News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @12:48PM (#8835144)
Well that clinches my decision.

I've been getting around on public transit for quite a long time, but have been thinking of getting a car.

Now I've decided not to.

I'm a generally law-abiding citizen, but I simply do not wish to be tracked. How would you feel were someone to follow you around everywhere you went? Even if they kept their distance, never spoke to you our overtly harmed you in any way, it would be very disturbing.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by lozf on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:50PM (#8835783)
I guess it depends where you are but UK cities are right up there with surveillance on public transport too, both trains and buses[0]. Transport for London have a system that detects if you're still on a platform after a train to each destination has departed, and alerts a human - ostensibly in case you're contemplating suicide or otherwise need help. It stands to reason that implementing the likes of facial recognition and "Gait DNA"[1] is high on the agenda if not already functional.

Not to mention the huge incentives (>50% discount) for using a traceable RFID card as your "ticket" instead of paying with cash.

[0] http://boingboing.net/2009/08/31/london-bus-with-16-c.html from 2009 - newer buses, e.g. the 2012 "new" routemaster may well have more.

[1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspon... from 2007.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by RossM on Sunday January 04, 2015 @06:21PM (#8836322)
Got a source on the face-recognition-after-departure? That's a really interesting idea and I'd like to read more.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by lozf on Sunday January 04, 2015 @07:48PM (#8836572)
I saw a video / TV program where they talked about it a few years back... possibly in the BBC series called "The Tube"(2012)[0].

As I recall it wasn't doing actual facial recognition, but object / shape recognition, and comparing the objects in an area over time. So you'd have the outline of a person sitting on a bench and if they're still there after all destinations served by that platform (obviously depending on the line) have had at least one train, it'd be flagged up as suspicious as apparently some jumpers like to contemplate first.

Of course there must be a fair few false positives - people waiting to meet friends to either travel together or head out maybe etc, heck - I've even met someone to buy a laptop on a tube platform before... and I don't know how well it would cope if the person moved about between trains - but that didn't seem to matter much for their use case, and I'm sure they must have better tech in place by now.

Sorry I can't be more precise with a source, but I'll let you know if I find anything helpful.

[0] http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01cmsfd/episodes/guide

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:54PM (#8835797)
Fuck.

I'm never leaving my house ever again.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by lozf on Monday January 05, 2015 @07:47AM (#8838473)
That's just what they want - at least you won't be out spreading nefarious ideas that they can't monitor, and starting the revolution.

Now sit down here like a good little citizen and watch this lovely entertaining "programming" we have for you - and don't forget to buy some of the products we show you too - you know you need them really. ;)

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by JetSpiegel on Sunday January 04, 2015 @05:00PM (#8836043)
They already now where you live, and you better tape your webcam.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by Theodores on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:15PM (#8835645)
You need a bicycle.

Then you can ride the exact same route every day at exactly the same time wearing the same high visibility clothing that you wear every day, decorated 'Christmas tree' style in flashing lights. Just to make things easier for those that might track you, cruise along at 10-20 miles per hour, obeying the Highway Code every inch of the way.

Ah, but what about the mobile phone? You don't need that turned on whilst cycling. In fact, if you are used to babysitting the battery it makes sense to turn it off just for practicality reasons.

Ah, but what about the CCTV? Look at the route options, there is bound to be a park or canal tow path to take and, as well as a nice car-free ride you get to expose yourself to far fewer CCTV operators, although total CCTV absence is unlikely. Even then though, options are pretty good. You might take that 'winter warmer' coat off part way through your route. Or that bright yellow jacket is kind of ubiquitous, 'hard to spot' amongst the hordes of other cyclists with the same jacket. You can also legitimately completely cover your face with mask, sunglasses and helmet.

Even listening for a cyclist is not exactly easy, particularly if you don't let that tell-tell freewheel announce your presence (keep pedalling).

In not one film in the entire history of Hollywood has the bad guy/good guy evaded getting caught due to the simple tactic of riding a bicycle at a leisurely pace. So there just isn't even the group-think out there to suspect the cyclist.

Nobody expects the cyclist!

