For example, many labs have been studying an important gene and how other genes are functionally related to it for more than 10 years. The research involved are simply tedious, but indispensable, biological experiments. It is a waste of time to study math for this work, because it doesn't apply, except some basic statistics on data analysis.
Disclaimer: I have advanced degrees in both biology and computer science, and has multiple years of biomedical research experience. I have met exceptionally smart people working in both biology, CS, math, and physics. Yes, these smart biologists don't understand advanced topics in math and physics. I believe, however, if they had studied math or physics, they would have been excellent mathematicians or physicists.
[1] https://www2.hu-berlin.de/biologie/theorybp/docs/dipl_scharp...
The study of biology is further complicated by the large number of confounding factors that muddle experimental results. Because of this, it is hard to know exactly when it is appropriate to bring in mathematics. Without a proper understanding of all the variables, math can only get you so far.
Another way to consider this is that biologists have not pushed back hard enough to mathematicians in the sense of asking for some tools which would allow for just slurping up a vast amount of unstructured, unprocessed data and getting something out of it.
It is certainly true that mathematical modeling as it is done now currently will indeed only get you so far.
But spirit of math in conjunction with physics has been to create tools that allow leaps and bounds. If we want to follow that spirit, it seems appropriate to ask for tools to help with messy things that now can't easily be dealt with. It may not be possible but it seems worthwhile to go all the way to the brick wall and pound on it.
There are some other points to consider. First, the dataset sizes for most biomedical research are very small. Most advanced statistical methods don't apply. Due to curiosity, I took some advanced stat courses and tried to apply the methods to our lab's data. It didn't provide any significant improvement compared to basic ones, like linear regression, logistic regression, etc.
Second, biomedical research is highly collaborative these days. For some research that generate a large amount of data, either the researchers themselves understand statistics very well, or they collaborate with statisticians very closely. There is a field called biostatistics. Most biostatistics professors are either math or stat major, and many of them are adjoint professors in biomedical departments.
Biomedical research is really tedious and time-consuming. The professors I knew when I was doing biomedical research worked more than 60 hours a day, and they wish they had more time. One young woman professor came to the lab at 8am, left at 6pm, spent some time with her 4 children, and came back to lab at 9pm again, and worked until midnight, on every weekday. She brought her children to the lab on Saturday, and worked the whole day. IMHO, it is better for her to focus all her energy on the biomedical part, which she is best at, and collaborate with statisticians.
For example, for much of the work I do, you could get away with never using anything more sophisticated than ANOVA.
The general rule in biology is if you need to use statistics you did the wrong experiment. The reason for this rule is it is all too easy to use clever statistical methods to solve a flawed experimental design.
The odd thing is that this difference in attitudes between physicists and biologists seems to me to be at least as much historically contingent as really dependent on the subject matter. Physics is hugely sprawling too, and a great deal of it is only passingly-mathematical.
If Darwin had been more mathematically minded he could have easily come at the problem of the origin of species from a viewpoint as strongly idealized and mathematically compact as Newton did with regard to physics. Newton was admittedly blessed with a very-nearly ideal system to study (the solar system) but was able to apply his ideas to other systems using a wide variety of increasingly sketchy approximations.
But I'm still pretty sure a mathematical mind on the order of Newton's could find a way to state evolution by variation and natural selection as a theorem rather than a theory, that follows necessarily from the laws of probability and the facts of chemistry (many of which Darwin didn't know, but still). It is at the very least a fun idea to speculate about: http://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Theorem-TJ-Radcliffe-ebook/dp/...
Apart from the chemistry part (where I don't understand what you mean), biology has had this for 85 years, with numerous extensions and generalizations [1].
- Analysis of variance (ANOVA)
- Maximum likelihood estimation (MLE)
- Fisher's exact test
- The Fisher-Yeats shuffle algorithm
In many ways Fisher exemplifies the author's point about what can happen when someone is both fluent in biology and mathematics!How interesting. Usually, it's the math folk who ridicule everyone else for being sloppy with their reasoning. For example, physics = hand-wavery :D
However, they can also be pretty free with their assumptions (which can be wild, though if reasoned from carefully usually turn out to be useful even if nobody anticipated that they would).
People working with mathematicians probably spend a lot of time wondering why they're so persnickety about some things most people would consider obvious ("but how do you really know 2+2=4?") but sometimes not so much about whether the constructions they're working with actually reflect a particular concrete reality.
Biologists (or in my case epidemiologists) may, on the other hand, be very concerned about why the value you chose for a particular parameter is 6 instead of 7, and whether or not it's really exponentially distributed.
Another way of putting it is "A mathematician might be interested in the general properties of dynamical systems, and a biologists entire research agenda at the moment may very well be this set of equations with a very specific parameter set."
I surely won't disagree, but I want to add the point that when the model turns out to be wrong (and most will), also the biologist will have an interest to know, whether just some parameters (say values of constants, wrong probablility assumption) are wrong or the fundamental model has to be reconsidered.
And the Dirac delta is the limit of a function with integral 1, not a function.
Maybe you need to hang out with a better class of physicists? There are certainly plenty of mathematicians who believe odds things, but I'd be leery of tarring the whole lot with the same brush.
On the other hand, it really is a useful result. The negative part is, for example, why the Casimir force is attractive.
Here's an article about the whole thing, with links to the various Numberphile videos and Phil Plait articles that have been done about it: http://physicsbuzz.physicscentral.com/2014/01/does-1234-112....
> In the Wikipedia article, they have an equation that looks like this \zeta(-3)=1/120, but the stuff on the left hand side is just another way of writing 1^3+2^3+3^3 +4^3+...
If you can't explain why the above claim is screwy, then every time you claim, "the sum of all positive integers is -1/12," you need to qualify it with "I have no idea why, but I know there's some complicated mathematics that removes the word 'sum' and 'positive integers' and replaces them with more complicated concepts I'm don't have the time to learn about, and we physicists abuse it to say what I just said."
> If QED is correct ... then I would argue that the things that go into QED calculations must be just as correct.
Also not how logic works.
Physics today does have some remarkably talented mathematical thinkers, like Edward Witten, but most of them are involved in very fanciful theories like string theory.
Sure sure, but do know that a lot of all that hacky regularization stuff can be made mathematically sound after all --see for instance [1,2].
[1] http://www.maths.qmul.ac.uk/~tp/talks/casimir.pdf#page55
[2] http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin...
And genomics in general has forced the combination of biology, stats, and math. Classical genetics and evolution departments are often seeded with lots of appreciation for mathematics, as well.
However, pure molecular biology doesn't often have that much to say to non-applied math, and vice versa.
When I was a biology grad student, I was the only person in the department that tried to do active collaboration with the math department. I took more math classes during my graduate program than biology classes.
On the biology side, I got ridiculed for all the 'hand waving' that seems to happen with the math. Biologists want to see concrete experiments and results.
On the math side I found people to be much more open and fascinated by the biology, but they had a tough time explaining what they were doing to a lay audience.
No easy answers, but I think more programs should graduate people with dual skills in both subjects(and of course have job opportunities for those grads, instead of having them jump into industry like I did).