Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by rurounijones on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @03:04AM
(#8728179)
The idea of drawing those maps, which now hang in every classroom I have ever seen, by hand seems like a Herculean task. There are so many mundane things that we take for granted now because it is easy to do on computer.
Ah, the stories where arrogant, condescending "top of the Field" scientists get proven totally and utterly wrong. Wonderful and a good lesson in humility. The Scientific establishment might be right most of the time, but "most" is not "all".
The fact this happened in a pretty sexist environment by a women just makes it better.
Interesting that having a "women on board" was taken to be bad luck, that just sounds so backwards coming from a ship engaged in scientific research and paid for by scientists.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by PhantomGremlin on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @05:28AM
(#8728548)
> Ah, the stories where arrogant, condescending "top of the Field" scientists get proven totally and utterly wrong. Wonderful and a good lesson in humility.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by steffenfrost on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @04:17AM
(#8728373)
The treatment of Wegener's theory of Continental Drift is a lesson for the scientific community.
If one is not allowed to mention or entertain an idea without career repercussions, it harms the scientific process. Similarity to the treatment of climate change "deniers" comes to mind.
The merit for the cause of climate change should be based on evidence, not by keeping opposing views off the table by threatening the careers of those who want to explore research other ideas.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by simonh on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @06:53AM
(#8728722)
The problem is that for every example of a radical new theory getting trashed by the scientific community before triumphant vindication, there are hundreds of examples of crackpot nonsense that realy honestly don't deserve to be taken seriously.
Sometimes a new idea needs to spend it's time out in the wilderness before proving itself. That's because real science progresses based on proof, not just one or two data points that may or may not be significant. The fact is there were scientists that supported the theory and they didn't all get sacked, and nor did Wegener.
The real problem is that sometimes all we have are a few data points. That's when opinion and fact can get blurred, and geology was in that situation before the 50s. Nobody could prove continental drift and nobody could disprove it. That doesn't mean that those who doubted it were stupid, in fact several of the scientists resonsible for producing the most compelling evidence for the theory were initialy sceptics. That didn't stop them doing good science and following the evidence.
Its far too easy to look at an episode in the hitory of science like this and draw a bright triumphalist line between those who were right and those who were in the end proven wrong.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by asgard1024 on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @04:37AM
(#8728429)
Come on. Nobody threatens opposing viewpoints to anthropogenic global warming. Competing hypotheses even get tested, things like CLOUD or BEST come to mind. They are just really weak explanations.
If you would read history, you would actually find that AGW had similar story as Wegener theory, if anything. Until Keeling and Plass came, nobody took the Arrhenius' and Chamberlin's idea seriously. And there was even experimental evidence from Calendar.
And the same goes for Milankovitch cycles, which are one of the most important pieces of evidence for AGW.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by dougabug on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @06:44AM
(#8728702)
This is an incredulous claim.
Even scientists such as Freeman Dyson and Hendrik Tennekes had their reputations smeared for daring to express skepticism over the most dire claims of catastrophic AGW proponents. Dyson didn't even claim that the Earth wasn't warming, he simply criticized the then strong faith in the predictions of GCMs, and the popularization of extreme catastrophic claims such as a 20 foot rise in global sea levels this century. Physics Nobel Laureate Ivar Giaever quit the American Physical Society, saying “In the APS it is ok to discuss whether the mass of the proton changes over time and how a multi-universe behaves, but the evidence of global warming is incontrovertible?”
The Climate Gate scandal showed irrefutably that prominent scientists in the climate research community conspired to spike the publication of dissenting scientists.
Expressing skepticism regarding catastrophic AGW has unquestionably been a 21st shibboleth. Even skeptics of the Big Bang aren't branded as "Deniers" with editorials from prominent policy advisors (James Hansen) calling for charging them with "high crimes against humanity and nature."
For the record, I am not a "Denier," so please no scarlett letter "D."
