Consultants are typically brought in to solve specific problems that are perceived to be high-value. If a company hires a consultant to sustainably reduce hosting costs by $15,000/month, a good consultant will probably have no problem pricing the engagement as a not insignificant percentage of the savings over a reasonable period of time. Good luck trying this as a rank-and-file employee. If you're that good and are serious about maximizing your earnings, become a consultant.
Your value to the company is how much it would cost, in time, effort, and money, to find a replacement(s).
That's the important component - the volatility of performance has a major impact on price of an option !
Let's imagine we are Board of BigCo. Our CEO just took home fifty mil for what is at best a lacklustre performance.
We could fire his ass, but who do we replace him with? We could get pretty much anyone here on HN to do the job, for just one tenth of the cost. But if we hire say that lifeisstillgood, the inevitable PR disasters will wipe more than fifty mil off our stock / revenue.
But if we hire (insert your name here), a clearly brilliant HN member, they will discover that being CEO of a major company means very little power or influence - these things are like oil tankers and do not turn for anything. So getting an even better CEO than our guy will not manage to bring in much upside.
So unless there is a massive upheaval in the market meaning plenty of opportunity, then replacing a CEO is always a bad idea - the downside is huge, the upside is minimal.
Maybe that's risk adjusted returns - but I prefer cynicism.
Some economist did a rather macabre study of share prices of companies as their CEO's died in various accidents. (Ie removal of the CEO controlled by factors outside corporate politics.)
The truth is that your employer doesn't consider your value as a major part of their compensation offer, they consider what would happen if you didn't exist. Is there or isn't there an endless ocean of other candidates who could more or less do what you do and do it for what they're willing to pay you and no what you're demanding?
In case you aren't sure what the answer is, there is.
Good STEM programmers (i.e. science companies) are very hard to find. The jobs aren't as abundant as web dev, but they are there, pay reasonably and it's easy to show how valuable you are to the company.
Yes, but the point is that if you want to make a good salary, that's the problem you need to fix. What is your approach when you encounter something that's "difficult or impossible" in your daily work? You apply intelligence and creativity and create a solution.
> The reality is [..] If you don't like that, time to go into management or sales.
Whatever you do, DO NOT try to change the rules. DO NOT try to learn what it is management and sales do to get those nice, big salaries. When something is hard, GIVE UP.
Of course you need to understand the employer's BATNA as well: If they don't appreciate tech, ie. their BATNA is to fire you/ignore you until you leave, then that's what you do. But companies can do that to their sales and management teams as well.
This is not a problem where you need precision, just a reasonable level of accuracy and a well-presented argument.
I can figure out which algebra to use and what light research to perform... but may you please educate me on these "Fermi estimates" regarding salary negotiation?
These two things can be precisely measured, provided you have the traffic. And you should be measuring them anyway, because that slick UI might be hurting things.
A/B test all the things. Then you'll know both your value, and whether any specific improvement you made is worthwhile.
you're right, pay is basically what your peers make +/-
So if you are in a situation where there is a glut of junior managers and a scarcity of talented engineers, then seemingly inexplicable things start happening to salaries.
What a beautiful and elegant description of software engineering!
In other words, the UK today.
"Transforming" the sales numbers should also be measurable. Example: "Before, salespeople were closing x% of deals and missing scheduled followup on y% of contacts. Now (x+5)% of deals close and only (y/2)% of contacts are mistakenly dropped."
Pretty much this. If you are not part of the profit generating side of the business, you will always be viewed as a cost overhead. Engineering is unfortunately a question of cost expenditure for businesses but even more so for smaller software companies who don't have monopoly.
That's nice in theory, but the techies' dilemma is that it's often difficult or impossible to put a hard number on the value they have added.
How many customers were retained because you decreased response times by 100ms? How many customers were gained because of that slick UI you created? How many discounts were not handed out because of downtime that wasn't suffered because of your cautious error handling and exemplary testing? How much money was saved because of that documentation you made that helped the new hire ramp up faster?
Even when you can put a hard number on work you've done, like decreasing hosting costs by $15k per month, isn't that why you're paid so handsomely already? How are you going to do that again next year? (Why haven't you done it already?) Wasn't it a group effort?
The reality is, you're basically going to get paid based upon what your employer has deemed everyone else in your position is earning, plus or minus some % based upon experience level, your reputation, and how badly the company needs the position filled. If you don't like that, time to go into management or sales.