it is quite high, indeed.