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by asgard1024 on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @07:02AM
(#8728739)
There is a difference, though. Wegener had an alternative theory. As far as I can tell, those "skeptics" don't have any good alternative explanation (or data), just a gut feeling. So they are not at all in the same position as Wegener.
Catastrophic claims do no good, that's true. But frivolous skepticism (without a good counter-theory) has policy implications (continuing business as usual, which is unsustainable). The scientists opposing AGW are not being mass criticized for their scientific opinion (because they don't have any), but for the policies they give support to.
I also disagree with your interpretation of climate gate, but let's leave that.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by simonh on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @07:05AM
(#8728747)
Climategate was wholy invented. "Finally, we have the emails! We've got the b@574rd5!" Except the emails contained nothing remotely incriminating. A few poorly worded comments maybe, perhaps some otuspoken opinions, a lack of sufficient transparency, but once the information was out and was transparent there wasn't even even the slightest shred of actual conspiracy or suppression of evidence.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by mavhc on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @11:03AM
(#8729842)
Only one of those things will kill billions of people though. Hopefully it ends up like Y2K, the publicity causes people to actually fix the problem so well that the general public thinks it was all hype.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by acqq on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @04:32AM
(#8728416)
Yes, Wegener died during his last Greenland expedition in 1930 trying to find additional proofs for continenal drift. The theory was very unpopular in the scientific community until decades later.
Just a small number of scientist were very sure, namely Wegener's father in law and mentor Köppen and also Milutin Milankovitch, whose own climate work was also mostly recognized and rightly understood only after his death. Milankovitch wrote about the continental drift in his books that popularised science in the thirties.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by simula67 on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @05:13AM
(#8728515)
> If one is not allowed to mention or entertain an idea without career repercussions, it harms the scientific process.
Can this be extended to politics as well ? What about the recent Uber executive mentioning that they thought about investigating the private lives of journalists to give them a taste about their own medicine ? If they did not actually do it, is it OK for them to mention it ?
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by WalterBright on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @04:18AM
(#8728380)
In the 1930's, my grandfather Ferdinand Bernauer, set up measuring stations in Iceland in an attempt to prove the theory of continental drift by showing that Iceland was spreading apart.
He was not able to take the confirming set of measurements because the war intervened and he was killed in 1945.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by PeterWhittaker on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @10:06AM
(#8729491)
Reminds me of The Map that Changed the World ([1]), a map of England drawn by a professional canal digger who had noticed and documented strata throughout England, Wales, and southern Scotland. It was essentially the first geological map and led both to modern geology and to Darwinian evolution.
Science advances at least partially through the collection of large amounts of data and the distillation of that data into useful forms by dedicated workers like Tharp and Smith.
Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by Luc on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @07:02AM
(#8728741)
What a crap article. It seems to be an amalgamation of other popular retellings (looking for more info I found paragraphs copied nearly verbatim) crafted into a 'just so' Hollywood script. No way the writer consulted original sources for this.
Ah, the stories where arrogant, condescending "top of the Field" scientists get proven totally and utterly wrong. Wonderful and a good lesson in humility. The Scientific establishment might be right most of the time, but "most" is not "all".
The fact this happened in a pretty sexist environment by a women just makes it better.
Interesting that having a "women on board" was taken to be bad luck, that just sounds so backwards coming from a ship engaged in scientific research and paid for by scientists.
Sailors (at least back then) were not exactly known for being exemplary individuals.
Max Planck is reported to have said:
If one is not allowed to mention or entertain an idea without career repercussions, it harms the scientific process. Similarity to the treatment of climate change "deniers" comes to mind.
The merit for the cause of climate change should be based on evidence, not by keeping opposing views off the table by threatening the careers of those who want to explore research other ideas.
Sometimes a new idea needs to spend it's time out in the wilderness before proving itself. That's because real science progresses based on proof, not just one or two data points that may or may not be significant. The fact is there were scientists that supported the theory and they didn't all get sacked, and nor did Wegener.
