Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by thisisdave on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @04:57PM
(#8821296)
>I'm still pretty sure a mathematical mind on the order of Newton's could find a way to state evolution by variation and natural selection as a theorem rather than a theory, that follows necessarily from the laws of probability and the facts of chemistry
Apart from the chemistry part (where I don't understand what you mean), biology has had this for 85 years, with numerous extensions and generalizations [1].
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by jfarmer on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @08:25PM
(#8821836)
Worth mentioning that the "Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection" was proposed by R.A. Fisher who was responsible for developing the following techniques and theorems (among many other things):
- Analysis of variance (ANOVA)
- Maximum likelihood estimation (MLE)
- Fisher's exact test
- The Fisher-Yeats shuffle algorithm
In many ways Fisher exemplifies the author's point about what can happen when someone is both fluent in biology and mathematics!
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by dnautics on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @04:27PM
(#8821167)
The biggest gulf between physics and biology is the general principle that ockham's razor is a poor heuristic for biology. A second source is that biological phenomena exhibit strong path-dependence, and physicists are typically trained to think from a path-independent (state function) point of view.
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by danieltillett on Thursday January 01, 2015 @01:53AM
(#8822353)
This is so true. Trying to use the mental tools that work well in physics with biology will lead you astray most of the time.
The odd thing is that this difference in attitudes between physicists and biologists seems to me to be at least as much historically contingent as really dependent on the subject matter. Physics is hugely sprawling too, and a great deal of it is only passingly-mathematical.
If Darwin had been more mathematically minded he could have easily come at the problem of the origin of species from a viewpoint as strongly idealized and mathematically compact as Newton did with regard to physics. Newton was admittedly blessed with a very-nearly ideal system to study (the solar system) but was able to apply his ideas to other systems using a wide variety of increasingly sketchy approximations.
But I'm still pretty sure a mathematical mind on the order of Newton's could find a way to state evolution by variation and natural selection as a theorem rather than a theory, that follows necessarily from the laws of probability and the facts of chemistry (many of which Darwin didn't know, but still). It is at the very least a fun idea to speculate about: http://www.amazon.com/Darwins-Theorem-TJ-Radcliffe-ebook/dp/...