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by eterm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @01:54PM (#8835375)
Public transport is tracked too. TFL have removed the ability to use cash on busses now, you must use oyster cards.[1]

[1] https://www.tfl.gov.uk/modes/buses/cash-free-buses

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by orf on Sunday January 04, 2015 @02:22PM (#8835460)
Only in London and for good reason, having people pay by cash each stop takes up a ridiculous amount of time on popular routes.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by eterm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @02:30PM (#8835490)
Yeah, transport in London barely functioned until oyster cards were introduced!

Also, I didn't claim that surveillance was the primary reason for oyster cards, but there is no doubt it also functions as an effective large surveillance network.

As for other cities, transport isn't as centralised as it is in London so is vastly harder to implement, but for sure others are looking into similar schemes.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by EliRivers on Sunday January 04, 2015 @02:35PM (#8835509)
That enables them to track the card, but not the person. The card does not have to be tied to a specific person. I suppose you could correlate known journeys someone made and work out which card is their's, or watch someone using the card on CCTV and use the timestamp to identify their card, or once you'd got someone in custody take their card and get their travel history, but if someone simply changes card (and pays cash for it) they vanish again.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by eterm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:13PM (#8835869)
Every time you change card you get charged an extra £5, so even cash payers won't be changing cards to clean their history very often.

And now they actually accept debit cards directly at the gates without even the oyster cards.

If someone tries, of course they can pay cash and they can change up cards. But the point isn't that it's impossible to avoid surveillance, but that we are in a surveillance state which you have to try hard enough to avoid that avoidance is a red flag in itself.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by jacquesm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:33PM (#8835709)
Can you pay for those cards with cash?

In NL they do everything possible to avoid you buying the cards with cash (and there is a surcharge for disposables).

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by lozf on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:54PM (#8835796)
You can pay a GBP5 "deposit", which is inconvenient to get back without registering, but cash top-ups are available from machines and ticket offices under certain circumstances.

Also, like with most things these days, we're sold on the convenience that registering adds i.e. no loss of funds if lost or stolen, and "auto top up" from your registered credit / debit card... most people don't care enough to pay an extra GBP5 to make their transport history "disappear" every so often - especially when there are so many other ways we're tracked.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by ycitm on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:00PM (#8835814)
Did you see the "Secure Beneath the Watchful Eyes" adverts? Pretty scary:

http://imgur.com/oR4iFYs

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:05PM (#8835831)
The artistic style of that image looks just like Soviet propaganda.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by TsiCClawOfLight on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:10AM (#8838088)
Or Sci-fi propaganda in a typical tyrannical setting.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by handinmouth on Sunday January 04, 2015 @01:16PM (#8835245)
> How would you feel were someone to follow you around everywhere you went?

On the Web, this happens already (try a browser add-on such as RequestPolicy which will show you the numerous sites that track you all over the Web - often 20 or more per page).

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @01:30PM (#8835293)
That I find particularly creepy, so I blackhole many of the analytics servers with my /etc/hosts:

127.0.0.1 hosted-pixel.com 127.0.0.1 cdn.hosted-pixel.com

When web bugs first appeared, there was a huge public outcry. Now that they call it "analytics" or "big data" everyone seems cool with it.

However I can't block everything with hosts; some of the tracking scripts come from the same hosts as I actually use. I'm planning to write a firefox addon which will do stuff like remove the Facebook "Like" buttons. Even if I don't click the button, Facebook knows that it served me the script.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by JetSpiegel on Sunday January 04, 2015 @02:43PM (#8835540)
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by dfc on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:26PM (#8835682)
I have always loved requestpolicy but for some reason something about RPContinued makes me nervous. Policeman would be a great alternative if Sync worked[^1]. I cant use policeman if it means I have to jump through the same hoops on every firefox installation in order to get things set up.

[^1]: https://github.com/futpib/policeman/issues/28 Plus issues 92 and 95.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by hrjet on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:12PM (#8835865)
Thanks to @JetSpiegel I just became aware of Policeman. And I am not sure why you are nervous about RPContinued.

So, I went ahead and created a wiki for this: https://github.com/UprootLabs/gngr/wiki/List-of-request-bloc...