The real problem is that sometimes all we have are a few data points. That's when opinion and fact can get blurred, and geology was in that situation before the 50s. Nobody could prove continental drift and nobody could disprove it. That doesn't mean that those who doubted it were stupid, in fact several of the scientists resonsible for producing the most compelling evidence for the theory were initialy sceptics. That didn't stop them doing good science and following the evidence.
Its far too easy to look at an episode in the hitory of science like this and draw a bright triumphalist line between those who were right and those who were in the end proven wrong.
If you would read history, you would actually find that AGW had similar story as Wegener theory, if anything. Until Keeling and Plass came, nobody took the Arrhenius' and Chamberlin's idea seriously. And there was even experimental evidence from Calendar.
And the same goes for Milankovitch cycles, which are one of the most important pieces of evidence for AGW.
Even scientists such as Freeman Dyson and Hendrik Tennekes had their reputations smeared for daring to express skepticism over the most dire claims of catastrophic AGW proponents. Dyson didn't even claim that the Earth wasn't warming, he simply criticized the then strong faith in the predictions of GCMs, and the popularization of extreme catastrophic claims such as a 20 foot rise in global sea levels this century. Physics Nobel Laureate Ivar Giaever quit the American Physical Society, saying “In the APS it is ok to discuss whether the mass of the proton changes over time and how a multi-universe behaves, but the evidence of global warming is incontrovertible?”
The Climate Gate scandal showed irrefutably that prominent scientists in the climate research community conspired to spike the publication of dissenting scientists.
Expressing skepticism regarding catastrophic AGW has unquestionably been a 21st shibboleth. Even skeptics of the Big Bang aren't branded as "Deniers" with editorials from prominent policy advisors (James Hansen) calling for charging them with "high crimes against humanity and nature."
For the record, I am not a "Denier," so please no scarlett letter "D."
Catastrophic claims do no good, that's true. But frivolous skepticism (without a good counter-theory) has policy implications (continuing business as usual, which is unsustainable). The scientists opposing AGW are not being mass criticized for their scientific opinion (because they don't have any), but for the policies they give support to.
I also disagree with your interpretation of climate gate, but let's leave that.
What are they hiding? It turned out, nothing!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Wegener
Just a small number of scientist were very sure, namely Wegener's father in law and mentor Köppen and also Milutin Milankovitch, whose own climate work was also mostly recognized and rightly understood only after his death. Milankovitch wrote about the continental drift in his books that popularised science in the thirties.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradigm_shift
Can this be extended to politics as well ? What about the recent Uber executive mentioning that they thought about investigating the private lives of journalists to give them a taste about their own medicine ? If they did not actually do it, is it OK for them to mention it ?
Is it because it is done as retaliation? If uber had started to dig up dirt first would that be ok?
Or is it because only media is allowed to dig up dirt? Would it be ok for uber to pay another newspaper to look into the first one?
He was not able to take the confirming set of measurements because the war intervened and he was killed in 1945.
See page 6 of http://www.raunvis.hi.is/~leo/greinar/thysk_exp.pdf
and his papers on the topic:
Bernauer, F. (1937) Geschichtete Lava an isländischen Vulkanen. Zeitschrift der deutschen geologischen Gesellschaft 89, 88–97.
Bernauer, F. (1939a) Vulkanische und tektonische Spalten auf Island. Zeitschrift der deutschen geologischen Gesellschaft 91, 405–420.
Bernauer, F. (1939b) Island und die Frage der Kontinentalverschiebungen. Geologische Rundschau 30, 357–358.
How did he intend to do that? Radio waves? Positioning related to the sun/starts?
Science advances at least partially through the collection of large amounts of data and the distillation of that data into useful forms by dedicated workers like Tharp and Smith.
[1] http://simonwinchester.com/books/the-map-that-changed-the-wo...