Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by wolfgke on Thursday January 01, 2015 @10:06AM
(#8823101)
In my experience mathematicians are definitely concerned whether, say, the assumption of exponential distribution is really justified. But what they are interested in is typically a quite general class of (in this case) distributions, where they typically begin with the "simple" cases (which are often normal or exponential distributions).
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by Fomite on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:30AM
(#8826522)
nod That example was more to illustrate one of several choices a mathematician might make in order to make a problem analytically tractable that might bother a biologist.
Another way of putting it is "A mathematician might be interested in the general properties of dynamical systems, and a biologists entire research agenda at the moment may very well be this set of equations with a very specific parameter set."
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology
by wolfgke on Friday January 02, 2015 @11:38AM
(#8827370)
> Another way of putting it is "A mathematician might be interested in the general properties of dynamical systems, and a biologists entire research agenda at the moment may very well be this set of equations with a very specific parameter set."
I surely won't disagree, but I want to add the point that when the model turns out to be wrong (and most will), also the biologist will have an interest to know, whether just some parameters (say values of constants, wrong probablility assumption) are wrong or the fundamental model has to be reconsidered.
Biologists (or in my case epidemiologists) may, on the other hand, be very concerned about why the value you chose for a particular parameter is 6 instead of 7, and whether or not it's really exponentially distributed.