If there are any known issues with RPContinued or there are other extensions that are not listed, please feel free to add them. Thanks.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by dfc on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:48PM (#8840371)
What is the mysterious "switchboard" column?
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by hrjet on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:09PM (#8842881)
The name for the concept comes from the name of the HTTP-SwitchBoard extension (predecessor to uMatrix). It's skeuomorphic.

The extensions which have a switchboard like interface enable the user to block requests based on the request's domain name, the primary frame's domain-name, and also the type of request.

In contrast, extensions like NoScript have a global switch. If I allow scripts from DontBeEvil.com, they are enabled on all domains. They don't prevent XSS attacks, for example.

If there's a better name for this concept, please do suggest one.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:17PM (#8842575)
That's used by the phone company to patch you into the NSA.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by JetSpiegel on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:47PM (#8835987)
Policeman is still "beta", despite being quite usable. It just need polish.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by Panino on Sunday January 04, 2015 @02:41PM (#8835530)
> Even if I don't click the button, Facebook knows that it served me the script.

You can stop a lot of trackers by minimizing referer leaks. Firefox has the config option network.http.sendRefererHeader which defaults to 2, "always send referer." 1=same FQDN, 0=never send. So by setting it to 0 or 1, a typical tracker that's gotten past your /etc/hosts entries, adblock, etc. will see you requesting their pixel image but never see the sites that initiated those HTTP GETs.

There are no silver bullets, just good tools, and reducing the referer footprint is one of them.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by maxerickson on Sunday January 04, 2015 @01:40PM (#8835338)
Ad block rules like this block content except on the home site:

    ||twitter.$domain=~twitter.com
Additional domains can be unblocked:

    ||twitter.$domain=~twitter.com|~another.com
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @01:53PM (#8835371)
Hey thanks - I owe you one.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by singold on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:06PM (#8835614)
Maybe EFF's Privacy Badger could help? I use it and like it, you can unblock individual scripts on a per page basis.

https://www.eff.org/privacybadger

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by asuffield on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:11PM (#8835630)
> Now that they call it "analytics" or "big data" everyone seems cool with it.

It generates massive value that everybody benefits from. People appreciate that.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by pdkl95 on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:35PM (#8835714)
I wonder how much real value is actually generated from web bugs. A lot of interesting stuff can be generated from server logs; much more if you use analyzers.

I just wonder how much of the set of "analytics" that requires involving 3rd parties (web bugs and other referrer tricks) is actually useful and a value. The set that is a value "that everybody benefits from" is going to be even smaller.

I'm sure most people want this data, and see a lot of potential use. Usually, there is a big difference between "want" and "need", and I suspect a lot of the current attitude that throws analytics on everything is some experimentation, a limited amount of real value, and a whole lot of people joining in because they can (fad, bandwagon effect, it's what a tutorial said, etc).

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:02PM (#8835820)
I spend a lot of time analyzing my own logs. I get a lot of value from it.

I am completely cool with someone analyzing their own logs if I visit their site. What I'm not cool with, is them finding out what _other_ sites I visit.

I regard the current focus on analytics as unduly obsessive. How much do you need to know about your customer to flog your products? Just because you can measure something, it doesn't mean that it's going to do anyone any good to measure it.

I used to do direct mail; all we ever did was what today is known as A/B testing - we'd send "test drops" to different lists, with different prices, different wording in the offer letters and so on. It worked really well.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by pdkl95 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:56AM (#8837527)
To clarify my previous post, I'm totally fine with server-logs. As the 2nd-party to the conversation, the server has to know who the request is from, and can log it. These logs can certainly provide a lot of value.

As you mention, I'm more concerned with tracking as a 3rd-party[1]. There is, obviously, at least some real benefit in these cases that would not be possible when only using server logs. It's probably a lot less than most people think. A lot of that data (or similar-enough data when measured in e.g. how much it benefits sales or makes marketing cheaper) can probably be found elsewhere.

If we knew what the core benefits (needs, not wants), we might (in an ideal world) even be able to have some sort of social negotiation where the data can be provided in some form (or an alternative, or by making sure the real social cost is covered properly).

[1] While the law currently doesn't work this way, involving a 3rd-party unauthorized should really be considered some new type of (criminal) wiretapping in states that require 2-party consent.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by asuffield on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:42PM (#8841398)
> A lot of that data (or similar-enough data when measured in e.g. how much it benefits sales or makes marketing cheaper) can probably be found elsewhere.

