I once got into a conflict with my immediate supervisor which escalated into legal territory. The hows and whys doesn't matter right now, but suffice to say I had every right on my side, but I still couldn't have done it without a lawyer from my union who knew exactly who to contact and what to do.
As you say, unions are a form of insurance system and when they work they are irreplaceable. It's a win-win situation for the company and the employee to get rid of the situations I mentioned above.
Few people willingly pay car insurance; fewer still have any confidence that their insurance will pay-out. But we pay the premiums because it is a legal requirement, even though it might be more effective for some people to put that money into a bond instead.
It's a similar situation for unions; few people expect that a union really protect them from a determined private-sector employer, so they assess the cost-benefit of such "insurance" to be negative. Particularly when the premium, much as in your example, costs a lot in terms of minimum wage.
What country are you from? In the US most people who can afford it have more than the legally-required car insurance and insurance companies are expected to pay out in the event of an accident.
A bond isn't insurance because, on average, it won't cover your expenses (if you earn enough on it to pay for a catastrophe, that means you didn't need it). The whole point of insurance (and unions) is to share risk over a large number of people, only some (random) fraction of whom will ever "need" the insurance.
Regarding unions, it's first and foremost not a question of protection from a determined employer, but protection from specific parts of the company doing illegal and/or wrong things.
As soon as your company has more than 10 employees, it gets a whole lot more complex than "employer" and "employee".
Actual experience has borne out these expectations.
I remember one jokey comment that low pay in prospect terms means some one who isn't paying any higher rate tax :-)
By that rationale, no-one would by the more expensive fully-comprehensive insurance (where your own car is insured, not just third parties) but they do.
Then when I became a manager and was no longer a union member, the union attacked my management position so hard, that I rage quit because I simply couldn't take it any longer.
It's also nice to have a group of people lobbying for the interests of IT workers, say.
Thanks, I didn't realise we had a union for our sector.
They are associated with and often still do a lot of things that I really want to part of. I associate joining a union more with joining a political party than what you describe, rightly or wrongly.
I think an actual lawyer would probably be better value for money.
If you murdered a customer, your Union will probably "advise" you that there is nothing you can do to keep your job.
>If you murdered a customer
Oh yeah, that was totally it eyeroll.
High-tech industry is not a monopoly. The only thing unionization would do is to complicate life of capable people who actually work by forcing them to work alongside unmotivated lazy-asses that are employed just because they can't really be fired. I can't pay good people better money and I still have to drag around these useless clowns that religiously observe their mandated 4 coffee breaks and time their arrival and departure with sub-second precision. This is counter-productive. Unionization in high-tech is a seriously bad idea. It's just a way for unqualified personnel to hold on to their jobs instead of developing themselves into someone actually employable on their merit.
If all you are looking for is a legal support in tight spots, then there's an actual regular insurance coverage for that. Just ask your insurance provider.
While that may be, employers in the same field with geographical vicinity are known to negotiate on shared terms of employment - in effect creating leverage over individual employees when negotiating the terms of their employment.
A union may devolve to many things but one of the valuable facets are that it creates leverage for the employees against the employers.
I don't have to like it, you don't have to like it but that is the way the market works.
"still have to drag around these useless clowns that religiously observe their mandated 4 coffee breaks and time their arrival and departure with sub-second precision."
I would have just used the words 'non-productive' - that amount of verbiage creates the feeling that there is non-spoken behavioural pattern that is used as the metric of an employeed value rather than the value they produce.
Especially in high tech the moments when an employee actually performs value adding work can be spurious, unlike in lower tech industries like logging where the work you see is actually the work input you are getting.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Li...
UK: Has software union. Developer salary in London =~ $65k
US: No software union. Developer salary in SF =~ $200k
I'll be sure to pull this out next time I'm trying to explain to somebody why unions are such a terrible idea for software developers.
And, that said, unions have very bad failure modes, as experienced by the problems with regards to (allegedly?) bad teachers. Also, they are able to mask problems for quite some time, and when they finally implode you have a half-broken sector on your hands with cascading effects and unemployment and defaults and ... well, Detroit-like consequences.
Furthermore, software developers have it good, and probably will be in demand for the coming part of the century, but that won't stop labor exploitation even in the tech sector for specific regions.
In the UK I pay ~£16/$25 per month to be a member of Prospect, a union for workers in the telecoms sector. When I was made redundant (downsized) they were able to get me an excellent settlement and provided me with incredibly useful professional advice.
I also know that if I'm in a disciplinary situation, they'll have trained employment rights specialists available to fight my corner.
The best way to think about a union (IMO) is as legal insurance. You pay for car insurance in case someone plows into your automobile - why wouldn't you do the same for your career?