Re:How One Woman's Discovery Shook the Foundations of Geology
by simonh on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @06:53AM
(#8728722)
The problem is that for every example of a radical new theory getting trashed by the scientific community before triumphant vindication, there are hundreds of examples of crackpot nonsense that realy honestly don't deserve to be taken seriously.
Sometimes a new idea needs to spend it's time out in the wilderness before proving itself. That's because real science progresses based on proof, not just one or two data points that may or may not be significant. The fact is there were scientists that supported the theory and they didn't all get sacked, and nor did Wegener.
The real problem is that sometimes all we have are a few data points. That's when opinion and fact can get blurred, and geology was in that situation before the 50s. Nobody could prove continental drift and nobody could disprove it. That doesn't mean that those who doubted it were stupid, in fact several of the scientists resonsible for producing the most compelling evidence for the theory were initialy sceptics. That didn't stop them doing good science and following the evidence.
Its far too easy to look at an episode in the hitory of science like this and draw a bright triumphalist line between those who were right and those who were in the end proven wrong.
Sometimes a new idea needs to spend it's time out in the wilderness before proving itself. That's because real science progresses based on proof, not just one or two data points that may or may not be significant. The fact is there were scientists that supported the theory and they didn't all get sacked, and nor did Wegener.
The real problem is that sometimes all we have are a few data points. That's when opinion and fact can get blurred, and geology was in that situation before the 50s. Nobody could prove continental drift and nobody could disprove it. That doesn't mean that those who doubted it were stupid, in fact several of the scientists resonsible for producing the most compelling evidence for the theory were initialy sceptics. That didn't stop them doing good science and following the evidence.
Its far too easy to look at an episode in the hitory of science like this and draw a bright triumphalist line between those who were right and those who were in the end proven wrong.