If you can find equivalent data somewhere else, you should go build a company around this. People built their products this way because it works. If you have a better idea then you should make it happen.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by asuffield on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:26PM (#8837271)
All the marketing people that I've worked with have used it to do things that you could never do before. Tracking the path people take through your website, which pages they land on, what they spend time reading and what they click through, who comes back tomorrow to buy something - it shows you what works and what doesn't on a level you can't otherwise get. Mapping that onto market segments lets you further narrow this down to just work on the things that are important to the people who buy your product, when most visitors to your site are random click-through traffic that will never buy anything, and feeds back useful information to your product design process.

The degree of focus that this permits is how startups and small companies can find and target their market quickly, where a large company could just market to everybody and see who responds. It's hard to tell how much of the tech startup boom has been driven by this, but after working for and with a few of them, third party analytics is critical because you usually don't have the time or money to find your market without it. Before we had analytics the strategy was "make a lucky guess and verify it before you run out of money". Now the default strategy is "measure who is interested and go directly to them".

I'll accept that large, successful companies don't really get much out of this sort of thing - they already know who buys their product, and have the scale and resources to target everybody. They probably do use analytics just because it's there, and not because they need to.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by DanBC on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:15AM (#8838101)
Your tickets are linked to your identity (unless you pay cash and don't get season tickets) and bus companies have an interest in collecting data about where you travel. Bus tickets need a lot of information for auditing.

Also, In England we have CCTV on the buses. I'll take a photo next time I get a bus but there are about 5 cameras on the top deck.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by roel_v on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:37PM (#8835725)
In a few years there will be enough processing power to do facial recognition that will be accurate let's say 90% or so of the time. More than enough to track you everywhere where there is public transport.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:19PM (#8835892)
Beards cause trouble for facial regulation. While I expect bears are the focus of much research, one way to screw with the system is to grow a beard for your ID photo, then shave it off - or vice-versa.

However, women don't generally have beards, so I expect that facial recognition is more effective at identifying them than us men.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by roel_v on Sunday January 04, 2015 @07:17PM (#8836482)
Such a system won't need a single ID photo as 'reference'. When it notices someone leaving a house on Wisteria Lane 2401, and walking into an office on 21 Main Street, and there are postal packages send to John Smith on Wisteria Lane 2401 and social security contributions for employee John Smith by an employer registered at 21 Main Street, it doesn't take much to put 2 and 2 together and conclude that the face of that person is that of John Smith. And that's just 2 data points - think about it, how many things are there that tie a person to a name and a location? How irregular are people's movements really? Apart from putting on another mask every day, and moving house every few days, given enough processing power and some time that future system will recognize all but the most determined individuals - although I don't see how anyone can live a 'normal' life without a fixed address, job, phone, internet use, and 0 tolerance for anything that resembles a 'routine'.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by carapace on Sunday January 04, 2015 @07:12PM (#8836468)
There are frequencies that reflect from skin but not beards.

I suffer from paranoia myself. I've been thinking for more than twenty-five years about how to handle this and the only thing I can come up with is that we must make our control systems good or devolve into some nightmare scenario.

Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by JetSpiegel on Sunday January 04, 2015 @05:03PM (#8836048)
I bet at least some woman would rather grow beards than be tracked.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by mrec on Sunday January 04, 2015 @04:12PM (#8835864)
Masks. They're terribly comfortable. I think everyone will be wearing them in the future.
Re:How Britain Exported Next-Generation Surveillance by MichaelCrawford on Sunday January 04, 2015 @03:58PM (#8835810)
"Just because you're paranoid it doesn't mean they aren't really out to get you."

I have Bipolar-Type Schizoaffective Disorder. It's much like being manic-depressive and schizophrenic at the same time. One of the schizophrenic symptoms is paranoia; if the paranoia gets bad enough, I have visual hallucinations as well.

Having all this surveillance going on, even to the extent I am assured they're not looking for me, makes my illness far worse.

It doesn't help to take more medicine.

I would be very interested to see a comparison of psychiatric hospitalization rates from before and after Snowden's disclosures. It's not hard to get such statistics but it would be some work to interpret them meaningfully.